╌>

California Supreme Court Cuts Back Fifth Amendment Right to Remain Silent When Questioned by Police

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  12 years ago  •  9 comments

California Supreme Court Cuts Back Fifth Amendment Right to Remain Silent When Questioned by Police
August 28, 2014 |

If youre in trouble in California and want to invoke your Fifth Amendment right to remain silent if questioned by police, you better speak up and say sobecause not saying a word can and will be used against you in a court of law, according to the California Supreme Court.

In a 4-3 ruling earlier this month, The People v. Tom , the California High Court held that a suspects silence can be used as evidence against him or her. The details of the case are truly horrendousbecause the accused, Richard Tom, had been drinking with a retired San Francisco police officer and then plowed into another car at an intersection, killing a girl in the back seat in 2007. Tom was driving 67 miles per hour in 35 mph zone, the court said. The other car was going 12 mph.

Tom never said a word to police as he was taken to the station and questioned, including asking about the injured, which state prosecutors said showed his callous character and guilt. He was convicted of manslaughter, where the judge said his lack of concern was relevant for showing criminal recklessness. That set the stage for an appeal, where a lower court ruled his silence could not be used as evidence. But the California Supreme this month ruled that it could.

The California Supreme Court cited a 2013 ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court, Salinas v. Texas, where Justice Samuel Alito weakened the rules for right to remain silent when questioned by police. In order to invoke that right, an individual has to explicitly assert ittelling police thats what theyre doing, Alito wrote. Californias Supreme Court followed that template:

Declaring that [t]he privilege against self-incrimination is an exception to the general principle that the Government has the right to everyones testimony,' the Salinas plurality applied the general rule that a witness must assert the privilege to subsequently benefit from it.' We likewise apply the general rule here and conclude that defendant, after his arrest but before he had received his Miranda warnings, needed to make a timely and unambiguous assertion of the privilege in order to benefit from it."

This case and the resulting California Supreme Court ruling are appalling for different reasons.

After Tom drove his Mercedes at high speed into the other car killing the young girl, local police went to his friends houseretired San Francisco Police Officer Peter Gaminowho, according to the decisions recitation of the facts, claimed that he and Tom had not been drinking, even though a large bottle of vodka was on the kitchen table and two-thirds empty. So we can point to someone who was trusted to enforce the lawand should have stopped an old friend from driving drunkfor contributing to the weakening of constitutional protections for citizens.

Then theres the continuing trend at the U.S. Supreme Court where, given the opportunity to assert and consolidate state police power, the right-wing majority will do soas shown in the Salinas v. Texas ruling. Meanwhile, in California, it appears there also are few winners in this decision apart from granting police and prosecutors more power for obtaining convictions.

The court today holds, against common sense expectations, that remaining silent after being placed under arrest is not enough to exercise ones right to remain silent, California Supreme Court Justice Goodwin Liu wrote in his reasoned dissent. Justice William Rylaarsdam concurred. Justice Kathryn Werdegar dissented separately, saying she agreed with Lius analysis, but that the court should not have even taken the case.

http://www.alternet.org/civil-liberties/california-supreme-court-cuts-back-fifth-amendment-right-remain-silent-when


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

The ruling seems to indicate that the accused can still remain silent (if he/she chooses to) but that the fact that the suspect refused to answer questions or talk to police can be relevant in sentencing consideration.

If one considers Miranda, the suspect has the right to counsel before answering questions, but must assert that right.

Presenting the fact that the suspect chose to remain silent, didn't express remorse for his actions to the judge and jury for their consideration of its relevance seem to be the question that the SCOTUS is asked to review

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

When this is appealed, it will go to the Ninth which will echo what the Cali SC said. When it gets to the Supreme Court, it'll be thrown back in their faces.

The two decisions referenced are state decisions and one Fed, with Alito making an ass of himself as usual. The investigation of the case was not complete - there was conflicting testimony - erroneous information passed on as fact - many other court errors.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

1stwarrior

An appeal of the guilt/innocence ruling may indeed go the route that you indicate, but the interesting aspect is the procedural ruling as to whether a judge/jury can should be told that a defendant refused to talk with or answer questions of officers investigating a crime and then have the judge/jury attach relevance or irrelevance to it.

That is the hard question to answer.

In this case for instance, telling the jury that the defendant never once inquired about the victims or showed any remorse during the investigation seems admissible, but I am not a lawyer

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

It it, but not the way she did it - it was said as a "sarcastic" statement - three times, so she knew what she was doing - totally mucking up the trial. The judge should be replaced because the Defense cried foul each time and was over-ruled.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

1stwarrior

If everything a prosecutor or defense attorney said sarcastically was disallowed there would be many cries of unfair and big brother control

The judge obviously decided (as is his or her right and responsibility) that the probative value of the information outweighed any inflammatory aspect of how the info was presented.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Robert, I'm agreeing with 1st. This might make it to SCOTUS but they will rule against it... I bet almost unanimously (which is quite a bet to take).

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Perrie

I obviously thinkit is not that open and shut, but I am sure that we will see this addressed by the higher courts sooner rather than later.

We can take apart the decision at that point I guess

The key point to decide is whether the probative value of the information outweighed any inflammatory aspect of informing the jury of it.

Appreciate the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I remember hearing that about Citizens United (which was upheld), the PPACA (which was upheld), the Hobby Lobby decision (which was upheld) etc etc

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Never say never.

 
 

Who is online





57 visitors