Where Are All the Middle-Skill Workers?
Heres a paradox of the U.S. economy: Millions of Americans are seeking work, but companies say they just cant find qualified workers to hire.
A new report from researchers at Accenture, Harvard Business School and labor market analysis firm Burning Glass, challenges employers to stop grumbling and instead develop plans to develop and hire a workforce that can meet the needs of 21 st -century corporations.
Among the recommendations: Develop a deep understanding of future staffing needs and write job descriptions based on core skills; provide educators with clear statements of the skills those jobs will require; partner with schools to develop and vet curricula and share data; create in-depth internship, apprenticeship and training programs; and collaborate with other employers to standardize job descriptions and build a pipeline of future workers.
As an example, the researchers note that when Siemens, discovered a need for workers with advanced manufacturing skills in 2008, the Central Piedmont Community College in North Carolina sent four faculty members to Germany to get certified on Siemens advanced manufacturing processes. The community college soon began offering a degree in Applied Science in Mechatronics Technology designed to meet Siemens specifications.
The report, called Bridge the Gap: Rebuilding Americas Middle Skills, is part of HBSs multi-year project on U.S. business competitiveness and warns that American companies are in danger of falling behind due to their inability to findor their unwillingness to trainthe workers of the future.
In a 2014 survey, Accenture found that 69% of about 800 human resources executives said that middle-skill talent shortages regularly affect their performance. (To be sure, some economists have questioned whether the skills gap is holding companies back, or even exists at all.
The report defines middle-skill jobs as those that require more education and training than a high-school diploma but less than a four-year college degree, and focuses on a subset of occupations that create value for U.S. businesses, are tough to fill, pay decent wages and offer a real career path.
Among the hard-to-fill jobs at the middle level are in healthcare, computers, mathematics and sales.
The authors recommend that companies manage their workforce pipelines like they manage their supply chains. That means investing in workforce planning to identify strategically relevant middle-skill capabilities and build roadmaps for closing potential gaps. The report also warns against what experts call credential creep, the phenomenon of employers demanding more degrees or experience than a position actually requires.

I and others have made the point in the past that it is time for businesses to partner with educational institutions to mold curriculum needed to educate and train the workers needed in the evolving production and services industry of the still recovering economy.
Seems like a few smart folks agree
Robert, a week or so ago I read what some companies are doing in this situation. VW being one. I'll try to find that article again. It fits really well with this article.
I think I remember the article you are talking about.
I, for one, think this education reform needs to start at the secondary level, with expanded offerings of technical skills training to those young people not interested in college or a liberal arts education and looking for a job in the trades or in the factories or in service industries that do not require college education for success.
I agree 100 per cent RIO. The belief that all kids need to go to collage is nonsense, many do not want to go, others would rather have a trade then a degree. This is something that European companieshave done quite well.
R o f F
Agreed
We always wrote our position descriptions for positions where a degree was desired or traditional to say that demonstrated experience and skills could offset the education requirement.
The problem is a mixed message from industry.
First, people were told that machines were taking their place, and they were. Automation killed a lot of jobs in the work force. So then schools were redirected into sending everyone college bound. This killed a lot of the vocational schools in districts. But then we ended up with a lot of kids who really at best were associate degrees (and these are your mid level skilled workers) ending up with BA's or BS's in degrees like business. They are useless degrees. But the people who have them, don't think of themselves as mid level skilled workers, since they have been told by their parents and educators that they were college material.
The school district that I am in, still has a BOCES program that let's kids get training in mid level skills, while still providing for the kids that are college bound. The difference is that we have good guidance counselors that guide the kids into fields best for them. The school is highly competitive, and those that don't make the grade, have another avenue to pursue. But this isn't going on around the US. And that is the problem.
Excellent points and a concise summary - which is why the new direction is needed
We have a VoEd high school that serves the entire county here that students can choose to attend beginning in grade 10 and there are multiple tracks cosmetology, security, information technology, nursing assistant, phlebotomists, carpentry, welding, electrician, food services, agriculture, and many more.
Night school is also available for adult education.
Local and state businesses strongly support the school through donations, co-op assignments and active recruiting of graduates. A lot of the kids are working before the graduate.
Thanks for the perspective of an educator on this subject
Exactly!
Exactly!
This came out last December, but I thought it very fitting:
Dirty Jobs' Mike Rowe on the High Cost of College
Big Oak.... That use to be a great avenue to travel, but with the cutting back of the military, I wonder how much demand there is for military personnel these days. I really don't know, but there are a lot of service jobs that pay very well and often a parent will encourage their child to get that college education and unless it is in some scientific curriculum it often times produces little toward a career.
It is going to be a very interesting race over the next 30 or so years.
A race between getting the needed middle-skill workers educated, and the evolution of automated systems to eliminate those same middle-skill workers.
There are lots of jobs in the trades available in Ohio and western Pennsylvania as construction has really taken off in the last year or so.
Good pay and steady work around here
Steve
Thanks for sharing the link
FLYNAVY
The challenge will be to embrace and evolve (the work force) with automation as it develops rather than fearing and fighting it