US Shut Down Effort to Help Locate Kidnapped Israeli Soldier
Staff Sgt. Oron Shaul, HY"D, killed in Operation Protective Edge.
Whoabruptly shut downin-processU.S. assistance to the Israeli government in its effort to locate a missing IDF soldier trapped in Gaza and in the clutches of Hamas? This is a mystery that demands to be answered.
The story first broke on Friday, Oct. 16, when top U.S. terrorism expert Steve Emerson penned a blockbuster report which appearedin his Investigative Project on Terrorism .
Emerson revealed there was an urgent, life-and-death request from the Israeli to the U.S. government for help in tracing the whereabouts of an Israeli soldier who was believed dragged dead or alive, no one was sure from a burning personnel carrier in the bowels of Gaza during this summers Operation Protective Edge.
The request was coursing through channels when all of a sudden the doors slam shut. An ordinary request that by all rights and beliefs shouldhave been processed swiftly by one ally for another was peremptorily quashed. The request was denied and instead the U.S. prosecutors who had already geared up to assist our ally were told to stand down. Someone, somewhere in the U.S. governmenthad decided instead that a formal, lengthy process was required, one that completely ignored the immediacy of the situation. That message was sent in an email from the FBI.
But the FBI does not make foreign policy decisions. It was not the FBI who yanked the lifeline from the Israeli captured behind enemy lines. So who did?
THE BACKGROUND
On July 20, the second day of the ground offensive during Operation Protective Edge, several members of the famed Golani brigade of the Israel Defense Force traveled into Gaza in an ancient armored personnel carrier.
The APC stalled in a crowded neighborhood and Hamas struck it with an anti-tank missile, causing it to explode. The blast was horrific a munitions stockpile within the APC must have been hit and Hamas terrorists fell upon the burning hulk, preventing IDF soldiers from immediately retrieving any IDF wounded or dead within the vehicle.
By the time IDF combat engineers were able to erect a barrier and seclude the APC from the marauding terrorists, one soldier remained unaccounted for. The body of First Sgt. Oron Shaul, 21, was missing. The bodies of six of his comrades were retrieved.
The next day, Hamas announced that it had capturedShaul. The announcement was met by singing and dancing and the distribution of candy in the streets of Gaza.
Hamas suggested that it had captured Shaul alive. It released Shaulspicture,his army ID number and other of his belongings.
HAMASPOSTED ON SHAULS FACEBOOK ACCOUNT
To prove its boast, Hamas hacked into Shauls Facebook page and posted claims in Arabic, Hebrew and English that he was being held by Hamas. The posts taunted Shauls family and his comrades.
Despite intense efforts to recover Shaul, the IDF was unable to do so and was not even sure if the soldier was living or dead.
But Hamas made a mistake in an effort to broadcast its treachery. By hacking into Shauls Facebook account, they left footprints which could be followed to determine their location. Those footprints are known as the Internet Protocol address. Facebooks servers automatically keep a record of the IP address whenever an account is accessed, and that IP address is accompanied by the physical location, which would show where the Hamas hackers were when they hacked Shauls account.
As Emerson explained, if the Israelis could obtain the Facebook server data as soon as possible, they might have had a chance to find the whereabouts of the terrorists who took Oron.
US COULD HELP LOCATE SHAUL WITH WARRANT FOR FACEBOOK
And that is where the U.S. comes into the picture. Facebook is a U.S. company, and in order torequire Facebook to turn over the IP address on its server, a court warrant has to be issued. This is the process on which U.S. prosecutors had begun working, after a request was forwarded from the U.S. Embassy in Israel to the Justice Department.
The Justice Department had to authorize the request, as it is the entity within the U.S. government which handles international terrorism matters. Hamas, of course, is designated by the U.S. government as a foreign terrorist organization. And the use of Facebook by a foreign terrorist organization to promulgate propaganda- the hacking into IDF Sgt. Shauls Facebook account constituted material support to a designated terrorist organization.
Upon receiving the request from Israel in Washington on July 21, the FBI immediately issued a preservation letter to Facebook, ordering them to preserve all data saved on the server pertaining to Shauls account, Emerson explained.
The FBI contacted the U.S. Attorneys Office to begin the legal process to get a court order to serve Facebook for the IP information on Shauls account. Late afternoon on July 21, theU.S. Attorneys office informed the FBIthat it was just about ready to proceed to obtain the court order for Facebook to turn over the information.
US SHUTS DOWN EFFORT TO LOCATE SHAUL
Suddenly, and to the shock of the prosecutors working feverishly to obtain the information that possibly could reveal where Shaul (or his body) was being held, ashockingemail arrived from the FBI. An email that spelled a death sentence for what many believed to be the best chance of finding Shaul and his kidnappers.
Thank you for your effort, input and assistance. I regret to inform you we have been denied approval to move forward with legal process.We were told by our management we need a MLAT [Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty] in order to continue to assist our partner with the request in question.
The MLAT requires a standardized process to wind its way through legal and diplomatic protocols and usually take weeks to process. They are used, Emerson explained, for non-pressing legal matters in which the United States or another country is carrying out some legal process, such as a prosecution of a citizen in another country. They are not used in urgent, life-or-death or counter-terrorism scenarios, especially with a close ally such as Israel, Emerson was told.
The flat-footed termination of a race to discover vital information regarding terrorist activity and the life or dignity of the remains of a soldier of a close ally was nothing less than shocking, not only for the Israelis, but for the American team originally tasked with obtaining the information.
Three days after thestand downemail was sent, the IDF concluded that Oron Shaul was dead. His body has never been recovered. Hamas is interested in using whatever parts of Shauls body they claim to have to swap for terrorist prisoners held by Israel.
According to Emersons investigation, those involved in the legal procedures in the U.S. believe the stop order was given by the attorney generals office.
That stand down order was a direct rebuff to a request made by Israel, what at least most members of congress believe to be one of Americas closest allies. There is a paper trail which will reveal who made the decision to shut down the effort to assist Israel in a desperate situation.
Congress should demand to know who gave the order. The U.S. Senate Judiciary committee is the address from which such an inquiry should be made.
http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/us-shut-down-effort-to-help-locate-kidnapped-israeli-soldier/2014/10/18/2/

It wouldn't surprise me if the article said the US refused to actively negotiate any help for the young man's release. Hell, we don't negotiate with terrorists, we only give them billions of dollars and feed their families.
But a simple warrant on Facebook? They do that all the time and for far less noble reasons.
This was no mistake. It was a blatant rebuff of our ally in it's time of need; there is a reason it happened, andneeds to be examined thoroughly.
In all honesty mimi, what should we expect from the most transparent administration in history? They've been told to turn over the "Fast and Furious" documents by court order, but they've requested for a delay. If they truly were honest and just they would have no problem turning over these documents back when they were first requested instead of Obama using Executive Privilege to deny the request. Obama and Eric Holder can not be trusted, it's plain to see. The evidence is overwhelming. We're heading toward a totalitarian government.
I remember when this young man went missing, when Hamas hacked into his Facebook account, and when Hamas offered to sell him back piece by piece.
This is so disgusting. Perhaps if this young soldier were a movie star or a hip-hop artist whose personal photos had been hacked, the request would have been granted right away.
And if you think THAT indicates that Obama would rather side with Hamas (declared by the US as a terrorist organization) than Israel, shipments of munitions such as Hellfire missiles were blocked by the USA during the Protective Edge campaign. Maybe Obama just wanted to even out the odds, like, make sure there are as many Israeli casualties as there are Gaza ones.
This is really disturbing. The reasoning for doing this needs to be explained ASAP.
Kavika, I remember this incident. Hamas offered to trade this young man's body parts back to the IDF piece by piece in return for the release of prisoners. They hacked his Facebook page to taunt his parents.
Israel wasn't asking for any type of interference by the US in the way of trying to negotiate for his release or for the release of his body, just the IP address since they had hacked his account.
Yes, it needs to be explained.
No, it never will be, and no, Holder will never be held accountable for any of his misdeeds. He is more untouchable than Biden.
I don't think any of Obama's staff had better end up kidnapped in a situation where the US would have to depend on Israel for help in tracking them down.
Hamas has established a method to get terrorist prisoners with blood on their hands released - simply kidnap Israelis. They are aware that Jews need to have closure in being able to properly bury their dead, so even body parts are considered a viable trading tool.
I am going to abandon my humanitarianism and my disdain for capital punishment here. In my opinion, since Israel is consistently being compared to the Nazis, this suggestion will fulfill such biased opinions. I suggest that Israel copy the method used by the Nazis to get what they want - they should announce that they will drown in a vat of pig's blood one prisoner with blood on his/her hands each day until the kidnapped Israeli is released ALIVE, and if the Israeli is killed, there should be much greater retribution.