Second Review Says Classified Information Was in Hillary Clinton’s Email
WASHINGTON A special intelligence review of two emails that Hillary Rodham Clinton received as secretary of state on her personal account including one about North Koreas nuclear weapons program has endorsed a finding by the inspector general for the intelligence agencies that the emails contained highly classified information when Mrs. Clinton received them, senior intelligence officials said.
Mrs. Clintons presidential campaign and the State Department disputed the inspector generals finding last month and questioned whether the emails had been overclassified by an arbitrary process. But the special review by the Central Intelligence Agency and the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency concluded that the emails were Top Secret, the highest classification of government intelligence, when they were sent to Mrs. Clinton in 2009 and 2011.
On Monday, the Clinton campaign disagreed with the conclusion of the intelligence review and noted that agencies within the government often have different views of what should be considered classified.
Mrs. Clintons work-related emails from when she was secretary of state are slowly being released by the State Department.
Our hope remains that these releases continue without being hampered by bureaucratic infighting among the intelligence community, and that the releases continue to be as inclusive and transparent as possible, said Nick Merrill, a campaign spokesman.
John Kirby, the State Department spokesman, echoed Mr. Merrill.
Classification is rarely a black and white question, and it is common for the State Department to engage internally and with our interagency partners to arrive at the appropriate decision, he said in a statement. Very often both the State Department and the intelligence community acquire information on the same matter through separate channels. Thus, there can be two or more separate reports and not all of them based on classified means. At this time, any conclusion about the classification of the documents in question would be premature.
The intelligence review is the latest development in continuing reverberations over Mrs. Clintons use of only a private email account for her public business when she was secretary of state, which gave her some control over what was made public. She faced criticism when the account became known this year, and after deleting what she said were more than 31,000 personal messages turned over more than 30,000 work-related emails for the State Department to make public.
Mrs. Clinton has said that her emails contained no information that was marked classified having classified information outside a secure government account is illegal and that she is fully cooperating with an F.B.I. investigation to determine who at the State Department may have passed highly classified information from secure networks to her personal account. She herself is not a target of the investigation.
I. Charles McCullough III , the inspector general for the intelligence community, found the two emails containing what he determined was Top Secret information in the course of reviewing a sampling of 40 of Mrs. Clintons work-related emails for potential security breaches.
The senior intelligence officials briefed on the findings of the review spoke on the condition of anonymity because they did not want to jeopardize their access to sensitive information.
President Obama signed an executive order in December 2009 that defined Top Secret as information that if disclosed could reasonably be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to national security.
In the months after the disclosure, Mrs. Clinton and her campaign were unequivocal in their stance that there was no classified information on it. But after it was revealed in August that the F.B.I. was investigating how classified materials were handled in connection with the account, Mrs. Clintons aides began saying that she never sent or received anything that was classified at the time.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/08/us/politics/second-review-says-classified-information-was-in-hillary-clintons-email.html?_r=0

Top secret information in those emails?
You would think that someone who knew the rules would stick to them.
If it takes multiple reviews to determine the status of the information, today, perhaps there was room for reasonable uncertainty at the time.
I think the witch hunt against Clinton may succeed, because of the accumulation of stories regurgitated day after day. I'm not sure anyone could survive this level of gang up.
Hopefully she will be held accountable for her crimes but the Obama administration is so corrupt it is unlikely.
witch hunt
That term would indicate that there was no wrongdoing. I believe it's off base.
Hopefully she will be held accountable for her crimes but the Obama administration is so corrupt it is unlikely.
I would agree. They do often engage in cannibalism, but I think she will probably be punished in other ways.
f it takes multiple reviews to determine the status of the information
Every review has said the information is classified. The problem is that she operated outside secure systems so there was no review at the time. There's no dispute about the classification of top secret information. .
If it takes multiple reviews to determine the status of the information, today, perhaps there was room for reasonable uncertainty at the time.
This is the exact reason for using the more secure .gov address and there are specific rules for classifying information that were not followed. Basically over-classifying to be safe then the classification can be changed during review at a later time. Hillary would have had extensive training on the classification system and should have known damn well that she wasn't following standard procedure. Ignorance is no excuse, neither is convenience which has been completely discredited already anyways.
Hillary's email setup and the fallout from it are no one's fault but her own and deserves every bit of scrutiny it has been getting regardless of what partisan hacks think. If this sinks her campaign she has no one to blame but herself.
Some people would be embarrassed trying to defend the indefensible but there's always a group on either side with their head intentionally planted up their ass. Good job sir.
Sean, she was SENT these two e mails in this latest "report". If they were not marked classified at the time it was not HER fault.
I will tell you why I call this a "witch hunt". It is not because Hillary Clinton is blameless in terms of possibly using State Dept e-mail inappropriately.
The witch hunt element comes in the constant implication that what she did should disqualify her from being a viable presidential candidate. Or that she is a criminal for the way she used the e-mail.
I have seen reports that
a) many people believe the intelligence community overclassifies documents and e-mails.
b) the sending of classified material over unsecured e-mail accounts has been widespread, perhaps for many years
c) during the last republican administration, there was private e-mail used for government business, AGAINST THE RULES, within the Bush White House.
The witch hunt element comes from people who ignore all this in order to pursue the destruction of Hillary Clinton. To these people, there are no exculpatory or mitigating explanations on her behalf, they simply want her tarred and feathered and run out of town.
That is what a witch hunt is. The persistent element of unfairness when evaluating the totality of the circumstances and evidence.
Clinton will get her "day in court" when she testifies about all of this in front of the "Benghazi" committee in October. It would be nice if the witch hunt would pause until then, but we know it won't.
It is only a witch hunt if she is innocent. Let's face it she has a lot of baggage.
That is what a witch hunt is. The persistent element of unfairness when evaluating the totality of the circumstances and evidence.
Congratulations. You now know how the supporters of Mitt Romney felt when the persistent unfairness of his occupation ignored the totality of his experience and qualifications.
Get used to it, John.
428 until Election Day.
lol. I guess you believe the world misrepresented his gilded age dismissal of 47% of the American people as he spoke before a gathering of fat cats. Fortunately the voters did not agree.
It no longer matters what I or anyone thinks about Romney.
Now John, it's all about Hillary.
Enjoy the ride.
I see, we should all have sympathy for the put upon Mitt Romney. I would rather have sympathy for all the workers at the companies that his company plundered.
John, this is the lot that you have cast. You engage in extremely partisan politics, to the point that you will support someone no matter how deep or critical their transgressions are. You have cast your lot with Hillary, and you will bear the brunt of criticism for as long as she stays in the race. I did not put you in this place.
You did it all by yourself.
That is not the same as the presumption that Clinton approved of them sending classified material to her on e-mail. She has specifically said that she did not use e-mail to view classified information. She says that was done on hard copy or in person.
In the end, this controversy will be a version of "he said, she said". It should be decided at the ballot box, not daily over twitter, facebook, cable news, and blogs.
hey were not marked classified at the time it was not HER fault.
You keep making arguments that have no basis in reality. It absolutely is her fault if she received unmarked classified information and did not submit it for secure handling. She received all sorts of training about handling secured information and then promptly ignored it in favor of convenience. Satellite data of north Korea installations is so obviously classified that you look desperate claiming otherwise.
As someone said, it's like operating an illegal still and then claiming you didn't know its illegal because the still isn't marked as illegal.
It should be decided at the ballot box, not daily over twitter, facebook, cable news, and blogs.
Freedom of speech for you, but not for me?
Thank you for the suggestion.
Maybe you should go on MSNBC or CNN and explain your perspective. I am sure it would be interesting.
Sean, a few days ago the Associated Press surveyed numerous legal experts who deal with cases involving classified information every day. The reporter couldn't find one that believed that Hillary Clinton will be prosecuted.
Why not let her tell her story at the Gowdy hearing and stop with this insane witch hunt ?
I'm sure the Republicans there will ask all your favorite questions.
Just think, if she would have followed the law in the first place, this wouldn't even be an issue. Realize also, that in obfuscating her role in attempting to hide her law-breaking, she has sealed her own fate.
There will not be another Clinton in the White House.
"It it would not save a rank-and-file official with a security clearance who was caught sending classified information over email, said Bradley Moss, a lawyer who frequently represents intelligence officers. That person could lose his job, his clearance, or both.
"In real life, the 'everybody does it defense' doesn't fly," Moss said."
From the AP a few days ago
Why not let her tell her story at the Gowdy hearing and stop with this insane witch hunt ?
The FBI has nothing to do with Gowdy.
It's more of an assumption that training is required for the security clearances necessary for handling confidential security information. It's hard to imagine how the system could work without it.
A quick google search indicated that the state department's bureau of Diplomatic Security contains the following:
DS also provides new Department of State employees with training in the proper handling of sensitive and classified information.
DS contributed to the smooth transition of U.S. government officials by providing more than 180 members of the new Obama administrationranging from Secretary Clinton to various ambassadors and other presidential appointeeswith security training
Interesting way to misrepresent the AP story. When the day comes when Hillary Clinton is declared free from threat of prosecution, will you shut up about it? I don't even care about the election anymore, I just want all this nonsense to stop. You'd think Hillary Clinton was Benedict Arnold, from listening to you people babble about this 24/7.
A direct quote is a misrepresentation?
from listening to you people babble about this 24/7.
You've seeded more articles on this topic than anyone else.
I doubt it.
I think you're right about her being stupid . I can never forget when she referred to Dr. Kavorkian in a talk before congress . She didn't appear to grasp the import of her words .
Yes, it's a requirement before receiving access to classified information, the higher clearance, the more intense the training. Top Secret is the top of the pyramid.
Maybe you should go on MSNBC or CNN and explain your perspective. I am sure it would be interesting.
I'd be interested in watching that too.
Yep. Just as I thought about you. Never mind.
Now you know I can't do that.
I don't know their current classification. I will say one thing about them. The vast majority of Top Secret information is boring as all hell. At least at a SAC base.
I didn't ask you to.
Where is Jimmy Hoffa Woodie? That's Top Secret isn't it ?