Via: cm • 12 years ago • 27 comments
Valuable Intellectual Traits
Intellectual Humility : Having a consciousness of the limits of one's knowledge, including a sensitivity to circumstances in which one's native egocentrism is likely to function self-deceptively; sensitivity to bias, prejudice and limitations of one's viewpoint. Intellectual humility depends on recognizing that one should not claim more than one actually knows. It does not imply spinelessness or submissiveness. It implies the lack of intellectual pretentiousness, boastfulness, or conceit, combined with insight into the logical foundations, or lack of such foundations, of one's beliefs.
Intellectual Courage : Having a consciousness of the need to face and fairly address ideas, beliefs or viewpoints toward which we have strong negative emotions and to which we have not given a serious hearing. This courage is connected with the recognition that ideas considered dangerous or absurd are sometimes rationally justified (in whole or in part) and that conclusions and beliefs inculcated in us are sometimes false or misleading. To determine for ourselves which is which, we must not passively and uncritically "accept" what we have "learned." Intellectual courage comes into play here, because inevitably we will come to see some truth in some ideas considered dangerous and absurd, and distortion or falsity in some ideas strongly held in our social group. We need courage to be true to our own thinking in such circumstances. The penalties for non-conformity can be severe.
Intellectual Empathy : Having a consciousness of the need to imaginatively put oneself in the place of others in order to genuinely understand them, which requires the consciousness of our egocentric tendency to identify truth with our immediate perceptions of long-standing thought or belief. This trait correlates with the ability to reconstruct accurately the viewpoints and reasoning of others and to reason from premises, assumptions, and ideas other than our own. This trait also correlates with the willingness to remember occasions when we were wrong in the past despite an intense conviction that we were right, and with the ability to imagine our being similarly deceived in a case-at-hand.
Intellectual Autonomy : Having rational control of one's beliefs, values, and inferences, The ideal of critical thinking is to learn to think for oneself, to gain command over one's thought processes. It entails a commitment to analyzing and evaluating beliefs on the basis of reason and evidence, to question when it is rational to question, to believe when it is rational to believe, and to conform when it is rational to conform.
Intellectual Integrity : Recognition of the need to be true to one's own thinking; to be consistent in the intellectual standards one applies; to hold one's self to the same rigorous standards of evidence and proof to which one holds one's antagonists; to practice what one advocates for others; and to honestly admit discrepancies and inconsistencies in one's own thought and action.
Intellectual Perseverance : Having a consciousness of the need to use intellectual insights and truths in spite of difficulties, obstacles, and frustrations; firm adherence to rational principles despite the irrational opposition of others; a sense of the need to struggle with confusion and unsettled questions over an extended period of time to achieve deeper understanding or insight.
Confidence In Reason : Confidence that, in the long run, one's own higher interests and those of humankind at large will be best served by giving the freest play to reason, by encouraging people to come to their own conclusions by developing their own rational faculties; faith that, with proper encouragement and cultivation, people can learn to think for themselves, to form rational viewpoints, draw reasonable conclusions, think coherently and logically, persuade each other by reason and become reasonable persons, despite the deep-seated obstacles in the native character of the human mind and in society as we know it.
Fairmindedness : Having a consciousness of the need to treat all viewpoints alike, without reference to one's own feelings or vested interests, or the feelings or vested interests of one's friends, community or nation; implies adherence to intellectual standards without reference to one's own advantage or the advantage of one's group.
Valuable Intellectual Virtues (September 2014). Foundation For Critical Thinking, Online at website:
Fairmindedness: Having a consciousness of the need to treat all viewpoints alike, without reference to one's own feelings or vested interests, or the feelings or vested interests of one's friends, community or nation; implies adherence to intellectual standards without reference to one's own advantage or the advantage of one's group.
Much of what is stated is possible when you rely on math, and the sciences to drive your thinking and reasoning.
So many of the problems we are confronted with come from those driven by belief and fear rather than fact and truth. Self imposed ignorance is a mind killer.
As I read through these, I was reminded of a recent chapter of an ongoing disagreement I have been involved in with a certain NT member. I think that it simply is not possible to juggle all of these characteristics at once, for any human being. And if you mix religious ideology into the discussion, fuhgetaboutit - all critical thinking potential goes immediately down the toilet.
Critical thinking is only possible when one works at rejecting beliefs and prejudice in order to seek truth.
On another thread I am engage in a discussion with another NT member who's hatred and dislike is so blinding that it will be impossible for them to ever consider truth.
So what if people admire themselves, why denigrate other people's motives? that speaks to # 8 in my opinion - Fairmindedness: I appreciate everyone's input on this article..thanks...
While they all can't be totally summarized in a single sentence or phrase-- I think this may cover most of it:
Having a passion for discovering the truth
And not because Mommy told you that God will punish you if you lie (or worse yet-- that Mommy and Daddy will punish you). Its not about feeling guilty or feeling yourself to be "bad" if you lie...And not just the truth only when it supports your political, religious (or Atheistic), scientific, psychological, or philosophical agenda.
Truth for its own sake- - even if there's no evidence it supports some other goal...
(Some people refer to this trait as "integrity").
And not just truth-- but a passion to pursue the facts when they are not immediately evident. Even if it means using your entire brain-- not just "the left brain" or the "right brain".
Critical thinking is only possible when one works at rejecting beliefs and prejudice in order to seek truth.
On another thread I am engage in a discussion with another NT member who's hatred and dislike is so blinding that it will be impossible for them to ever consider truth.
It is unfortunate that that "Other NT member" isn't nearly as good at "rejecting beliefs and prejudices" as you are. (And I wouldn't be surprised if that other member doesn't display such strong evidence of the first item on the list as you do either [your great "intellectual humility"].
We are all products of our environment. Truth for one is a lie for another. I agree math is the closest we can come to truth in its use, but there again any disagreements must be based on the same math. You may say math is unique and there isn't but one true math, yet we find even math can be manipulated as an example of debating or producing a desired result.
For example we supposedly had 40000 without insurance of a 300000 population and let's not even consider any who lost their insurance with the onset of Obamacare in this example.
Some will say we've increased the percentages of people insured by 8000 new enrollees of the 40000 who didn't have insurance which would be an increase of 20%, but another person will say we had 300000 people and 260000 who had insurance and by increasing it by 8000 it is only 2.6% increase in the number of people insured.
And then the argument can be made we've decreased the number of uninsured by 20%. Sounds good. Can be used to promote how well Obamacare has done saying it this way, but in reality only 2.6% more people have insurance than did before which doesn't sound nearly as good.
To the casual observer who doesn't see the other side of the argument the first example sounds great. And the closer we get to 100% of the people insured the better the first example sounds. Example: We only have 30 people left without insurance and we increase the number of insureds by 8, we have decreased the number of uninsured by 27% and if we insure even more the percentages continue to look better such as when we have one person who doesn't have insurance left and we add that final person, we've decreased the number of people who didn't have insurance by 100%, whereas if we have 299999 people out of 300000 with insurance and we cover that last one we've only increased the number of insured by .1%.
Of course who cares, if everyone has insurance and the person making $46K compared to the person making 35k, who is 63, doesn't have to pay $3000 more in taxes and doesn't received a $5000 rate increase, not including state taxes on that additional $11K income.
It's rather discouraging to think if you work harder and increase your income my $11k you will not realize after rate increase and extra taxes you were just as well off making $11K less money and didn't have to work you butt off either. Just considering Federal taxes along you will only realize a $3K take home of the $11k you worked for. So to me it's a fact the middle class are paying for Obamacare. The elites aren't bothered by this and more people are less motivated to improve their lives.
A person making $100K pays the same as a person making $46k. A person making $200K pays the same, but a person making $35k pays $5k less and when you get around $20k for the mid grade policy they don't pay anything. So this idea of keeping your children on your policy until they're 25 or so doesn't make any real difference, since most students in college don't make $20k a year anyway. It's a con sales pitch and some people aren't able to see grasp the concept.
Most of the time people don't have all the facts even though they think they do or their facts are flawed and they aren't even aware of it.
Living this life knowing I don't have all the facts, it is my constant search for the truth in an elusive world of truth and it is nearly futile. Even things I've believed all my life have proven to not be fact, which has led me to change my beliefs I've held for many years.
Oh, it is so frustrating when you have what you consider the facts and others can not see it your way and I have to revert back to the idea, we're all a product of our environment, but when something is really important to me it is hard to value others opinions as much when I feel I have the facts I need to have the correct opinion.
That's one reason I put things on this site many do not like and it's understandable, but maybe someone will see a different perspective that may make a difference and maybe I will as well.
Aren't we all correct in our beliefs based on our own facts? I don't think so. I'm not a very good conformist. I like to look at history and when I see things I perceive as being detrimental I am not patient with others who can't see them. I need proof when my beliefs are challenged when I have based them on what I consider facts.
I like to think, does it make any sense? I have to look for answers when I'm in doubt and I like to look at past situations to base my beliefs on for future situations that may come from current actions today.
I'm not a mountain that can't be moved by reason, logic or common sense. I have changed my ideas over the years as my experiences in life have moved me to do so. I value others opinions although I may not agree with them, but this doesn't keep me from expressing my own opinions.
Six.... If one understands math, one can see through any numerical obfuscation if they choose to. Math and true science are the tools in the search for truth.
Honesty in visual observation can be another tool of truth, but in order for it to be taken as such, perspective and location to that which is being observed must be taken into account. Photos and video can capture and report things accurately from their viewing point. The same thing cannot be said of individuals reporting on what they have seen as observational skills vary from person to person. As such, historical records and analysis are always suspect due to human bias and perspective.
You are correct that we are products of our environment. Myself, my upbringing, education, and training all related to a team mentality. I am motivated by what will bring success to the group to the point of putting myself second. For many, my personal philosophy of team first is as foreign as can be. For those I suspect that the concept of "I" and "me" is key in their lives. These people place their needs ahead of the needs of others. Both personal philosophies have merits and detractors.
I have said on different occasions that you have strong reasoning and logic capabilities, along with solid communications skills. What I don't understand is your willingness to post seeds that you know are untruthful in what or how it is being reported all in an effort to push a political agenda. You have the ability to see through to the truth better than most here on NT. It is such a disappointment to me at times that you choose not to make use of that special talent.
Six.... If one understands math, one can see through any numerical obfuscation if they choose to. Math and true science are the tools in the search for truth.
Fly, that's the problem, obviously some can't.
I never feel I'm posting anything that I don't believe is true, honestly. Maybe you see something I don't, I don't know. It is certainly worth working on. I generally post articles to combat the lies I read from the other side, in my opinion....notice I say in my opinion.
Honesty in visual observation can be another tool of truth, but in order for it to be taken as such, perspective and location to that which is being observed must be taken into account. Photos and video can capture and report things accurately from their viewing point.
This is very true.
I appreciate your compliment and I am aware you also have those same qualities, and probably many others as well, I noticed recently when you were able to avoid confrontation and I don't mean that in a bad way either. I feel as much as I see. I appreciate your civil comment back to me. Thanks - six
I know I bite, but usually only after bitten. LOL Of course you may have a different opinion of that.
I noticed recently when you were able to avoid confrontation.
I'm combative only when I choose to be. I come to NT to try and learn, sometimes to try and teach.
I'd like to send you a friend request. That way when the BS starts flying on the topics in public we can at least discuss our thoughts in the background with clarity.
Unfortunately Flame, we have people here on sites like these, from both sides of center that purposely promulgate propaganda and disinformation to push a political agenda. Truth doesn't matter.
Some would believe that we are too stupid to see through the obfuscations. I guess it is our fault in thinking that these are sites are for discussion and learning. Closer to the truth would be that they are just another outlet for political propaganda and pontification.
Your are probably right Flame, about having to endure the pontification and propaganda. (What doesn't kill you makes you stronger?)
My entire adult life as an engineer has been about getting to the truthful answer, or when problem solving, the root cause of problem in order to apply a permanent solution. I guess it is my mistake to try and apply an analytic approach to problem solving when politics are involved.
I can tell you one thing that I have come to clearly realize in this thread. There are two types of people we are dealing with in America (possibly the world). One is the "we/us" type that believes that success of the group is more important that the self. The other is the "I/Me" type that puts themselves ahead of anyone and anything else. One is suited better for civilized interactive participation, while the other is best adapted to a singular survivalist approach to life. Given these types, its no wonder we have a government as disliked as it is.
I need to think this out a bit more and see what parts of our government gripe the grits of each type. At first glance, it is quite possible that the needs/desires of each are forever mutually exclusive of one another. Hence our current problems
I can tell you one thing that I have come to clearly realize, There are two types of people we are dealing with in America (possibly the world). One is the "we/us" type that believes that success of the group is more important that the self. The other is the "I/Me" type that puts themselves ahead of anyone and anything else.
Agreed 100% Fly, I have that in my own Family, e.g. this is personal but I will reveal, my brother, had some bad financial dealings, he was able to survive from gifts and some loans from other relatives, he is coming back on up, but, he is the Me, Myself and I type of person, totally ignoring who extended that helping hand out of compassion for a relative or friend, become boastful as previously, in the time of despair, humble as pie, now getting back together a bit boastful, now, I am not the type to call anyone on such behavior, I just observe, it teaches me that sometimes been too generous is not a good thing for the giver, If a person wants to give, give and forget because the receiver has already forgotten the gift...This is what I have noticed with Republicans, they are always for themselves, not interested in the well being of a fellow human being, Democrats I think will help others, we really have to be careful not to be taken advantage of with being too generous...
Many people are not trained to see through propaganda. This skill is generally developed during the course of a good college education.
Flame, please don't tell me that a good college education from many of the colleges today is the only way to have common sense. I know too many college professors to fall for that one. I know you are sincere, but that doesn't fly, excuse me Fly, with me.
From the Article:
This sounds very familiar..
Can't teach new tricks I suppose...
I would add another to the list, which is essential in order for the others to come into play, CM...
absence of Ego.
Good article.
Yep. I'm an old dog.
Much of what is stated is possible when you rely on math, and the sciences to drive your thinking and reasoning.
So many of the problems we are confronted with come from those driven by belief and fear rather than fact and truth. Self imposed ignorance is a mind killer.
Ah yes..... Dune must be where I borrowed that from.
Pick any science fiction writer, Herbert, Asimov, Clarke, or Heinlein for critical thinking.
One of my neighbors said she "hated" science fiction simply because what was written often has become science fact.
She is a wonderful woman, but truth and reality often just made her mad. She really wants everyone to get along and for everything to work "just so.".
Nothing to apologize for Flame...... Your comments point out the realities of the matter.
Me too.
Agreed.
Critical thinking is only possible when one works at rejecting beliefs and prejudice in order to seek truth.
On another thread I am engage in a discussion with another NT member who's hatred and dislike is so blinding that it will be impossible for them to ever consider truth.
So what if people admire themselves, why denigrate other people's motives? that speaks to # 8 in my opinion - Fairmindedness: I appreciate everyone's input on this article..thanks...
Agreed FlyNavy just as stated....
A great list!
While they all can't be totally summarized in a single sentence or phrase-- I think this may cover most of it:
And not because Mommy told you that God will punish you if you lie (or worse yet-- that Mommy and Daddy will punish you). Its not about feeling guilty or feeling yourself to be "bad" if you lie...And not just the truth only when it supports your political, religious (or Atheistic), scientific, psychological, or philosophical agenda.
Truth for its own sake- - even if there's no evidence it supports some other goal...
(Some people refer to this trait as "integrity").
And not just truth-- but a passion to pursue the facts when they are not immediately evident. Even if it means using your entire brain-- not just "the left brain" or the "right brain".
___________________________________________________________
(Of course I could be wrong!
)
But you aren't.
It is unfortunate that that "Other NT member" isn't nearly as good at "rejecting beliefs and prejudices" as you are. (And I wouldn't be surprised if that other member doesn't display such strong evidence of the first item on the list as you do either [your great "intellectual humility"].
We are all products of our environment. Truth for one is a lie for another. I agree math is the closest we can come to truth in its use, but there again any disagreements must be based on the same math. You may say math is unique and there isn't but one true math, yet we find even math can be manipulated as an example of debating or producing a desired result.
For example we supposedly had 40000 without insurance of a 300000 population and let's not even consider any who lost their insurance with the onset of Obamacare in this example.
Some will say we've increased the percentages of people insured by 8000 new enrollees of the 40000 who didn't have insurance which would be an increase of 20%, but another person will say we had 300000 people and 260000 who had insurance and by increasing it by 8000 it is only 2.6% increase in the number of people insured.
And then the argument can be made we've decreased the number of uninsured by 20%. Sounds good. Can be used to promote how well Obamacare has done saying it this way, but in reality only 2.6% more people have insurance than did before which doesn't sound nearly as good.
To the casual observer who doesn't see the other side of the argument the first example sounds great. And the closer we get to 100% of the people insured the better the first example sounds. Example: We only have 30 people left without insurance and we increase the number of insureds by 8, we have decreased the number of uninsured by 27% and if we insure even more the percentages continue to look better such as when we have one person who doesn't have insurance left and we add that final person, we've decreased the number of people who didn't have insurance by 100%, whereas if we have 299999 people out of 300000 with insurance and we cover that last one we've only increased the number of insured by .1%.
Of course who cares, if everyone has insurance and the person making $46K compared to the person making 35k, who is 63, doesn't have to pay $3000 more in taxes and doesn't received a $5000 rate increase, not including state taxes on that additional $11K income.
It's rather discouraging to think if you work harder and increase your income my $11k you will not realize after rate increase and extra taxes you were just as well off making $11K less money and didn't have to work you butt off either. Just considering Federal taxes along you will only realize a $3K take home of the $11k you worked for. So to me it's a fact the middle class are paying for Obamacare. The elites aren't bothered by this and more people are less motivated to improve their lives.
A person making $100K pays the same as a person making $46k. A person making $200K pays the same, but a person making $35k pays $5k less and when you get around $20k for the mid grade policy they don't pay anything. So this idea of keeping your children on your policy until they're 25 or so doesn't make any real difference, since most students in college don't make $20k a year anyway. It's a con sales pitch and some people aren't able to see grasp the concept.
Most of the time people don't have all the facts even though they think they do or their facts are flawed and they aren't even aware of it.
Living this life knowing I don't have all the facts, it is my constant search for the truth in an elusive world of truth and it is nearly futile. Even things I've believed all my life have proven to not be fact, which has led me to change my beliefs I've held for many years.
Oh, it is so frustrating when you have what you consider the facts and others can not see it your way and I have to revert back to the idea, we're all a product of our environment, but when something is really important to me it is hard to value others opinions as much when I feel I have the facts I need to have the correct opinion.
That's one reason I put things on this site many do not like and it's understandable, but maybe someone will see a different perspective that may make a difference and maybe I will as well.
Aren't we all correct in our beliefs based on our own facts? I don't think so. I'm not a very good conformist. I like to look at history and when I see things I perceive as being detrimental I am not patient with others who can't see them. I need proof when my beliefs are challenged when I have based them on what I consider facts.
I like to think, does it make any sense? I have to look for answers when I'm in doubt and I like to look at past situations to base my beliefs on for future situations that may come from current actions today.
I'm not a mountain that can't be moved by reason, logic or common sense. I have changed my ideas over the years as my experiences in life have moved me to do so. I value others opinions although I may not agree with them, but this doesn't keep me from expressing my own opinions.
Six.... If one understands math, one can see through any numerical obfuscation if they choose to. Math and true science are the tools in the search for truth.
Honesty in visual observation can be another tool of truth, but in order for it to be taken as such, perspective and location to that which is being observed must be taken into account. Photos and video can capture and report things accurately from their viewing point. The same thing cannot be said of individuals reporting on what they have seen as observational skills vary from person to person. As such, historical records and analysis are always suspect due to human bias and perspective.
You are correct that we are products of our environment. Myself, my upbringing, education, and training all related to a team mentality. I am motivated by what will bring success to the group to the point of putting myself second. For many, my personal philosophy of team first is as foreign as can be. For those I suspect that the concept of "I" and "me" is key in their lives. These people place their needs ahead of the needs of others. Both personal philosophies have merits and detractors.
I have said on different occasions that you have strong reasoning and logic capabilities, along with solid communications skills. What I don't understand is your willingness to post seeds that you know are untruthful in what or how it is being reported all in an effort to push a political agenda. You have the ability to see through to the truth better than most here on NT. It is such a disappointment to me at times that you choose not to make use of that special talent.
Fly, that's the problem, obviously some can't.
I never feel I'm posting anything that I don't believe is true, honestly. Maybe you see something I don't, I don't know. It is certainly worth working on. I generally post articles to combat the lies I read from the other side, in my opinion....notice I say in my opinion.
This is very true.
I appreciate your compliment and I am aware you also have those same qualities, and probably many others as well, I noticed recently when you were able to avoid confrontation and I don't mean that in a bad way either. I feel as much as I see. I appreciate your civil comment back to me. Thanks - six
I know I bite, but usually only after bitten. LOL Of course you may have a different opinion of that.
I noticed recently when you were able to avoid confrontation.
I'm combative only when I choose to be. I come to NT to try and learn, sometimes to try and teach.
I'd like to send you a friend request. That way when the BS starts flying on the topics in public we can at least discuss our thoughts in the background with clarity.
Regards
Unfortunately Flame, we have people here on sites like these, from both sides of center that purposely promulgate propaganda and disinformation to push a political agenda. Truth doesn't matter.
Some would believe that we are too stupid to see through the obfuscations. I guess it is our fault in thinking that these are sites are for discussion and learning. Closer to the truth would be that they are just another outlet for political propaganda and pontification.
Your are probably right Flame, about having to endure the pontification and propaganda. (What doesn't kill you makes you stronger?)
My entire adult life as an engineer has been about getting to the truthful answer, or when problem solving, the root cause of problem in order to apply a permanent solution. I guess it is my mistake to try and apply an analytic approach to problem solving when politics are involved.
I can tell you one thing that I have come to clearly realize in this thread. There are two types of people we are dealing with in America (possibly the world). One is the "we/us" type that believes that success of the group is more important that the self. The other is the "I/Me" type that puts themselves ahead of anyone and anything else. One is suited better for civilized interactive participation, while the other is best adapted to a singular survivalist approach to life. Given these types, its no wonder we have a government as disliked as it is.
I need to think this out a bit more and see what parts of our government gripe the grits of each type. At first glance, it is quite possible that the needs/desires of each are forever mutually exclusive of one another. Hence our current problems
Agreed 100% Fly, I have that in my own Family, e.g. this is personal but I will reveal, my brother, had some bad financial dealings, he was able to survive from gifts and some loans from other relatives, he is coming back on up, but, he is the Me, Myself and I type of person, totally ignoring who extended that helping hand out of compassion for a relative or friend, become boastful as previously, in the time of despair, humble as pie, now getting back together a bit boastful, now, I am not the type to call anyone on such behavior, I just observe, it teaches me that sometimes been too generous is not a good thing for the giver, If a person wants to give, give and forget because the receiver has already forgotten the gift...This is what I have noticed with Republicans, they are always for themselves, not interested in the well being of a fellow human being, Democrats I think will help others, we really have to be careful not to be taken advantage of with being too generous...
Flame, please don't tell me that a good college education from many of the colleges today is the only way to have common sense. I know too many college professors to fall for that one. I know you are sincere, but that doesn't fly, excuse me Fly, with me.
The rest of your comment I totally agree.
It would be my honor Fly. I may come across as a mean old man, but I have lots of friends who like, I guess, mean old men.