╌>

60 Minutes piece

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  my-2-cents  •  12 years ago  •  13 comments

60 Minutes piece

Link below to segment that was on this week's (sunday) 60 minutes episode. it's pretty interesting and highlights what's wrong with the healthcare system in our country. This particular piece focuses on cancer drugs specifically, however, I encourage EVERYONE to watch it for several reasons.

This isn't just about cancer drugs. Healthcare costs are out of control for many reasons. Pharma companies aren't doing us any favors, as you will see in this segment. Pay particular attention to the Pharma lobbyist who blurts out a bunch of hogwash (as reported by forbes). Here is an excerpt from the Forbes article related to 60 minutes....

"Instead, we got John Castellani, the CEO of the industry lobbying group PhRMA, explaining that The drug companies have to put a price on a medicine that reflects the cost of developing them, which is very expensive and takes a long period of time, and the value that it can provide.

"This is, of course, either hogwash or a misstatement of a hard truth, depending on your perspective. Its hogwash in that you never buy anything because it cost more to develop. You wouldnt pay more for a car because GM wasted extra money in R&D without results, nor would you buy a yogurt from Danone Danone because the company spent R&D dollars on the bacteria in it. You buy the car or the yogurt for the result of that R&D, because the car is safer in a collision or the yogurt is claimed to help you poop. The same with drugs: we should pay what theyre worth, not what it cost to develop them."

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-cost-of-cancer-drugs/

When I heard that similar excuse in the 60 minutes piece, I wanted to jump up and down and grab that dude by the throat. What a crock of excrement!!

Now, before you Obama naysayers, and Obamacare haters jump on me, listen to this. Do I think Obamacare is the best solution to our failing healthcare system? No, not by itself. However, I do think the Affordable Care Act is going to open the door to a single payer system. From my time in healthcare, a single payer system will eliminate a lot of the bullshit associated with insurance companies and paying for services.

Also, I think it also opens the door of exploring the possibility of telling pharmaceutical companies to fuck off on their prices. That is essentially what occurs in Europe. They unlike most of us here in the US, believe in regulation. They regulate the pharma companies and tell them, no. If a pill costs $3.30 to manufacture, they cap how much pharma companies can then charge to sell it.If itcosts $3.30, they say fuck you, you aren't selling that pill for $330.00 dollars.

At some point, we need to do the same thing. That is of course, if we can get over this whole "government regulation" is a bad thing, mindset.

Lastly, the most telling piece of information in the 60 minutes piece....listen when Leslie Stahl asks about the price mark up on certain meds. 50-80% markup between here in the US and other parts of the world. Uneffingbelievable!!

~A


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
My 2 Cents
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  My 2 Cents    12 years ago

Just a friendly reminder, this isn't liberal/conservative, democrat vs republican like most discussions. This is something we can all offer our input on, AND leave all that political rhetoric and bullshit out of it. I mentioned "obamacare" not to interject political beliefs, but because it is relevant to what this topic has to do with.

~A

 
 
 
My 2 Cents
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  My 2 Cents    12 years ago

No, not a loss. They were smart, lowered the price to manufacture it, which in turn, allowed them to lower the cost to sell it.

The interesting point is, many opponents said that very thing couldn't be done...and yet, there it is. They are still making money, of course, it's a business....but, not as much. As I understand it anyways.

~A

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    12 years ago

With a 5 to 7 years exclusivity given to pharma, I believe it sufficient time to recoup R&D costs. Hubby needed a 30-day steroid regiment, drug had a retail price of $1200.00 our insurance copay was $300. Told drug store to keep it! Went online, Canada shipped drug to our home for $99!

 
 
 
My 2 Cents
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  My 2 Cents    12 years ago

Boom!!

Good for you! Way to take one away from those bastards!!

~A

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Ifcthe end-user doesn't pay to develop a drug, who does? Every product has development costs built in. The issue with drugs is that many never go anywhere.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
And then the price goes up for everyone else because Canada gets a free ride.
 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    12 years ago

At issue is where I was able to purchase the generic. Astro-Zeneca continues to have exclusivity in the U.S., but not in other countries. So if a consumer wants to pay $1200 for the brand in this country, by all means.

I found the generic so my husband could get the drug he needed and we could afford to pay for it.

BTW, I contacted AZ since they "advertise" we can help with drug costs....right! After you fill out financial papers, get approved, the would send us a $25.00 coupon.

Lest we forget grant monies (taxpayer $'s) are at the disposal of all U.S. pharma. We already subsidize R&D.

 
 
 
My 2 Cents
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  My 2 Cents    12 years ago

Lynne,

I happen to agree with you. If someone wants to pay 1200, let them. Maybe the price goes up for everyone else....but only for a short time, because US manufacturers realize the money they are losing, and then decide to do the right thing. So be it. It's business. I am like you, I'm going to go where I can get the most "bang" for my buck.

~A

 
 
 
My 2 Cents
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  My 2 Cents    12 years ago

So that's your justification for gouging citizens and the obscenely high prices? Yes, there are development costs...but if you read the article, and watched the piece on 60 mins you would have heard and read that those costs don't have to be as high as they are. Nor do we, the paying citizens, have to tolerate it.

~A

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
No justification. I just wonder who should pay? There is no free lunch.
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Ifcthe end-user doesn't pay to develop a drug, who does? Every product has development costs built in. The issue with drugs is that many never go anywhere

That would be true in a free-market economy-- if we let the marketplace determine the price of things (including drugs). But in the case of drugs its not a free market.

In a totally free market (often referred to as laissez-faire capitalism) prices are determined by the marketplace-- what the consumers are willing to pay. And others can compete, and offer them at lower prices.

But the sale of drugs are not significantly determined by the competition of free market forces. Rather, usually no competition is allowed, because these drugs are on patient. (no one can compete by producing them at a lower price-- or any price at all!)

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Both my parents had VA coverage through WWII and in their senior years needed medications. The price for one particular pill went down from $70.00 to about $3.00 through the VA.

My hubby has a Rx that in the US which is $200.00 for a 30 pill bottle. In Finland we paid about $9.00 for the exact same Rx.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Nailed it Krish.....

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
JohnRussell


76 visitors