╌>

Let’s Talk About How Islam Has Been Hijacked

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  12 years ago  •  3 comments

Let’s Talk About How Islam Has Been Hijacked

Let's Talk About How Islam Has Been Hijacked

I'm appalled by what is done in the name of my religion. Yet my American friends don't want to hear it.

By Ali Salem, The Wall Street Journal, October 26, 2014

LAST week a Canadian Muslim gunman went on a rampage in Ottawa, killing a soldier and storming into the parliament building before he was shot dead. Authorities have since said he had applied for a passport to travel to Syria. Three Muslim schoolgirls from Colorado were intercepted in Germany apparently on their way to Syria, the base for attacks there and in Iraq by the terror group Islamic State. An August 20 article in Newsweek estimated that perhaps twice as many British Muslims are fighting for Islamic State as are serving in the British Army.

What could possibly inspire young Muslims in the West to abandon their suburban middle-class existence and join a holy war? How could teenagers in Denver or anywhere be lured by a jihadist ideology or are grisly videos of Islamic State beheadings and crucifixions not enough of a deterrent?

What is so compelling about radical Islamism may lie within its founding texts. It is time we acknowledged the powerful influence these texts have had even on ordinary Muslims. The political ideology based on them has already dragged the Middle East back towards the Stone Age.

As a teenager growing up in Egypt in the 1980s, I liked to stroll through Cairos outdoor book market, fishing out little gems like an Arabic translation of War and Peace. One day I stumbled upon a book that shook everything I believed in.

The book was In the Shadows of the Koran, Sayyed Qutbs magnum opus. The Egyptian writer, who died in 1966, remains arguably the most influential thinker in contemporary Muslim societies. He was the principal theorist of the Muslim Brotherhood and the intellectual impetus behind the Islamist parties it spawned. Qutbs ardent disciples included Osama bin Laden and Ayman Zawahiri of al-Qaida. It is not an exaggeration to say that Qutb is to Islamism what Karl Marx is to communism.

Qutbs brilliance as a theorist was in how he applied Western-style literary criticism to the Koran to interpret Gods intentions. He concluded that the reason for the Muslim worlds decline were external cultural and political influences that diluted Islam: the culprits included everything from Greek empiricism and liberal democracy to socialism, Persian poetry and Hegelian philosophy. The only path to an Islamic renaissance was to cleanse Muslim societies of these contaminants and restore Islam to its seventh-century purity.

Today, Qutbs outlook Islamism is the dominant political ideology in most Muslim-majority countries, often taking root in vacuums where secular politics have never had space to develop. Polls by the Pew Research Centre, such as last years The Worlds Muslims, indicate that in many Muslim countries, the population is overwhelmingly in favour of veiling for women, the death penalty for leaving Islam and stoning as punishment for adultery; rabid anti-Semitism is rampant. The few exceptions to these statistics tend to be countries with a long history of militant secularism (like Turkey), or former communist states (Tajikistan, Bosnia, Albania, etc.) where religion was effectively wiped out of the public sphere. But Islamism is now growing even in those places.

The trend of history is being reversed. In Egypt, for instance, veiling was unheard of 50 years ago and was virtually extinct until the Islamists resurrected the practice in the 70s. Today an estimated 90per cent of Egyptian women are veiled. In many other countries the veil originally a tribal norm, not a religious one is now ubiquitous, as are views on apostasy in countries that werefar more progressive 50 years ago.

Many of my fellow Muslims are trying to reform Islam from within. Yet our voices are smothered in the West by Islamist apologists and their well-meaning but unwitting allies on the Left. For instance, if you try to draw attention to the stark correlation between the rise of Islamic religiosity and regressive attitudes towards women, youre labelled an Islamophobe.

In America, other contemporary ideologies are routinely and openly debated in classrooms, newspapers, on talk shows and in living rooms. But Americans make an exception for Islamism. Criticism of the religion even in abstraction is conflated with bigotry towards Muslims. There is no public discourse, much less an ideological response, to Islamism, in academia or on Capitol Hill. This trend is creating an intellectual vacuum, where poisonous ideas are allowed to propagate unchecked.

My own experience as a Muslim in New York bears this out. Socially progressive, self-proclaimed liberals, who would denounce even the slightest injustice committed against women or minorities in America, are appalled when I express a similar criticism about my own community.

Compare the collective response after each harrowing high-school shooting in America. Intellectuals and public figures look for the root cause of the violence and ask: Why? Yet when I ask why after every terrorist attack, the disapproval I get from my non-Muslim peers is visceral: The majority of Muslims are not violent, they insist, the jihadists are a minority who dont represent Islam, and I am fearmongering by even wondering aloud.

This is delusional thinking. Even as the world witnesses the barbarity of beheadings, habitual stoning and severe subjugation of women and minorities in the Muslim world, politicians and academics lecture that Islam is a religion of peace. Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia routinely beheads women for sorcery and witchcraft.

In the US, we Muslims are handled like exotic flowers that will crumble if our faith is criticised even if we do it ourselves. Meanwhile, Republicans and Democrats alike would apparently prefer to drop bombs in Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan and beyond, because killing Muslims is somehow less offensive than criticising their religion? Unfortunately, you cant kill an idea with a bomb, and so Islamism will continue to propagate.

Muslims must tolerate civilised public debate of the texts and scripture that inform Islamism. To demand any less of us is to engage in the soft bigotry of low expectations.

Aly Salem is an Egyptian writer based in New York.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"Many of my fellow Muslims are trying to reform Islam from within. Yet our voices are smothered in the West by Islamist apologists and their well-meaning but unwitting allies on the Left. For instance, if you try to draw attention to the stark correlation between the rise of Islamic religiosity and regressive attitudes towards women, youre labelled an Islamophobe.

In America, other contemporary ideologies are routinely and openly debated in classrooms, newspapers, on talk shows and in living rooms. But Americans make an exception for Islamism. Criticism of the religion even in abstraction is conflated with bigotry towards Muslims. There is no public discourse, much less an ideological response, to Islamism, in academia or on Capitol Hill. This trend is creating an intellectual vacuum, where poisonous ideas are allowed to propagate unchecked."

There is no doubt that some of the"Islamist apologists" and "Left" of whom he speaks post the kind of articles and make the kind of statements he refers to on social/news network sites.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

This should be published everywhere. We handle these folks with Kid Gloves while screaming about things like how hard it is to be an atheist. Our priorities are plainly and obviously wrong.

 
 
 
Neetu2
Freshman Silent
link   Neetu2    12 years ago

Aly Salem has written a very articulate and well-thought out article on the very essence of the bigotry that runs through the fabric of Islam as we know it.

Unfortunately, he is so right about every point he states. There is the "crumble" factor, the "do not offend" factor, the "you are intolerant" factor, the "All Muslims are not fanatic" factor, among all the others. I am frankly appalled by the academia circles in the top universities of this country where any fingers pointing at the absence of human rights. women's rights, and civil rights within the Islamic world is seen as an offense to the feelings of peace-loving Muslims who have suffered under the yoke of "western oppression" for so long!

Indeed, they cry out against every other violation of human and women's rights, but talk about those things afflicting Islam, and they scream "Vengeance"!

 
 

Who is online

CB
devangelical
Right Down the Center
Gazoo


76 visitors