Mapping The Market For Sex
New report details Minneapolis trade in Native flesh by mary annette pember
Seventy-five percent of juvenile sextrafficking cases in Minneapolis, Minnesota
in 2013 involved Native Americanvictims even though Native people make
up just two percent of the citys population,a new study has found.
The study, Mapping the Market forSex with Trafficked Minor Girls in Minneapolis:
Structures, Functions and Patterns,dissects the multi-level criminal
enterprise that targets primarily young,vulnerable girls of color from poor
neighborhoods. The study was recentlyspotlighted by Minnesota Public Radio
(MPR).
The reports two lead researchers, LaurenMartin and Sandi Pierce, chose not
to focus on statistics. Rather, they emphasizedthe patterns and contours of
sex trafficking.
Martin and Pierce examined court andpolice data from 2008 to 2013 and gathered
anecdotal information from adultsources working directly with prostituted
and trafficked youth. Researchersfrom the University of Minnesotas
Urban Research Outreach-EngagementCenter and Othayonih Research worked
in cooperation with the Womens Foundationof Minnesota to create the report.
Among the findings were these:
Higher income white men representonly a slightly higher percentage of
johns. Buyers cut across all ethnicand income levels.
Facilitators (pimps) are mostly AfricanAmerican, Native American
and multi-racial males. They oftenshare similar backgrounds of their
victims. There is evidence they mayalso have been victims of abuse.
Native American facilitators andbuyers tend to be much closer in
age to their victims than African-American and Latino men.
Facilitators are often peer girls whoare rewarded by their pimps for
bringing in fresh recruits.
The community sometimes views facilitators as resources. For instance,
gangs often force sex trafficking victims to shoplift cheap luxury items,
the items then being sold at boostersales in low-income neighborhoods. Community members maycome to depend on such sales andturn a blind eye to the gangs other
criminal activities.
http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/sites/default/files/ictweeklynovember192014_0.pdf

Pay particular attention to this FACT -
"Seventy-five percent of juvenile sextrafficking cases in Minneapolis, Minnesota
in 2013 involved Native Americanvictims even though Native people make
up just two percent of the citys population,a new study has found."
This is a sad commentary for the Native peoples in Minnesota, 'specially since they have such a large Indian population - so to speak.
It has been this way for quite some time and can be traced back to the 1950's when Natives were ''forced'' to move from the Rez and surrounding area's to Minneapolis and Duluth to ''assimilate''.
Duluth has one of the worst sex trafficking problems in the country involving Indian women.
What I can't truly believe is the 75% figure. Something is wrong with our Warriors - this should NOT be happening.
No it shouldn't be. The Ojibwe have been fighting this for decades, as has AIM. The history of it is disgusting. Another experiment by the US government that went wrong.
But they don't friggin' quit with the experiments.
Even now there are discussions about how much better off the Indians would be if the reservations were closed and they were made to assimilate.
I personally feel it's just a ploy to take the remaining resources on the reservation lands and flood the abandoned inner city buildings with another ethnic group that can die by the hundreds as they try to claw "territory" out of the concrete jungle. The politicians can demand more federal funds for housing and education for them that somehow never reaches them and the prison systems can demand more funds to build more cages for them as they manage to keep the beds full for the privately managed institutions.
Have you noticed how no one seems to be interested enough in this article to even pretend to be shocked or have any sympathy for the plight of the Native Americans trapped in this situation? Or even to be astounded at the disparity in the percentage that are Native American victims versus the number of them that make up the percentage of the city's population?
We are invisible, as 1stwarrior has often said.
Sadly, one of the largest issues not brought to the surface is the discrimination against the Indian people in those state - and those cities.
Not me. Until you made your comment Mimi, it had been 7 hours ago since 1stwarrior's comment. This is the first time I've seen this.
Let me give you another perspective, if I can. I know in the eastern part of North Carolina where the Lumbee Indians reside for the most part, things have changed quite a bit over the last 20 to 30 years. Meth and other drugs have stolen our youth. Life there and in all honesty the surrounding areas are rampant with it.
The families were closer before, but drugs have invaded the lives of many of our young people like the plague. It's the same with many whites and blacks. I don't know of a family who doesn't have someone, a child, cousin, nephew or niece who isn't involved in drugs.
Don't get me wrong. I know plenty of families who don't have immediate family involved in drugs, but it seems in every extended family there is at least one or two suffering from drug addiction.
I'm not familiar with the area in the article, but I mean Pembroke and all the towns around there are almost entirely Lumbee, so being a minority isn't the reason for their problem. I don't know if they have the sex trafficking problem, but I'm pretty sure they would since they have the heavy duty drug problem.
Back in the old days the elders would come together and straighten someone out who stepped out of line in a community, but it seems that time has come and gone in our society.
Got a real good friend, she's Rappahannock, married to a Lumbee and they're really active in working with the youth. She says the primary problem is from the college folks at Pembroke, coming from out of state, bringing in the drugs, alcohol and sexual abuse. If they could only get the college administrators to step up and help, the issues would be reduced greatly.
RL - go to the link and read the article - it explains pretty well - I think.
This was the ''experiment'' that helped startthe cycle.
The Ojibwe faced growing pressure to leave the rez and migrate to urban areas. A piecemeal experiment began in 1948. Thenfrom 1953 to 1960 , the commissioner of Indians Affairs issued a mandate, supported by congressional funding in 1956. Relocation provided one-way transportation for Indian families to urban areas and rental assistance for the first month relocation. The policy dramatic effects on the Ojibwe in MN. Under the program , thousands of Ojibwe re-located to Minneapolis, St. Paul and Duluth.
Re-location succeeded in moving Indians, but it failed to provide jobs, housing, and other economic opportunities. Indian unemployment in urban areas's were as high as 80 percent. Relocation was abandoned in 1960 for being too expensive, but the damage had been done.
These are my personal notes regarding this ''experiment'' by the government. When we were moved to Duluth, there were no jobs, none for Indians. No matter how educated or skilled you were, you wereIndian and would not get hired, period. We scrambled for a place to live, no one would rent to Indians. No jobs, no place to live, no schools that would accept you. That is the one of many ''government programs'' that helped in the long down hill journey of the Ojibwe.
I could go on, but right now I'm so frickin pissed off that I best stop writing.
The study portrays a glimpse into the underbelly of youth sex-trafficking in America, a "business" generating billions of dollars every year. Unfortunately most people rely on television to know what the hell is going on in our world and are ignorant of the plight of our nation's children. Its projected over 5 million children globally are in the sex-trafficking trade.
From the article: Although researchers found evidence of such clubs across all economic and ethnic groups, they are the preferred venue for white wealthy men. One in- terviewee told the researchers, They (johns) pay for sex like they pay for golf. Sex is what they do with their free time.
Wonder how the headlines would read if wealthy, white girls were being trafficked. For sure we'd have a national crisis! The fact white wealthy men are the majority buying and paying for sex doesn't garner a line in any newspaper.These are our children, America's children and it's about time people wake up and give a shit!
I'm enraged, have been enraged and when I read words like "pay for sex like they pay for golf" I weep. How did we become the self-centered perverse society where even children are thrown away? Is it because most of them are just a part of the "have nots".
Reading your "experiment" notes brings an outrage to my very core and I find no outlet. I grieve for the inhumane treatment of people, the discarding of people and feel so utterly helpless.
I'm sorry is all I have to offer, heartfully sorry that you and so many others have suffered and continue to suffer injustices.
The issue of wealthy white men paying for juvenile sex is not some pipe dream of mine.If you decide to research you'll find doctors, lawyers, professional men whoare sexual predators paying pimps, brothels, and sex clubs.The johns are always the last to be prosecuted and often names are not in the papers since it involves a minor.
How can you discount race or wealth, both of which are addressed in the Minnesota findings.
1stwarrior... I looked at the crime records of a lot of universities. Pembroke is a dangerous school to go to it seems, but it is not alone. I looked at the statistics of many schools and really was amazed at how different it is today compared to when I attended many years ago. I have to say it isn't safe in most and many and I mean many are actually dangerous to attend. Like the University of North Carolina which use to be one of the safest places you could be now has a safety rating of (F). It's hard to believe. Most crimes were burglaries but rapes were right in there as well. I'm afraid our society has gone to hell.
You can view and download the full report here: for those of you who are interested.
When a person is raised believing there is no hope for the future and opportunity to have a comfortable life without struggle (or becomes convinced of that notion at some point in their life) hopelessness sets in and living a noble, rational life means nothing. Hopelessness is crushing - don't expect happiness, because there isn't going to be any. Thrills, luck and trouble are all that is left.
Thank you Aeon - very helpful - sorry I didn't link it.
Absolutely great points and questions are being brought up. Kavika and Grump have hit on two of the primary points that somewhat answer Lynne's questions - and the responses from some of you are helpful.
The two primary points? For thousands of years, the Indian people had very distinct and separate cultures/traditions/heritages - they were, and still are, sovereign nations who could live without interference as they have, again, for thousands of years. With the intro of Euro society, the Indians were all of a sudden - "The Invisible" - peoples to be pushed aside and under the radar. Justice Marshall, in 1823, made it quite clear that we accounted for "nothing" - we were, and still are, designated as "dependent wards" of the U. S. government and that Congress and the Courts could do what they wanted with us - no matter what it was.
We were a people who went from a population of over 89 Million, when the Euro's got here, to a population of 252,000 in the 1900 Census , all in a matter of 300 years. In 1934, Congress passed the Indian Reorganization Act after realizing that the Allotment Act and its policies were f*cked up, to enable the tribes/nations to "redevelop" their governments - to gain back their pride, heritage, traditions, culture, and it was working 'til the late 1940's. As Kavika said, the government then started the Assimilation program in 1953, to again rip the tribes/nations of their "individuality" - reservations disappeared, the "alarm clock, bus ticket, job" program that started in 1956 relocated many of us - but did not give us the jobs as promised, money needed for sustainment and tore our families apart. Over 80,000 Indians "relocated" to the big cities - and immediately became prey to dominant society. Hell, we were "Indians" - we were lower in society than a whale's belly and nobody in dominant society saw anything wrong with that treatment. Hence the inner city poverty, destitution, suicides, alcoholism, drugs, prostitution - anything to try to keeps food on the table - if at all possible.
As Grump said - we have gone from communities of care-takers of our people to a people who have very little, if any, opportunities for advancement on a large number of reservations. The closest school for Pine Ridge that is not a BIA school,is in Rapid City - a 1.5 hours bus ride both ways. The interstate is 72 miles from the rez - to get a job, if you have a car, you have to drive 102 miles ONE WAY - one helluva commute. The people on those rez's have NOTHING that they can rely on. The Feds cut their funding (guaranteed by treaties, mineral rights, rights-of-way leases, etc.), the houses are in worse conditions than ANY of the inner cities - no electricity, plumbing, heating oil, groceries - and the kids look around and see that they are NOTHING in dominant society's eyes, so they turn to - yes, drugs, alcohol, prostitution, sexual abuse, domestic violence, murders (271 unsolved murders last year alone on the rez).
But, what I am amazed at in the study is the 75% figure - how in the hell can society allow that to happen? Is it blatant racism? Discrimination? Power trips? Or just the way dominant society is aligned against Indian people?
I've calmed down from my posting last night...LOL
To answer your question, ''all of the above''. AIM was started in Minneapolis, and one of the main reasons was that discrimination and racism against Natives. There was a time that AIM members, would drive native women to the store, or anywhere they had to go, because they were prey to the dominant society. Police abuse against Indians was out of control.
In many cases it has remained much the same. The ACLU had to put a branch office in northern MN to handle the number of cases that were there. The FBI opened new offices in ND recently because of the crime against Indians. The DOJ has become involved in northern MN because of the racist there.
If you think that ''arrested for walking while Indian'' is some far fetched idea, please let me take you to areas of MN that will cement the fact that this is what is really happening.
I pointed out Minnesota, because I was born and raised there, and still go back once or twice a year and have personally experience it,but don't think that this is the only state in which this happens. It is happening all across the US.
1st mentioned SD, try being an Indian there, it's a whole other world. Or ND, the same thing. NM, AZ, MT, ID etc etc.
Agree my proclamation of wealthy white men goes beyond the scope of the article but nonetheless is true. Much like prostitution in general, you see the round up of street girls and their pimps.....where are the buyers?
Am I biased, probably since life experiences tend to instill biases. Who determined what was "best" for our Indian nations? Certainly not the minorities of our country, it was and continues to be the elite of our country who are predominately white.
The hierarchy of sex-trafficking is evident in every state. The lowest denominator are the children we've turned our backs on, the homeless, abused, drug addicted, unemployed. Up the chain are the facilitators, many of whom are elevated from within the trade. We've now climbed to the pimps, the entrepreneurs and purveyors of this perverse trade, often minorities. Then the top of the food chain, the buyers, who are usuallyinhigher socio-economic groups than the supply side.
Until we target the consumer in this travesty, it will continue to grow as the chasm between the have and have-not continue to grow. IMO
Lynne - when I was stationed in DC, I lived in Glen Burnie, MD,and commuted. Glen Burnie is right next to Baltimore and Annapolis. They have a policy of publishing the names of the "John's" arrested and it is working wonderfully. However, Baltimore and Annapolis don't, and business is thriving.
1st - That's my point, buyers drive the sex-trafficking trade. Every city should publish the names of"johns" ALL "johns" that have contact with our nation's children.They desperately need our help.
Sadly, as you've mentioned, many of the Johns are wealthy - hence there will be no notification because of their "position power".
Elders are no longer allowed to do that in any community the way they used to. In my youth, even the whites and blacks had "elders" that were not blood related who would step in and administer some help to youths that were off track. If they got to them in time it would often help.
Now "the law" says you can be arrested for interfering in "family affairs."
No one listens to "Elders" anymore - at least folks not living on rez's.
Luv it when your "anger" opens up your valves
You are right, 1stwarrior. I can remember my Aunt Irene who was an "elder" even when I was very young, living in a housing project, babysitting my sister and me while my Dad was working. Her apartment was facing the playground. All the kids, black and white, played together (this was in the 50s, in AL) and if anyone got out of line, she came out the door with a flyswat.
Both parties got to tell their "mama" why there was trouble and it was handled. Sometimes mamas said, "Wait till your daddy gets home," but most times mamas took care of it. Bad language was usually the daddy's baliwick.
Whites lived on one side of the project, blacks on the other, but the lines were crossed during the day on the playground when the kids and mamas were the only ones around.
Back in the day, we had the "elders" for our unasked for guides. Today, the youth, based on their upbringing, ridicule and ignore them. How much better it might be if they listened - maybe they wouldn't be in positions as in the article.
I agree RL, having their names in the newspaper, and then prosecuted would be a great start.
Didn't that lady pimp in the East get jailed/fined and her John's names were published? Sounds like a good plan to me.
What needs to happen is for the Indian community to be joined by all those "do-good" groups to start pulling the victims back into the community.