╌>

Mary Burke Resorts to Use of Swastikas in her Advertising

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  10 comments

Mary Burke Resorts to Use of Swastikas in her Advertising

"Mary Burke hits Scott Walker in ad with swastika imagery," says the headline at the Washington Post.

Democrat Mary Burke released a new ad Friday accusing Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker (R) of using a Republican county chairman's "lies to attack" her. The ad includes images of swastikas, it says, the county chair posted to his Facebook page.

Burke's ad seeks to tie Walker to Gary Ellerman, the Jefferson County Republican Party chairman and a former human resources director at Trek Bicycle, the Burke family company where the Democrat used to work.

Ellerman was quoted in a report on the conservative Web site Wisconsin Reporter that cited sources saying Burke was fired from the company. In the report, Ellerman said, She was not performing. She was (in) so far over her head. She didnt understand the bike business." Burke denies being fired.
You can watch the whole ad at the link, but here's a screen shot of the part where swastikas float across the screen and have whatever subliminal effect they're supposed to have


There's writing on the screen, but are we supposed to read it or just have feelings that something awful is going on? If you're watching it on line, you can freeze it and read it, and if you do, you'll find swastikas used against Obama in exactly the same way swastikas were used against Scott Walker back in the 2011 protests, to say that a politician you oppose is like the Nazis.

Burke seems to be saying that Ellerman is bad because he used the swastika, and since Ellerman asserted something about Burke that could help Walker, Walker is connected to Ellerman, and Ellerman's form of expression should be attributed to Walker, making Walker bad.

If we had the time to read the words on the screen, it would be clear that Ellerman's use of the swastika is not pro- but anti-Nazi, but the ad doesn't give us that time, and in fact, the words on the graphic on the left never fully appear appear on screen. The most you ever see and I had to freeze the frame to read this is "cordance with the/Order, all Christian/-ches must hand over/-rmons regarding/-sexuality and gender/state so that we may/or and "correct" any/-rsive speech that/-dicts our Manifesto," a quote attributed to "-ton's Democrat Mayor, Annise Parker." The words "-sexuality and gender" line up with the eyes of the unfamiliar woman who is smirking and has her hands in what could be called the I-have-an-evil-plan position.



What subliminal effect does that have? One might, in so little time, subliminally read the "evil" woman as Mary Burke. And it is Mary Burke who is wafting swastikas in front of our eyes. I've seen anti-Walker protesters holding signs that put a swastika on Walker, so a casual viewer might think that's what Burke is doing here, even though she wants to say that's the kind of thing that Ellerman does. But most of us don't know or care about Ellerman any more than we know or care about Parker, so I think the subliminal effect probably intended was to make us think of Walker as a Nazi. That's something that Burke herself cannot say as a mainstream candidate, but it is something Walker-haters have been expressing for years.

At the 2011 protests, we saw many, many signs comparing Walker to Hitler. Meade and I frequently approached people who were holding these signs. Asked to explain, they always defended the comparison. Here's of photo of mine from February 2011:



I asked that woman behind the sign if she thought Scott Walker was like Hitler, and she said "Yes." So I followed up with: "Are you saying that you think fascism could come to America?" And she said, "It's what's happening."

And then there was this woman, also from February 2011:

The expression on her face and the tone of her voice when she said "like Hitler" is something Meade and I have never forgotten. (Watch how quickly she otherizes Meade.)

Here's an "Adolf Walker" sign with a swastika.


Here's a young woman with a sign that says "Walker is a dictator" and has an image of Walker with a Hitler mustache. She says she "definitely" thinks Walker is like Hitler. Why? "He doesn't do nice things. He's not a nice person."


Meade follows up: "So, anyone who's not nice is like Hitler?" She tries again: "Well, no. He doesn't do what he should, doesn't do the right thing, and he's doing something that might ruin a lot of things for people. He's pretty much ruining, like, our future."

Meade offers: "You don't think that's over the top, that you're comparing him to Adolf Hitler?" She responds: "It might be a little over the top." Meade: "Just a little?" She makes the concession that might be perhaps what Gary Ellerman would say about Obama: "Just a little, but we kind of need to be dramatic in something like this."

An older woman cuts in and says: "It brings the point across." Meade: "And the point is?" Woman: "The point is this is a democracy, not a dictatorship." Meade asks whether there was something undemocratic about the election back in November, and she says: "Nothing. But what he's doing now is undemocratic." The woman continues, admitting that she didn't vote for Walker, but it's undemocratic because he's not "willing to compromise and negotiate... and that's what democracy is." That's what a lot of people thought about about Obama quite aptly when he said "I won" and foisted Obamacare on us when clearly there wasn't majoritarian support for it.

Now, you can see that the young and the older woman are nice people, not extremists, but aggrieved by the policies of the candidate who won the last election, and that they are appropriating a vivid graphic symbol for dramatic effect. Personally, I would not display a swastika as a way to make an exaggerated point about an American politician, but others do on the right and on the left.

Obviously, I don't refrain from showing you that others are using a swastika in their form of expression, and you might say, that's exactly what Mary Burke is doing in her new ad.

But I am showing you things carefully, so you can study them, and to slow things down so there is no subliminal effect, no irrational roiling of the emotions. And that's exactly what Mary Burke is not doing. Her ad begins with a picture of Walker standing with "a Walker campaign worker and donor who puts pictures like this on his Facebook page." The image my screen shot, above slips by in 3 seconds, obliterating any hope of figuring out that Ellerman is not a Nazi fan and that he's just another Wisconsinite using dramatic imagery to get his point across.

Ironically, Burke's use of the swastika works exactly like Ellerman's, and she's doing the very thing defenders of the ad will say she's trying to criticize Ellerman for doing. Arguably, it's worse, because it's not a still image that you can gaze at until you understand. It means to creep in by the backdoor to your mind.

AND: From February 20, 2011: "Do you think Scott Walker deserves to be compared to the Nazis?"/"Yes, I do":



ALSO: I'd written "Annie Parker," but it's Annise Parker. Here's the story the swastika graphic was about:
The city of Houston has issued subpoenas demanding a group of pastors turn over any sermons dealing with homosexuality, gender identity or Annise Parker, the citys first openly lesbian mayor. And those ministers who fail to comply could be held in contempt of court.

http://althouse.blogspot.com/2014/11/mary-burkes-use-of-swastika-in-her-ad.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"Burke seems to be saying that Ellerman is bad because he used the swastika, and since Ellerman asserted something about Burke that could help Walker, Walker is connected to Ellerman, and Ellerman's form of expression should be attributed to Walker, making Walker bad.If we had the time to read the words on the screen, it would be clear that Ellerman's use of the swastika is not pro- but anti-Nazi, but the ad doesn't give us that time, and in fact, the words on the graphic on the left never fully appear appear on screen. "
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"In proving that Godwins Law applies to struggling Democrat campaigns just like it applies to the Internet, the Mary Burke campaign has decided to flash some swastikas in some ads that are encouraging people to vote for Mary Burke...." Leon Wolfe

Race bating, fear mongering and swastikas, democrats should be very proud of the elections they are running in 2014.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Actually the Ellerman use of the swaztika is anti-Obama.


So what? This Walker supporter is not supporting the Nazis, he pointing out what a danger they are. The misleading ad tries to paint him as a Nazi supporter.

As Professor Alehouse says:

"But most of us don't know or care about Ellerman any more than we know or care about Parker, so I think the subliminal effect probably intended was to make us think of Walker as a Nazi. That's something that Burke herself cannot say as a mainstream candidate, but it is something Walker-haters have been expressing for years"

Shameful, desperate tactics.

I added the link to her site in the parent post. I forgot when seeding it. Thanks for calling it to my attention.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Using a swastika is a million times worse than mailing ads calling your opponent a liar. basically evert candidate in America calls their opponent a Liar. Burke is the only one I know of to use a swastika to try and paint their opponent as a Nazi.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Tell the whole story and the origin of things before trying to make it appear that something came from a pure whim.

MARTIN NIEMLLER: "FIRST THEY CAME FOR THE SOCIALISTS..."

Martin Niemller, a prominent Protestant pastor who opposed the Nazi regime. He spent the last seven years of Nazi rule in concentration camps. Germany, 1937.

Bildarchiv Preussischer Kulturbesitz

Martin Niemller (18921984) was a prominent Protestant pastor who emerged as an outspoken public foe of Adolf Hitler and spent the last seven years of Nazi rule in concentration camps.

Niemller is perhaps best remembered for the quotation:

First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist.

Then they came for the Trade Unionists, and I did not speak out
Because I was not a Trade Unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for meand there was no one left to speak for me.

The quotation stems from Niemller's lectures during the early postwar period. Different versions of the quotation exist. These can be attributed to the fact that Niemller spoke extemporaneously and in a number of settings. Much controversy surrounds the content of the poem as it has been printed in varying forms, referring to diverse groups such as Catholics, Jehovah's Witnesses, Jews, Trade Unionists, or Communists depending upon the version. Nonetheless his point was that Germansin particular, he believed, the leaders of the Protestant churcheshad been complicit through their silence in the Nazi imprisonment, persecution, and murder of millions of people.

Only in 1963, in a West German television interview, did Niemller acknowledge and make a statement of regret about his own antisemitism (see Gerlach, 2000, p. 47). Nonetheless, Martin Niemller was one of the earliest Germans to talk publicly about broader complicity in the Holocaust and guilt for what had happened to the Jews. In his book ber die deutsche Schuld, Not und Hoffnung (published in English as Of Guilt and Hope)which appeared in January 1946Niemller wrote: "Thus, whenever I chance to meet a Jew known to me before, then, as a Christian, I cannot but tell him: 'Dear Friend, I stand in front of you, but we can not get together, for there is guilt between us. I have sinned and my people has sinned against thy people and against thyself.'"

Slippery slopes grow from seeds planted in the small minds of haters by politicians who, in the time of things like economic downturn, make scapegoats for those small minds to blame.

Martin Niemoeller

(1892 - 1984)



In 1934, he started the Pastors Emergency League to defend the church. Hitler became angered by Niemoellers rebellious sermons and popularity and had him arrested on July 1, 1937. He was tried the following year and sentenced to seven months in prison and fined.Martin Niemoeller was a Protestant pastor born January 14, 1892, in Lippstadt, Westphalia. He was a submarine commander in World War I. He was anti-communist and initially supported the Nazis until the church was made subordinate to state authority.

After Niemoeller's release, Hitler ordered him arrested again and he spent the next seven years in concentration camps in protective custody. He was liberated in 1945 and was elected President of the Protestant church in Hesse and Nassau in 1947. He held the title until 1964. He was also a President of the World Council of Churches in the 1960s.

Niemoeller was a pacifist who spoke out against nuclear weapons. He is best known for his powerful statement about the failure of Germans to speak out against the Nazis :

First they came for the Communists, but I was not a Communist so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Socialists and the Trade Unionists, but I was neither, so I did not speak out. Then they came for the Jews, but I was not a Jew so I did not speak out. And when they came for me, there was no one left to speak out for me.

He died in Wiesbaden on March 6, 1984.

Hitler also came for homosexuals, gypsies and other minorities sound familiar?

DO I APPROVE OF THE WALKER/HITLER POSTERS NO, I DON'T.

But the references to Walker's targets are precedented in history as preludes to escalated scapegoating and worse.

Nothing comes from nothing.

Ancient Greeks et al believed that things cannot disappear into nothing, just as they can't be created from nothing, but if they ceased to exist, they transform into some other form of being

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Is Ellerman running for office against Barack Obama? T

This is what I said and pay attention to each word (if you need help there are several online dictionaries available for free) :

"Burke is the only one I know of (candidate) to use a swastika to try and paint their opponent as a Nazi."

I know readingcomprehension, integrity and honesty aren't your strong suits, but this is sad, even for you.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"Burke is the only one I know of (candidate) to use a swastika to try and paint their opponent as a Nazi."

Sean, did you read the analogous tactics regarding Republican and Nazi scapegoats?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
I guess I don't follow. I'm very aware that rank and file republicans and democrats have used swastikas for decades to symbolize where the road leads if you follow the policies of said republican or democrat. That's what ellerman was doing on Facebook and that's what the anti walker demonstrators did at thier protests.What I'm asking for is evidence of a major party candidate using swatstika imagery in paid advertising to suggest their opponent is a nazi, or nazi supporter. The only thing I can think of that might qualify are the false claims made in 1964 that Goldwater was an actual Neo nazi, but I can't recall if LBJ actually used that slur in paid advertisements.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I guess I don't follow.

It's not the use of the swastika -- it's offensive when any candidate uses it. My issue is the similar scapegoats, the targeting of minorities in voter suppression laws, the pandering to religionist-Christians, the attacks on unions, calling democrat policies and Obama "Socialists," xenophobia-baiting

Hate and fear-mongering to target demographics overtly and via buzzwords/dog whistles/red meat "issues" is how Nazis and other tyrant-regimes whipped up the haters and zeal-without-knowledge types.

Surely you can check the history and follow that, Sean.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I guess I don't follow.

It's not the use of the swastika -- it's offensive when any candidate uses it. My issue is the similar scapegoats, the targeting of minorities in voter suppression laws, the pandering to religionist-Christians, the attacks on unions, calling democrat policies and Obama "Socialists," xenophobia-baiting

Hate and fear-mongering to target demographics overtly and via buzzwords/dog whistles/red meat "issues" is how Nazis and other tyrant-regimes whipped up the haters and zeal-without-knowledge types.

Surely you can check the history and follow that, Sean.

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
JohnRussell
Gazoo
CB


96 visitors