╌>

New GOP Strategy On Iran Deal - turn the deal into a never-ending political circus.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  8 comments

New GOP Strategy On Iran Deal -  turn the deal into a never-ending political circus.

"Republican lawmakers, having lost the battle to block the Iran nuclear deal in Congress, appear to be considering a new strategy: turn the deal into a never-ending political circus.

The old and busted GOP plan was to vote on a measure formally disapproving of the Iran nuclear deal. Republicans could express their rejection of the deal, forcing President Obama to veto their resolution. That way they'd get to oppose the deal without actually taking responsibility for finding an alternative. But Obama got more supporters in the Senate than was expected enough that he won't have to veto and the resolution became something of an embarrassment for Republicans.

So now the new hotness among Republicans is that they shouldn't bother voting to disapprove of the Iran nuclear deal, and instead should vote for a resolution that, according to Politico's Jake Sherman , "would delay a disapproval vote because they believe Obama has not disclosed some elements of the deal." The entire caucus is not yet on board, but it looks like they're moving in this direction.

The Washington Post's Greg Sargent called this "snatching defeat from the jaws of defeat," which is a great line, but to me this looks like a much stronger political strategy for Republicans, even if it is also cynical and dishonest. So much stronger, in fact, that I'm sort of surprised they're only coming around to it now.

Why Republicans love this new Iran deal strategy: even less responsibility, more political controversy

Republicans, in this new plan, would argue that President Obama didn't live up to his promise to fully inform Congress about the Iran nuclear deal, so therefore Congress cannot vote on whether to approve the deal.

This is not really true, but that's beside the point. The point is that Republicans don't like their current strategy because it means, after they vote on their doomed resolution, they will have conceded the Iran deal as politically legitimate.

This new strategy would allow Republicans to argue in perpetuity that the Iran nuclear deal is somehow illegitimate, without ever actually proving that. It would create a definitionally irresolvable political "controversy" over the deal, allowing Republicans to raise money and hold hearings and go on conservative talk radio for many years to come, making conspiratorial claims about the Obama administration withholding some vital information.

It would look, in other words, a lot like Republicans' years-long political campaign over Benghazi . In that campaign, the focus was almost never on actual US mistakes in Libya which are substantial but complex but rather was on misleading conspiracy theories and nonsense political controversies .

Similarly, this new GOP anti-deal strategy would let them avoid the actual substance of the Iran deal, and instead focus on dark claims about self-inspections and the like. This not only lets Republicans direct the focus to talk-radio-friendly conspiracy theories, but also allows them to assert, for years to come, that Obama never followed correct procedure on getting congressional approval, and thus that the Iran deal is illegitimate.

The first such conspiracy theory they appear to be going with the first of many, I am sure is the alleged "secret side deal."

The "secret side deal" controversy, explained

Republicans' argument is basically this: President Obama promised to send Congress the full text of the Iran nuclear once it was reached (true), after which Congress has 60 days to review before voting on whether to disapprove of the deal (true), but Obama did not technically complete his end of the bargain (false) because he did not send Congress the text of the "secret side deal" with Iran (complicated; see below). Therefore the 60-day congressional review never happened (false), thus the deal is illegitimate (false).

The alleged "secret side deal" is an agreement between the International Atomic Energy Agency (the UN nuclear watchdog) and Iran over how the IAEA will conduct certain inspections and verification procedures of Iranian facilities, as well as IAEA investigations into past elements of Iran's nuclear program that may have had a military component.

The IAEA has such agreements with every country where it works, including the United States. Because the IAEA wants as much access as possible, and because countries do not necessarily want the details of their nuclear facilities broadcast to the world, the details of these agreements are typically secret. That is the case with the IAEA's agreement with Iran.

It is not a "side deal," nor is its existence secret; the nuclear deal requires the IAEA to monitor Iranian facilities, so naturally the IAEA was going to work out the logistical details of that with Tehran. As nuclear experts Mark Hibbs and Thomas Shea explained recently in the Hill , anyone with the most basic knowledge of the IAEA understands that this is how it works, and that this secrecy ultimately helps the IAEA and thus the US against Iran's nuclear program:

The IAEA has safeguards agreement with 180 countries. All have similar information protection provisions. Without these, governments would not open their nuclear programs for multilateral oversight. So IAEA Director General Yukiya Amano was acting by the book on August 5 when he told members of Congress that he couldnt share with them the details of a verification protocol the IAEA had negotiated with Iran as part of a bilateral "roadmap" to address unresolved allegations about Irans nuclear behavior.

Like Iran, the United States has a safeguards agreement with the IAEA. Were lawmakers from Irans Majlis to ask the IAEA to see documents concerning its negotiations with the United States, members of Congress would presumably be pleased to hear that Amanos answer would also be no. Of course, Iran may choose to share its information with other parties and, in this case, Iran provided details of the roadmap to negotiators from the U.S. Department of State. Congress may not be happy that it is not in the loop, but it is not up to the IAEA to decide whether to share information about where and how its personnel do their work in Iran.

Republicans are now pretending that this is all a big surprise and that they have a right to see the complete text of any IAEA agreements. In fact, there is nothing guaranteeing Congress review over IAEA agreements with Iran. The IAEA would never agree to such a thing (fortunately for the US, which has its own agreements with the IAEA), and neither would the Obama administration.

Don't take my word for it: You can read, for yourself, the law that Congress passed articulating its authority to disapprove the Iran deal. Section 135 describes the congressional review period, and specifically articulates the documents that the Obama administration is required to give Congress. There is nothing in there about the text of IAEA safeguards agreements with Iran.

The "secret side deal" controversy is designed to be impossible to resolve

It seems likely that Republicans will counter this by arguing that they didn't put that into the law because they didn't anticipate such IAEA agreements. But, to be clear, this is a lie. The IAEA has safeguards agreements with 180 countries ; it is a standard practice. The Iran nuclear deal requires the IAEA to conduct extensive monitoring and verification of Iranian facilities, so by definition it would compel the IAEA to work out safeguards agreements with Iran.

The next line of Republican argumentation is going to be that, sure, IAEA safeguards agreements are routine, and sure it is standard practice that the text of such agreements is not opened up to curious third parties such as the US Congress. But someone will inevitably leak some prejudicial and selective details to make those agreements look bad it's already happened which Republicans will seize on to argue that there are "questions" about this particular IAEA agreement or another and thus they must be granted permission to see it.

But they know this demand would be impossible: The moment the IAEA starts opening up its safeguards agreements to satisfy domestic political controversies in one country or another, its credibility will be devastated.

Imagine you are a head of state in some country with a nuclear program: Would you let in nuclear inspectors, knowing that one day if American lawmakers decide to get up in arms, they could compel the IAEA to release all sorts of secret details about your country's facilities? Maybe you still would, but maybe you wouldn't, and that's a risk the IAEA can't take."

MORE OF THIS STORY http://www.vox.com/2015/9/9/9296551/iran-nuclear-side-deal-republicans


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

So, they will never try and vote on the deal, and then claim that it is illegitimate for that reason. And we will hear all this whining and lying far into the future.

I wonder just what year gridlock will be ended ? We are already up to 2025 and counting.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Let's practice reading 101. To quote the Washington Post, "The act defines agreement, with exceptional precision, to include not only the agreement between Iran and six Western powers but also any additional materials related thereto, including...side agreements, implementing materials, documents, and guidance, technical or other understandings, and any related agreements, whether entered into or implemented prior to the agreement or to be entered into or implemented in the future.The secret side deals are obviously "related," to pretend otherwise is a perversion of logic and language.

Vox has apparently learned nothing after being so thoroughly embarrassed when it tried to discredit the AP's reporting on the Parchin agreement. Much like termites eat wood, Vox has to spin for the democrats. It's simply what it does.

Corker Cardin is unambiguous. All side agreements have to be turned over to Congress that relate to the joint agreement (including those with our "allies" that protect their businesses from sanctions if Iran somehow manages to get caught violating the agreement) Thereare no exceptions and Obama should have negotiated for them if he wanted certain secret agreements excluded from the light of day. He failed to do so, and the law is clear.

Obama hasn't complied with Corker Cardin. Sanctions remain in place.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean, since the IAEA does not ever reveal it's "secret" arrangements with various countries that it monitors, just how will any of the Republicans complete a "better" deal with the Iranians? EVERY deal with Iran that involves the IAEA will result in these "secret" terms.

This is all bullshit, everyone who reads the article will see that, and the "strategy" is a cynical attempt by the political right to mislead the American people. For about the 5,000th time.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Your own source admits these agreements are only "typically" secret. This is not a Typical deal.Do you think obama is competent lawyer? Does he understand English? The language in the law he signed is broad and contains no exceptions. If he didn't want to turn over all agreements, he should have vetoed corker Cardin. But that assumes he Beleives in the rule of law, which we know he doesn't.He just picks and chooses which laws or parts thereof help him politically and ignores the rest.
 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"Whatever course House Republicans choose will have almost no practical impact.

Obama has won the support of enough Democrats in the Senate to sustain his veto. The move would force Democrats to vote for the agreement, instead of against disapproval.

But, as of next week, Obama can implement the multi-nation agreement with Iran. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) called Roskam's plan "cute," and said that no matter what, Obama's deal goes into effect on Sept. 17.

House and Senate Republicans find themselves deeply split. Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), who drafted the process that gave Congress the right to review the agreement, doesn't think Roskam's motion is worth considering. Corker said the Senate will vote on a disapproval resolution,

"Where does that take you?" Corker asked Wednesday, speaking of Roskam's plan to halt the vote because Obama has not submitted the so-called side deals. "I think we know where the votes are We ought to stay on the substance of why we oppose this deal."

For Boehner, McCarthy and Scalise, this is a serious warning sign. They are entering a month that will set the tone for the rest of their congressional careers . If they're struggling on how to register their opposition to the Iran deal which they're unanimously against how will they deal with a potential government shutdown over funding Planned Parenthood, over which there's real dissension among GOP lawmakers?

It's a question many senior Republicans are asking Wednesday."



Read more:

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

They have until September 17th. And the clock is ticking.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean, I don't see anything outside of the usual suspect right wing media sources that indicates this "strategy" could be actually meaningful in terms of preventing the agreement going into effect.

Why doesn't your party work on doing something to benefit the people of this nation instead of constantly going off on tangents ?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

The GOP in the House can argue over this until they are blue in the face. If they don't pass a bill saying they object by the 17th, the deal is going to go into affect because they won't have a bill to pass up to the Senate, where they don't have the votes anyway. If the do pass a bill saying they object by the 17th, the deal is still going to go into effect anyway, because they don't have the votes in the Senate. The President doesn't need the approval of the House or really anything from them. It doesn't matter.

 
 

Who is online







75 visitors