╌>

Hamas leader's daughter received medical treatment in Israel: sources

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  screminmimi  •  12 years ago  •  23 comments

Hamas leader's daughter received medical treatment in Israel: sources

Reuters

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - A daughter of the leader of Hamas in Gaza was admitted to an Israeli hospital for emergency medical treatment this month after she suffered complications from a routine procedure, two sources familiar with the case said.

Ismail Haniyeh's daughter's week-long admission to a hospital in Tel Aviv - which Israeli and Palestinian officials declined to confirm or deny - shows humanitarian coordination between the sides continues just weeks after the Gaza war ended.

Haniyeh, who has 13 children, is the leader of the Islamist group in Gaza and one of its most senior figures overall, serving as a deputy to Khaled Meshaal, who lives in exile.

Two sources - one Palestinian and the other a foreign diplomat with knowledge of the case - declined to name the daughter and, out of respect for her privacy, asked that details of her condition not be published.

Like many Hamas officials, Haniyeh spent the seven-week-long war largely in hiding. His home in the northern part of the Gaza Strip was destroyed by an Israeli air strike.

An Israeli official said he could not discuss specific medical admissions from Gaza.

But he said that in most cases a request by a Palestinian doctor to allow a patient across the border for urgent treatment was sufficient - indicating Haniyeh may not have been personally involved in his daughter's application.

During the war and since it ended in late August, dozens of patients from Gaza have been brought to hospitals in Israel, where the resources and technology for advanced treatment and complicated operations are vastly better.

Hamas is sworn to Israel's destruction but has voiced openness to a long-term truce and a measure of cooperation with Israel which, along with neighboring Egypt, controls access to the coastal enclave, home to 1.8 million Palestinians.

Israeli media has reported that one of Haniyeh's granddaughters was treated in an Israeli hospital last November, while his mother-in-law sought treatment in a Jerusalem hospital in June.

http://news.yahoo.com/hamas-leaders-daughter-received-medical-treatment-israel-sources-154814306.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

BDS?

Only when something the Jews are so good at isn't needed by them. Hypocrites.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

The Palestinians refused to allow a mobile emergency hospital to be stationed at the border crossing during the war this summer to treat civilians. Israel offered to send blood plasma to them to treat the wounded and they refused to accept it because it was "Jewish blood."

Israel then offered to collect blood only from its Arab residents to send and the Palestinians also refused to accept that as well.

It seems that receiving help from the Jewish medical community depends on where you stand in the Arab "Who's Who."

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Oh, the irony of it...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Yes, it is "human interest" John.

Sorry I forgot to check with you about it being appropriate to post. I'll see if I can find the article about the Palestinians painting swastikas on the Temple Mount.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Of course they refused Jewish blood, and they couldn't be sure that what was promised as Arab only blood did not contain a bit of Jewish blood in it, so they refused it. After all, it is contrary to the Q'oran to touch pigs (and apes) or their descendants. s/

Pesonally, I think they read my article about Ziodine and are afraid that it could be included in the blood and used to pacify the shahids.

Those Gazans and other Palestinians who have been treated in Israeli hospitals or clinics since the invention of Ziodine have not been known to join the conflict against Israel. which is proof of its effectiveness.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

This is an interesting "human interest story", but that's about it.

DNFTT!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

The story is just an example of two things:

1. The humanitarian efforts of the Israelis

2. The hypocrisy of the Gazans/Palastinians

In that respect it IS a human interest story, and if the Israel-bashers choose to deny those facts then let them do so. There is no reason to have posted it on the Cockroach Club.

So go ahead, John and flame, consider the article one to elicit discussion.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

How, in what way that is not factual, does the story describe the Palestinians negatively? If you were to write the story, and we both know that you are very competent in using words, would you tell the story truthfully in a light that in your opinion puts the Palestinians in a positive light?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

WRONG, John. Show me a story of Gazans helping a wounded Israeli soldier or something of that nature, and I will certainly lay credit where credit is due. I'd like to see YOU do that one day.

You seem to revel in criticizing my support of Israel - so thank you, you are just strengthening my resolve.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

And you think YOU are objective? Pot/kettle. Glass houses.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

My first comment on this article are the letters "BDS."

It is to show, once again, that the hypocritical nonsense of the BDS faction is just that... nonsense. The accomplishments of the Israelis/Jewish people in every field touches the lives of individuals around the world in ways they don't even realize.

In this case, even Hamas leaders place the lives of their families in the talented hands and medical knowledge of the hated Jews rather than chance them with with their own, or with anyone else. I posted an article about irrigation systems a few weeks ago. They have developed an app for cell phones that will tell you, regardless of where in the world you are, the nearest facility in case you think you are experiencing heart problems, and how to get there. (A minor convenience unless you are having heart problems.)

Instead of this drivel about attacking Buzz, and saying this article should have been posted in the Cockroach Club where everyone will agree with each other, try a comment about the hypocrisy of Hamas in not allowing Gaza citizens to avail themselves of Israeli hospitals and medical treatment but making sure their own family members were treated to it? Or how the people and companies signing off on the BDS movement are in no way living up to the lip service they are showing for press coverage, because the accomplishments of the Israelis are too vast and important in their daily lives to cast aside?

You talk endlessly about "truth" and you conveniently turn aside from it when it doesn't suit you. Since you can't argue with the article you resort to saying it shouldn't have been published.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

However, my question was whether you consider your side to be objective?

I cannot answer for "my side" if you are referring to more than myself, but for myself I can say that if I am stating facts, then I am being objective. If I am quoting what another said, it would only be subjective on my part if I agreed or disagreed with it. But if I am providing my own feelings or opinion on something, then how can I, or ANYONE (including you), be objective?

And Buzz, can you honestly say that you believe the Pro-Israel folks deal with dissent to their views on Israel objectively?

Sometimes yes and sometimes no. People are only human and if they are attacked, or baited, or faced with the comments of a troll they might well be subjective. However, I can speak only for myself, and I see nothing wrong with dissent although I might try to correct something that is merely repetition of propaganda bullshit.

And if ya'll do not; then who does this hurt. Israel and her supporters or everyone else?

You mean someone gets hurt by being subjective in response to dissent? I don't know. Do you?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Well said, screminmimi.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

The typical Pro-Israel response is to make a surface defence and then retire from the field once questions get a bit to uncomfortable to manage. Whether this retreat is a personal attack like accusing the dissenter of being a troll, anti-semitic or worse, doesn't change the nature of the response. Or the simple refusal to continue the discussion once it moves to uncomfortable areas.

The typical Pro-Israel response to someone beating a dead horse or baiting just for the fun of it is exactly as you describe, and rightly so. Live with it.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Do you consider criticisms of Israel's policy with a mind open to change?

When I first started on NV a number of years ago I was more supportive of Israel than I am now. In my opinion Israel could do no wrong, but by increasing my knowledge through the comments of FAIR-MINDED people and becoming more critical of Israel and Israelis I gradually changed my mind and began to realize that Israel is not perfect, but then is there a country that is? Is there a person who is? I admit that I am not perfect, and my opinions may not be perfect, but I am only human.

Do you patiently answer criticism with facts?

I try to. Sometimes such criticism is obviously meant to taunt and bait in which case I see nothing wrong with ignoring it and letting the perpetrator stew in his own bullshit.

Do you allow your opponents their views without making them less than you simply because you disagree?

Once again, that depends upon the intent of the opponent. If I feel that they are just baiting me or lying or just repeating obvious bullshit such as calling Israelis murderers I just might tell them to go to hell, or maybe just ignore them and walk away.

One good example of what to do is what Randy (Micky Mouse) and I have agreed to, and I respect him for it. Since neither of us will change our view, we agreed to not discuss that particular topic between us or criticize the other for our opinion on it. In all other matters, for a number of reasons, we get along very well and are almost always in agreement, and we have been friends for years, both on NV in the past and now here.

Now, YOU answer those same questions.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Kind of hard nosed to intentionally destroy businesses and infrastructure, repeatedly, and then blame the civilian victims of these depredations for being poor and incapable of caring for themselves properly.

First of all, the necessary stopping of the rocket attacks on Israel from Gaza was not, as you exaggerate, an intentional destruction of businesses and infrastructure. Don't fire rockets and Israel need not respond.

Unfortunately, people who refuse to make peace and prefer to keep shooting themselves in the foot are bound to suffer for it. Just imagine how viable a Palestinian state could have been if the Arabs/Palestinians had actually made peace. Gaza could have been the Riviera of the Arab world, for example. There was evidence from independent journalists that the Hamas militants used the hospitals as bases, and NOBODY is sneering - so stop the bullshit.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I'm also quite aware of your position on the issues we discuss. I just happen to disagree with many of them.

My position, or the issues?

Actually it doesn't matter. Whatever we have to say is not going to stop the world from spinning. I think that rather than running away from facing whatever is being said, since as I said it has proven in so many cases to be beating a dead horse, we should just agree to disagree and (using your expression) wave goodbye on the issue.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"In the same way, if you can pull some quotes from me where I have insulted or baited you. Then why don't you go ahead and do that, and I'll apologize."

Right now I don't have time to research, and besides, I never meant to insult you, if in fact I have. However, if I see that you do so in the future I'll point it out to you. Now I'm going to be busy for a while on a project so I'm signing out NOT BECAUSE I CANNOT RESPOND TO ANYTHING, BUT BECAUSE I HAVE WORK TO DO. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

As I said, in the face of factual evidence and honesty, I'm not backing out of arguing the point. I'm just tired of beating a dead horse.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

As for hypocrisy, I wonder at the hypocrisy of blowing up Palestinian infrastructure. including hospitals, over the course of decades. And then sneering about the poor Palestinian healthcare system.

flame,

I was not sneering about the poor healthcare system. My comment was about the hypocrisy of Hamas not allowing Palestinian civilians who were injured to be treated by Israelis, yet sending their own families to be treated by the "enemy" because presumably, the care is better.

Kind of hard nosed to intentionally destroy businesses and infrastructure, repeatedly, and then blame the civilian victims of these depredations for being poor and incapable of caring for themselves properly.

Neither did I make any inference of the above statement.

Again, those who beat the drum for the BDS movement do not practice what they preach even when they have the financial means to do so. Even the liberal actors who lend their fame and name to the movement, when presented with a script that could be a huge blockbuster, do not check first to see if it was written by, will be produced by, or directed by, a Jew... an ethnicity that dominates the entertainment industry.

See what I mean. Our opinion is not welcome unless it follows your idea of what? Correctness or something?

I disagree that no one is sneering. It's the point of the article to point out Hamas hypocrisy, and establish Israel's moral superiority.

The point of the article was to point out the hypocrisy of the BDS movement, but have at it. Your comments here are astounding. Because you don't have a leg to stand on to defend this action you are attacking the fact that it was posted.

Hamas would not allow Gazan citizens to be treated by Israel.

Hamas would not allow blood plasma to be donated by Israel.

Hamas sent its own family members to be treated by Israel.

The BDS blowhards only want others to BDS; they themselves are exempt from BDSing if it inconveniences them.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Actually this article does not make Israel morally superior, it merely gives voice to that fact. If giving aid to one's foe doesn't give clarity to the notion of moral superiority, then there is no such thing. We aren't justtalking about individuals from warring factions giving aid to the other side's citizens, we are talking about the leadership and very government, giving aid to the citizens of the other side. This is no plain ol' human intrest story as some one like to make it out to be; but, at it's core, exemplifies the moral, cultural, humanitarian, andspiritual differences between the two sides. Existentially, Israel is of more value to the world than hamas by far. Relativism is the last breath of dying ideologies, and obviously in wide usage here. Most Americans will easily recognize this account for the truth it represents; that Israel is righteous in it's endeavors to live in peace.

You bet I'm sneering. The devil hates to be mocked and is more than deserving of ridicule and derision. If Israel acted the same way as hamas, this gal would have had her head sawed off on youtube while soldiers sang hymns, women passed out candy, and children danced in the streets around her.

Be encouraged supporters of our greatest ally in the ME. America and most of her citizens are not fooled by anachronistic tribalism; nor, patheticattempts to derideIsrael for it'sgood will, even yetwhile batteling thatout-dated tribalism. We will continue to fight along beside her against gross violenceand evil doers. We will not be swayed by corrosive and deceptive rhetoric,or let Israel face it's enemies alone; but, will help to destroy all those who oppose us, regardless of twisted morality or the purposeful confusion of analysis.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Fact: Hamas and their supporters have unleashed rocket attacks on Israel.

Fact: Israel has responded with attacks to make the Hamas attacks stop.

Fact: Like any nation, Israel has responded with the superiority of their weaponry, because the goal of 'war;' is to disable the other guy's ability and will to fight.

Fact: The Israelis are treating the injured as patients, not as Palestinians, not as Israelis, but as patients.

Fact: The Israelis have been treating the Palestinians as patients since long before this latest chapter.

So, yes, the Israelis occupy the moral high ground in this article. The moral of the story is, Fire rockets at someone else, expect them to respond and when they respond, they will play to win.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Fact: The story illustrates to me that Hamas, like the god Janus, shows two faces depending on which is more convenient at any given time.

Fact: I posted this story to illustrate that the BDS movement is a sham as none of the people claiming to support it, even Arabs, will stand by it when Israeli accomplishments will benefit them.

Fact: The next time this farce concerning how Israel should have kept the death toll even on both sides in the last Gaza-implemented war is mentioned, it should be balanced out with a byline of how many innocents the US is now killing with air strikes as it attempts to help allies in the latest Middle East skirmishes.... and be sure to point out that the enemy we are firing on has not bombarded the US with rocket fire, dug tunnels to infiltrate our country for the purpose of terrorist acts, or kidnapped and murdered any of our children.

 
 

Who is online

Right Down the Center
Dismayed Patriot


78 visitors