Colo. school to students: No praying during free time
ADF files suit after public school censors religious discussion, expression during open period
Monday, November 10, 2014
COLORADO SPRINGS, Colo. Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys filed suit in federal court Friday on behalf of a Pine Creek High School senior told that he and a group of other students may no longer informally meet to pray and discuss religious topics during free time as they have for the past three years.
School officials claimed the separation of church and state required the religious speech ban during an open period of the day equivalent to recess when students are free to spend time together, text on their phones, or discuss any other topic. Academy School District #20 and its legal counsel support the schools decision despite the fact that ADF attorneys explained in an Oct. 7 letter to the district that the policy violates the First Amendment, which protects the students religious speech.
Public schools should encourage the free exchange of ideas. Instead, this school implemented an ill-conceived ban that singles out religious speech for censorship during free time, said ADF Senior Legal Counsel Jeremy Tedesco.
Far from being unconstitutional, religious speech is expressly protected by the First Amendment, and public schools have no business stopping students from praying together during their free time, added ADF Legal Counsel Matt Sharp.
The school districts Open Time Policy permits all students to leave class 15 minutes after the beginning of the seminar home-room period on Mondays and Wednesdays. Students who are earning more than a D grade can do the same on Fridays. School district policies and procedures define open time in numerous places as consisting of lunchtime and the seminar period.
During the free time, students are permitted to engage in a virtually unlimited variety of activities, including gathering with other students inside or outside; reading; sending text messages to their friends; playing games on their phone; visiting the bathrooms; getting a snack; visiting teachers; and conducting official meetings of school clubs.
For three years, student Chase Windebank met during the free period on Mondays and Fridays with students in an unoccupied choir room to pray, sing Christian songs, and discuss issues of the day from a religious perspective. On Sept. 29, Assistant Principal James Lucas told Windebank that the meetings could continue but any religious speech would have to stop because of the separation of church and state, an inaccurate shorthand description of the First Amendment, which actually protects private religious expression.
Lucas and Principal Kolette Back said Windebank and the other students could only engage in religious speech before or after school. Because the school forced the students to meet for prayer and religious discussion either before or after school and because of the difficulties students have in meeting at those times due to sports, work, or other factors the number of students participating has dwindled from approximately 90 students to as low as 12.
ADF attorneys sent a letter to the school district explaining the unconstitutionality of the schools policy and practice, but the district responded in its own letter that it stands by the schools decision. That prompted the lawsuit Windebank v. Academy School District #20 , filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado.
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

And some say tell me any freedoms you're losing and then there are those who claim to be tolerant and rejoice that you are losing your freedoms.
As this kind of activity was taking place on public school grounds, the school was within their right to disallow such a practice.
Yet they teach the 5 pillars of Islam in school....go figure.
It wasn't a "class" and it wasn't required of them to "attend" and it wasn't being "taught."
Perhaps that's the problem. It should have been a class, a "teaching experience" to be tolerated under current guidelines. Then it would be okay.
Let's be honest here, kids do not go to school and do what their parents want them to; their parentscan't make any teenager do what they want at school...guaranteed.You'd be surprised Fishy how many of those kids don't have religious parents at all.
I went to school with a group of students who got together at lunch and Study Hall period and started each session with prayer. Same students, all through sophomore, junior and senior years. Other students would sometimes join.
What surprises me is the same school who is teaching the kids about the Constitution, does not understand the meaning of "Separation of church and State". That phrase DOES NOT give the school the power nor the authority to silence speech about religion. What it does do is say the Government (in this case the school) CAN NOT say which religion can or can't be observed or practiced by the students. It prevents the school from endorsing any one religion. Nothing more and nothing less.
I take it that some of you are not aware that there are public schools, notably in Michigan, that allow Muslims to take time from class for their daily prayers and to leave school early on Friday with an unexcused absence for prayers off campus?
That these same schools do not allow Christian students to attend any Bible Study classes, with permission from their parents, because it violates the separation of church and state provision? That it used to allow for the Christian students to attend the Bible Study classes but stopped when CAIR (Council on American-Islamic Relations) came down on them about allowing religious activities in a public school; three years later, CAIR petitioned the school to allow Muslim students their prayers in the public schools.
The Constitution is there for a reason. It protects EVERYONE.
Mimi, why do you bother us with such facts. LOL
Religious clubs may hold meetings on public high school grounds in accordance with the Federal Equal Access Act as long as other similar non-curriculum related student groups are allowed to meet during non-instructional time ; the club does not interfere with regular educational activities; and the school does not initiate, direct, sponsor, par-ticipate in, or promote during instructional time the religious activities of student clubs.
1) " during regular school hours ". Key phrase.
2) Know Your Rights: Religion in Public Schools - - A Guide for Administrators and Teachers
There use to be an unwritten military command polity in the Navy that went something like this:
What you do for one you must do for all. If you can't do for all, you shouldn't do for the one.
Interesting Hal. I didn't know you were in favor of a government that tells the people when , where and what they can say and think....
Just so you know,. farm animals are a part of school in some parts of the country Ever hear of the 4H club?
Hal, its really hard to take what you say seriously when you say things like " Hal A. Lujah Praise Jesus! Back to normal.
Not only is it difficult to take what you say seriously, but you can't even deliver sarcasm correctly. I saw this ad on the TV
One day, one night, any night is alright so get your degree at fly by night school.....financing available to those who qualify...and I think you do.
Yes, Aeon. They are allowed to pray during regular school hours.
Then you've had more spectacular experiences than I have. Tell me, do you attend many prayer meetings withhigh school students? We could all gain from your vast experience! Perhaps you would care to share.
True, even the Supreme Court affirms that. There is no law that prevents a public school student from praying silently.
" You are a moron. Understand that ?" says the person who said "Praise Jesus" then said "...nurturing every version of sky fairy myth..."
The Muslim students were given time and permission to go to a separate classroom that had been set aside for them to pray together. Actually it was two classrooms as the males and females are required to pray separately.
Someone, maybe the ADF, should file a lawsuit in Michigan too.