╌>

Questions About Ground Troops Pile Up, With No Satisfying Answers

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  12 years ago  •  15 comments

Questions About Ground Troops Pile Up, With No Satisfying Answers

centcomm.jpg "In less than a week, the administrations position has gone from 'absolutely no ground troops, period' to 'well, actually.'"

President Barack Obama on Saturday repeated his promise not to use additional U.S. ground troops in his assault against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, or ISIS, even as war hawks made clear they didn't want to rule out the possibility and Iraqis warned against such action.

"I wont commit our troops to fighting another ground war in Iraq, or in Syria," Obama said in his weekly address, during which he also thanked Congress for authorizing his plan to arm and train Syrian militants in opposition to ISIS. "Its more effective to use our capabilities to help partners on the ground secure their own countrys futures."

However, Obama added: "When the world is threatened; when the world needs help; it calls on America. And we call on our troops. Whether its to degrade and ultimately destroy a group of terrorists, or to contain and combat a threat like the Ebola epidemic in Africa; we ask a lot of our troops."

As Trevor Timm writes at the Guardian, "in less than a week, the administrations position has gone from 'absolutely no ground troops, period' to 'well, actually.'" - Source

************************************

Simply put, we have no business there. The fear mongering chicken hawks, unwitting thralls of the corporations, are pounding the war drums. If you can install fear in a population, you can get the support for any military action.

Goering_quote.jpg


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Cutting past all your rhetoric, such as the president being caught in a vice (since when has he ever listened to the people....he has one master, the corporations) there are only two questions; should we or should we not be involved in the ISIS fight?

Obama, congress, the oil cartels, the MSM and the military industrial complex have their own agenda--- War, which equal profits.

The US has no legal or moral mandate to be the worlds policeman especially when all those wars work in at the behest of monied interests.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

I am no fan of war. And I do have concerns about civilian casualties.

With the exception of a few conservatives, warmongering democrats and republicans, who doesn't care about the death of innocent civilians? However, the Bush-Obama wars seem to exponentially add to those deaths.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago
Permalink Reply by badfish 6 hours ago

One of the lame excuses I hear from the shamed Monday morning general isSaddamkilled a few hundredthousandKurds.

Of course what you neglect to mention is the horrible way many of them died-- they died a horrible death because Saddam murdered them using one of his weapons of mass destruction (WMDs which allegedly he never had, of courseFrown.gif )-- poison gas.

But the victims were Kurds, not Arabs-- so its not surprising you would minimize their suffering.

However-- here's a question for ya, Badfish: As a self-proclaimed "expert' on the Middle East-- how many Kuwaitis did Saddam kill?39.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

However-- here's a question for ya, Badfish: As a self-proclaimed "expert' on the Middle East-- how many Kuwaitis did Saddam kill? 39.gif

How many Iranians did he kill???

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

It would be interesting to see how many Iraqis would say if they are better off today than they were when Saddam ruled.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result.

-Wrongly attributed to Albert Einstein

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Saddam Hussein was a mass murderer who had hundreds of thousands of political opponents a

nd other enemies killed, many of them quite innocent. To say he was "better" than anything, is absurd.

True.

Whenever I see someone defending a barbarian such as Saddam (or defending any any other, be it Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, etc) I often wonder about that person-- what is their personal sense of morality-- or ethics?

IMO, their defense of tyrants says more about the person defending them than anything else...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago
Saddam Hussein was a mass murderer who had hundreds of thousands of political opponents and other enemies killed, many of them quite innocent.

Yup.

And then there's the Elephant in the room (or camel?). You mentioned the atrocities to his own people--people often overlook what he did outside his own country. (When mentioned, people either deny it, try to change the subject-- or ignore it hoping people won't notice.

I posed an important question-- still waiting for a reply:

Permalink Reply by badfish 6 hours ago

One of the lame excuses I hear from the shamed Monday morning general isSaddamkilled a few hundredthousandKurds.

___________________________________________

Of course what you neglect to mention is the horrible way many of them died-- they died a horrible death because Saddam murdered them using one of his weapons of mass destruction (WMDs which allegedly he never had, of course)-- poison gas.

But the victims were Kurds, not Arabs-- so its not surprising you would minimize their suffering.

However-- here's a question for ya, Badfish: As a self-proclaimed "expert' on the Middle East-- how many Kuwaitis did Saddam kill?

Guess he doesn't want us to know about that...47.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

You never even saw that coming, huh?

No-- because its a false analogy.

Jews in Germany were not attacking Germans. Hamas, however, had been attacking israelis for years. (As well as torturing and murdering fellow Palestinians in Gaza-- and Egyptians as well.

Hamas is a true terror group, and has been engaging in terror for years-- when Israel, Egypt or other Palestinians attack Hamas, it is in self-defense. Jews in Germany were not terrorists-- Hitler's attacks were on Jews who were innocent.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

And Israel has been attacking Gaza fordecades.

Nope.

(If that were true, you would have no trouble providing numerous links from reliable sources to prove it...how about just one?)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

"How manyIraniansdid he kill???"

Your deep concern for Iranians is noted.

Nice attempt at deflection.

You still haven't answered my question-- how many Iranians did Saddam kill?

(If you knew the answer you might change your tune).

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

And yes I know that Israel was attacked first. But they also attacked back

Well, yes, cause and effect. Action and reaction.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

However-- here's a question for ya, Badfish: As a self-proclaimed "expert' on the Middle East-- how many Kuwaitis did Saddam kill? 39.gif

How many Iranians did he kill???

Well, since you are unwilling to supply the correct answer (although I can't blame you for not knowing it-- most Americans are unaware of what went down), perhaps this will be helpful. Saddam started two wars. In the war he started against Iran, the casualties were enormous:

The war cost both sides in lives and economic damage: half a million Iraqi and Iranian soldiers, with an equivalent number of civilians, are believed to have died, with many more injured.

Saddam started this war-- which resulted a million deaths! Frown.gif

(Even for the Middle East that number is huge).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

should we or should we not be involved in the ISIS fight?

It is interesting that people see this as an "either..or". That we only have 2 choices-- to totally commit and send in tons of troops like we did in Iraq-- or that we stay out of it totally. So many people fail to realize that there are other options, between those two extremes.

Obama, congress, the oil cartels, the MSM and the military industrial complex have their own agenda--- War, which equal profits.

Sounds like you've been too much time on the RT site! (or is it Press TV? Perhaps the so-called "Global Research" site? The so called "veterans Today"?

1. Obama? Whether you like or dislike Obama-- it seems to me to be pretty far-fetched to say that he wants to start wars-- and even more absurd that his actions as President are driven by a need to increase his personal finances.

And BTW, it seems that currently Obama really wants the price of oil to go down-- not up. For at least two reasons.. (most people on NT probably have no idea why he would want that).

2. Congress? Since the war in Iraq (and Afghanistan) Americans have really soured on war-- at least "boot on the ground". And Congresspersons who don't vote their constituents wishes can lose their lucrative jobs & other privileges when they're voted out of office.

3. Oil Cartels? OPEC is the biggest, and the Saudis have a lot of influence. And this time they fooled a lot of people-- they are taking action that will have the effect of lowering oil prices, not raising them. (although for different reasons than Obama). But do you really think the Democratically controlled Senate will go along with the Republican controlled House?

4. The MSM? I normally don't watch Fox or MSNBC News, but the last few weeks I been watching both. Amazing! I don't think they agree on anything-- total opposites!

And do you rally believe that popular MSM news anchors like Rachel Maddow, Al Sharpton, Melissa Harris-Perry, Ed Schultz, Joy Reid and others on MSNBC are hawks-- well, that's just plain absurd!

5. That leaves the Military Industrial Complex. And that topic is a bit more complex (pun intended). Polls initially showed Americans opposed to involvement vs ISIS, but the numbers declined slightly. Why? Not because of influence of the Military-Industrial Complex-- what caused a shift was the beheading videos.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Plus, he instigated a decade long war with Iran that caused a million deaths.

Actually its even worse than that. He gassed the Kurds and he used poison gas on Iranian civilians as well. This cause horrendous deaths....

(Some people used to argue that well, it doesn't matter, he's only killing,is own people. Which was totally false). But let's not forget-- he actually started two wars!

First, the one you just mentioned. (Strangely, it seems most Americans aren't even aware of that). But he also started a second war as well! He invaded a soverign country with the aim of totally conquering it-- and annexing it. (Kuwait).

Its even possible that he planned to go beyond that. he was developping a nuclear reactor-- supposedly to supply Iraq's energy needs. (Which seems a bit ironic that he claimed to need nuclear power as Iraq has the fifth largest proven oil reserves in the entire world). Fortunately for the world, the reactor, like Assad's reactor, was bombed and never rebuilt..

Seems kinda odd that people feel the need to defend this tyrant...and stranger still, the time and effort they put into defending him, eh?

 
 

Who is online


Dismayed Patriot
shona1


55 visitors