'Oversimplifiction' , wildly off base,' Left Wing Slams President's Plan to Deal with the "JV" Team
President Obamas Wednesday-night speech laying out the United States military strategy against the Islamic State didnt get the best reception on the left, and not because it was too hawkish: Chris Matthews repeatedly called it not sufficient, NBC correspondent Richard Engel slammed it as wildly off-base and an oversimplification, and even Al Sharpton admitted the plan left a lot to be desired.A panel composed of some of MSNBCs brightest stars lit into the president almost immediately after he wrapped up his address to the American people. I heard all the necessary conditions, but not the sufficient conditions for defeating ISIS, Matthews lamented. Nothing really about the building of a posse. And everyone who really knows this region are saying the only way you defeat a cancer like this, like ISIS, is within the Islamic world itself . . . and I didnt hear in this speech how were going to do that.NBCs chief foreign correspondent Richard Engel, phoning in from northern Iraq, took issue with President Obamas plan to confront the Islamic State in a manner similar to ongoing U.S. operations in Somalia and Yemen. I think it is wildly off-base, frankly, he accused. I think its an oversimplification of the problem. He explained there is a partner government in Yemen that requires the United States to help with reconnaissance and hard-to-reach targets, and a cooperative government in Somalia, too.Thats not at all the situation that we see in Iraq and Syria, he said. Here we have a large group, tens of thousands of fighters. They control an area the size of Maryland. They control an area with 8 million people living inside of it. Its much more akin to regime change than it is waiting back, picking targets with allied forces. They are not comparable at all.Andrea Mitchell, an NBC foreign-affairs correspondent, largely agreed with Engel but was more favorable to the president, describing the speech as balanced and giving him cautious praise for not overstating the threat of the Islamic State.Al Sharpton tried gamely to defend the president, saying he didnt believe he would give us everything that may be happening and that he was smart to separate [the Islamic State] from Islam. But even he was forced to note that the plan still seemed vague. Where this goes, we dont know, he said. We did not hear it tonight, Ill concede to Chris Matthews. But that does not mean there is not a plan. http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/387662/oversimplification-wildly-base-msnbc-slams-obamas-isis-speech-brendan-bordelon
Tags
Who is online
57 visitors

None of the talking heads (left or right) have any idea of what it is going to take to get the job done in this matter.
I do think that getting the upper hand on ISIS in Iraq should have a high likelihood of succeeding. I'm not so sure about activities in Syria and dealing/training the rebels. It's still the best choice out of a bunch of bad choices, but I think of this part of having things go well is less than 50/50.
And we have a bunch of pre-schoolers telling the military how to conduct their operations/missions?
The pre-schoolers have been with us a long time 1st.
The World Must Unite Against the US-Saudi-Israeli Proxy War in Syria - "Since 2007, the US, Saudi Arabia, and Israel have been documented as conspiring to overthrow the Syrian government by way of sectarian extremists, including groups sympathetic to Al Qaeda, and in particular, the militant, sectarian Muslim Brotherhood. While the West has attempted to portray the full-scale conflict beginning in Syria in 2011 as first, a pro-democracy uprising, to now a sectarian conflict, recent atrocities carried out by US-Saudi-Israeli proxies have shifted the assault to include Sunni Muslims unable or unwilling to participate in the destruction of the Syrian state."
Indian Media: USA/Saudi Proxy War against Iran created ISIS - " All over the world, people are blaming the United States for ISIS. This information is being censored in the USA."
The oil rich Saudi Arabia has been using our military, with the implicit consent of both parties, to further their own religious aims.
Maybe you need to read more outside your narrow list - Is The Anti-ISIS Campaign Attempting to Renew War Against Assad?
Thanks for your skewed opinion on this issue. Read on; U.S. Wants to Bomb ISIS In Syria ... Maybe We Should (cough) First ...
Obama's foreign policy seems to be that, if you topple a dictator, it's like breaking up a concrete driveway so democracy can naturally grow in the rubble like flowers on a hillside. Well, if you don't cultivate it, you'll likely get weeds, not flowers. Obama toppled Qaddafi and now the country is a failed state, exporting terrorism into Egypt and Europe. In his bid to topple Assad, he has done little more than get almost 200,000 people killed and weakened Assad's grip enough to allow ISIL to flourish and spread into Iraq. As a consequence of Obama's folly in Syria, the entire region is sliding into a sectarian war. Obama's plan doesn't work.
If we use Somalia and Yemen as models for how to handle this problem, we'll be fighting ISIL until the dinosaurs return. Obama's central theme is an aversion to using American ground forces but he doesn't explain where he's going to get any other boots on the ground (in adequate numbers) within our lifetimes and you can't win this simply by an air campaign operated like a video game.
The key to this is Syria. We are now on both sides of a Sectarian war, supporting the Sunni in Syria and fighting them in Iraq. This creates an overly complicated problem. Stop trying to topple Assad and broker a peace deal. Assad and his allies, Iran/Hezbollah, can turn their full attention to exterminating ISIL in Syria. And no I don't care if Assad is a bad guy.
Simultaneously, start moving ground forces into Iraq (at Iraq's request) to back stop the Iraqi army and Kurds. Strip the Sunni groups off ISIL . . . pay them if you have to. Force the Shia to be more inclusive . . . pay them too and/or threaten to leave which could result in their heads stuck on poles. Push ISIL back toward the Syrian border and smash them between our forces and Assad's. If other countries want to help with the heavy lifting, then fine. If not, do it without them. As for Middle Eastern countries, we really can't expect meaningful help from the same countries fighting a sectarian war through proxies. Make it clear that our fight is with the ISIL savages, not Sunni Islam.