The Presidential Election is Really About the Future of the Supreme Court by Perrie Halpern
This week Ruth Bader Ginsburg had heart surgery. This follows various other health issues. At 81, she is also the oldest Justice on the court. She has no plans of stepping down. With this in mind, the next presidential election could determine theSupremeCourtfor years to come.
Right now, the court leans conservative. Not since Clarence Thomas replaced Thurgood Marshall,

Supreme Court Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
could the court have a major shake up and this could have lasting results for years to come. If a Republican President is elected, and she has to step down, the court could be an overwhelming conservative court.
Democrats could see this as a selfish move on her behalf, and they should. In reality, she should have stepped down at least in the beginning of the Obama's second term. Now she can't as we have a lame duck president. At 81 and ill, her only choice now is to stay on in hopes of a Democrat president. I wouldn't place money on that. If we look at recent trends inelections, after 8 year terms of one party, it is usually replaced by the other. Unless the Republicansunderminethemselves with infighting within their own ranks, the outcome will probably be a Republican President.
So thepresidentialelection has a much bigger picture of where we are going as a nation. Presidents can come and go, but justices last for decades and so do their decisions.

Play nice and be courteous.
Another reason for term limits of the Judicial Branch and Legislature Branch which will only come about by the use of Article 5 from the states, not Congress.
She couldn't even if she wanted to. And I doubt that she will make it through another 4-8 years of any presidency.
Now that isn't even a MILF that is a GILF.
Fill me in. Inquiring minds want to know....
You are forgetting what could be the Republicans biggest weapon.... Jeb. Latino wife... middle of the road Republican, 42% of Americans identifying as independents..... even if the electorate looks different... he kind of fits the bill.
Six
What would you suggest those term limits on SCOTUS justices be?
Four years, eight years, ten years, twenty years, thirty years....or perhaps each president should appoint nine justices upon inauguration .....?
Nothing disruptive about a oft changing interpretation of the constitution, right?
Judges could this campaign for and lobby presidential candidates for the positions on key courts - no danger of corruption there.
Six I tend to agree with you. The life span of Justice when the Constitution was drawn, was mid 40's. Now we have justices in their late 70's and early 80's. Also it would make the court less political.
Right now with the makeup of house and senate, there is no way that a justice with Ginsberg ideology would make it through the process.
Nope. I totally get it.
Robert in Ohio, it is better I post this link than to try to explain it all to you as I see it. I will say it is not going to happen with a Constitutional Convention. It will have to come about from a Convention of States.
The Founding Fathers v. the Supreme Court
You have got to be kidding Perrie. The entire reason for giving justices lifetime tenure was to remove them from the active political scene as much as possible. Placing shorter limits on their terms could only have the effect of starting a political runaround each time the tenure of one of the justices ends. Much better to keep that nonsense until their lives end; at least that doesn't happen as often.
TTGA,
The court is political already... and I am not sure if term limits are the way to go, per se, but something needs to be done along the lines of what Six is talking about. But I have to agree that there is some truth in what you said here:
Haven't thought about that JW. Very interesting perspective. Something to be considered along with other methods in my opinion. Like anything variations of everything that is being proposed here should be considered, but one thing for sure is it is not going to happen from Congress. It has to come from the people and that can only be accomplished through Article 5, thru "Convention of States".
Six
That is not what I asked in the least.
I know how a constitutional convention would work, asked what you thought the term limits you are advocating should be - number of years?
To some extent, yes; but, if it were completely so, why did Chief Justice Roberts vote to save Obamacare? Why did Chief Justice Warren (Eisenhower appointee) vote to save the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and why did Chief Justice Warren Burger (Nixon appointee) vote for abortion in Roe v Wade? I would submit that Supreme Court Justices are intensely political in a partisan way until they get to the Supreme Court and realize that they no longer have to run for office for the rest of their lives. Then, their real beliefs come out. While many of those beliefs can be predicted by their past behavior, not all can be predicted. A lot of the past actions and decisions were the result of looking for political survival (winning the next election), which is no longer a factor once you are on the Supreme Court.
Robert,
While this is true about Ginsburg, it has not been true of other justices. She is the exception and not the rule. And I doubt in today's atmosphere of partisanship she would clear the Senate, but there is no way to prove or disprove that.
TTGA,
I think that in past courts that what you said is true. Sadly, I think that this is a recent phenomenon. We as a nation have become more partisan, which in turn has spread into even our court. Please don't get me wrong, I don't want a court that would run for office. That would be the worst. But the life time appointments were based on a much shorter lifetime, and so the effects of a less than great court, could be redirected far swifter than now.
It's an idea, BF... but then again.. there are a lot of people who would like direct voting and do away with the college.
LOL Feronia... sounds about right!
Well Randy that is counting your chickens before they are hatched. No one knows how this election will play out, which is why I wrote this article. I think that most people have SCOTUS in the back of their minds when they are voting for President, but this election, it might be at an even higher level.
Sorry there RIO, all those questions we all should consider. At this moment I have no real idea what would be best, but I know it isn't a lifetime Supreme Court Justice or a lifetime Congressman or Congresswoman simply because you have it wrapped up with the money you can pretty much guarantee your position for as long as you want. Without putting too much thought into it and not having other suggestions to consider I would say 8 to 12 years for Congress and I'm not sure the best way to handle the Supreme Court, but as it is becoming more of a solution considered I guess we will figure that out.
I'm not sure I agree with you Randy, but that's OK as we would really be in a mess if we all agreed all the time. I wouldn't have much of a problem with the Supreme Court if it did its job, but they have decided not only are they authorized to interpret the laws, but to write them as well by their decisions.
Six
So you disagree with the concept that people should be able to vote for and elect the person that they want to represent them, regardless of how long or how short a time that person has already served.
Mickey
I do not get to say this very often, but you are absolutely correct!
Very true, but ...
'0E%2C*P%2C%3B%3C%20P%20%20%0A
Robert,
This is a bit of detour on the subject... especially on freedom of speech issue, but while you are giving us info on democrats that have made it through, what are the stats of Republican Justices that have made it through?
And in a way, you have proved the thesis of this article. The president puts forth the nominee, and usually they get through. That is exactly why JusticeGinsburg should have left before Obama became a lame duckpresident, If she cared about the balance of the court, since I would say that the outcome of the nextpresidentialelection isgoing to be questionable at best.
R G
I think it would be very, very unlikely that President Obama could get a recognized liberal confirmed after January 1, 2015
And when a nomination is withdrawn by the president, it has essentially been defeated by the opposition
R G
If you will note I said it would be very unlikely (not impossible) and I also noted that the candidate(s) that would be difficult to get confirmed would those seen as liberals.
I'll give you 50/50 on that Robert. I was referencing the last part of your comment not the whole thing
"Any further Obama nominees will be questioned as to their views as to whether they think the US really needs a Congress, in light of Obama's executive orders."
Feronia's comment was about the confirmation, which was on topic. Our media is a big part of it, which it wasn't as much say 20 years ago. We do have more negativity from both sides than we used to, and instead of telling us why we should vote for someone, what we get is fear mongering about why we shouldn't and that all plays into who gets the vote.
And I have never called anyone a bastard.
I never said that.
OK who?
OK so has there ever been a case that by executive order a justice was turned down?
And, believe it or not, you just don't know how close to the mark you are with that comment.
And John I can't imagine what would make blacks or latinos vote for a Dem candidate. The Dems are, indeed, the party of Dementia and the blacks and latinos are finding that out very quickly - remember the elections last month???
SCOTUS of today no longer rule on constitutional laws - they vote on policy and morals. Show me in the Constitution where a corporation is a person.
RIO and Randy do not agree with my idea at taking a look at term limits and that is their right to feel that way. The reason I feel the way I do about it is even the people in the states seem to want to get rid of some in Congress and there is no way. Money and connections buys elections these days. Take Thad Cochran Senator from Mississippi. He's been in Congress since 1973. That's 41 years. Think about it. You finished high school, went to college, got married, had children, now have grandchildren who may have children of their own making you a great grandparent. It was never intended for someone to make a career out of politics.
So you like both of your Senators and your House of Representative. That's great! But what happens when you find yourself not liking them and you can't get rid of them because they have weaved their web so deep into the corruption in Washington the party will not provide any support for anyone who runs against them and we the people really have a hard time competing with the big corporations and other organizations who are benefiting by keeping them in office?
So you don't like McConnell, who probably spent Thanksgiving hunting wild turkey. Well you'd have an easier time removing a rusty nail from concrete in tack than get rid of him.
And you don't like John Boehner, who probably spent his Thanksgiving drinking Wild Turkey. He's so tied into the corruption in Washington of the Uptown crowd he doesn't have a worry about getting defeated.
Maybe you don't like or maybe you do like Harry Reid? Well, even the Democrats in Congress don't like Harry Reid, but he has so much power like Boehner only a few will stand up to them. And the reason why? Because they will spend their whole time in Washington only having the power to vote if Boehner or Reid allow it and when the next election comes they will be replaced, not by the people, but by Harry Reid and Company and John Boehner and Company.
Now tell me which states have the same representatives for over 12 years and look at these unemployment rates.
Statistic set below: November 21, 2014 for October, 2014. [ 4 ]
(seasonally adjusted)
(
Oh yes, you think you elect these people when you vote for them and they win, but when you and everyone you know is against someone and they continue to win in spite of it, you must realize the corruption combined with the power of money really elects them.
So in saying this I think we should take a look at term limits and I would say the same thing no matter who is in office. Can you say the same thing?
Six
Interesting data
But are you familiar with the fact that correlation does not prove causation?
And by the way as pointed out earlier, elections are the term limits built into the process by the constitution.
Republicans would see it as a political move in a "presumptively" non-political institution. Basically, she is in a no-win situation.
The people always decry a court that "makes law", yet they keep electing people who make no laws, or bad laws.
I'm sure that they would, but let's all be real here and realize that the court has become political to various degrees. But put that aside, people do retire from the court for various reasons.
I am so with you on that 1st. One of the worst rulings ever. Talk about taking away the power from the people.
1st, which comment?
Well, if you don't like corporations being considered people then the only way you're going to change it will be through the "Convention of the States". The delegates from each state can have as many delegates as they want, but each state only has one vote on each amendment and they have to bring the ideas of the people to the table. The President, Congress nor the Supreme Court has any say-so in the matter. They have to abide. You have to get 75% of the states to pass each and every amendment or it goes nowhere. This means amendments that don't receive the 75% are dead in their tracks. If this isn't bi-partisan, I don't know what is. Only amendments agreed and passed by 75% of the states which would require 38 states will become amendments to the Constitution.
Keep electing "progressives" and we will have a SCOTUS with nine Obamas as the makeup.
Is that what you want?
Is a union a person?
RIO, I'm like you completely aware of what you are saying. Are you trying to say the original Constitution hasn't had amendments put in place since its inception? We know that isn't true, so I'm suggesting it is something to think about and there are already a number of states considering it.
Has there ever been a time when the court wasn't political?
Each of the cases listed was very political in its time.
The vision (attributed and interpreted by various groups) of the founding fathers has never fully taken hold of the institutions they gave us.
As for voting on policy and morals, what is politics if not policy and morals? Your morals dictate your policy and therefore your politics.
Good to see you Len. I know exactly what you're talking about. Corporations and Unions have far too much power to influence elections.
I know we've gotten off topic from the title of this article, but Courts are becoming legislatures instead of interpreters. For example in California the people voted to recognize a marriage between a man and a woman, but was over ruled later by basically a judge. Roberts rewrote the Constitution and for the first time in history Americans were required to pay a Federal tax for not buying something.
I don't want 9 Obamas nor do I want 9 Ted Cruz either.
LOL Randy, I'm sure you would be thrilled not understanding the consequences of it.
Our Hidden History of Corporations in the United States
When American colonists declared independence from England in 1776, they also freed themselves from control by English corporations that extracted their wealth and dominated trade. After fighting a revolution to end this exploitation, our country's founders retained a healthy fear of corporate power and wisely limited corporations exclusively to a business role. Corporations were forbidden from attempting to influence elections, public policy, and other realms of civic society.
Initially, the privilege of incorporation was granted selectively to enable activities that benefited the public, such as construction of roads or canals. Enabling shareholders to profit was seen as a means to that end.
The states also imposed conditions (some of which remain on the books, though unused) like these:
* Corporate charters (licenses to exist) were granted for a limited time and could be revoked promptly for violating laws.
* Corporations could engage only in activities necessary to fulfill their chartered purpose.
* Corporations could not own stock in other corporations nor own any property that was not essential to fulfilling their chartered purpose.
* Corporations were often terminated if they exceeded their authority or caused public harm.
* Owners and managers were responsible for criminal acts committed on the job.
* Corporations could not make any political or charitable contributions nor spend money to influence law-making.
For 100 years after the American Revolution, legislators maintained tight controll of the corporate chartering process. Because of widespread public opposition, early legislators granted very few corporate charters, and only after debate. Citizens governed corporations by detailing operating conditions not just in charters but also in state constitutions and state laws. Incorporated businesses were prohibited from taking any action that legislators did not specifically allow.
States also limited corporate charters to a set number of years. Unless a legislature renewed an expiring charter, the corporation was dissolved and its assets were divided among shareholders. Citizen authority clauses limited capitalization, debts, land holdings, and sometimes, even profits. They required a company's accounting books to be turned over to a legislature upon request. The power of large shareholders was limited by scaled voting, so that large and small investors had equal voting rights. Interlocking directorates were outlawed. Shareholders had the right to remove directors at will.
In Europe, charters protected directors and stockholders from liability for debts and harms caused by their corporations. American legislators explicitly rejected this corporate shield. The penalty for abuse or misuse of the charter was not a plea bargain and a fine, but dissolution of the corporation.
In 1819 the U.S. Supreme Court tried to strip states of this sovereign right by overruling a lower court's decision that allowed New Hampshire to revoke a charter granted to Dartmouth College by King George III. The Court claimed that since the charter contained no revocation clause, it could not be withdrawn. The Supreme Court's attack on state sovereignty outraged citizens. Laws were written or re-written and new state constitutional amendments passed to circumvent the Dartmouth ruling. Over several decades starting in 1844, nineteen states amended their constitutions to make corporate charters subject to alteration or revocation by their legislatures. As late as 1855 it seemed that the Supreme Court had gotten the people's message when in Dodge v. Woolsey it reaffirmed state's powers over "artificial bodies."
But the men running corporations pressed on. Contests over charter were battles to control labor, resources, community rights, and political sovereignty. More and more frequently, corporations were abusing their charters to become conglomerates and trusts. They converted the nation's resources and treasures into private fortunes, creating factory systems and company towns. Political power began flowing to absentee owners, rather than community-rooted enterprises.
The industrial age forced a nation of farmers to become wage earners, and they became fearful of unemployment--a new fear that corporations quickly learned to exploit. Company towns arose. and blacklists of labor organizers and workers who spoke up for their rights became common. When workers began to organize, industrialists and bankers hired private armies to keep them in line. They bought newspapers to paint businessmen as heroes and shape public opinion. Corporations bought state legislators, then announced legislators were corrupt and said that they used too much of the public's resources to scrutinize every charter application and corporate operation.
Government spending during the Civil War brought these corporations fantastic wealth. Corporate executives paid "borers" to infest Congress and state capitals, bribing elected and appointed officials alike. They pried loose an avalanche of government financial largesse. During this time, legislators were persuaded to give corporations limited liability, decreased citizen authority over them, and extended durations of charters. Attempts were made to keep strong charter laws in place, but with the courts applying legal doctrines that made protection of corporations and corporate property the center of constitutional law, citizen sovereignty was undermined. As corporations grew stronger, government and the courts became easier prey. They freely reinterpreted the U.S. Constitution and transformed common law doctrines.
One of the most severe blows to citizen authority arose out of the 1886 Supreme Court case of Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad . Though the court did not make a ruling on the question of " corporate personhood ," thanks to misleading notes of a clerk, the decision subsequently was used as precedent to hold that a corporation was a "natural person."
From that point on, the 14th Amendment, enacted to protect rights of freed slaves, was used routinely to grant corporations constitutional "personhood." Justices have since struck down hundreds of local, state and federal laws enacted to protect people from corporate harm based on this illegitimate premise. Armed with these "rights," corporations increased control over resources, jobs, commerce, politicians, even judges and the law.
A United States Congressional committee concluded in 1941, "The principal instrument of the concentration of economic power and wealth has been the corporate charter with unlimited power...."
Many U.S.-based corporations are now transnational, but the corrupted charter remains the legal basis for their existence. At ReclaimDemocracy.org, we believe citizens can reassert the convictions of our nation's founders who struggled successfully to free us from corporate rule in the past. These changes must occur at the most fundamental level -- the U.S. Constitution.
Thanks to our friends at the Program on Corporations, Law and Democracy ( POCLAD ) for their permission to use excerpts of their research for this article. Please visit our Corporate Personhood page for a huge library of articles exploring this topic more deeply. You might also be interested to read our proposed Constitutional Amendments to revoke illegitimate corporate power, erode the power of money over elections, and establish an affirmative constitutional right to vote.That is the bottom line, unfortunately.
I think that RIO expressed what I was trying to say well here:
Executive orders are dicey, but they are subject to judicial reveiw... that would be SCOTUS and major orders are under legislative review. Now I understand your concern about Obama, but given that he has just lost the bulk of that power... I would say he has his limitations.
Where did I ever say that we don't need a supreme court? Our checks and balances would be gone. And I have spent some time before responding to you about whether or not Obama could nullify a SCOTUS ruling against an executive order and it appears that he can't do that. That is one of the things they do to keep checks and balances.
It is "Citizens United", because free speech was supposed to be for individuals and what Citizens United did was give it to large bodies.
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission , No. 08-205 , 558 U.S. 310 (2010), is a U.S. constitutional law case dealing with the regulation of campaign spending by organizations. The United States Supreme Court held that the First Amendment prohibited the government from restricting independent political expenditures by a nonprofit corporation . The principles articulated by the Supreme Court in the case have also been extended to for-profit corporations , labor unions and other associations .
These are not individuals, Robert... no matter how you like to couch it.
More like a G-GILF
Which one does it for you kinky fish? Blanche? That seems too obvious... Betty White? Bea Arthur with her huge shoulder pads? Or was Sofia more your style?
LMAO Miss!
Robert,
You must have missed the preamble:
We the Peopleof the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
The People... not corporations, organizations or unions... the people. Those bodies are not people. And by giving it to these large bodies, removed the power of the people. It doesn't benefit you, or me so why do you like it so?
Robert,
I like to look at facts... not fear. So I looked up the executive orders from past presidents....
Theodore Roosevelt 1,081
William Howard Taft 724
Woodrow Wilson 1,803
Warren G. Harding 522
Calvin Coolidge 1,203
Herbert Hoover 968
Franklin D. Roosevelt 3,522
Harry S. Truman 907
Dwight D. Eisenhower 484
John F. Kennedy 214
Lyndon B. Johnson 325
Richard Nixon 346
Gerald R. Ford 169
Jimmy Carter 320
Ronald Reagan 381
George H. W. Bush 166
William J. Clinton 364
George W. Bush 291
Barack Obama 194
The Republic still stands.
Reply by Perrie Halpern yesterday
Robert,
While this is true about Ginsburg, it has not been true of other justices. She is the exception and not the rule. And I doubt in today's atmosphere of partisanship she would clear the Senate, but there is no way to prove or disprove that.
Thanks 1st for clearing that up!
No it isn't and as for the limits... all of this is subjective...