Proposed Water Rule Could Put ‘Property Rights of Every American Entirely at the Mercy’ of EPA
November 12, 2014
It seems incredible, but a single missing word could turn a water law into a government land grab so horrendous even a U.S. Supreme Court justice warned it would put the property rights of every American entirely at the mercy of Environmental Protection Agency employees.
The missing word is navigable. The Obama administration is proposing a rule titled Definition of Waters of the United States Under the Clean Water Act, which would strike navigable from American water law and redefine any piece of land that is wet at least part of the year, no matter how remote or isolated it may be from truly navigable waters, as waters of the United States, or WOTUS.
The proposed rule would provide EPA and the Corps of Engineers (as well as litigious environmental groups) with the power to dictate the land-use decisions of homeowners, small businesses and local communities throughout the United States. There would be virtually no limit to the federal governments authority over private property.
Puddles, ponds, ditches, ephemerals the EPA wants to regulate it all. (Photo: American Farm Bureau Facebook)
The proposed rule has ignited a firestorm of protest. Agricultural and business interests, free-market think tanks, state agencies, attorneys general and governors have joined the Ditch the Rule movement and demanded it be withdrawn.
The Obama administration is conducting an aggressive shield campaign to downplay the proposed rules huge negative impacts and paint critics as opponents of clean water, shills for development interests or anything other than concerned citizens.
Obamas own political shills for anti-development interests, such as Organizing for Action, Natural Resources Defense Council and Clean Water Action, are marching in lockstep with the agencies to discredit any opposition to the rule.
But recently, a group of 25 U.S. senators called out the Obama administration for misleading Americans on the proposed rule. In a scathing letter to the EPA and the Corps, the senators detailed the administrations deceptions and bias:
- The Obama administration claims the proposed Waters of the United States rule responds to prior requests for a Clean Water Act rulemaking. It does not.
- The Obama administration insinuates that opposition to the proposed rule is equivalent to opposition to clean water. It is not.
- EPA has attempted to delegitimize questions and concerns surrounding the proposed rule. Concerns are legitimate.
- EPA and the Corps have blatantly misrepresented the impacts of increased Clean Water Act jurisdiction. The impacts are real.
- EPAs social media advocacy in favor of the proposed Waters of the United States rule prejudices the rulemaking process. It kills debate.
Affected parties are more credible in this battle than the administration. The American Farm Bureau started the Ditch the Rule movement with pictures that showed what the EPA and Army Corps of Engineers would regulate if the Waters of the United States rule takes effect: wetlands that are nothing more than low spots on a farm field, the decorative pond of a suburban home or even a vacant lot that the agency designates as possessing the requisite wetness.
If the farmer fills in low spots or the homeowner builds a childs playhouse by the pond, or a business constructs a new office on the vacant lot or anyone touches any bureaucrat-designated wetland in any way, the EPA or Corps may order the owners to cease activity, restore original conditions and abandon any use of the property.
If the owners do not comply, they could be fined up to $75,000 per day$37,500 for violating the rule and another $37,500 for violating the agencys order. The property owner is blocked from going to court until sued by the agency, which could dawdle until fines have skyrocketed into the millions.
Thats no exaggeration.
A promotional graphic the American Farm Bureau put out to stress their Ditch the Rule campaign. (Photo: Farm Bureau)
Its from Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alitos concurring decision in the 2012 case of Michael and Chantell Sackett, an Idaho couple who placed fill material on their property to build their dream home and suffered exactly the outrageous treatment the justice described.
After failing in lower courts, the Sacketts finally won a Supreme Court ruling that they had the right to sue the EPA for exceeding the reach of the Clean Water Act. At least three other Supreme Court rulings have rejected parts of the administrations interpretation of the Clean Water Act.
The Supreme Court trumps the president of the United States, and in this instance shares the concerns of the Senate 25. But none of the high courts decisions answer the exact question: What is the reach of the Clean Water Act?
Therein lies the crux of the WOTUS menace: The reach of the Clean Water Act is notoriously unclear, and EPA and the Corps have kept it that way.
The Farm Bureau is particularly concerned by EPAs refusal to answer direct questions such as, Name three things that get wet, like roadside drainages, irrigation ditches, and livestock watering ponds, that would not be regulated by WOTUS. Dead silence. And a permit to do anything in a designated wetland can cost upwards of $250,000.
The National Federation of Independent Businesses asserted in its official comments to the EPA, The CWA is unconstitutionally vague because the regulated community cannot readily determine whether a given property is, or is not, a jurisdictional wetland. The uncertainty helps the Obama shield campaign.
Two weeks before the Senate 25 called out the EPA, the attorneys general of 11 states and the governors of six states sent a similar letter to the EPA and the Corps.
This rule should be withdrawn and replaced with a common-sense alternative that respects states primary responsibility over lands and waters within their borders while also giving land owners clear guidance, the letter stated.
Scott Pruitt, Oklahomas attorney general and a leader in drafting the states letter, told The Daily Signal, The proposed WOTUS rule unlawfully and unconstitutionally asserts federal control over local water and land by needlessly replacing state and local land-use management with top-down, federal control.
Unlawful and unconstitutional are not words attorneys general use lightly. When asked to size up the overall issue, Pruitt said, The WOTUS rule appears to be another attempt by federal agencies to implement an agenda through regulations to affect land-use decisions that should be left to the states and private property owners.
In September, the House passed bipartisan legislation, H.R. 5078, that prohibits the EPA and Corps from finalizing the WOTUS rule. A companion bill is stalled in the Senate.
With the coal industry overpowered, Obamas rogue administration looks to have declared war on the rest of us.
http://dailysignal.com/2014/11/12/proposed-water-rule-put-property-rights-every-american-entirely-mercy-epa/
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

Liberty..... Another one bites the dust!
More tyranny brought to you by the Obama administration.
People ignore all of this now because they feel they are getting what they want. They don't care if the president lies or Congress lies, but when the tables are turned around on them they will all of a sudden change their tune, but it will be too late. This is not a Republican or Democrat problem. This is an American Citizen problem and just because your man is in office now and acting lawless doesn't mean when the other side gets in office they won't do the same thing. I'll fight against them just as much when that time arrives. If it never comes to pass, we will have a Totalitarian government and it will suddenly dawn on all we should have done something when we could.
I've been saying for years that the next war wont be over oil, it will be over water.
There are two sides to this.
One being that in a few decades we may be wishing we had the foresight to control water so that it remained clean enough for us to continue to drink out of the tap.
Another being that we may be wishing we hadn't instituted government control, which inevitably goes to contractor/business control and screws us all.
I heard on the radio the other day a story about how leaky our pipe system is. We lose billions of gallons of water to leaking pipes in the ground that are from the turn of the century. Our infrastructure is all very old.
It made me wonder though, what the water table and water cycle would look like without the leaking pipes.
Give it 10 more years (20 at most) and water is going to be a very touchy subject.
Water in that respect is already an important subject Miss_Construed. This is a different situation though. Don't get me wrong. I totally agree with your comment.
I dont think this is a different situation. Broadening the definitions of water under EPA control is done with good intentions in order to safeguard the watershed and keep tap water safe to drink for years to come.
The drawback is, of course, that the government controls the system and becomes totalitarian (in your terms).
And as they say... good intentions pave the road to hell.
The crux here is weighing the value of EPA control vs. businesses/developers and common man use of the current land with water on it.
How much freedom is worth sacrificing to keep clean water a public commodity? Some say none, some say all...
-- The crux here is weighing the value of EPA control vs. businesses/developers and common man use of the current land with water on it. ---
I will err on the side of government over any "For Profit" industry.
I don't concern myself with popular paranoia. I understand a lot about aquifers. water tables, etc. However slight it may be, I still have a voice in government whereas with the for profit corporations, I have none.
I agree with you wholeheartedly!
1) leaky pipes. Yes, we lose a LOT of water through leaky pipes. In Louisville, we are still replacing pipes that were originally drilled out of pine trees... That being said, you can look at it as recharge to the aquifer, (which then goes to the surface water), and that's not all a bad thing. Be that as it may, we are paying to treat this water, so we may as well have full use of it. Most utilities don't have the money to replace all the pipes that leak, until they rupture, (main break), and then, they put a bandaid on it. I once worked at a community that treated about 150,000 gallons per day, but only sold about 50,000 gallons per day. Oops.
2) This may be a means of protecting surface and groundwater bodies from FRACKING, in which case, I'm all for it. Right now, there is not much anyone can do. IF an expansion of the Clean Water Act can somehow protect our water supplies from the chemicals used in the fracking industry, well good.
3) Any time a For Profit company gets involved, the consumer gets screwed. Water should be a utility, a non-profit entity. By that same token, as a non-profit entity, just about every water utility in this country needs to replace pipes, update treatment facilities, and, in general, fix stuff. Many utilities are not allowed to charge enough to actually have the money to do it. They are subject to the Utility Regulator Commission, who sets rates, who also have an eye on what the customers are willing to pay. People here have got it in their heads that they should pay no more than about $15/mo for their water. Ok, I can see that. Water bills have gone up from $12/mo 20 years ago to $15/mo today-- Basic 4,000 gallons per month. Know anything else that is vital for life that is really such a great bargain?
4) Water is already a touchy subject. Just ask anybody who is facing a water price increase. People don't care if the infrastructure is bad-- they just don't want to pay for it. Look at the weeping and wailing over possibly taking water from Lake Michigan and pumping a minute amount to a small town outside the watershed...
5) Water wars are coming, and likely to a state near you. Hopefully, it won't be fought with guns, but, it will still be fought. Just ask what is going to happen when the west has no water left... Are we going to pipe water out to them? We have it, but are we going to build a huge pipeline from point A in KY to point B in NV? Nope. Not without some quid pro quo. We'll take your solar powered energy in partial trade... But, let's face it-- you can live without power, but you can't live without water.
6) No one gives a damn about their drinking water until the turn on the faucet and it's not there. So, smarten up, people. The day is coming when we'll all turn on the faucet and it won't be there.
I should do an article about potential contaminants of aquifers and surface water bodies... You wouldn't believe the every day things we just don't think about that can make a HUGE difference in water contamination...
Mike, that is bullshit, unless the bikers plan on draining the oil out of their bikes onto the ground... And I don't think they're going to do that.
This is to keep cows from standing and pooping in streams that then flow through the next property to be used as a drinking water supply. This is to keep swamps from being drained to be used as housing developments-- all using lawn care chemicals. This is to keep farmers from spraying pesticides, (like Guardsman Max-- the most popular corn fungicide), in and around standing water-- pesticides that are listed as having a hydrolitic half-life of 6 months, and should not be sprayed within 100' of standing water. You think that farmers care about the water on their property? HAHAHA They only care when their well water suddenly tastes funny.
Erosion control isn't likely a huge part of this, anyway. As far as people doing what they want on their property is fine by me, until it affects my drinking water. THEN I have a say-so about what's going on, and so should YOU.
Everyone that hates the USEPA needs to stop and take a deep breath. If it weren't for the EPA, the Cayugah River may just catch on fire again, the fish would taste like oil in the Ohio River, and all of KY would have no streams that could be used for drinking water due to septic system drainage, pesticides, acid mine drainage, etc.
I would too if the government offices werent bought and sold by the "for profits". I can see this being contracted out under the farce of saving money.
Dowser you're looking at the extreme here. No one wants the river to catch on fire and The EPA has done right and I expect they will do right by the people in the future, but there are too many situations that are ridiculous.
I remember an article some time ago about a man who had a little stream running at the back of his property. There was a road down stream that crossed the stream. The water ran under the road. Some branches stopped up the flow of the water and accumulated in a short period of time until the stream turned into a lake in his back yard and was fixing to flood his home. He removed the accumulated crap at the road and the EPA came down on him and I forgot the amount of the daily fine, but it was way on up there. He went to court and won. Then they changed the charges somehow and came right back down on him again. I will see if I can find the article.
Six, I agree that there are situations that are ridiculous. But, as a whole, the EPA has helped keep a lot of people healthy.
Instead of everyone getting all hysterical, why don't we look at it reasonably?
The EPA is not going to stop you from having a biker party. The EPA is not going to keep you from plowing your field. It may keep you from spraying Guardsman Max on your corn crop that is next to a stream, (and I hope they do!), but they are NOT going to keep you from spraying it on the rest of your crop. But wait, pesticide useages are regulated by the USDA, not the EPA. (To use many pesticides, you have to be a Licensed Pesticide Applicator.)
Maybe you weren't alive back in the 1960s to remember what it was like. I surely remember. I remember when Rough River Lake had a ring of oil around the lake on the rocks. It doesn't any more. I remember the black smoke billowing up out of the power plant's smoke stack. The EPA has done a lot of good for this country.
To accuse them of trying to stop a biker party, or making you unable to use your farm property, or what many of you are so hysterical about, is what is ridiculous!