Why Libertarianism is a Fantasy
http://www.amnottheonlyone.com/why-libertarianism-is-a-fantasy-a-letter-to-my-teenaged-son/
"Human nature ensures that the libertarian paradise will always be a fantasy. While this is true of any utopian ideal, libertarianism is currently the only one getting any real play in the field of ideas. It would be valid but unfair of me to stop there. Libertarianism has other issues, but human nature really is the problem for libertarians all brands of them.
Who are the Libertarians?
Dont let them play Libertarian/libertarian/Objectivist/anarcho-capitalist hot potato with you. All of them have the same general means to the same general end. Its like Baptists and Pentacostals arguing over the value of church on Sunday.
Despite assertions to the contrary, neither human beings nor the marketplace are even remotely rational in the short term, and are only marginally rational in the long term.
The Psychological Roots of Libertarianism
Human nature is such that we are constantly warring with ourselves over our short term desires and our long term best interests. For some, long term interests largely win out, for others short term interests largely win out, and for the vast majority of us, a blend of the two fills our lives, with various justifications. This is the root of human nature. We are social beings, we are rational beings, we are rationalizing beings, and we are beings filled with wishful thinking.
Libertarianism is the Freudian id writ large. At some point, every teen goes through a stage where they are superior to everyone around them and no one can tell them anything, where their own desires drive their existence to the detriment of all else. Libertarians just carry that through to adulthood. Its in the same class of desires as racism and sexism and other -isms libertarians want to be different, special, and better than others. (Its no coincidence that there is a great deal of racism and sexism and homophobia among the neo-libertarians of the Tea Party, in Ron Pauls work, and in Ayn Rand s work).
But Aside From That I Did it All Myself
I earned it. Its MINE has a nice ring to it, doesnt it? Unfortunately, like the usher who asked Mrs. Lincoln but aside from that, how was the play? after her husband was shot, it doesnt take reality into account. In reality, aside from:
- Your parent, parents, or parental substitute providing material well being and guidance,
- Your education that someone else paid for, whether your family or taxpayers,
- Your genetics which were passed down without choice,
- Your neighborhood which is the sum of the collective choices of your neighbors [amazon_link id=1596915986 target=_blank container= container_class= ][/amazon_link]and the larger society,
- The state of your health and mental health, over which you have imperfect control at best,
- The state of the larger economy, over which you have imperfect control at best,
- The nature of the education and/or indoctrination you received,
- The infrastructure, material, informational, and social, of your society,
- The health of your local and broader ecosystem,
- The sociological class you were born into, including economic class, religion, race, etc.,
- The sociological customs that protect you when youre vulnerable throughout your lifespan, including various forms of welfare and insurance,
- and a myriad of other factors.
Aside from all that , you earned it, kiddo. Its yours. And now, the interesting part:
- In order to believe that perfect freedom means freedom from taxes (economic coercion), one has to believe that one is a separate, superior creation, apart from those who benefit from the long list of factors above because otherwise one understands that taxes are the price one pays for the conditions under which a civilized society exists that values human lives.
- One has to believe that none of the factors listed above had any impact on oneself.
- One has to therefore define any other human being who lays a claim to being paid back for helping to provide, or to use the services that help to build a level starting gate (for that long list of factors above) as a parasite who is after what one earned, but at the same time,
- C arefully and completely fail to acknowledge the myriad benefits of living in a well-governed society. Its a sort of willful blindness thats mind-numbing in its totality, especially considering that libertarians of all varieties pride themselves on their rationality.
Human Nature and the Nature of Community
Living in a community means developing and following rules. We can argue all day about what those rules should be, and that is a useful and productive argument. The problem with the libertarian ideal that no one should be forced to do anything for anyone else is that it simply doesnt work in human societies.
Gaming the system is part of human nature.
Aggression is a part of human nature.
Governments are instituted to control both of those aspects of human nature, but they need money to do it. Taxes provide that money. Often, they are by far the least cumbersome way to gather the money and most equitable way to distribute cost in a society.
and heres the other thing (good) governments are instituted to do
Governments are instituted to maintain the material, informational, and social infrastructure necessary to ensure general prosperity.
This has never, in human history, been achieved without government assistance through human enterprise alone. Never. There is a reason for this.
The goals of human enterprise and the goals of human government are fundamentally different.
Human government seeks to ensure that human beings can co-exist peaceably and cooperatively in groups, and protect human beings from aggression by other groups and other existential threats. In other words, governments exist to create the conditions under which human beings can best survive (and ideally thrive) over the long term . Governments therefore must seek to understand and balance the goods of various groups of humans under their rule in some form or another.
Governments are concerned with the intrinsic value of humanity.
Human enterprises seek to ensure that human beings and groups of human beings profit (the definition of profit varies among societies, but generally means accumulation of something that is societally valued, regardless of intrinsic value). It is immaterial whether or not a good or service is produced, so long as the activity engaged in brings gain to those engaged in it. I
t is immaterial whether the enterprise harms others outside the group, so long as the enterprise group continues to profit. Enterprises are concerned with extrinsic values within a particular culture.
Lets go back to the earlier point about human nature that humans often act only on their short term interests and rarely understand, let alone act upon, their long term interests. An important part of a well-run government is to identify and protect the long term interests of its citizens.
Some of these interests are not amenable to market solutions (for example: health care and social services for the disadvantaged, disabled, children and the aged, large infrastructure projects such as roads and bridges, and the protective services of fire and police and military officers).
Market solutions that have been attempted for these long term interests have been unnecessarily bulky and unwieldy at best, and downright counterproductive at worst. (Comparing the health care system in the United States to other world health care systems is particularly illustrative).
Barring very expensive, successful propaganda, suppression, and disinformation campaigns, it is nearly impossible to keep the majority of human beings in a society from recognizing that market solutions to some problems are not in their best interest. Look at how the GOP announcement that they are planning to dismantle Social Security and Medicare has been received, and how quickly most mainstream GOP backed down once they saw the reaction.
Which leads to another aspect of why libertarianism is a fantasy (in all variations): It simply cant be implemented in the real world.
In the real world, no democratic society will vote for such a system , because those born without advantages, but who have the right to vote, will recognize instantly that they will be locked out of the possibility of advancement.
From the other side of the spectrum, no dictatorship will implement libertarianism either, though it may mouth free-market platitudes. Power-brokering demands tit-for-tat tradeoffs to keep dictatorships in power, and no dictatorship will ever free the market at the expense of its supporters.
If you are truly concerned about liberty as a US citizen, and certainly I agree there is some reason to be, there are other ways to go about it than to embrace a fantasy that will necessarily fail spectacularly. Instead, think carefully about what institutions function best as government functions (a nd follow primary research from unbiased sources to discover this I suggest strongly that you look at examples from all over the globe rather than limiting yourself to the US ), and which as enterprise functions.
Think in terms of human capital and investment in building a strong middle class.
Generally, if it needs a long term solution or is not likely to turn a profit without losing value to recipients, its a government function.
If it can be solved in the short run and someone can make money doing it without causing undue harm to recipients, its a n enterprise function.
Think in terms of unnecessary influence.
- Why is it okay for the government to tap our phones without a warrant?
- Why is it okay for businesses to spend unlimited amounts of undeclared money to influence elections?
- Why is it okay for the government to demand that we submit to an invasive search to get on an airplane?
- Why is it okay for businesses to do business in the US without paying for the privilege by 1) providing living wages and 2) paying taxes on their earnings? The list goes on, on both sides. The questions are good to ask.
Think in terms of both individual and societal good.
- What harm does this do?
- To whom?
- What good does it do?
- To whom?
- Does the harm outweigh the good?
- To whom?
Tags
Who is online
75 visitors

Getting rid of government is a total fantasy. In a world (and a country) of such stark disparity in wealth and income, even shrinking government a great deal is utterly impractical.
We can strive to make government more efficient, less corrupt, more user friendly, more fair, and perhaps more streamlined.
What we can't do is do away with it. This is not a deserted island with a few dozen people on it, an environment where libertarianism might make a little sense. It is a vast and populous nation.
Just like John has no idea what it is.
It would help to understand that Libertarianism is a way of life, not a political/religious ideology.
No one understands you.
Yeah, juveniles usually denigrate and insult that which they do not understand.
well that article is written four years ago by Maureen O'Danu, A self professed...
Let me put it in her own words......
And like all liberals, they wear their lie in public and state it whenever they can.
They stand for the rule of law, except when the rule of law disagrees with their agenda. The law is a tool for them to use to promote their ideological agenda. That is not respect for the law.
It is in fact, very autocratic of them.
Want proof? Gay marriage FAILED in Kalifornia, when put to a vote of the people. That's right KALIFORNIA! crazy progressive liberal Kalifornia!
And has failed everywhere else when put to a vote of the people. Failed here in Washington also. Another left coast liberal bastion. when put to a vote of the people.
Progressive liberals don't give one hoot about the people want, they only care about spreading their agenda. And forcing it upon others. By using the law as a hammer.
Why do you think they are so despised at this point in the national zietgiest. and for the last 6 years the people have been going about fixing the mistake of 2008.
But progressive liberalism, burrows like ticks on a hound, once it is are embedded in the flesh of a society, it is VERY VERY difficult to remove them. They just refuse to give up sucking the lifeblood out of their victims.
I pray for the day such vultures are so small a minority that we can laugh at their tantrums like the parent of a petulant child who isn't going to die cause they didn't get their way.
Calling libertarians teenagers, is recognizing that we are higher up the ladder of intelligence that you are. Being as you progressive liberals are nothing but petulant children.
If you feel the article doesn't describe your style of libertarianism, fine.
Libertarians never want to be criticized. I wish I had a dollar for every time I've hear a libertarian say in a forum that their beliefs were being misrepresented.
I guess in your case the truth would make you rich.
I wish I had a penny for everytime I've heard anyone insult libertarianism,
I'd be richer than you.
That statement is a great example of a person who 'thinks that they they are superior to everyone around them and no one can tell them anything, where their own desires drive their existence to the detriment of all else.'
Here's some reality for you: Progressive Liberals are despised by the only media sources that you subject yourself to, but they are very much not despised by the huge segment of society that you think doesn't matter.
You miss the point as usual, Libertarians do not despise people.
We despise ideology.
To you, ideology and people are the same thing. You cant separate the two, that is why all such progressives feel this great need to dismiss or disparage anyone who believe otherwise than you.
It also fuels your claim that your ideology is supreme above all others.
See, I subject myself to nothing except my own failings, I am my own worst enemy.
You subject everyone else to your failings, and you are everyone else's worst enemy.
Diametric opposites. That is why the progressive liberal hates so much and loves nothing.
Yeah that and the voters for congressional office .
I have all the help I need, thank you for the advice.
{Chuckle}
WE all came into the world in one way.
Naked and Brainless (read ignorant). Crying for our mama's to take care of us.
Some of us never left that state because their parents didn't teach them any better. Those are the ones your egalitarian senses want everyone to feel pity for.
I won't pity them. they don't deserve any pity, what they deserve is the chance to stand up and be a human being. Which I will help all who wish it in whatever manner I can.
Which progressivism will never give them.
How do I know?
Quote:
Your kind will never give those poor and downtrodden what they really need, Equality.
You keep them poor and downtrodden, it salves your guilt feelings.
Your own words and characterizations condemn you.
Now your sealioning, myriad little points which mean nothing but to keep the argument going when you have nothing else to offer. That is typical of the progressive. When you can't discuss on a point / counterpoint level you run out of anything intelligent to say.
Can't respond to your own inadequacies of your own learned ideology, so you need to denigrate and turn it around.
Alas it is what's to be expected around here.
Less and less decent discussions. More and more garbage passed off as discussion. Nice to know that trash passes for intelligence on your side of the aisle.
You sir, can enjoy your inadequacies, I will no longer indulge you.
AS I said, your own words condemn you.
What is illustrative here is the fact that you cannot see it, (which is ignorance manifested)
Or, you do see it and you feel you need to lash out in an attempt to cover it up. (which is actively seeking ignorance)
Whichever, I will leave it to the reader to determine which is the truth. (it's not often you get such on so prominent of a display)
Have a nice day.
The seeded article goes to some lengths and depth to explain it's point-of-view. The dispute to it offered, such as it is, seems to be based on the belief that libertarianism is being mischaracterized.
No specifics are given to back this claim.