I Have 3 Questions About the "Illegal" Settlements
This week, Prime Minister Netanyahu announced plans for another 1,000 residences in East Jerusalem. By the Palestinians' account, this represents further encroachment upon what will be part of the eventual Palestinian State. Many such announcements of construction in the Occupied Territories have been announced in the last few years, anda numberhave actually resulted in home construction.
The Palestinians, backed by the Arab World, and thecourt of world opinion (whatever that means), claim that this activity is illegal, immoral, a "land grab", and of course, a reason to incite hostilities of every kind against the Jewish State. This has prompted a number of questions in my mind. My hope is that someone will be able to answer one or more of them:
1)If, after the Palestinians secure a State that they call their own, and these residences are inside their new borders, are they part of the Palestinian State?
2)If Jews live in these residences, are they permitted to stay, as citizens of the Palestinian State?
And, a more general question, which is an offshoot on Question 2:
3)Will Jews be allowed to live in Palestine?
There have been agood numberof seeds and articles onNewsTalkers in the lastcouple ofyears that have given everyone ample opportunity to vent their hostilities at the "enemy" of their choice.
It is my fervent hope that, should you comment, it will be to answer one or more of these questions.
Thank you.

There are important issues relating to these questions. It raises the issue of a pluralistic Palestinian State, versusthe "apartheid" label that critics of Israel (which is 20% Arab), often invoke in criticism of the Jewish State.
These are very good questions, John. Perhaps you should write an article, soliciting answers.
Why not give my questions a shot?
If a separate state is created for Palestinians, the physical property should become part of the new Palestinian state. The rights of Jews occupying stolen land inside the new Palestinian state should mirror how Palestinians would be treated if they illegally occupied land by force inside Israel and built a home on it. Specifically pay compensation, be evicted, and/or have the homes bulldozed. Jews should be allowed to remain in the new Palestinian state to the same extent that Palestinians are allowed to return to their land in Israel.
What about the homes in Silwan that Jews just purchased from Arab owners.
The settlements are illegal under international law . . . so they stole it.
The settlements are illegal under international law
Please provide the citation for the law. I'd like to read the law that you are referring toin its entirety.
Thank you.
From who, Egyptand Jordan?
But what law is being referenced here? From which code of law? What set of laws points to the settlements being illegal?
The international community considers the settlements in occupied territory to be illegal, [ 9 ] and the United Nations has repeatedly upheld the view that Israel's construction of settlements constitutes a violation of the Fourth Geneva Convention . [ 10
Thank you.
The General Assemblyof the UN considers them illegal.
If you are a comedian, I hope you're getting paid, because I just busted a gut laughing.
PATHETIC FAIL
Not binding to any party.
Ever.
It was taken from Jordan in 1967. The "Palestinians" had no stake, until the Arab League said they did.
But don't worry. Despite the utter falsity of the claim, they will be getting some land they can call their own. That being the case, they should be grateful for whatever they get. And if they'd like it sooner or later, they're going to have to sit down at the table with Israel. The world does not have the authority to grant the Palestinians a state, complete with borders. Nor does the UK, Sweden, Ireland or any other country.
It's not "moot" in any way.
If these residences are built on the Palestinian side of the border, it's to the benefit of the Palestinians. What could be more beneficial than thousands of apartments, actually built to code? What could be better than an already developed neighborhood, where the chance for Jews and Muslims to go to the same supermarket has a chance?
Is it a foregone conclusion that "Palestine" will be Judenrien?
See, that's just the point. It's not "Palestinian" land until there is Palestine. Jump up and down all you want. And, of course, don't forget to blame Israel for all the Palestinian misery.
Never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity. Words said so long ago, still so applicable.
The sky is blue.
"Advisory opinion"? Basing it initially on the UN Partition resolution THAT THE PALESTINIANS NEVER AGREED TO? I've seen other opinions, such as the Levy Commission. One's as good as the other, is it not? I'm looking around to try to find someone to enforce the "advisory opinion" and the UN Resolutions it purports to use for reaching its decision.
Tell you what, 1ofmany, since you're so gung ho on the rights of the Palestinians, why don't you start a movement to get the countries who want to do so go in to conquer and take back those so-called Palestinian lands to give to the Palestinians? I'm sure you will have no difficulty recruiting all the Muslim/Arab countries of the world who despise the Jews for starters. Oh, are their potential soldiers too busy slaughtering each other? Too bad. What about the western countries that click their tongues about the issue, or the Communist countries that have such amazing human rights records? If you succeed you could be the "Deborah" of the conquering army and become a biblical hero.
You will win me over to your arguments when Russia gives back the sugar refinery they confiscated from my great-grandfather and his family forcing them to be refugees to Canada without a dime in their pockets. But the funny thing is, UNRWA didn't bankroll them or provide them with pogey throughout the generations so they had to actually make lives for themselves like every other refugee throughout history except for the Palestinians.
It was not "illegally seized". But I see no point in arguing about that.
So my questiontion is-- if we pretend it was "illegally seized"-- who was it seized from? The answer, of course, is Jordan. (Previous to israel control, the WEST Bank was part of Jordan. (Jordan illegally seized it-- but that's another discussion).
What about Gaza? Well, again-- if you were to argue that Israel "illegaly seized Gaza"-- who did they seize that from? Yup-- pror to them "seizing " it-- Gaza was illegally occupied by Egypt. (Of course that whole discussion is moot, because after Israel "seized Gaza from Egypt, in 2005 they "Un-seized" it-- they left (there's not a jew left in the entire place) and Gaza is now an independent entity run by a Palestinian government.
P.S. Personally, I don't recognize the "authority" of the UN-- over me or anyone else. For all I know, I could be doing things that are illegal--illegal under UN law. I don't care-- anymore than I care if In happen to be doing things that are illegal under the laws of Mongolia-- or uruguay-- or the imaginary Land of Oz. I do observe the laws of the United States-- by choice.
And here's the "dirty little secret" of the Arab World-- most of them despite the Palestinians as well. The only reason these hypocrites publically obsess about "Palestine" is because its an efective propaganda tool to bash the Jews.
Look how the Arabs treat the Palestinian "refugees" in their midst....
Not really.
The opinion you linked was about the safety wall that Israel built to stop getting blown up in pizzerias and discotheques.
And not so amazingly it was quite successful in serving its purpose.Most of the "wall" is a fence, andnot much different than many other countries erect on their borders, but after all, what right does Israel have to protect its citizens?
The advisory opinion gives you the context of the illegal nature of the settlements in the context of discussing the wall. The opinion is sound whether or not the Palestinians agreed to the Partition.
Nothing will win you over so I'm content to let history run you over. In time, Zionism will find itself in the trashcan along with apartheid and colonialism. Goodriddance.
An occupied people have at least as much right to resist occupation.
"The truth is on the march and nothing will stop it" It took years of Zola saying this before he was proven right. I can wait too.
By blowing up innocent women and children?
Did you have a problem with Israel blowing upinnocentwomen andchildrento"protect"themselves?
The Palestinians will seek to blow up Jews even after they get their State. They will have to compromise, and that doesn't sit well with them.
Israel is currently 80/20 Jews/Arabs. The Palestinian State will invariably be Judenrien. But having no Jewswon't be enough. They'll still try to kill the ones in Israel.
Israel will not make a bad deal with the Palestinians. Too much will be lost in the distant event of the "fair deal" that will eventually be procured. It would do the Palestinians well to conduct themselves in a more civilized manner, at least until they achieve statehood.
In law, to be guilty of a crime requires proof of intent. The terrorists who blow themselves up in the hopes of killing others have established intent to do so, whereas the collateral damage in a war is not only avoided as much as possible, but expected in the circumstance where Hamas facilitates it.
http://www.unwatch.org/site/apps/nlnet/content2.aspx?c=bdKKISNqEmG&...
Are they not taking the matter to the ICC? (not that I would have any respect for a court that I consider biased).
How can they be an independent state without defined borders?
I doubt that they would join anyway, because then they too would be subject to being convicted of war crimes.
If criminal intent cannot be proven, then opinions about it are just opinions and subject to bias. I, for one, consider Col. Richard Kemp's opinion valid, and I note that those who don't agree with him had no choice because of his status to accuse him of being a patsy for Israel - which is bullshit.
....
Selling land to Israeli settlers is viewed as treason by the Palestinians and carries a penalty of life imprisonment. There have even been several cases in which perpetrators have been killed.
When I first started practising law in Toronto, I was aware that there were residential properties in the Province of Ontario wherein the historical titles contained restrictions preventing selling the properties to Jews, but a court judgment made such restrictions illegal and null and void, I think not until the 1940s. In that case there were no beheadings for doing so, it just meant the title could not legally be passed to a purchaser.
The issue is one of the severity of the penalty for the property seller . Being accused of treason with all that implies matches up with the severity of the penalty for apostasy in Arabic countries ...
It's a little difficult to be a state without defined borders and Israel refuses to agree to them. When the ICC showed willingness to allow Palestine to join anyway, the US and Israel pressured Abbas not to do so. In this instance, the inability to show criminal intent is the direct result of the alleged complainant evading the jurisdiction of the court and/or pressuring the complainant not to pursue action. Is obstructing justice OK in your neck of the woods?
I doubt Abbas is reluctant to join the ICC on the grounds that it would subject certain Palestinians to war crime charges. Those charges would be brought against Hamas, not him (or the PLO), and he couldn't care less whether his political rivals are hanged.
On questions 2 & 3
In a final resolution, we would not see the presence of a single Israeli civilian or soldier on our lands, Abbas said following a meeting with interim Egyptian President Adly Mansour in Cairo.
Damn those Egyptians for creating that prison ! They won't let those poor Gazan smugglers smuggle weapons . How are they expected to earn a living ?!
Glad to see you back, Hyde Whyte - You've been away too long.
I can tell you what will not happen. Israel will not follow the example set by the Palis; that of perfecting their role of victimization, by self-inflicted oppression. The palis obviously also relish their role as spoiler to the existance of Israel, and being used as pawns by their Arab brothers, while Israel will not be used by anybody. Israel will also not give up lands that have been captured in defensive wars, that now serve to further security for the state. Israel will not give up Jerusalem to arabs, who woulduse it to stash more rockets, bombs and ammo. Israel will not allow others to determine it's own course, unlike the palis who have never been in charge of their own government, economy, or foreign affairs; instead forfeiting those responsibilities to the arab league and known terrorist orginazations. Palistine is not a state of their own, because they have failed to act like a state or seize the opportunities to do so.
All kindsa things may be said, that are not true. Also, In particular, many Indians and tribes do not care for that comparison as it actually denigrates their own history and causes. When ya think about it, if Indians had been presented even a hundreth of the opportunities that Palestinians have, their state of affairs would most likely be vastly different now. No, the palestians position is a unique one, and is being exacerbated by their own refusal to come to a peace agreement with their neighbors.
Thanks, Buzz. If it hadn't been for all those emails from NT telling me that you had posted and/or commented on this or that article, I wouldn't even have bothered trying to figure out the forgotten password I used when I joined NT.
Are we really comparing the historical plight of the American Indians to that of the 'palestinians'? Were the Europeans returning to their ancestral homeland like the Jews returned to theirs? The answer to the rhetorical question is obviously no they were not, they simply took what was not theirs to take.
That is much different than the situation in Israel, where the squatters on land that is not theirs are trying to enlist the world's help to keep what they are proving unable to keep themselves. Good thing for the squatters that the Israelis are not nearly as ruthless as the 'white man' was.
Riiiiight . That's exactly what happened in Gaza . Israel was suckered into taking claim to Gaza by Egypt in their peace agreement . After awhile that "illegal settlement" was abandoned to the original inhabitants . If Israel wanted to do a land grab that would be it .
flameaway,
"Who? The Jews or the Europeans?"
The Europeans, in taking the Americas from the Indians.
"Really? You don't see it, huh? Watch this...
Israel convinced the world to give Her land, land Israel had proven incapable of keeping. Then Isralel moved in and displaced the people who had been living there and called them squatters."
There once was a people who were militarily driven from their land (by the Romans in AD70) but they never ceased from longing to return. When they did (yes, roughly 2000 years later) the current conflict ensued. Question is, is there a statute of limitations on stolen property where it no longer belongs to those from whom it was stolen? How would a person feel if they found others had moved into their home after an extended absence, or would they consider them squatters and want them to relinquish the home?
"And about the land...
The land Israel was given belonged to the people that you now sneer at as being unable to keep what they had.
Because Israel took it."
I think it meet to clarify that I see a huge difference between peaceful Palestinians who are willing to live in peaceful co-existence with the Israelis. It is the bloodthirsty murdering terrorists whom my sneering is directed at.
"Israel just murdered 800 women and children; they are sufficiently ruthless."
Clarify please? Are you referring to Israeli military actions directed at stopping the incessant attacks coming from Palestinian held areas such as Gaza?