"The Overnighters" and the Pastor who Scandalized His Town
There are many moments in The Overnighters , an astonishing documentary set amid the North Dakota oil boom that opens Friday at New Yorks IFC Center and later this fall in cities nationwide, where the truth seems almost unbearable.
In one such scene, the Rev. Jay Reinke is shown ministering to a desperate Arizona man named Todd, a visitor with a history of drug abuse, alcoholism and aggravated assaultand looks it. He has turned up on Reinkes doorstep in the 21st century boomtown of Williston.
At this particular moment in the film, Reinke is the pastor of the Concordia Lutheran Church, anddespite the concerns and even objections of his congregation, and the ire of certain citizens of the townhe has offered Army cots, floor space and parking spots to scores of unemployed men like Todd whove arrived from places as far away as Iraq, looking for work and shelter.
He throws his arms around Todd, whos in the midst of confessing his evil ways and adding that he was born only because his mother was raped.
Can I tell you something? You and I are a whole lot more alike than we are different, the good reverend announces. Im broken. Were broken. Were just broken. Were in this together.
Little more than a year after documentary filmmaker Jesse Moss captured that fraught encounter, Reinkes life, along with that of his wife and three kids, has been shattered apart and cobbled together in surprising, painful and possibly hopeful ways.
Reinke lost his pulpit and was drummed out of the conservative Missouri Synod of the Lutheran denomination. He has been hounded by muckraking newspaper reportersone of whom is shown chasing him down the street and asking accusatory questions like a modern-day Javert.
He has struggled to keep his marriage together after confronting some inconvenient truths about himself. He has just begun to recover from an ordeal he calls The Scandal, only recently lifting his eyes from the pavement to greet neighbors as he strolls through downtown Williston. (The revelation of the nature of that scandalno spoilers hereproves the films pivotal moment.)
Although hes finally found another job, Reinke dearly wishes he could earn a living at something other than selling welding equipment and other gear to oilfield companies.
Oh, man, todays been a comedy of errors,Reinke says over the phone after a hard days toil. I was not born to work the pipelines, let me tell you.
Warning that his cell phone might die at any moment, Reinke adds: I dont like working in the pipeline industry. I enjoy working with customers if I feel like Im serving them well. But I dont know this industry. When I dont feel competent I dont like my job. Its a very steep learning curve for me. Im not by nature an industrial kind of guy or a mechanic kind of guy. But its getting better for me. Im really getting to where the process is going okay. Its just not my passion.
In a separate phone call, Moss tells me: Jay can never be a pastor again in that denomination. So he works for a company that provides oilfield supplies. Its hard for hima kind of penance. Hes a really smart man. Hes got great gifts. And yet hes selling latex gloves to oilfield workers.
The San Francisco-based Mosswho, with his wife, producer and editor Amanda McBaine, has made documentaries on subjects ranging from a demolition derby driver to a virtuosic con manwas irresistibly drawn to Reinkes story, and that of the men he tried to assist, as a Grapes of Wrath made real.

The Overnighters is feature documentary directed by Jesse Moss . The film premiered in the US Documentary Competition at the 2014 Sundance Film Festival, where it was awarded the Special Jury Prize for Intuitive Filmmaking .
Other prizes include the Golden Gate Award for Best Feature Documentary at the San Francisco International Film Festival, the Grand Jury Prize at the Miami International Film Festival, and the Inspiration Award at the Full Frame Documentary Film Festival.
The Overnighters will be released theatrically by Drafthouse Films in Fall 2014.
Desperate, broken men chase their dreams and run from their demons in the North Dakota oil fields. A local Pastor risks everything to help them.
Festival Screenings:
Sundance (Winner: Special Jury Prize)
True/False (Closing Night Film)
Miami International Film Festival (Winner: Grand Jury Prize)
Full Frame (Winner: Inspiration Award)
Wisconsin Film Festival
Martha's Vineyard
Dallas International Film Festival
Minneapolis/St. Paul International Film Festival
San Francisco International Film Festival (Winner: Golden Gate Award for Best Documentary)
Hot Docs
Tribeca Film Festival
Independent Film Festival of Boston
Nashville Film Festival
Montclair Film Festival
Little Rock Film Festival
MountainFilm Telluride
Los Angeles Film Festival
Provincetown Film Festival
Sydney (AU) Film Festival
Sheffield Doc Fest
Munich Film Festival
AFI Docs
Flyway Film Festival
Traverse City Film Festival
Hardacre Film Festival
Free Range Film Festival
New Zealand International Film Festival
Melbourne International Film Festival
Dokufest Kosovo
Hamptons SummerDocs Series
Cambridge Film Festival
Milwaukee Film Festival
Camden International Film Festival
Vermont International Film Festival
Institute of Contemporary Arts (ICA - London)
Philadelphia Film Festival
Viennale
CNEX Taipei Documentary Film Festival
Reviews:
The Hollywood Reporter : "riveting...superior documentary filmmaking"
Variety : "powerful... Steinbeckian...an indelible snapshot of a despairing moment in American history"
Indiewire : "devastating... one of the most remarkable examples of layered non-fiction storytelling to come along in some time"
The Playlist : "It will leave you stunned...starkly bleak and devastatingly humane, and an indelible American documentary"
Filmmaker Magazine : "remarkable... magnificent"
Filmmaker Magazine II : "unravels with the jagged edges of a thriller"
Movie City News : "fascinating... a standout documentary at Sundance 2014"
Twitch : "a shattering experience; a masterwork of unbridled honesty... an exceptional, haunting film."
Film Threat : "stellar...a masterfully directed piece of work"
First Showing : "an utterly compelling, nuanced film... a fantastic accomplishment."
The Dissolve : "bracing and unforgettable"
Nonfics : "brilliantly develops into a snowballing drama of the human condition"
Salt Lake Tribune : "Every moment... will bring tears to your eyes"
Screen Daily : "terrific... shocking"
Sight & Sound : "The narrative tensions... create the sense of watching a lion tamer at work."
Moving Image Source : " The quandaries at the heart of Jesse Moss's intimate, empathetic, and nuanced feat of immersive filmmaking are as old as the Union itself"
Paste : "engaging, heartfelt and timely... incredible off-the-cuff moments"
Real Screen : "A modern-day Grapes of Wrath... an interesting, complicated and vertiginous documentary."
World : "a fantastically complex film that treats its Christian subjects fairly and compassionately"
People's World : "what really makes this morality play a masterpiece is the sensitive and penetrating filmmaking... as the story takes unexpected twists and turns, leaving the viewer stunned"
The Moveable Fest : "With Moss clear-eyed examination, its beyond belief in every way"
The Clapper Bored " (UK): "Reinkes story grounds the film and provides it with its astonishing final act (one of *the* great moments of modern documentary filmmaking)... an astonishing portrait of working class America, as well as a profound and riveting domestic drama"
LA Daily News : "Searing... epic human drama"
Pique Magazine : "a superb piece of documentary filmmaking"
Flickfeast : "a complex account of individual struggle, class and community... a truly incredible film"
Huffington Post : "demonstrates the power of non-fiction filmmaking to touch un-scriptable hidden truths"
~LINK~
Yeah, me too. Looks like it'll be a little while before it gets around to theaters.
You're welcome fishy, it does look really good!
It sounds riveting. Thank you for the post.
From Rolling Stone ...
Gonna have to see this documentary.