Tired of reading BS/slanted ferguson articles? Here are the actual facts and evidence of the Michael Brown Ferguson case. Grand jury and witness testimonies.
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Tired of reading BS/slanted ferguson articles? Here are the actual facts and evidence of the Michael Brown Ferguson case. Grand jury and witness testimonies.
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: 96ws6 • 12 years ago • 37 comments
Is it still, you still stay with the fact that Michael Brown had his hands up and was charging?
Sergeant: Thats what Darren told me he was charging at me.
Thanks for highlighting unscrupulous behavior by the prosecutor. Or maybe the question was simply poorly asked. The question is actually compound in that it ask the witness to confirm two separate things in one question, namely that he had his hands up and that he charged. An unwary witness may simply say yes thinking he's only answering one question. Here the officer only agrees that Wilson told him that Brown charged him.
Really though who cares? The operative fact is that he charged a police officer who he had already tried to kill, where his hands are is irrelevant if he was charging at Wilson. The state has the burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Wilson wasn't afraid for his life when he shot Brown. Charging at the police officer makes that impossible to overcome.
The second discrepancy is even less relevant. If that's the best you can do, this case is even more open and shut than I presumed. You realize its possible to still hear things even if you aren't close enough to hear distinct words. Sounds vary.
The operative fact is that he charged a police officer who he had already tried to kill, where his hands are is irrelevant if he was charging at Wilson.
Sean, do you know the distance between Brown and Wilson and the number of shots fired from the distance when the alleged "charge" began?
Note: Like Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown was unavailable to testify regarding the events leading to his death.
The question is how far apart they were when Wilson started to shoot. How far from the car doesn't really matter because everyone seems to agree that Wilson chased him for some distance.
How close to do you have to let someone who already tried to kill you seconds before get to you before you are allowed to defend yourself?
That has not been established as there was no real cross-examination by the "prosecution."
Again, Michael Brown was unable to attend the GJ "investigation."
And the only witness account cited by McCullough on Monday night was the one that corroborated Wilson's. That witness (#10) changed his story from the first account he offered a day or two after the killing and when he gave it to the GJ.
Asking rhetorical questions based upon what you cannot possibly know is tragically and outrageously characteristic of many who have run with the orchestrated path to no-indictment.
The purpose of this post is that people can view the facts and evidence of the case and not rely on completely biased statements from people like Sharpton. But thank you for another biased contribution. I really think it wouldn't make a difference if this went to trial and the outcome was the same. Somehow, I think we may actually find out.
There are parallel investigations still on-going, investigations in which a "prosecutor" doesn't rig the game and act in the defense of the suspect.
You know I think this may actually go to court again. However, I highly doubt the outcome will be different in any respect. He will still not be prosecuted, People will still shout RIGGED, and the riots will happen all over again.
The AP reported on the witness inconsistencies:But Johnson also declared on TV, in a clip played for the grand jury, that Wilson fired at least one shot at his friend while Brown was running away: "It struck my friend in the back."Johnson held to a variation of this description in his grand jury testimony, saying the shot caused Brown's body to "do like a jerking movement, not to where it looked like he got hit in his back, but I knew, it maybe could have grazed him, but he definitely made a jerking movement."Other eyewitness accounts also were clearly wrong.One woman, who said she was smoking a cigarette with a friend nearby, claimed she saw a second police officer in the passenger seat of Wilson's vehicle. When quizzed by a prosecutor, she elaborated: The officer was white, "middle age or young" and in uniform. She said she was positive there was a second officer even though there was not.Another woman testified that she saw Brown leaning through the officer's window "from his navel up," with his hand moving up and down, as if he were punching the officer. But when the same witness returned to testify again on another day, she said she suffers from mental disorder, has racist views and that she has trouble distinguishing the truth from things she had read online.Prosecutors suggested the woman had fabricated the entire incident and was not even at the scene the day of the shooting.Another witness had told the FBI after the shooting that he saw Wilson shoot Brown in the back and then stand over his prone body to finish him off. But in his grand jury testimony, this witness, acknowledged that he had not seen that part of the shooting, and that what he told the FBI was "based on me being where I'm from, and that can be the only assumption that I have."The witness, who lives in the predominantly black neighborhood where Brown was killed, also acknowledged that he changed his story to fit details of the autopsy that he had learned about on TV."So it was after you learned that the things you said you saw couldn't have happened that way, then you changed your story about what you seen?" a prosecutor asserted."Yeah, to coincide with what really happened," the witness replied.Another man, describing himself as a friend of Brown's, told a federal investigator that he heard the first gunshot, looked out his window and saw an officer with a gun drawn and Brown "on his knees with his hands in the air." He added: "I seen him shoot him in the head."But when later pressed by the investigator, the friend said he had not seen the actual shooting because he was walking down the stairs at the time and instead had heard details from someone in the apartment complex."What you are saying you saw isn't forensically possible based on the evidence," the investigator told the friend.Shortly after that, the friend asked if he could leave."I ain't feeling comfortable," he said....
And the prosecutor discredited her before the grand jury. The prosecutor's actions certainly don't fit with your rigged inquiry theory. They clearly didn't want the jury to rely on her testimony.
I can't speak as to what right wing websites believe, but it's clear the prosecutor did not believe the witness's story and informed the jury she was making the story up.After reading her full testimony, I find it hard to believe the grand jury gave it any weight. She's obviously a very troubled woman.
The GJ procedure was biased as well; it was unorthodox to say the least, rife with conflict-of-interests and was allowed to become a forum for demonizing the victim much like the Zimmerman case.
I'm not sure to whom you thank for "another biased contribution," but I back every position I take and invite rebuttal on a point-for-point basis.
Anyone who thinks the GJ "investigation" is conclusive is misinformed; anyone who believes the GJ established innocence or guilt which it did not establish, and, which is not the function of a GJ, is hoping for a particular outcome and not an open and fair procedure. That's what a TRIAL is intended to do and that's what a flawed GJ procedure prevented.
Some witnesses said Michael Brown had been shot in the back. Another said he was face-down on the ground when Officer Darren Wilson "finished him off." Still others acknowledged changing their stories to fit published details about the autopsy or admitted that they did not see the shooting at all.
An Associated Press review of thousands of pages of grand jury documents reveals numerous examples of statements made during the shooting investigation that were inconsistent, fabricated or provably wrong. For one, the autopsies ultimately showed Brown was not struck by any bullets in his back.
I was thanking John for his Sharpton post. As you have pointed out, we may see a trial yet. I really do doubt the outcome will be different. This is a case with conflicting eye witnesses testimonies and evidence...enough for "reasonable doubt" IMO. The purpose of the seed was to provide ONLY facts and evidence for people to make their decision on. The same facts the jury were presented. I thought this prudent given the multitude of articles offering slanted opinion and speculation.
Of course its in the law ... the right to self defense .
The officer must have a REASONABLE that his life is in danger. That's the law.
Its a legal loophole where police officers are given basically carte blanche if they say that they have a reasonable fear that their life is in danger "
Police officer with a gun vs. an unarmed individual.
And in your opinion, obviously the fear in Officer Wilson's mind was not reasonable, but in the opinion of the grand jury the fear was reasonable.
Pesky things those opinions
Hypothetically, if an indictment had been returned and the supporters of Officer Wilson had complained, I wonder if the grand jury process would have been defended by all of those who are not attacking it.
As always, Robert G tries to mitigate the murder of one by reminding us of the murder of others; his compassion for the victimized minority children of America is touching, albeit selectively shared with us at times when it diverts from the Wilson/Zimmerman things.
And he never mentions the illegally obtained guns used in the black-on-black murders he so deeply loathes, and he likewise never mentions the efforts made in those black communities by its residents who rail against the murderers, the guns, the drugs, to curtail such things. Neither does he note the permanent underclass status of their neighborhoods due to the agendas of unsympathetic right-wing politicians owned by the 1%, nor does he remind us of the fact that black communities are populated with the same kinds of caring families as in white communities.
I have often reminded Robert G that no reasonable person looks the other way on any unjustified taking of a life each loss is a human tragedy.
But Robert G plays his crocodile-tears game like it was fantasy football; he points to the "scoreboard," and insidiously implies, that because there is black-on-black murder, I and others are somehow misguided in REMINDING AMERICA THAT THERE IS A SICKENING, ALARMING INCREASE IN WHITE POLICE OFFICERS AND VIGILANTE WANT-TO-BE TYPES THAT KILL UNARMED BLACK KIDS AND WALK FREE BECAUSE OF A RACIST SYSTEM.
Robert G, the prisons are filled with blacks who kill other blacks and commit all of the same kinds of crimes committed by whites THAT FUCKING FAIL TO BE INDICTED BY A RIGGED SYSTEM
as long as you're keeping score.
TO QUANTIFY ANY UNJUSTIFIED DEATHS SO AS TO MAKE ANY ONE APPEAR MORE JUSTIFIED THAN ANOTHER IS ONE REASON WHY WE DON'T SEEM TO BE GETTING TO SOLUTIONS.
Same response; no one has tried to make Michael Brown a hero just to allow him to be the victim he was.
Your intentional mischaracterization is consistent with the leaks coming from the GJ (police, etc.) attempting to make the victim's life not worth sparing.
My viewpoint is consistent with the findings of the grand jury.
Both of which are tainted as previously explained in detail.
Until then, the only thing I knew was that Michael Brown was an out of control mugger, who acted on whatever impulse popped into his head. Without any influence on him as to whether the impulse was right or wrong. Or intelligent.
You don't know that as also has been previously explained in detail.
But hey. We all have our heroes.
And yours appear to be the racial profilers who kill unarmed minorities.
And let's deal with the canard of "black-on-black" crime which falsely concludes that such crimes are racially motivated or somehow an indicator of an inherent racial characteristic/behavior.
Most crimes are crimes of opportunity, that is, the perpetrators and victims live, work etc. in a close proximity situation. An all or mostly black neighborhood will obviously have black perpetrators and black victims BUT THOSE CRIMES ARE NOT MOTIVATED OR PRECIPITATED BY RACIAL PROFILING!
Zimmerman/Trayvon Martin and Wilson Michael Brown and the shitload of other such murders happening in America ARE RACIAL PROFILING CASES !
Agreed, the majority of black murder victims are murdered by blacks, but the same holds true for whites: Most whites are murdered by whites. And in both cases, this race statistic is not available for all murders, but only ones where the race of both perpetrator and victim can be determined.
from 1976 to 2005, 94 percent of black victims were killed by black offenders, but that racial exclusivity was also true for white victims of violent crime -- 86 percent were killed by white offenders. Indeed, for the large majority of crimes, you'll find that victims and offenders share a racial identity, or have some prior relationship to each other.
The point is that black lives only matter if they are taken by white and thus politely exploitable. Most of the people who profess to be so upset about mike brown don't even spend a second worrying about why so many innocent black kids are violently killed. Instead they focus all of their energy on the black swan events of a white killing a black, even when those killings are arguably justifiable.The lesson to be learned from the obsessive focus on these rare events is that black lives matter to progressives, but only if they are taken by white men.
The point is that black lives only matter if they are taken by white and thus politely exploitable.Most of the people who profess to be so upset about mike brown don't even spend a second worrying about why so many innocent black kids are violently killed.
That's not a point all; that's the racist canard, hyperbole, a pronouncement, a broad-brush indictment that diverts from what's true.
If one hasn't been in any of these black communities (and I don't mean driving through on the way from one white neighborhood to another, or, hauling one's white ass from the suburbs to buy one's illegal drugs), and clearly, anyone who buys Sean's assessment has not, then they comfort their zeal-without-knowledge bigotry with such statements.
The lesson to be learned from the obsessive focus on these rare events is that black lives matter to progressives, but only if they are taken by white men.
Where TF did you decide that such a POS generalization constitutes reality, Sean?
Wait, I think I know.
"I'm not racist! I'll be the first to say it, it's not their fault they're colored!"--Archie Bunker
I was terrified. I thought I was going to be beaten up for hours, said the 17-year-old girl, while wearing a neck brace. July 17, 2014 by Site Staff in News
I opened the door and there were these policemen standing there pointing a gun that looked like one you use to shoot elephants. July 7, 2014 by Site Staff in History
If one black person deaths is so important then all black persons deaths should be important.
That's what I wrote and more than once.
To say it is only when a white kills a black is it important enough to be brought to the forefront is BS. And is racist.
Who said that?
Seeing death day in and day out, being there in the mix of it all will show one that all life irregardless of color, or origin is precious.
You're essentially quoting what I've written any number of times.
My on-going objection is to the citing of murders in black communities by certain individuals ONLY WHEN A STORY ABOUT A WHITE COP/WANNABE KILLS AN UNARMED BLACK KID, and that to focus away from police profiling.
Before you misquote or mischaracterize my meanings, you need to read what I have actually written.
Give it up John - the GJ made their decision - Wilson is not guilty.
Give it up.
I learned that a new slant on peaceful and productive protests to affect social change is
"Burn the Bitch Down"
Is it still, you still stay with the fact that Michael Brown had his hands up and was charging?
Sergeant: Thats what Darren told me he was charging at me.
Thanks for highlighting unscrupulous behavior by the prosecutor. Or maybe the question was simply poorly asked. The question is actually compound in that it ask the witness to confirm two separate things in one question, namely that he had his hands up and that he charged. An unwary witness may simply say yes thinking he's only answering one question. Here the officer only agrees that Wilson told him that Brown charged him.
Really though who cares? The operative fact is that he charged a police officer who he had already tried to kill, where his hands are is irrelevant if he was charging at Wilson. The state has the burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Wilson wasn't afraid for his life when he shot Brown. Charging at the police officer makes that impossible to overcome.
The second discrepancy is even less relevant. If that's the best you can do, this case is even more open and shut than I presumed. You realize its possible to still hear things even if you aren't close enough to hear distinct words. Sounds vary.
That is incorrect 1st; the grand jury does not decide innocence or guilt, rather whether or not it believes there's enough evidence to indict.
There are parallel investigations still on-going, investigations in which a "prosecutor" doesn't rig the game and act in the defense of the suspect.
You should know
The Wilson witness who corroborates the 'charge' claim, wrote racist journal entries
National Bar Association calls for federal charges against Darren Wilson
The questions no one asked St. Louis prosecutor Bob McCulloch
Let's put the no indictment into numerical context
Darren Wilson, perfect and sweet vs. the big black demonic super monster
Sean, do you know the distance between Brown and Wilson and the number of shots fired from the distance when the alleged "charge" began?
Note: Like Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown was unavailable to testify regarding the events leading to his death.
How close to do you have to let someone who already tried to kill you seconds before get to you before you are allowed to defend yourself? .
The question is how far apart they were when Wilson started to shoot. How far from the car doesn't really matter because everyone seems to agree that Wilson chased him for some distance.
That has not been established as there was no real cross-examination by the "prosecution."
Again, Michael Brown was unable to attend the GJ "investigation."
And the only witness account cited by McCullough on Monday night was the one that corroborated Wilson's. That witness (#10) changed his story from the first account he offered a day or two after the killing and when he gave it to the GJ.
Asking rhetorical questions based upon what you cannot possibly know is tragically and outrageously characteristic of many who have run with the orchestrated path to no-indictment.
Read the witness accounts.
Brutal and effective, even if not very civil.
Read the witness accounts.
Anyone on the GJ or in the "prosecutor's" office call for polygraph analyses of Wilson and witnesses?
The purpose of this post is that people can view the facts and evidence of the case and not rely on completely biased statements from people like Sharpton. But thank you for another biased contribution. I really think it wouldn't make a difference if this went to trial and the outcome was the same. Somehow, I think we may actually find out.
You know I think this may actually go to court again. However, I highly doubt the outcome will be different in any respect. He will still not be prosecuted, People will still shout RIGGED, and the riots will happen all over again.
He's guilty John - he's guilty.
Feel better?
The GJ procedure was biased as well; it was unorthodox to say the least, rife with conflict-of-interests and was allowed to become a forum for demonizing the victim much like the Zimmerman case.
I'm not sure to whom you thank for "another biased contribution," but I back every position I take and invite rebuttal on a point-for-point basis.
Anyone who thinks the GJ "investigation" is conclusive is misinformed; anyone who believes the GJ established innocence or guilt which it did not establish, and, which is not the function of a GJ, is hoping for a particular outcome and not an open and fair procedure. That's what a TRIAL is intended to do and that's what a flawed GJ procedure prevented.
Looting is wrong a crime inexcusable.
We get it.
So is murder that is swept under the rug by a corrupt system.
Your joy is palpable, your commentary, adolescent and Nugent-like.
Read the transcript.
Anyone who physically attacks an on-duty cop has basically signed his own death warrant . It is our tradition in the US .
Of course its in the law ... the right to self defense . Too bad you don't believe in that . It is part of western tradition , especially in the US .
Of course it was :
Some witnesses said Michael Brown had been shot in the back. Another said he was face-down on the ground when Officer Darren Wilson "finished him off." Still others acknowledged changing their stories to fit published details about the autopsy or admitted that they did not see the shooting at all.
An Associated Press review of thousands of pages of grand jury documents reveals numerous examples of statements made during the shooting investigation that were inconsistent, fabricated or provably wrong. For one, the autopsies ultimately showed Brown was not struck by any bullets in his back.
I'm tired of reading BS/slanted ferguson articles.
AMAC
I was thanking John for his Sharpton post. As you have pointed out, we may see a trial yet. I really do doubt the outcome will be different. This is a case with conflicting eye witnesses testimonies and evidence...enough for "reasonable doubt" IMO. The purpose of the seed was to provide ONLY facts and evidence for people to make their decision on. The same facts the jury were presented. I thought this prudent given the multitude of articles offering slanted opinion and speculation.
Seconded!
Thirded.
The officer must have a REASONABLE that his life is in danger. That's the law.
Police officer with a gun vs. an unarmed individual.
Who has the reasonable fear?
Thanks for the clarification 96.
A Mac
I understand your point
And in your opinion, obviously the fear in Officer Wilson's mind was not reasonable, but in the opinion of the grand jury the fear was reasonable.
Pesky things those opinions
Hypothetically, if an indictment had been returned and the supporters of Officer Wilson had complained, I wonder if the grand jury process would have been defended by all of those who are not attacking it.
Interesting to wonder about that
As always, Robert G tries to mitigate the murder of one by reminding us of the murder of others; his compassion for the victimized minority children of America is touching, albeit selectively shared with us at times when it diverts from the Wilson/Zimmerman things.
And he never mentions the illegally obtained guns used in the black-on-black murders he so deeply loathes, and he likewise never mentions the efforts made in those black communities by its residents who rail against the murderers, the guns, the drugs, to curtail such things. Neither does he note the permanent underclass status of their neighborhoods due to the agendas of unsympathetic right-wing politicians owned by the 1%, nor does he remind us of the fact that black communities are populated with the same kinds of caring families as in white communities.
I have often reminded Robert G that no reasonable person looks the other way on any unjustified taking of a life each loss is a human tragedy.
But Robert G plays his crocodile-tears game like it was fantasy football; he points to the "scoreboard," and insidiously implies, that because there is black-on-black murder, I and others are somehow misguided in REMINDING AMERICA THAT THERE IS A SICKENING, ALARMING INCREASE IN WHITE POLICE OFFICERS AND VIGILANTE WANT-TO-BE TYPES THAT KILL UNARMED BLACK KIDS AND WALK FREE BECAUSE OF A RACIST SYSTEM.
Robert G, the prisons are filled with blacks who kill other blacks and commit all of the same kinds of crimes committed by whites THAT FUCKING FAIL TO BE INDICTED BY A RIGGED SYSTEM
as long as you're keeping score.
TO QUANTIFY ANY UNJUSTIFIED DEATHS SO AS TO MAKE ANY ONE APPEAR MORE JUSTIFIED THAN ANOTHER IS ONE REASON WHY WE DON'T SEEM TO BE GETTING TO SOLUTIONS.
The game is rigged.
Same response; no one has tried to make Michael Brown a hero just to allow him to be the victim he was.
Your intentional mischaracterization is consistent with the leaks coming from the GJ (police, etc.) attempting to make the victim's life not worth sparing.
Both of which are tainted as previously explained in detail.
You don't know that as also has been previously explained in detail.
And yours appear to be the racial profilers who kill unarmed minorities.
Indeed.
And let's deal with the canard of "black-on-black" crime which falsely concludes that such crimes are racially motivated or somehow an indicator of an inherent racial characteristic/behavior.
Most crimes are crimes of opportunity, that is, the perpetrators and victims live, work etc. in a close proximity situation. An all or mostly black neighborhood will obviously have black perpetrators and black victims BUT THOSE CRIMES ARE NOT MOTIVATED OR PRECIPITATED BY RACIAL PROFILING!
Zimmerman/Trayvon Martin and Wilson Michael Brown and the shitload of other such murders happening in America ARE RACIAL PROFILING CASES !
Agreed, the majority of black murder victims are murdered by blacks, but the same holds true for whites: Most whites are murdered by whites. And in both cases, this race statistic is not available for all murders, but only ones where the race of both perpetrator and victim can be determined.
That's not a point all; that's the racist canard, hyperbole, a pronouncement, a broad-brush indictment that diverts from what's true.
If one hasn't been in any of these black communities (and I don't mean driving through on the way from one white neighborhood to another, or, hauling one's white ass from the suburbs to buy one's illegal drugs), and clearly, anyone who buys Sean's assessment has not, then they comfort their zeal-without-knowledge bigotry with such statements.
Where TF did you decide that such a POS generalization constitutes reality, Sean?
Wait, I think I know.
Wow! Talk about backing up a contention, validation, verification, specific examples you should give it a try.
The real lesson to be learned is that those who prefer profiling and stereotyping to fact
have lessons to be learned.
That's what I wrote and more than once.
Who said that?
You're essentially quoting what I've written any number of times.
My on-going objection is to the citing of murders in black communities by certain individuals ONLY WHEN A STORY ABOUT A WHITE COP/WANNABE KILLS AN UNARMED BLACK KID, and that to focus away from police profiling.
Before you misquote or mischaracterize my meanings, you need to read what I have actually written.
Without your realizing it, you and I agree.
That's your read into my comments
Here's one of the comments to which I refer I've written such comments many times
...
If I put certain comments in laymen's terms, I'd likely be asked to prove them by citing the legalese can't win some days, Gunny.