╌>

No Laws Broken - Justice Dept. Says Hillary Clinton Had Legal Authority To Delete E-Mails

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  18 comments

No Laws Broken - Justice Dept. Says Hillary Clinton Had Legal Authority To Delete E-Mails

hillary-clinton-econy-speech.jpg?resize=485%2C367

"Reality has bitten Republicans in the backsides again as the Justice Department is saying that Hillary Clintons emails broke no laws.

Justice Department lawyers argued before a federal court that Hillary Clintons handling of her emails broke no laws.

The Washington Times reported :

In the most complete legal defense of Mrs. Clinton, Justice Department lawyers insisted they not only have no obligation, but no power, to go back and demand the former top diplomat turn over any documents she hasnt already given and neither, they said, can the court order that.

The defense came as part of a legal filing telling a judge why the administration shouldnt be required to order Mrs. Clinton and her top aides to preserve all of their emails.

There is no question that Secretary Clinton had authority to delete personal emails without agency supervision she appropriately could have done so even if she were working on a government server, the administration lawyers argued. Under policies issued by both the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) and the State Department, individual officers and employees are permitted and expected to exercise judgment to determine what constitutes a federal record.

Republicans like Donald Trump love to compare Hillary Clintons emails to the crimes that were committed by David Petraeus, but the difference is that Petraeus broke the law by giving classified materials to his mistress.

The Republican email scandal is falling apart. If Clinton didnt break any laws, why are Republicans wasting time and millions of taxpayer dollars investigating her emails? There is a reason Republicans would not allow Clintons aides to testify in public. Information is the enemy of the GOPs bogus email scandal. The more information that is available to the public, the sooner the email scandal will fade away.

The email scandal is a media fueled time killer that only serves to distract attention from the real issues. Republicans dont want to talk about their positions on the issues. They would rather try to distract the electorate with meaningless scandals.

Republicans cant hide from the truth. There is nothing to the Hillary Clinton email scandal."

http://www.politicususa.com/2015/09/11/hillary-clinton-email-scandal-crumbles-justice-department-laws-broken.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Not too long, Clinton's enemies and the irresponsible media were howling about the nerve Clinton had, and the "illegality" involved in deleting e-mails from the system she used to conduct government business. They wanted to string her up for that aspect alone.

Today, when she is cleared on those counts by the Justice Dept. of the United States, it barely makes the news.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I'm sorry. I missed the part where the Judge said it's okay to send and store classified email on a private server? Do you think that might be an issue? Funny this silly partisan blog brings up the petrues case when the DOJ brief has nothing to do with classified material.

Of course you can delete private emails from a private server. No one has claimed otherwise. The issue with the deletions is that no one believes her when she said she only deleted private emails. Since she took so much care to wipe the only server she used to conduct government business, no one will ever know if she was honest.

Given her record of destroying and hiding docs (Rose Law Firm) only a fool would believe she acted in good faith.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

One down and one to go. When she is cleared of the rest of the "charges" you will have your whine in place on that day too. No doubt.

No one expects this to ever go away. It is Benghazi Too.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
John's liberal source has no idea what it's talking about. The DOJ said absolutely nothing about exonerating her for sending and recieving classiifed email on her home server. Their filing of a brief, which is all this "story" is, doesn't address the classified information issue on an unsecure private server at all.
 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

I am not responsible for anyone's lack of reading comprehension, lol.

Stick together though boys, you are going to need it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

lol. I know what I seeded Woodie.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

As Sean points out, this article only repeats the argument that the Justice Department put in its brief. It is not a ruling from the federal District Court that the Justice Department is right. Judicial Watch deserves a lot of credit for basically smoking Hillary out of a hole when even Congress was unable to do it. After all, we only know about the private server because Judicial Watch filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit.

Judicial Watch has recently filed an FOIA lawsuit against the State Department for failing to comply with a separate FOIA request. According to the complaint, it is seeking information regarding Brian Pagliano's activities. Pagliano may be able to get away with taking the 5th before Congress but Judicial Watch took an alternative approach by seeking government records pertaining to him. As background, the Complaint notes that Pagliano was the Clinton campaign's IT director up until he got a job at the State Department in 2009 as an IT specialist. They want information pertaining to his hiring, his travel records to and from Chappaqua NY, his time-sheets, calendars, and emails to and from Clinton. Why? From reading on the website, Judicial Watch is arguing or intends to argue that Clinton HAD NO private email server if the State Department used public money to pay a government employee to maintain it.

In other lawsuits, Judicial Watch takes a position contrary to the Justice Department and argues that personal emails on a government system cannot be simply deleted or removed without violating State Department rules specifying that a presidential appointee must first submit the "records" for an independent review. In my opinion, the Justice Department's argument that Clinton has unfettered authority to determine what constitutes a "record" and then delete it on her own, completely eviscerates the State Department requirement for an independent review before removing or destroying it.

Apparently, Judicial Watch has some big news that it plans to announce on Monday regarding Hillary's emails and I doubt they plan on capitulating.

I guess I need to make a financial contribution to Judicial Watch.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

The Justice Dept is the entity that would prosecute Clinton and they say they have no basis for going forward on the issue of the deletion of the e mails. Maybe you or Sean will be appointed special prosecutor by President Obama , lol.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

The Justice Dept is the entity that would prosecute Clinton and they say they have no basis for going forward on the issue of the deletion of the e mails. Maybe you or Sean will be appointed special prosecutor by President Obama , lol

I think you're reading more into the caption of your article than is warranted by the text. The Justice Department didn't make a blanket statement that no laws were broken. All the Justice Department said was that, in their view, Clinton didn't break the law by deleting or removing her personal emails and that neither the Department nor the court can make her produce them. These arguments are taking place in the context of a civil FOIA lawsuit not a criminal action. The Justice Department was not talking about government information on Clinton's server at all or whether her handling of it broke any law. The court is free to disagree with the Justice Department on the question of personal emails and order Clinton to produce them.

There are a number of FOIA actions going on at the same time trying to pry information out of Clinton and the goverment. With regard to government information, District Judge Sullivan has expressed a view that Clinton violated State Department policy by keeping government information on a private server and directed the Justice department to produce information. To my understanding, that Judge wasn't addressing personal emails.

The problem in Clinton's case, highlighted in a number of FOIA lawsuits, is that she used a personal account, had no government account, and the State Department either authorized it or was complicit in it. Judicial Watch is arguing that, under these circumstances, the account cannot be considered personal. Judicial Watch is focused solely on getting information. The Court could determine that the question of whether Hillary broke any law is legally irrelevant to the question of whether the server is a de facto device for housing public records and order her to produce the emails (perhaps for independent review as required by Department regulations).

All of this doesn't devolve into a witch hunt because the Justice department makes an argument on a narrow issue in one FOIA case.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

I am well aware the DOJ statement refers only to the deletion of emails. I said so on this thread. This is all going to come down to whether or not Clinton "knowingly" sent or stored classified e-mails. No one will be able to prove this either way, it appears. She is not going to be indicted.

She is testifying before Congress about this in about a month, everyone should just keep their pants on until then.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

Initially you said:

Not too long, Clinton's enemies and the irresponsible media were howling about the nerve Clinton had, and the "illegality" involved in deleting e-mails from the system she used to conduct government business. They wanted to string her up for that aspect alone. Today, when she is cleared on those counts by the Justice Dept. of the United States, it barely makes the news.

I see nothing here that makes a distinction between personal and government emails. In fact, it appears to conflate the two and then declare that the Justice Department has found no culpability in either case simply by making an argument in a brief relating solely to an FOIA lawsuit. As long as you agree that your article or the Justice Department's argument has no logical or legal bearing on Clinton's handling of public emails, then fine by me.

 
 

Who is online












83 visitors