My dad came from the old German and Dutch stock who believed that "proper" discipline, including spankings, helped strengthen character - and I totally agree.
As the eldest child in the family, I was pretty much the example of "learning" how to behave for my two sisters and brother. They learned from watching/listening to my periods of discipline of what was acceptable behavior and what was not.
Dad, when I did something inappropriate, would tell me what I had done that was wrong - then, the belt would come out, the "punishment" administered. 15 - 30 minutes after administering the punishment, he and I would sit down and discuss what I had done, why it was inappropriate, and I had to give alternate actions that could have been done to prevent the punishment. Worked like a champ. The talking out of the situation gave me a much better insight into how interactions with other people/things/activities could have various impacts on a wide variety of things. My brother and sisters, believe it or not, would also discuss what had happened and they learned, quite well, what was acceptable and what was not. In fact, thanks to me being the whipping boy, neither of the three of them received much, if any, "education" time from Dad - because they learned from example.
I have used the same principle with my son and step-daughter with amazing results. I think I've "punished" them maybe twice throughout their lives, but we have had many, many discussions as to what is and what is not appropriate in the family and society's more's. They both have mentioned that the "punishments" have given them a much better perspective and have actually said they appreciate the method of attention getting thatthey were given 'cause they learned, and, most importantly, remembered their world is not the only one.
Children are not dogs but the behavior can be similar. When my wife and I were dating she had an undisciplined Labrador Retriever. She never hit him and he rarely listened. It was ridiculous. He would run down the alley and push over trash cans so he could eat garbage (in addition to his dog food that he apparently didn't like all that much). She would call him to make him stop. He would raise his head so I know he heard her and then he would resume what he was doing. If she went out after him, he would run further down the alley tipping over cans until he was tired. He once jumped into the middle of somebody's picnic and gobbled as much as he could before we got to him. When I asked why she doesn't hit him with something, she said that a dog trainer told her not to do that. One day when she was gone, he got out and ran to the neighbor's trash can and pushed it over. I called him and he ignored me. I grabbed a belt and ran after him. Everywhere he ran I ran too until I caught him. I beat him and dragged him home. This happened maybe two more times. After that, every time I called him, he would run to me and sit at attention. I never had to beat him again but he continued to ignore my wife. And yes he went to obedience class and no it didn't control his off-leash behavior.
Fast forward to having a son. My wife didn't believe in spanking. I, however, spanked him when he engaged in deliberate disobedience. Spanking was never the first option but only when he defied me after I had already explained what needed to be done and why he had to do it (I also had other means of non-physical punishment but sometimes only a spanking brought results). Once he understood the consequence of disobedience, I rarely had to spank him. My wife avoided spankings but when she ran out of ideas, he would listen if she threatened to involve me. He has always been well behaved at home, in public, and in school. In fact, his teachers have always commented that he was one of the most well behaved children in class.
Physical discipline was tempered with my often sitting down with him and asking whether he had any complaints about how I was raising him or things he thought were unfair. It didn't mean that I would change anything but I wanted to know what he thought. These discussions were helpful because, sometimes, he interpreted things completely differently than what I intended. Once a month, I would have a special day for him where I would agree to do what he wanted to do (movies, video games, water park etc). We were very close and he once commented that I was like having a best friend with money and a car but he knew that I was a parent first. He has grown up into a very well adjusted non-violent and successful adult. We are still close . . . he doesn't mind going to the movies with his dad from time to time. I told him when he was a little boy that, if I could design the perfect son. it would be just like him. He would smile and run off. My opinion of him never changed.
As I think back on it, physical discipline is perfectly fine as long as you temper it with love and understanding.
Would washing out a child's mouth with soap if he/she is caught swearing be considered a similar punishment? My mother did that to me when I was a kid and I sure as ... didn't swear where they could hear me again.
I know about Dr. Spock's concepts, but I wonder if a modern valid study has ever been done to compare children who have been disciplined by spanking to those who were not has ever been carried out. It would have to be a very broad study consisting of thousands of cases in order to overcome differences due to personality, social and economic status, race, religion, ethnicity, etc.
Only one time did I ever strike my kids. I never hit my daughter but only once did I punish my son physically. I had a souvenir German officer's bayonet given to me by an uncle who fought the Nazis in Holland during WWII. My son, who was about 13 or 14 took it to school without my knowledge and used it to threaten a gang of kids who were taunting his best friend. It was reported to the Principal and so we were advised. Because I had learned to box in high school I had a set of gloves, and I had also bought a pair for my son for us to play-box, so I told him to put on his gloves and I hit him hard enough to knock him over. He never touched the bayonet after that. But the problem is that over the years I have often recalled having done that and regretted it. However, the result is that both my kids have grown up to be law-abiding citizens very successful, admired and respected in their respective professions.
Same as when training animals, for the punishment to be effective, it must be immediate so that the connection is made between the offence and the punishment. I know that using rewards for compliance is supposed to be effective as well, but whether it is reward or punishment, proximity is important. Randy did the right thing to make the punishment immediate to the behaviour.
I was always told that in training animals (especially dogs an horses) that it is much more important to reward the desired behavior than it is to punish the undesirable
Denis Leary: My parents used to beat the living shit out of me, okay? And I'm glad they did, and I'm looking forward to beating the shit out of my kids
You can't reason with a 2 or 3 year old. Spanking teaches children that there are consequences for bad behavior. Setting boundaries and enforcing them is important with young kids. We told our kids what would happen if they misbehave and I only had to spank each of my kids only once, in both instances they were being blatantly and willfully disobedient. They are both teenagers now and too old for spanking, but even if they weren't I wouldn't have to.
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
To spank or not to spank: Hitting your kids is legal in all 50 states
The line for what constitutes illegal behavior is subject to different rules .
Big difference between a spanking and a beating, but times they are a changing
A lot of people have spoken in the survey, I am curious as to what parents, grand parents and other interested parties have to say here on NT
badfish
Appreciate the perspective
My dad came from the old German and Dutch stock who believed that "proper" discipline, including spankings, helped strengthen character - and I totally agree.
As the eldest child in the family, I was pretty much the example of "learning" how to behave for my two sisters and brother. They learned from watching/listening to my periods of discipline of what was acceptable behavior and what was not.
Dad, when I did something inappropriate, would tell me what I had done that was wrong - then, the belt would come out, the "punishment" administered. 15 - 30 minutes after administering the punishment, he and I would sit down and discuss what I had done, why it was inappropriate, and I had to give alternate actions that could have been done to prevent the punishment. Worked like a champ. The talking out of the situation gave me a much better insight into how interactions with other people/things/activities could have various impacts on a wide variety of things. My brother and sisters, believe it or not, would also discuss what had happened and they learned, quite well, what was acceptable and what was not. In fact, thanks to me being the whipping boy, neither of the three of them received much, if any, "education" time from Dad - because they learned from example.
I have used the same principle with my son and step-daughter with amazing results. I think I've "punished" them maybe twice throughout their lives, but we have had many, many discussions as to what is and what is not appropriate in the family and society's more's. They both have mentioned that the "punishments" have given them a much better perspective and have actually said they appreciate the method of attention getting thatthey were given 'cause they learned, and, most importantly, remembered their world is not the only one.
JMHO.
1stwarrior
Thanks for the feedback and the real life perspective on child rearing
I bet you have some great kids!
They see the world from a reality perspective - not a "selfish" one - and I luv'm with all my heart
And they return that love and respect I am sure
Gunny
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
Children are not dogs but the behavior can be similar. When my wife and I were dating she had an undisciplined Labrador Retriever. She never hit him and he rarely listened. It was ridiculous. He would run down the alley and push over trash cans so he could eat garbage (in addition to his dog food that he apparently didn't like all that much). She would call him to make him stop. He would raise his head so I know he heard her and then he would resume what he was doing. If she went out after him, he would run further down the alley tipping over cans until he was tired. He once jumped into the middle of somebody's picnic and gobbled as much as he could before we got to him. When I asked why she doesn't hit him with something, she said that a dog trainer told her not to do that. One day when she was gone, he got out and ran to the neighbor's trash can and pushed it over. I called him and he ignored me. I grabbed a belt and ran after him. Everywhere he ran I ran too until I caught him. I beat him and dragged him home. This happened maybe two more times. After that, every time I called him, he would run to me and sit at attention. I never had to beat him again but he continued to ignore my wife. And yes he went to obedience class and no it didn't control his off-leash behavior.
Fast forward to having a son. My wife didn't believe in spanking. I, however, spanked him when he engaged in deliberate disobedience. Spanking was never the first option but only when he defied me after I had already explained what needed to be done and why he had to do it (I also had other means of non-physical punishment but sometimes only a spanking brought results). Once he understood the consequence of disobedience, I rarely had to spank him. My wife avoided spankings but when she ran out of ideas, he would listen if she threatened to involve me. He has always been well behaved at home, in public, and in school. In fact, his teachers have always commented that he was one of the most well behaved children in class.
Physical discipline was tempered with my often sitting down with him and asking whether he had any complaints about how I was raising him or things he thought were unfair. It didn't mean that I would change anything but I wanted to know what he thought. These discussions were helpful because, sometimes, he interpreted things completely differently than what I intended. Once a month, I would have a special day for him where I would agree to do what he wanted to do (movies, video games, water park etc). We were very close and he once commented that I was like having a best friend with money and a car but he knew that I was a parent first. He has grown up into a very well adjusted non-violent and successful adult. We are still close . . . he doesn't mind going to the movies with his dad from time to time. I told him when he was a little boy that, if I could design the perfect son. it would be just like him. He would smile and run off. My opinion of him never changed.
As I think back on it, physical discipline is perfectly fine as long as you temper it with love and understanding.
1ofmany
Thanks for sharing a personal perspective that speaks directly to the issue
Appreciate the feedback
Beautiful Mike - absolutely great.
Would washing out a child's mouth with soap if he/she is caught swearing be considered a similar punishment? My mother did that to me when I was a kid and I sure as ... didn't swear where they could hear me again.
I know about Dr. Spock's concepts, but I wonder if a modern valid study has ever been done to compare children who have been disciplined by spanking to those who were not has ever been carried out. It would have to be a very broad study consisting of thousands of cases in order to overcome differences due to personality, social and economic status, race, religion, ethnicity, etc.
Only one time did I ever strike my kids. I never hit my daughter but only once did I punish my son physically. I had a souvenir German officer's bayonet given to me by an uncle who fought the Nazis in Holland during WWII. My son, who was about 13 or 14 took it to school without my knowledge and used it to threaten a gang of kids who were taunting his best friend. It was reported to the Principal and so we were advised. Because I had learned to box in high school I had a set of gloves, and I had also bought a pair for my son for us to play-box, so I told him to put on his gloves and I hit him hard enough to knock him over. He never touched the bayonet after that. But the problem is that over the years I have often recalled having done that and regretted it. However, the result is that both my kids have grown up to be law-abiding citizens very successful, admired and respected in their respective professions.
Same as when training animals, for the punishment to be effective, it must be immediate so that the connection is made between the offence and the punishment. I know that using rewards for compliance is supposed to be effective as well, but whether it is reward or punishment, proximity is important. Randy did the right thing to make the punishment immediate to the behaviour.
Buzz
A punishment in our family as well, bur many likely would now call it child abuse
Hard to prove or disprove that cause and effect relationship but this is an argument brought up and believed by many people
Mickey
Excellent point, but the problem arises when different people have different views of when, how hard and how much spanking is appropriate
That you explained and talked out the situation is the key regardless of what punishment ir meted out to the child
Buzz
I was always told that in training animals (especially dogs an horses) that it is much more important to reward the desired behavior than it is to punish the undesirable
Yes. is one way to look at it.
Another great line:
Denis Leary: My parents used to beat the living shit out of me, okay? And I'm glad they did, and I'm looking forward to beating the shit out of my kidsYou can't reason with a 2 or 3 year old. Spanking teaches children that there are consequences for bad behavior. Setting boundaries and enforcing them is important with young kids. We told our kids what would happen if they misbehave and I only had to spank each of my kids only once, in both instances they were being blatantly and willfully disobedient. They are both teenagers now and too old for spanking, but even if they weren't I wouldn't have to.
Appreciate the personal perspective.
Still remember the taste of a 'Zest' bar now....50 or so years on........yeah. Same here-didn't swear within my mom's hearing after that.......