╌>

HOLDER DOJ EXPERT WITNESS: BLACKS ARE DUMBER AND LESS CIVIC-MINDED THAN WHITES

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  12 years ago  •  17 comments

HOLDER DOJ EXPERT WITNESS: BLACKS ARE DUMBER AND LESS CIVIC-MINDED THAN WHITES

An expert witness hired by Eric Holders Department of Justice testified that North Carolina election law requirements have an adverse impact on black voters because they are less sophisticated than white voters and therefore have more difficulty figuring out how to register to vote. Christian Adams has the details.

The requirements that the DOJs witness found blacks less able than whites to comply with are (1) registering to vote before the day of the election and (2) voting in the precinct where one lives. Since one neednt be at all sophisticated to comply with either requirement, the DOJs witness, who was paid with our tax dollars, must have little regard for African-Americans.

Asked whether terminating the ability to register to vote on the day that someone casts a ballot impacts blacks disproportionately, the DOJs witness, Charles Stewart, testified in court that it does. He reasoned that (1) people who register at the last minute tend to be less sophisticated voters, tend to be less educated voters, tend to be voters who are less attuned to public affairs and (2) people who correspond to those factors tend to be African Americans.

Does the Holder Justice Department really believe that African Americans are less sophisticated voters than whites? Does it really believe they are less attuned than whites to public affairs?

To be sure, blacks vote overwhelmingly in favor of Holders party. Other than that, I see no reason to conclude that they are less sophisticated and less attuned to public affairs than whites.

If a conservative were to so conclude, Eric Holder would be the first to condemn him as a racist. Yet the Holder DOJ is paying a witness to advance this position in a court of law on behalf of the United States of America.

Nor did the DOJs disparagement of blacks end here. Stewart went on to testify that its less likely to imagine that these voters [the unsophisticated ones who, according to Stewart, are disproportionately black] would can figure out or would avail themselves of other forms of registering and voting [besides showing up at the polls and registering]. (emphasis added)

Asked point blank whether African American voters have less ability to figure out what the rules are for voting, Stewart responded: I said African Americans have less education, which leads to an ability to navigate the rules of the game. I assume he meant that less education leads to an inability to navigate them.

As noted, however, the rules of the game at issue here are straightforward. How much education does one need to navigate rules that require registering before election day and voting in the precinct where one lives?

Virtually none. To the extent that the rules of the game exclude people from voting, they exclude those who dont pay attention to the rules because they dont care very much about public affairs.

To assume that African Americans pay disproportionately small amounts of attention to their rights and responsibilities as citizens is to make quite an assumption. It is tantamount to saying that, collectively, African Americans are worse citizens than the rest of us.

Stewarts position, advanced in court on behalf of the Holder DOJ, is an insult to African Americans, and yet another part of Eric Holders disgraceful legacy .

http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2014/10/holder-doj-expert-witness-blacks-are-dumber-and-less-civic-minded-than-whites.php


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Here's the testimony:

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

And who are those less sophisticated voters who cant figure out how to register to vote? They tend to be African Americans, according to Stewart. He added that people who register to vote the closer and closer one gets to Election Day tend to be . . . less-educated voters, tend to be voters who are less attuned to public affairs. Stewart said that these voters tend to be African Americans. Of course, the voter-registration data in North Carolina directly contradicts this, since Stewart was forced to admit that blacks in North Carolina actually were registered at a higher rate than whites before Election Day in the 2012 election.

Stewart leveled the same type of criticism at a measure to reduce the number of early-voting days. African Americans would be deterred from voting, he said again, because they are less sophisticated voters. He denied that he was racially stereotyping blacks even when he said that they have a harder time figuring out how to navigate the rules of the game. He admitted that he did not survey black voters in North Carolina to ask them directly about understanding the rules of registering and voting.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

So where is the equal education opportunities that are supposed to be available to all children in this country? It seems to me that that is the root of the problem, for I do not believe that blacks are less able to learn given the same quality of education.

I do suppose, however, that home environment would have to be a factor as well. Unfortunately, no one wants to address that particular skeleton in the closet.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Its interesting to see the DOJ expert admit what conservatives have argued all along, the objection to voter i.d. laws on the grounds that they are discriminatory only makes sense if you believe blacks are uniquely dumb or ignorant to the point that they can't complete basic tasks like other racial groups.

Its surprising to see A DOJ expert spell that out so forthrightly, but kudos to him for being honest.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago

designed to disenfranchise minority and student voters

It's designed to stop fraud, plain and simple. It's incredibly, incredibly easy to a cast a ballot using someone else's name and the examples are legion. Remember the white guy given the black Eric Holder's ballot? Or the New York City study showing investigators were able to successfully vote 97% of the time as the wrong person and zero percent of the attempted fraudulent votes were reported? In one example from that study, a 24-year female agent gave the name of someone who had died in 2012 at age 87 and was given a ballot.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    12 years ago

"It's that simple." This will probably be the only time I say this to you JR, but you just said a mouth full. Yes it is JUST that SIMPLE. get a photo ID or don't vote. You say just compare signatures, but over time peoples signature have change. also it hard to sign your name exactly twice the same way. But with a photo ID theperson checking the validity of the voter just has to look at the person presenting the ID and the actual ID Yes JR it JUST that SIMPLE.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Signatures change over time. Look up the Charles Parnell case.Election judges check signatures as often as retail clerks do with bank cards, which is to say never.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago


....
For some reason we are brainwashed to think, if you're not a thug or an idiot, you're not black enough, Barkley said. If you go to school, make good grades, speak intelligent , and don't break the law, you're not a good black person.

 
 
 
Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom
Professor Participates
link   Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom    12 years ago

It's been a long time since I have laughed until I peed. Yep, I peed.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
It's funny that simply reporting the testimony of a DOJ witness is a breach of civility. If the fact that your tax dollars are given to a man who characterizes blacks as ignorant of Public affairs, and less sophisticated than whites, blame Eric Holder for paying him to testify on the government's behalf.I find such beliefs abhorrent and racist, it's sad the Obama administration spreads them.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"BLACKS ARE DUMBER AND LESS CIVIC-MINDED THAN WHITES"

Except for the hateful, stupid whites who buy such an insensitive, piece-of-shit of a broad brush generalization.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Of course it's repugnant. the opinion was bought and paid for by the obama administration, you should protest to them. It's your party that offered that position in court.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

North Carolina election law requirements have an adverse impact on black voters because they are less sophisticated than white voters and therefore have more difficulty figuring out how to register to vote.

Total fucking bullshit; the registration process is made intentionally tortuous for the working poor -- many of whom are black, who can't afford cars so don't have drivers' licenses with photos -- AND THUS CAN'T DRIVE TO THE DESIGNATED PLACES THAT ISSUE THE REQUIRED ID (BY FUCKING DESIGN) -- DITTO THE ELDERLY, STUDENTS and THE SICK.

'Reasonable Impediment' Clause Becomes Focus Of S.C. Voter ID Law Hearing

Study: Many Could Face Obstacles In Voter ID Laws

Some of the recent history (as in after Republicans won many states in 2010)

Attacks On Voting Rights

Over the past year and a half, several states have attempted to implement laws that, in practice, will greatly restrict access to the ballot box. Lawmakers have designed legislation to restrict access to the polls by shortening the early voting period, eliminating Election Day registration, making it harder for third-party groups to register voters, and restricting the types of identification a voter can use to vote. While proponents defend these bills by using false claims of widespread voter fraud, it is hard not to see the underlying intent is to erect barriers to make voting more difficult. Instead of eliminating fraud, these laws have the effect of discouraging voting among minorities, low-income voters, the elderly, voters with disabilities, young people, women, and low-wage workers.

SHORTENING EARLY VOTING PERIODS

This year Florida and Ohio passed legislation to shorten the period when voters can vote early. In Florida, the number of days to vote early was reduced from 14 to eight. In Ohio, the in-person early voting window was shortened from 35 days before Election Day to 17 days and the period for absentee voting by mail from 35 days to 21. These changes will result in longer lines, more complications, and more provisional ballots on Election Day that will turn many voters away or make their ballot not count. However, Ohio lawmakers repealed the law shortening early voting after a referendum to reject the law was placed on the November ballot. Unfortunately, the repeal did not restore early voting the weekend before Election Day.

ENDING ELECTION DAY REGISTRATION

Last year, Maine passed legislation that would end the states 38-year history of registering to vote on Election Day. The legislation would have cut off voter registration two days before an election. Proponents of ending Election Day registration state that it results in errors and increases the likelihood of voter fraud. However, after allegations by Maine GOP Chair Charlie Webster that over 200 ineligible students voted in Maine, the Maine Secretary of State investigated and only found one instance of voter fraud in the past decade. Fortunately, Mainers gathered enough petition signatures to place the bill up for a peoples veto and the law was overturned last November. The Montana legislature also passed a bill to end Election Day registration last year. Fortunately, it was vetoed by Governor Brian Schweitzer (D).

RESTRICTIONS ON THIRD-PARTY REGISTRATION

Both Florida and Texas passed laws last year that make it harder for third-party groups to conduct voter registration drives. In Florida, black and Hispanic Floridians and those from Spanish-speaking homes are over twice as likely to register to vote via third party groups as white Floridians or those from English-speaking households. The new law will require voter registration groups to register all paid staff and volunteers with the state if they are collecting voter registration forms. These groups will have 48 hours to return signed voter registration forms or face fines up to $1,000. The League of Womens Voters (LWV), a group that has registered voters for over the past 70 years in Florida, ended its voter registration program in Florida because of the new law. Fortunately, LWV has resumed its voter registration program after parts of Floridas new law were blocked in federal court. Michigan is also considering legislation to restrict third party voter registration.

STRICTER VOTER ID LAWS

In 2011, 34 states considered more restrictive voter ID laws. Of those, 12 states passed legislation to require or request a photo ID to vote, however in five of those states the Democratic governor vetoed the legislation. Those states include Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, and North Carolina. The seven states with new photo ID requirements are Alabama, Kansas, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Texas,Tennessee, and Wisconsin.

Mississippi voters passed a constitutional amendment requiring voter photo ID that must go through preclearance from the US Department of Justice. In South Carolina and Texas, the U.S. Department of Justice denied preclearance of the voter ID law because the state could not prove the law would not have a discriminatory affect on minority voting. Those cases are on appeal. In Wisconsin, two separate state judges issued injunctions suspending the law, ruling that the law violated the state constitutions guarantee to the right to vote.

This year, several more states have introduced strict ID legislation including Colorado, New Mexico, New Hampshire, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. Recently, Virginia passed a voter ID law that also allows non-photo ID. Pennsylvanias new photo ID law is considered one of the strictest in the country. New Hampshire passed a voter photo ID law after overriding a veto.

Proponents of photo ID laws claim these laws need to be put in place to stop voter fraud. However, no evidence exists of widespread voter fraud. The incidence of voter fraud is so low that an American is more likely to be struck by lightning than an incidence of voter fraud to occur for a good reason. Its not worth the hefty fines and jail time for one extra vote. Moreover, voting is the foundation of our democracy. Disenfranchising millions for something that rarely occurs weakens our democracy not strengthens it.

PURGING OF VOTER ROLLS

Recently, Florida Governor Rick Scott and Secretary of State Ken Detzner ordered the Florida Division of Elections to send county supervisors of elections a list of nearly 2,700 voters that they flagged as possible non-citizens by comparing voter lists with the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) database and jury recusal forms. These matches are scheduled to be removed from the rolls if they do not respond to notification within 30 days. Already over 500 of those on the list have shown documentation proving they are eligible voters. Given the high error rate, many eligible voters in Florida could lose their right to vote if they do not respond to the letter. The U.S. Department of Justice filed a lawsuit challenging the program. The Fair Elections Legal Network, along with other civil and voting rights groups, also filed a challenge to the program.

THESE LAWS WILL LOWER VOTER TURNOUT

Instead of protecting the integrity of the voting process, these new laws will actually harm the election process because they will make voting less convenient for everyone. These laws have a disproportionate impact on traditionally underrepresented groups including minorities, low-income voters, the elderly, voters with disabilities, young people, women, and low-wage workers. These groups are less likely to be registered to vote, have one of the forms of photo ID required by the new laws, or the means to attain one, and are more likely to take advantage of early voting periods.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Take it up with the Obama administration, it's their opinion that blacks are less sophisticated. Read the transcript of the hearing and see how loathsome the DOJs position is.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Show me the part of the transcript that leads to the quote and the quote itself the report is rather cumbersome and firs time around in going through Stewart's testimony, I did not come across the quote.

And let's correctly characterize the idea of sending an "expert witness" or any other to testify at a hearing or trial. Upon being questioned, the witness, etc. is supposed to give honest answers -- not scripted answers if they are not honest.

Does anyone really believe that Holder or anyone in the Obama Administration would have sent anyone to give a response as "reported" in the headline?

This story, as predictable, appears throughout the right-wing blogosphere. I'll review Stewart's testimony again later today, in the meantime

Start on p.184 of the transcript.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"the simplest way to defend the charge that you made up a bullshit title in order to race bait."



It's the actual title of the article that I seeded. I assume you didn't bother to actually read the linked article or the copy of the DOJ experts testimony that I attached in the first response. It's all there.

The race baiting, as you so aptly characterize it, is bought to you by the Obama administration, which blows yet another hole in the silly conservatives are racists meme you've been peddling.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Just post the transcript page number and the line number where the comment appears.

 
 

Who is online


Right Down the Center
Gazoo
Sean Treacy


79 visitors