╌>

“The Largest Funder of Al-Shabaab Is the Minnesota Taxpayer”

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  s  •  last year  •  38 comments

“The Largest Funder of Al-Shabaab Is the Minnesota Taxpayer”

S E E D E D   C O N T E N T


Minnesota is drowning in fraud. Billions in taxpayer dollars have been stolen during the administration of Governor Tim Walz alone. Democratic state officials, overseeing one of the most generous welfare regimes in the country, are asleep at the switch. And the media, duty-bound by progressive pieties, refuse to connect the dots.

In many cases, the fraud has allegedly been perpetrated by members of Minnesota’s sizeable Somali community. Federal counterterrorism sources confirm that millions of dollars in stolen funds have been sent back to Somalia, where they ultimately landed in the hands of the terror group Al-Shabaab. As one confidential source put it: “The largest funder of Al-Shabaab is the Minnesota taxpayer.”

Our investigation shows what happens when a tribal mindset meets a bleeding-heart bureaucracy, when imported clan loyalties collide with a political class too timid to offend, and when accusations of racism are cynically deployed to shield criminal behavior. The predictable result is graft, with taxpayers left to foot the bill.

If you were to design a welfare program to facilitate fraud, it would probably look a lot like Minnesota’s Medicaid Housing Stabilization Services program. The HSS program, the   first of its kind   in the country, was launched with a noble goal: to help seniors, addicts, the disabled, and the mentally ill secure housing. It was designed with “low barriers to entry” and “minimal requirements for reimbursement.” Nonetheless, before the program went live in 2020, officials pegged its annual estimated price tag at $2.6 million.

Costs quickly spiraled out of control. In 2021, the program paid out more than $21 million in claims. In the following years, annual costs shot up to $42 million, then $74 million, then $104 million. During the first six months of 2025, payouts totaled $61 million.

On August 1, Minnesota’s Department of Human Services   moved   to scrap the HSS program, noting that payment to 77 housing-stabilization providers had been terminated this year due to “credible allegations of fraud.” Joe Thompson, then the Acting U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota, went even further,   stating   that the “vast majority” of the HSS program was fraudulent.

On September 18, Thompson   announced   criminal indictments for HSS fraud against Moktar Hassan Aden, Mustafa Dayib Ali, Khalid Ahmed Dayib, Abdifitah Mohamud Mohamed, Christopher Adesoji Falade, Emmanuel Oluwademilade Falade, Asad Ahmed Adow, and Anwar Ahmed Adow—six of whom, according a U.S. Attorney’s Office spokesperson, are members of Minnesota’s Somali community. Thompson made clear that this is just the first round of charges for HSS fraud that his office will be prosecuting.

“Most of these cases, unlike a lot of Medicare fraud and Medicaid fraud cases nationally, aren’t just overbilling,” Thompson said at a press conference announcing the indictments. “These are often just purely fictitious companies solely created to defraud the system, and that’s unique in the extent to which we have that here in Minnesota.”

Thompson said many firms enrolled in the program “operated out of dilapidated storefronts or rundown office buildings.” The perpetrators often targeted people recently released from rehab, signing them up for Medicaid services they had no intention of providing. He noted many owners of companies engaged in HSS fraud had “other companies through which they billed other Medicaid programs, such as the EIDBI autism program, the . . . Adult Rehabilitative Mental Health Services program, the . . . Integrated Community Support program, the Community Access for Disability Inclusion . . . program, PCA services, and other Medicaid-waivered services.”

“What we see are schemes stacked upon schemes, draining resources meant for those in need. It feels never ending,” Thompson said. “I have spent my career as a fraud prosecutor and the depth of the fraud in Minnesota takes my breath away.”

On September 18, the same day that the HSS fraud charges were announced, the U.S. Attorney’s Office   reported   that a man named Abdullahe Nur Jesow had become the 56th defendant to plead guilty in the $250 million   Feeding Our Future fraud scheme .

Founded in 2016, Feeding Our Future was a small Minnesota nonprofit that sponsored daycares and after-school programs to enroll in the Federal Child Nutrition Program. The organizations that Feeding Our Future sponsored were primarily owned and operated by members of Minnesota’s Somali community, according to two former state officials with connections to law enforcement.

In 2019, Feeding Our Future received $3.4 million in federal funding disbursed by the state. In the months after the Covid-19 pandemic began, however, the nonprofit   rapidly increased   its number of sponsored sites. Using fake meal counts, doctored attendance records, and fabricated invoices, the perpetrators of the fraud ring claimed to be serving thousands of meals a day, seven days a week, to underprivileged children. In 2021, Feeding Our Future received nearly $200 million in funding.

In reality, the money was being used to fund lavish lifestyles, purchase luxury vehicles, and buy real estate in the United States, Turkey, and Kenya. In   2020 , Minnesota officials raised concerns about the nonprofit’s rapid expansion. In response, the group   filed a lawsuit   alleging racial discrimination related to outstanding site applications, noting that Feeding Our Future “caters to . . . foreign nationals.”

“That’s the standard operating playbook for that cohort: when in doubt, claim racism, claim bias,” says David Gaither, a former Minnesota state senator and a nonprofit leader. “Even if the facts don’t point to that, it allows for many folks in the middle, or on the center-Left, to stay silent.”

Gaither believes the mainstream media, alongside Minnesota’s Democratic establishment, have long turned a blind eye to fraud within the Somali community. This, in turn, allowed the problem to metastasize. “The media does not want to put a light on this,” Gaither said. “And if you’re a politician, it’s a significant disadvantage for you to alienate the Somali community. If you don’t win the Somali community, you can’t win Minneapolis. And if you don’t win Minneapolis, you can’t win the state. End of story.”

The fraudsters have leveraged their growing political influence to cultivate close ties with Minnesota’s elected officials. Several individuals involved in the Feeding Our Future scheme   donated   to, or   appeared publicly with , Ilhan Omar, the Somali-born congresswoman from Minneapolis. Omar’s deputy district director, Ali Isse,   advocated   on behalf of Feeding Our Future. Omar Fateh, a former state senator who recently ran for Minneapolis mayor,   lobbied   Governor Tim Walz in support of the program. And one of the accused, Abdi Nur Salah, served as a senior aide to Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey.

Just days later, on September 24, U.S. Attorney Joseph Thompson   announced   his office’s first indictment in yet another fraud case. This time, the scheme involved federally funded autism services for children.

The accused is a woman named Asha Farhan Hassan, a member of Minnesota’s Somali community, who has also been charged in the Feeding Our Future scam. She’s alleged to have played a role in a $14 million fraud scheme perpetrated against Minnesota’s Early Intensive Developmental and Behavioral Intervention program.

Hassan and her co-conspirators “approached parents in the Somali community” and recruited their children into autism therapy services. It didn’t matter, prosecutors suggested, if a child did not have an autism diagnosis: Hassan would facilitate a fraudulent one.

In a press release announcing the indictment, the U.S. Attorney’s Office made clear that the alleged autism fraud scheme extended to a wide network of people. “To drive up enrollment, Hassan and her partners paid monthly cash kickback payments to the parents of children who enrolled,” the release reads. “These kickback payments ranged from approximately $300 to $1500 per month, per child. The amount of these payments was contingent on the services DHS authorized a child to receive—the higher the authorization amount, the higher the kickback. Often, parents threatened to leave . . . and take their children to other autism centers if they did not get paid higher kickbacks.”

Much like with the HSS program, autism claims to Medicaid in Minnesota have   skyrocketed   in recent years—from $3 million in 2018 to $54 million in 2019, $77 million in 2020, $183 million 2021, $279 million in 2022, and $399 million in 2023. Meantime, the number of autism providers in the state   spiked   from 41 to 328 over the same period, with   many in the Somali community   establishing their own autism treatment centers, citing the need for “ culturally appropriate programming .” By the time the fraud scheme was exposed, one in 16 Somali four-year-olds in the state had reportedly been   diagnosed with autism —a rate more than triple the state average.

“This is not an isolated scheme,” Thompson, the U.S. attorney,   said   in a press release. “From Feeding Our Future to Housing Stabilization Services and now Autism Services, these massive fraud schemes form a web that has stolen billions of dollars in taxpayer money. Each case we bring exposes another strand of this network.”

What Thompson arguably hinted at, but left unsaid, should be obvious: this “network” of “fraud schemes,” which “form a web” that has stolen “billions of dollars in taxpayer money,” involved many members of Minnesota’s Somali community. The Feeding Our Future, HSS, and autism-services cases are far from the only examples. At least 28 fraud scandals have surfaced since Walz was elected governor in 2019. Most of the large-scale fraud rings, according to two former FBI officials who spoke with   City Journal , have been perpetrated by members of the Somali community.

Kayesh Magan, a Somali-American who had worked as a fraud investigator at the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office,   identified the problem   last year: “We must grapple with something that is uncomfortable and true: Nearly all of the defendants in the cases I’ve listed are from my community. The Somali community.”

Perhaps the most surprising aspect of the Somalia fraud story is the scale, with total costs running into the billions of taxpayer dollars. That raises the question: What happened to all that money?

The Somali fraud rings have sent huge sums in remittances, or money transfers, from Minnesota to Somalia. According to   reports , an estimated 40 percent of households in Somalia get remittances from abroad. In 2023 alone, the Somali diaspora sent back   $1.7 billion —more than the Somali government’s budget for that year.

Our investigation reveals, for the first time, that some of this money has been directed to an even more troubling destination: the al-Qaida-linked Islamic terror group Al-Shabaab. According to multiple law-enforcement sources, Minnesota’s Somali community has sent untold millions through a network of “hawalas,” informal clan-based money-traders, that have wound up in the coffers of Al-Shabaab.

According to Glenn Kerns, a retired Seattle Police Department detective who spent 14 years on a federal Joint Terrorism Task Force (JTTF), the Somalis ran a sophisticated money network, spanning from Seattle to Minneapolis, and were routing significant amounts of cash on commercial flights from the Seattle airport to the hawala networks in Somalia. One of these networks, Kerns discovered, sent $20 million abroad in a single year. “The amount of money was staggering,” Kerns said.

Kerns’s investigation eventually expanded to Minnesota, where he realized the same thing was happening. “I worked on it for five years,” Kerns said. “We had sources going into the hawalas to send money. I went down to [Minnesota] and pulled all of their records and, well shit, all these Somalis sending out money are on DHS benefits. How does that make sense? We had good sources tell us: this is welfare fraud.”

Kerns then investigated the hawalas in Somalia that were receiving the money transfers. He determined, primarily through human sources, that significant funds were being sent from America to Al-Shabaab networks in Somalia. Whether the money was intended for Al-Shabaab or not, Kerns said, they were taking a cut.

A second former official, who worked on the Minneapolis JTTF, confirms the story’s general structure. This former official, who requested to remain anonymous, worked on two terrorism cases that intersected with Minnesota’s Somali community and has studied the flow of funds from Minnesota to Somalia.

“Every scrap of economic activity, in the Twin Cities, in America, throughout Western Europe, anywhere Somalis are concentrated, every cent that is sent back to Somalia benefits Al-Shabaab in some way,” the former official said. “For every dollar that is transferred from the Twin Cities back to Somalia, Al-Shabaab is . . . taking a cut of it.”

A third source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, described the close links between the Somali-American community in Minnesota and Islamic terror groups abroad. Ten years ago, the source was recruited as an “independent contractor” for a three-letter agency investigation into the “Minnesota men” who had joined, or attempted to join, ISIS. That year, a Homeland Security task force report found that Minnesota led the nation in the number of Americans who had joined, or attempted to join, ISIS. Of the 58 Americans who had done so, nearly half came from Minnesota.

Scott Johnson , who has covered these and  related stories  for years, attended several of those men’s trials,  reporting on them  for  City Journal . He noted that the Minnesota men “gave the outward appearance of American assimilation”—including being “sophisticated users of social-welfare benefits.” 

The relationship is ongoing. “This is a third-rail conversation, but the largest funder of Al-Shabaab is the Minnesota taxpayer,” the third source said. “There is an issue here that is real, and if there is ever an event that is traceable back to these funds, or to people from this area, then this situation will take on a whole new set of optics.”

Welfare fraud is likely to become a major issue in Minnesota’s 2026 elections. Governor Tim Walz, now seeking a third term, has presided over a litany of scandals and faces Republican Kristin Robbins, who has made fraud prevention central to her campaign.

Gaither, the former state senator, said “political blowback is brewing” in the state and that, as more information emerges from ongoing investigations, “it’s a real rough place to be if you’re the current administration.” He added that if you talk to law-enforcement officials and others close to the probes, “they will tell you off the record that we aren’t even close to being halfway there” in understanding the true scale of the fraud.

The first step to solving a problem is acknowledging it. By extension, that means recognizing the problem’s true source. So far, Minnesota’s governing class and its media establishment have failed to take that basic step. Minnesotans will have to confront the uncomfortable but unavoidable reality: members of the Somali community have played a central role in the massive fraud now engulfing the North Star State.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
1  seeder  Sean Treacy    last year

There's so much to this story.  The entirely predictable fruits of mass migration as taxpayers get ripped of by welfare  fraud by immigrants and NGOs  and the fact that Tim Walz is somehow a national figure after seeing his state plundered by illegals to fund terror on his watch.   

To be a successful democrat, competency doesn't matter if you performatively hate Trump  

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
1.1  Vic Eldred  replied to  Sean Treacy @1    last year

They have lied and cheated to do it. 

There can be no longer be any doubt that "replacement theory" was a reality.

 
 
 
MrFrost
Professor Guide
1.2  MrFrost  replied to  Sean Treacy @1    last year
There's so much to this story.  The entirely predictable fruits of mass migration as taxpayers get ripped of by welfare  fraud by immigrants and NGOs  and the fact that Tim Walz is somehow a national figure after seeing his state plundered by illegals to fund terror on his watch.   

Yet you are 100% ok with trump taking 230 million from the DOJ, (taxpayers)... 300 million for a ballroom, another 150 million for golf. But all that is ok, but funding food for kids is too much? Are you fucking serious?

 
 
 
devangelical
Professor Principal
2  devangelical    last year

gosh darn those radical muslims that think they can come over here and take advantage of incompetent US gov't officials ...

... wtf? f'n rug-sniffing bonesaw shows up to meet the POS/POTUS at the white house and won't wear a suit or take his hat off ...

 
 
 
Trout Giggles
Professor Principal
2.1  Trout Giggles  replied to  devangelical @2    last year

yeah...how about that?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.1.1  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.1    last year

Trump met with a Saudi leader therefore its okay for Somalis to defraud Minnesota of hundred of millions.

Thank for you for perfectly exemplifying my point that to be a successful democrat, competency doesn't matter if you performatively hate Trump . Just say "Trump" and the lemmings will follow no matter how ignorant the point being made. 

 
 
 
Trout Giggles
Professor Principal
2.1.2  Trout Giggles  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.1.1    last year

No. That's not it. The man trmp met with is a murderer. He's also giving trmp millions of dollars to look the other way.

Do you live in Minnesota? No? Then what are you bitching about? Let Minnesotans take care of themselves.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.1.3  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.1.2    last year
what are you bitching about? Let Minnesotans take care of themselves.

Lol. 

 
 
 
Split Personality
Professor Participates
2.1.4  Split Personality  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.1.2    last year

The source is an admittedly biased right wing source and the two authors are members of the Manhattan Institute whose reputation is slightly worse than the publisher, but hey, it's a free press. Scotus has found that some lies are protected free speech.

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.1.5  Vic Eldred  replied to  Split Personality @2.1.4    last year

What is the lie here?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.1.6  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Split Personality @2.1.4    last year

Thank you for providing the textbook example of a logical fallacy

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.1.7  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.1.5    last year

As the weakness of the answer demonstrates, there isn’t.

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.1.8  Vic Eldred  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.1.7    last year

It only takes a question that can't be answered.

 
 
 
devangelical
Professor Principal
2.1.9  devangelical  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.1.8    last year
It only takes a question that can't be answered

patel, bondi, and noem have certainly faced plenty of those in congress ...

 
 
 
MrFrost
Professor Guide
2.1.10  MrFrost  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.1.1    last year
Saudi leader

9/11/01 ringing any bells?

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2  Vic Eldred  replied to  devangelical @2    last year

All part of the scheme to change the values of the US.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.2.1  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.2    last year
l part of the scheme to change the values of the US.

But all cultures are equal!  Look at the paradise the Somalis built..

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2.2  Vic Eldred  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.2.1    last year

I assume that is being taught now with the sudden rise of middle eastern courses at the University.

 
 
 
Trout Giggles
Professor Principal
2.2.3  Trout Giggles  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.2.1    last year

Look at the paradise the Saudis built!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.2.4  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.2.3    last year
t the paradise the Saudis built!

Are we importing tens of thousands of Saudis and placing them in concentrated geographic areas? Because if we are, I full agree we should stop that immediately. Where are we doing that? 

 
 
 
Trout Giggles
Professor Principal
2.2.5  Trout Giggles  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.2.4    last year

I get it. Certain Muslims are fine as long as they have money to bribe trmp with. Others can go back to where they came from, amiright?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
2.2.6  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.2.5    last year

No, you really don’t.  You equate the  president meeting with foreign leaders with  immigrants stealing hundreds of millions of dollars in welfare from a state . 

 
 
 
Trout Giggles
Professor Principal
2.2.7  Trout Giggles  replied to  Sean Treacy @2.2.6    last year

whatever

I'm done with you

 
 
 
devangelical
Professor Principal
2.2.8  devangelical  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.2    last year
All part of the scheme to change the values of the US

the current pedophile POS/POTUS won't live long enough to accomplish that goal ...

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2.9  Vic Eldred  replied to  Trout Giggles @2.2.7    last year
whatever

Next!

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2.10  Vic Eldred  replied to  devangelical @2.2.8    last year

Ya, call somebody a name as an argument.

 
 
 
MrFrost
Professor Guide
2.2.11  MrFrost  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.2    last year

All part of the scheme to change the values of the US.

You cannot legislate values or morals. Nice try. 

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2.12  Vic Eldred  replied to  MrFrost @2.2.11    last year
You cannot legislate values or morals.

Have you ever heard of the Civil Rights Act?

 
 
 
Split Personality
Professor Participates
2.2.13  Split Personality  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.2.10    last year

I take it that you are speaking from experience again?

 
 
 
Split Personality
Professor Participates
2.2.14  Split Personality  replied to  MrFrost @2.2.11    last year

and yet values change, hvac and indoor plumbing constantly improves and we still have stupid people pining for the "old days"

 
 
 
Split Personality
Professor Participates
2.2.15  Split Personality  replied to  Vic Eldred @2.2.12    last year

Yes. In an obvious Utopia that only you seem to remember, the Civil Rights Act would have been unnecessary.  Strangely enough, it was all of those liberal Republicans that caried the day.

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
2.2.16  Vic Eldred  replied to  Split Personality @2.2.15    last year
Strangely enough, it was all of those liberal Republicans that caried the day.

So, it was!

 
 
 
Thomas
Professor Guide
3  Thomas    last year

I’m going to type slowly so you can follow me.

Some defendants in these fraud cases are Somali or Somali-American. That is a fact.

Nobody needs to dance around it.

Nobody needs to deny it.

Certainly nobody needs to dress it up.

But you know what is most certainly not a fact?

This idea, this leap of speculation, that because fewer than a hundred individuals were indicted, somehow an entire community of 87,000 Somali-Americans in Minnesota should be treated like a criminal syndicate.

Now that’s not analysis.
That’s not pattern recognition.
That’s not vigilance.

That is statistical malpractice with malicious intent.

It’s like trying to paint a fine portrait using a driveway tar brush. 
It is, in a word, absurd.
But more importantly than that: it’s deliberate.

And we should say so plainly.

Because when a certain Mr. Rufo steps into our reading room, we are not dealing with an honest broker.
This is the same man who lied about CRT…
who manufactured a moral panic out of thin air…
and who now repurposes that same machinery to lie about immigrants.

And some amongst us, bless their earnest little hearts, have exactly the right predilections to visually inhale the finer lies printed in the rags they read, incorporating them into their twisted corpus of fear, never stopping to ask, “Does this math even add up?”

So let’s stop pretending this is about fraud.
It’s about fear.
It’s about scapegoating.
And it’s about a man who’s made a career out of it.


Just what does Ilhan Omar have to do with the story?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
3.1  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Thomas @3    last year
hat because fewer than a hundred individuals were indicted,

Lol. That's just the people who've been indicted. The Autism fraud case, which is just getting started, relied on Somali community members fraudulently signing up kids for treatment that they didn't need in exchange for cash kickbacks.  None of the lower level people have been indicted. The prosecutor in the feeding our future fraud admits they don't have the   resources to prosecute all those  involved.  The fraud permeated the community and relied on its members silence. 

his is the same man who lied about CRT…

Lol. How desperate you are. The ad hominem is desperate enough, the dishonest ad hominem is just pathetic. 

Does this math even add up?”

Let's see if does.. Why in the world does it make sense to import thousands of foreigners whose contribution has been to defraud taxpayers of a billion dollars?  

Make the math add up why this benefits American citizens

 
 
 
Thomas
Professor Guide
3.1.1  Thomas  replied to  Sean Treacy @3.1    last year

Hahahahaha. Nice try

That's why articles like this are called propaganda. Someone as bright as you should be able to figure that out. 

Here is why your argument is logically fallacious as well as factually wrong:

You start from the premise that the Somali community at large is all bad: "The fraud permeated the community and relied on its members silence"

and work backward from that assumption. You're treating the statement "They didn't indict everyone" as if it logically means "everyone is in on it."

That is simply untrue. It's a non-sequitur.

Show me how one can logically get from:

 The prosecutor in the feeding our future fraud admits they don't have the resources to prosecute all those involved.

To

The fraud permeated the community and relied on its members silence. 

I say you can't.

Saying:

"prosecutors have limited resources and can't indict everyone (true of most every large fraud case in American history), therefore every Somali immigrant is guilty of fraud,"

is like saying

"because some Catholic priests abuse children, the whole of the Catholic Church, members and clergy, should be held guilty of the scandals." 

It is nonsense, and were it applied to your community, you would reject it categorically for the same reasons I am rejecting your argument now: because it is illogical and wrong.


And no, it isn’t an “ad hominem” to point out the track record of one of the authors of this piece of journalistic trash. That is a statement of fact about the credibility and reliability of the source.

This article you are defending:

  • it misinforms
  • it cherry picks
  • it places hate and fictions before verifiable fact.   

And that is the textbook definition of fake news. (As well as propaganda.)

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
3.1.2  seeder  Sean Treacy  replied to  Thomas @3.1.1    last year
You're treating the statement "They didn't indict everyone" as if it logically means "everyone is in on it."

You literally made the mirror of that argument. Odd you object to your own tactic.  

I say you can't.

Explain how a widespread fraud involving a small community of people occurred without people knowing about it? I say you can't. 

And that is the textbook definition of fake news.

Lol. You don't like the facts so you deflect to claims about  fake news rather than deal with them. 

I notice you didn't do the math. How is this benefitting the US? 

 
 
 
Thomas
Professor Guide
3.1.3  Thomas  replied to  Sean Treacy @3.1.2    last year

How about you prove something for once instead of just saying “NO.” ’Cause that’s all I see you doing.

How about this: when you’re done showing precisely and logically how one gets from

“They did not indict everyone”

to

“The fraud permeated the community and relied on its members’ silence,”

you can then show where I supposedly claimed that

“Because they indicted only some, therefore the community is innocent.”

That would be the mirror of your argument, and I didn’t make it.
This “mirror” you mention is your own strawman, not anything I actually wrote.

Once again, you can’t show these things because they’re not there.
They do not exist in the real world.

Crooks and bad actors, unfortunately, exist everywhere.
They are not the exclusive property of any one community…
and no community is entirely free of their stain.

But the urge, the temptation, to find a convenient scapegoat,
to blame [insert perceived problem here] on an entire group of people,
that’s been with us for a long, long time.
Across cultures. Across history.
And yes, politicians and pundits have always known how to feed off that impulse.

This article is just another attempt to demonize Somali immigrants in particular, all immigrants by association.
And if one does not pay close attention,
if one reads it casually,
it’s easy to walk away with the simple, seductive conclusion of

“Immigrant bad.”

And that, that conclusion right there... is exactly what the article is designed to do. 

 
 
 
Vic Eldred
Professor Principal
3.2  Vic Eldred  replied to  Thomas @3    last year
This idea, this leap of speculation, that because fewer than a hundred individuals were indicted, somehow an entire community of 87,000 Somali-Americans in Minnesota should be treated like a criminal syndicate.

You know what Thomas, I'd rather you carefully explained to us how 87,000 Somalis, who don't seem to be assimilating, found their way to Minnesota?

 
 

Who is online




112 visitors