When should you fight back against police?
Yes the question may seem shocking to some, but realize that this is not a call to violence in the least, only a rational discussion.
Self-defense is a natural right, stemmed from the root of all rights, self-ownership. When someone tries to hinder your ability to own yourself through brutal oppression and violence, it is not only your right, but your responsibility as a free individual to resist.
There is a huge difference between self-defense and proactive violence. Going off and shooting people whove done nothing to harm you is immoral, whether or not they are a cop, is irrelevant; unprovoked violence has no place in a just society.
Here at the Free Thought Project we abhor violence as a means to an ends, and advocate against it. Civil resistance is the means we advocate to bring about peaceful revolution. But to quote JFK, Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable. Which is why we are bringing up this question.
Even small factions of the state are beginning to realize this right to self-defense. In the video, Larken Rose mentions an old law in Indiana, but they have since come around and actually realized that it is okay for a person to protect themselves , regardless of the aggressor wearing a badge and uniform.
There is nothing wrong with asking these questions. Resistance is the means by which freedom is attained. To quote Frederick Douglas,
Those who profess to favor freedom and yet depreciate agitation, are people who want crops without ploughing the ground; they want rain without thunder and lightning; they want the ocean without the roar of its many waters. The struggle may be a moral one, or it may be a physical one, or it may be both. But it must be a struggle. Power concedes nothing without a demand; it never has and it never will.
Here is a thought to ponder. Had Kelly Thomas fought back, or others stepped in to help him, he may still be alive today.

It is scary to think of a situation where police are abusing you or your family. When do you defend yourself or someone you love? How far does it go?
I agree you should try to intervene if you see it happening, but if you are alone in a situation of abuse and you resist police and don't do it with deadly force do you think you would survive? If you did survive what do you think the chances of staying free are given it's your word against the cops? Also how far do you intervene if you see it happening?
In this case I agree. There were too many police. Though if he had a gun and shot the first two, that started clubbing him, I somehow think that had he survived, he would still be rotting in jail.
EXACTLY!
I am fully aware that the police have gotten out of control, and something needs to be done about it, but that video is definitely WAY over the top and most definitely does not provide the answer to the problem we are facing at this time with our police and our government.
The answers are in the Constitution that has guided us and provided the means to remain a free republic for the last 238 years.
Advocating the killing of law enforcement officers, regardless of the reason is not the way a civilized society corrects a problem and for sure is NOT the way to correct our growing abuse of authority problem.
IMO, this article is in violation of Article 7 of the NewsTalkers Code of Conduct and should be taken down.
(Myemphasis)
Jerry, I disagree. This is a very topical subject worth discussing and in an academic sense, worth offering an opinion on even if such an opinion runs contrary to the law.
The Constitution you mention also provides for "Free Speech". While at first glance, a poster may be advocating the killing of all cops, which is an exception to the Free Speech right, the Supreme Court has held that "threats may not be punished if a reasonable person would understand them as obvious hyperbole".
Key phrase; "Reasonable Person." Considering that, the NT CoC becomes very subjective, if one is examining violations case by case. Yeah, there are a few loose cannons here whom I disagree with but under "rational review" I personally don't see anyone here who continually advocates such actions as to constitute an unlawful and/or harmful action. I see such people using hyperbole or excited utterances.
Having said that, the Freedom of Speech is NOT applicable to a private forum (here), which may enact their own rules as to what constitutes acceptable speech. The ultimate responsibility for such determinations lays with the owner.
This is a "hot button" topic and in light of that, certain leeway should be allowed.
The video does not suggest dissent but the right of one to defend themselves.
Mike,
I only put this up for rational discussion. I would hope as long as I have been hanging around (without changing my on line identity) here people would realize that. I believe the video is about ones right to defend themselves from bodily harm tyranny even from authority, but I could see how someone a little off beat could interpret it otherwise so I have removed it.
Thank you Aeon, and of course the video is hyperbole. I think history shows that most the worlds greatest heroes of oppression were working outside the current laws of the time. Sometimes one must be outside the law to do the right and moral thing. This was the case many times in Germany during Nazi rule.
I think it is about time for a third party seeing as the the two party system has been morphed into a beast. Both parties game the system, cheat taxpayers and seem to to only unite under these circumstances or to pass laws that restrict our rights.. The two party system is designed to keep others out for a reason. It is sad that people brainwashed into thinking a vote for a third party is a wasted vote. I believe a vote that could break this two party system is the most important vote one could make.
Me too, but let's face it. Voting Third Party takes guts and most voters are afraid to leave the cozy confines of their partysecurity blanket. Until more than 3% are willing to cast their shackles aside, we truly will get the government we deserve.
This is the mentality that is constantly bombarding you about both government and the police. The mentality of inability to oppose authority has also caused the death of millions, maybe even billions throughout history. I must admit it is very effective though.
It may have been different had someone tried to help him though.
Good to see you again Chucky. Unfortunately I fear you are not only right but that we will be stuck with this government for quite some time.
No problem Mike.
True. The problem is when the abuse becomes intolerable. Look at Furgeson. It makes me think a bit harder about the recent militarization of police.
You know, with some of the things I have seen on NT I really didn't think that the video was that shocking. I guess one point it was trying to make is true. It really is difficult to think about having to defend yourself in a situation where you think your life is in peril from authorities. Whether they be local or governmental.
I emailed Perry about the video and her response was;
However, she is looking into it a little farther, but she hasn't gotten back to me yet. I'm going to send her a reminder,because IMOthat video is really over the top.
As much as the cops are becoming more and more brutal, I cannot condon advocating they should be killed.
I see I'm a little behind in monitoring the discussions I've been involved in and I apologize for my negligence. I didn't know 96 had taken down the video until just now. Thanks 96, I think you did the right thing.
I agree with MiG that your integrity was never in question here. It's apparent you ran the video to point out that something must be done about the level of police brutality that has reached the point to where the people have to start responding. However, as MiG said, that video had the tendency to cast a poor light on NT.
IMO, the real solution to police abuse and brutality is better training and more important, better screening of police academy candidates. Meanwhile the American public has a real problem on it's hands regarding the present attitude of the police in the streets.
Anti-police abuse advocates and lawyers say to never confront or argue with police at the time of an incident, just let hem do their thing, then later bring the incident to the attention of authorities. A little hard to do, but trying to fight back when a cop starts to get physical could possibly get you killed or at least get you a 'resisting arrest', or 'interfering with a police officer' charge.
Which brings us directly to the 'Citizens United' issue. Allowing corporations and the rich to donate unlimited contributions to election candidates is effectively handing the reins of government to the guys with the most money.
However, although there is connection, the issue here is police brutality and police behavior in the street, supposedly guided by whatever 'police protocol' is established by their respective departments. The problem is, that 'protocol' has a tendency to bend and flex, depending on whatever is necessary to defend the actions of the cops. But there is a connection between police procedure and Citizens United. (everything we do is someway connect to Citizens United)
If we accept the premise that Citizens United is effectively handing the reins of the government to the Oligarchs, and the police are controlled by the that government, then Citizens United is effectively financing a police state, because the Oligarchs need a police state to protect the Plutocracy they have established and through the government they're going to allow the police a loose rein in setting their 'protocols'.
If this county stays on its present course it will soon become a Police State controlled by a relatively small group of Oligarchs. If you're not one of those Oligarchs, paying a minimum $100,000 donation to election campaigns, your $25 dollar contribution is a fart in a whirlwind and if you piss off a cop and he beats the crap out of you, no one is going to help you.
I have beendiscussingthis concern about becoming a police state for the past 10 years. Perhaps your right flame, maybe it's time to stop talking aboutmovingtoward a police state and acknowledge we have allowed ourselves to be lured into actually being in that position.
In December of 2013, Chase Madar posted an article in Mother Jones titled;
How Every Part of American Life Became a Police Matter
Mader wrote; " From the workplace to our private lives, American society is starting to resemble a police state. "
He went on to say;
" By now, the militarization of the police has advanced to the point where "the War on Crime" and "the War on Drugs" are no longer metaphors but bland understatements. There is the proliferation of heavily armed SWAT teams, even in small towns; the use of shock-and-awe tactics to bust small-time bookies; the no-knock raids to recover trace amounts of drugs that often result in the killing of family dogs, if not family members; and in communities where drug treatment programs once were key, the waging of a drug version of counterinsurgency war."
"(All of this is ably reported on journalist Radley Balko's blog and in his book, The Rise of the Warrior Cop .) But American over-policing involves far more than the widely reported up-armoring of your local precinct. It's also the way police power has entered the DNA of social policy, turning just about every sphere of American life into a police matter. " [ Read the entire article ]
I explained the correlation, but, like almost everything else, it obviously went over your head.
That's a slight exaggeration.
Anyway there is not a direct correlation between CU and the police, the CU decision is only supporting and helping to perpetuate the overbearing attitude of the police, and even accelerate our evolving into a police state.
CU allows big money to practically insure their candidate of choice, ie; the guy that will support legislation most favorable to their business position, which is the guy (or gal) that wins the election. I know you're likely to point out that Unions and other groups that are in opposition to the big business position also put a lot of money into campaigns. However, there is no way to match the billions of dollars these big corporations have at their disposal.
The police correlation is, the candidates the big corporate money helps to get elected are usually, by necessity, are political conservatives, and conservatives by nature are usually very supportive of the police. So getting legislation passed to gain more control of the the police is almost impossible.
It's a very complex and difficult problem Robert, and you'reintelligentenough to understand it,but you just don't want to understand it, you would rather ignore the reality of the CUdecisionand expound on your ideological support of the 1st Amendment.
Like that sarcastic remark. No one is trying to 'get rid' of the First Amendment, but the Rights granted to us in the Bill of Rights are not without limits. The 2nd Amendment gives us the Right to bear arms, but that does not mean you can have an RPB launcher stashed in your closet, or an armoured personnel carrier parked in your driveway.
Likewise, the 1st Amendment gives us the Right to free speech, but it does not give us the Right to shout the other guy down. The CU decision allows exactly that to happen in political campaigns, the guy with most money can buy the most ads, and those ads can and do have an effect on the outcome of elections. If they didn't they would not so widely used by candidates.
Not directly, however there have been numerousoccasionswhen police have been charged for Federal Civil Rights violations.The Rodney King case is an example, after a juryacquittedfour cops on statedeadly weapon and excessive force charges in that case, the Feds stepped in an brought civil rights charges against the four cops resulting in two of them going to prison.
Also the DOJ has been monitoring the copious number ofabusiveof force cases being brought againstpoliceall over the country, resulting in many police departments being investigated by the Feds for the excessive number of abuse and brutality charges being brought against them.
Nothing is "automatic" with thesescenarios Robert. As I said above, it is a complex and difficult problem.
Corporations = big money, Big money = heavy campaign donations to candidates that support corporate positions. Those candidates are most often Republicans which support moreconservativepositions. Conservatives are more supportive of police and are less likely to support any legislation the police are not in favor of. The more the politicians stay out of the cops business the more liberties the cops are going to take with their power and authority.
Just spotted that. Typo, it's supposed to be RPG launcher. An RPB is a Rocket Propelled BB launcher. Those we're allowed to have.
To me? I would say NEVER. They have guns and are bigger than I am. I have no desire to become a bloody puddle of goo on the ground.
When you have no choice or, rather, when the only choices left to you are to die or to fight, which may ultimately be the same thing.
Do the makers of that video have a sequel offering solutions to the terrible enslavement of mankind they envision?
It's an interesting (sort of) project, with a look at realities, many of which are not so good, and some of which are really bad. But the really bad shit, like the police brutality and oppression, can and must be corrected. However, most of the rest of it, just as it is shown in the beginning of the video, is just the way society is structured, but now we're in the 21st century.
What do the video producers suggest we do with almost seven and a half BILLION people on the planet, divided into hundreds of countries, cultures, cults, religions and beliefs?? They produce a very cynical outlook for for mankind, suggesting 'government' is a bad thing, but I see no suggestions of any solutions or alternatives.
Interesting album Broli, I never got into Floyd too much after Dark Side and The Wall, but IMO those guys were at genius level in creativity and performance. There was a subtle change in their sound after Waters left and I kind of stuck with their earlier stuff, favoring 'Brain Damage', 'Eclipse', 'Hey You', and 'Another Brick..', but of all their work I think 'Comfortably Numb' was their best ever creation. (Which was pretty much the condition I was in whenever I was listening to their albums)
I think Nick mason, the drummer and only original Floyd member, is still around and there is a new Floyd album "The Endless River" that's out or is coming soon.
I'm curious what it will be all about.
That's not what he's referring to, and you fucking know it!
Law enforcement has seized millions of dollars in personal assets, to the point where the DOJ is investigating many police departments and DA offices for egregious excess and wrong doing regarding illegal seizure and retaining of personal assets.
He makes a lot of sense, and no one but you and your 'friends' ever refer to a "Great Corporate Conspiracy".
These guy do not "conspire" to illegally confiscate assets, they just do it!
Great comment flame, I posted almost the same thing yousaid about confiscations before I read your comment. But you'respot onabout the seizures become a major problem in todays' society.
But we're not moving toward becoming a police state.
Haven't seen Robert G. since Oct 11 when he made his brilliant ' Homeless Man and the Shopping Cart ' analogy.
Perhaps he realized after reading the responses he got, who the one is in this discussion that really doesn't make sense.