Asking "[w]ho really rules?" researchers Martin Gilens and Benjamin I. Page argue that over the past few decades America's political system has slowly transformed from a democracy into an oligarchy, where wealthy elites wield most power.
Using data drawn from over 1,800 different policy initiatives from 1981 to 2002, the two conclude that rich, well-connected individuals on the political scene now steer the direction of the country, regardless of or even against the will of the majority of voters.
TPM Interview: Scholar Behind Viral 'Oligarchy' Study Tells You What It Means
"The central point that emerges from our research is that economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on U.S. government policy," they write, "while mass-based interest groups and average citizens have little or no independent influence."
As one illustration, Gilens and Page compare the political preferences of Americans at the 50th income percentile to preferences of Americans at the 90th percentile as well as major lobbying or business groups. They find that the governmentwhether Republican or Democraticmore often follows the preferences of the latter group rather than the first.
The researches note that this is not a new development caused by, say, recent Supreme Court decisions allowing more money in politics, such as Citizens United or this month's ruling on McCutcheon v. FEC . As the data stretching back to the 1980s suggests, this has been a long term trend, and is therefore harder for most people to perceive, let alone reverse.
"Ordinary citizens," they write, "might often be observed to 'win' (that is, to get their preferred policy outcomes) even if they had no independent effect whatsoever on policy making, if elites (with whom they often agree) actually prevail."
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/princeton-experts-say-us-no-longer-democracy

And it took a college education to figure this out?
Hope you're doing well Perrie.
Nice to see you too, Fly! Always miss when you are not around!
Well at least it's official, LOL!
I agree Mike!
Well, it would be nice if SCOTUS didn't allow "Citizens United". And those PACS suck. Also we could do away with the Electoral College and go with one man one vote and gerrymandering.
RL,
You are correct that we are a Constitutional Republic, but we do have democratic elections. So we are a blend of both. I think that this study is about our elections. You are also right that we have been headed this way for a while, but as I said, "Citizens United" has made it much worse.
Although I'm really pissed off at myself for agreeing with you RG, your point is very well taken...
LOL ,
Such a hopeful post. What we need is a third party.
Never was a democracy. It is a republic.
Arguably this nation was more an oligarchy 100 years ago than it is now that the franchise has broadened due to voting changes and demographics.
The study sponsors appear to be promoting Occupy and Warren issues.
MiG Said:
Such blanket statements about liberals or conservatives are seldom true, often inflammatory, and generally lead conversations down the path to pissing matches where the participants speak in wrote, memorized patterns instead of actually thinking critically and responding thoughtfully.
Not all of any group is any particular way, and the grouping itself may be pejorative on its face. So, as a thinking, living, respiring human being who happens to be liberal, I would contend that we need to define our words that we are using so everyone knows just what they are saying and who means what when they are saying it. This lack of definitional consistency is a large part of the gridlock that we see in Washington and elsewhere around the country and around the globe. When words can mean anything they, in effect, mean nothing.
First off, we need a realistic definition of the different socioeconomic classes: What is poor? What is middle class? What is rich? Without these distinctions, we can't move the conversation forward in any meaningful way.
The oligarchy begins where? What are the parameters of that said oligarchy? Is there some line that separates merely rich people from the oligarchy?
(Snicker)
Greed or success? There is a difference. I think that most people are looking for a degree of happiness, or the pursuit of happiness.
Years ago I read a study that after a certain point in earnings, people no longer have a higher degree of happiness.
The Declaration of Independence does not promise happiness -- only "the pursuit of happiness."
TheMishna (Ethics of theFathers)asks, "Who is rich?" and responds:
"He who is satisfied with his lot."
The middle class will be screwed only if the next has president has a "D" or an "R" after their name. In other words, the middle class is screwed.
MiG:
You don't start a conversation based on a blanket number, which was the point of my comment. We all need to put down the catch phrases such as the ones that you used (liberal, 99%, 1%) and look calmly and rationally at the information presented to us and that we present to others. That is known as discussion, and something that I have seen very little of around here.
How am I supposed to converse with someone who will not let go of the fluff words that are out there and just answer a simple, direct question?
That is the most accurate description.
Chucky,
Gotta agree with ya. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
Perrie said:
What we need is thedismantlingof the party system. We need a paradigm shift from one of voting for specific people to implement our ideas and ideals to voting on the idea and ideals themselves. The way it exists now, we have to vote for one personto representourideals, but nooneperson represents our them exactly.(If you think that there is someone out there who represents your ideas and ideals to a T, marry them. If it is politically representative of all your ideals and ideas, you need to examine your ideas and ideals to make sure they are yours and that the person who claimsto representthem is actually doing so.) So we need to vote on theideas, both in the abstract and the detailed, maybe elect a specific representative based on that idea, for that idea only.
(Yeah, I know... just shook up the Constitution.)
You obviously have no fear of it.
Really, MiG, I am a liberal. Or do I not fit under your term libs ? If someone is saying something that you do not agree with, note it and move on. Don't wear yourself out jousting windmills, just state your piece.
How about this: I will assume that I am talking to an intelligent human being and you can assume the same? If we make these assumptions, we have established a plane of relative equality and can advance the conversation, just between the two of us, anywhere and an way that we so desire.
So, starting over, how would you define rich? Poor? Middle class?
To me, poor means that you lack the financial capability of sustaining your basic needs on a consistent and reliable basis. Middle class means that you do have these abilities and can save income, be comfortable. Rich is where you have all that you could ever need or want in excess.
I linked this before, but it is pertinent, I feel, to the discussion .
Yes Robert, they were affluent men. But there was a big difference. They were the creators of this, and therefore had faith in what they were creating. They knew their master plan. We guess at what their intentions were by what they left behind in writing. But I am sure they never saw "Citizens United" or PACs in the formula. And the very point of giving our Justices life positions was that they were not supposed to be partisan. That has not gone that way by a long shot.
As you are so well demonstrating.
Mike,
My kids go to Hopkins, which is unofficially considered an Ivy league school. They are there on total scholarship as are 44% of the student body.
At Yale, it is 57% of the student body. So this isn't the rich kids school that people think it is.
Let's stick to the topic.
MiG,
I did not, purposely, provide the qualification of in excess . We are still defining the terms, and it is best to not jump to the conclusion that we think we see in order to frame a reply consistent with our personal attitudes.
As such, it would be prudent to define excess or find another word to fit the meaning which we intend: From the Merriam Webster Dictionary -
Yes there are. But there are also people who wealthy and have a sense of social conscientiousness, like Buffett and Gates. You can't make a blanket statement about people. Those who are never happy are sick, cause you can't take it with you and more so, are never happy in their lifetime.
Yes Len. And most people would be happy not to worry if they can take their kid to the doctor. A society is judged not by their rich, but how we treat the poor.
Lovely thought... though even the many rich are not happy with their lot and so carry on making more.
BTW the Mishna also says:
We can all cherry pick from the scriptures.
RL,
These things needed for basic needs of life should be covered at least somewhat. I am sorry that they are not for you. You would think that they would be through Medicaid.
There was no such thing as multinational conglomerates when they wrote the Constitution. Deciding that a business entity was an individual, was never intended under freedom of speech. It was meant for the people. Citizens United robbed the people.
BTW even freedom of speech has it's limitations. Funny that it seems to only apply to the common man.
So says one, who obviously does not suffer from self esteem problems.
Mow away, I have to get out and do, also.
I think that the whole of living is subjective to the individual, on one level or another. But we, meaning the nation in this case, should to come up with some way of making the determination of who and what is rich, are poor and middle class(there is a great deal of subjectivity there, also). These determinations will, by the fact of their existence, be arbitrary and subject to scrutiny.
As to where we are going with this? I have no pre-set agenda. I was engaging you in conversation for practice at communication, critical thinking and conflict resolution skills. Personally, I feel that we (humans) fall far short of potential because we 1) fail to communicate our ideas, and 2) respect the fact that others can think differently than us and not be, by default, stupid.
Happy labor day!
I wonder though-- isn't that way it always has been-- and is in almost all major countries throughout history & throughout the world? There always seems to be a ruling elite, a small group that actually wields the power. (Even under Communism, where perhap the biggest effort in history towards creating egalitarian countries was attempted-- there was a small elite who wielded power-- and yes, the Communist rulers became wealthy, & the general populatio was kept booth poor and disenfranchised).
The only exceptions might be small soverign entities. Isolated groups on Pacific Islands-- or deep in African or Amazonian jungles...???
What I do wonder however-- is this situation actually getting worse in the U.S.? There does seem to be evidence that the middle class is shrinking.
But is it worse than in the era of "The Robber barons"-- or during Slavery in the Old South?
Future Politics? Naw, it's NOW
The people don't really care who rules, just so long as you keep telling them they are safe.
Actually, yes it is worse... because 'The Robber Barons' aren't Carnegie, Rockefelleror Hearst or Gould now; well, we have the Koch Bros. and Buffett and the Walton heirs, but the modern Robber Barons aren't even human, they're corporations. Corpshave finally succeeded in doing exactly what (in large part at least) they were created for: shielding individual persons from responsibility & consequences of their decisions. Everybody bitches that executive decision-makers don't go to jail, yet we continue to accept that somehow 'corporate decisions' are independent of the individuals that make them.
When Ford Motor made the Pinto with a gas tank that was certain to rupture in a rear-ender & spew gasoline into the back half of the car, engineers noted that hazard, and showed that a minor design change would solve the problem--- it would have factored out to about a nickel on every car (based on projected sales). Accountants & lawyers did the math, and found that it would be less expensive to pay out on X number of lawsuits by survivors of Pinto fireballs than to fix the car. The internal memos & reports that proved that design chance was nixed based on that analysissurfaced years later--- but no individuals were ever prosecuted for deciding that X number of folks would be scarred, crippled or burned to death in the interest of 'the bottom line'. The 'financial meltdown' in hyperinflated mortgages, Deepwater Horizon, thelist goes on & on and we all know it--- but 'corporations' don't get sent to prison, they pay fines. And the individual people who make decisions about shady mortgage bundling or inferior safetyequipmentaren't held responsible; "management decisions" apparently come out of thin air, disembodied, like the voice of an oracle. Seen anyone get charged for the tidal wave of fly-ash that was all over the news a while ago??? You won't... a corporation will pay some fines, but nobody's gonna do time for neglecting the containment ponds.
Robber Barons today are named British Petroleum, JP Morgan Chase, Halliburton & Duke Energy, and they're further above the law than Rockefeller or Gould or Citizen Kane ever were. Hell, even the Mafia or Columbian drug lords can be brought down--- how you gonna give Duke Energy 10 to 25 in the joint? Robber Barons don't pay 'bribes' any more... they make anonymous PAC donations for multimillion dollar campaign contributions. It's all been made legal... as many posters here on NT are fond of pointing out.
The reality is that America (like pretty much every nation on Earth) is and always was run by an Oligarchy... it's simply more organized, efficient, pervasive and 'legal' than it ever was before. Perhaps the ultimate irony is that 'Citizens United' put the final nail in the coffin, opening a floodgate of legal bribery we're only barely beginning to see. Consider the schadenfreude of a Supreme Court decision about 'freedom of speech' that legalizes & institutionalizes one of the oldest cliches in American politics: "Money Talks". Now, more than ever...
RL,
But I like you in a tin hat. I wear mine from time to time and don it with pride.
I think a legit 3rd party would stand on their own two feet. But their is a valid point with Judges... at least in the short term.
Observations of discussion:
1. Discussion? concerning the accumulation of wealth and whether it makes you happy
2. Convention of States, still no discussion of how that pertains to getting the individual involved in politics.
3. Obama, not sure how this fits in.
4. Perrie wants a third party (yes, still). So would I.
For you Constitutional scholars, it is the Electoral College who actually elects the President.
For me, the story is more along these lines: Why aren't average people participating in the political process?
There could be several reasons: 1. It takes too much time.
2. My vote doesn't count.
3. I don't have the time to vote (yes you do, by statute.)
4. I don't care.
I know that 'political activist' leaves a bad taste in some mouths, but isn't that what we really need? I'm pretty sure George didn't like the taste of the 'political activists' of his day either, but it got us what we have.
That's a distortion that occurred over time. I went to the page you linked-- here's the actual quote:
In other words-- if there's great success that can't be explained, it was the result of a crime that was covered up.
That's the sort of belief that's guaranteed to keep a person away from doing anything that will make them substantial money!
LOL.. Guilty as charged and have been for about the last 15 years now.
It is a necessary evil if we really want change.
Indeed it is Perrie, but it requires overcoming a lot of inertia.
While we are looking at things from a metaphoric point of view, why don't we add mass to your inertia to finish the concept.
And then there's this:
The people (citizens of political entity) should have a say in the way public institutions are run. But why should they have a say in how a private entity is run? The owner or owners should have that say.
If you don't like the way they run their business, you don't have to buy what they sell. And-- if you don't like the way they run it, you don't have to become a part owner (i.e. a stockholder).
False! All of the profit does not go to those people. Some goes to pay workers. (With rare exceptions, workers wouldn't work there unless they got paid.And where do you think the money to pay them comes from? yes-- from the profits!)
Yes, Mike, what DO we do??? We have all the questions, now we need to find the answers, right?
Masses would be more accurate.
Fly and Steve,
You guys crack me up!
Yet so true!
Corporations seem to keep getting bigger and bigger, and mpre and more powerful.
However, in terms of the U.S. becoming less democratic-- it may be that its sort of like a pendulum effect-- over time it sowly swings in one direction or another.
In some ways we are getting more democratic. Originally our so called "democracy" allowed considerably less than half the population to vote!
Women couldn't vote-- that's half the population right there. And in addition, African-Americans couldn't vote.
Now both groups can. (Of course some people don't want to take any responsibility for their fate, and don't vote, don't ever contact their elected representatives, etc).
Show me a person that would make a statement like that, and I'll show you a person that lives a very sheltered life.
Over my many years Mike, I have met quite a few people that prefer to live avery simple, unencumbered, no frills lifestyle. They're all different in one way or another, and for the most part, they all have different reasons for choosing their particular way of living. However, they all do have a common thread, ..... they're are all perfectly content and they have absolutely no interest orintentionin changing the way they live.
Money in politics is, and has been the issue with politics for decades now with all three branches of government having been sold off in one way or another.
Any manner of attempt to limit fundraising or political donations has been resoundingly struck down as it is seen as a limitation of free speech. Lost and trampled in all of this is the concept of "one person, one vote" as a way of selecting our leadership at every level. This has given rise to something akin to "We are all equal, but some are more equal than others". This too flies in the face of the goals for our constitution.
Hence the constitutional quandary we find ourselves in.
So you are going to tell me that our legislators write and pass laws/budgets with the people in mind above all else, or are you free to admit that money buys access for a quid pro quo relationship with the highest bidder?
The approval of Citizens United by the SCOTUS is all one needs to understand that money does indeed buy votes.
You say Bitching is not a system of government, but bribery isn't suppose to be either
And nowhere did I say the SC court did what you are accusing me of saying. My point is that in the 5-4 decision in favor of upholding Citizens United, the majority committed a grave error in treating corporate speech the same as that of human beings.
And we have come full circle..... corporations have now been afforded the same right to free speech as human beings. A huge mistake which confirms my statement of the loss of one man one vote, as the owner through his corporation now gets more influence in our government.
"Some are more equal than others.:
I'm surprised you didn't recognize my last posting as pretty much a direct quote from one of the dissenting SC judges Robert. It was his job to interpret the law against the constitution. So all your supporting statements are secondary to those whom made the ruling. His opinion even in dissent speaks volumes to the truth of what CU is all about.
Furthermore.... the vote split down the conservative/liberal line meaning that the politics that went into the judicial nominations determined the outcome.
Robert... you are obviously in the twilight zone when it comes to this decision and the constitution. Your interpretation is just as flawed as the right wing members of the SC that were only capable of reading the first five words in the amendment. There are fourty other words in that amendment that you and they have decided to ignore. The first amendment is about PEOPLE not corporations.
Furthermore... the next nine amendments that make up the bill of rights are there to guarantee PERSONAL rights. They don't say jack about corporate rights.
The five paid for justices that voted for CU ignored what the the first 10 amendments are all about when they narrowly made their decision.
You have been on that theme for a while now Robert. In the first place, people that do not agree with your way of thinking are not "liars", they're just people that disagree with you. Also, I don't know of anyone that thinks "succ ess and enterprise" is evil. However, I do know a lot of people that have a problem with GREED!
The wealth and enterprise in this country, although invented and promoted by the entrepreneurs, is actually created by the rank and file workers. But w hat has happened is, the wealth generated by the workers efforts is no longer getting back to those workers, instead it's all, or at least 99% of it, is pretty much going to the elite and exclusive occupants of the corporate board rooms. There was a time in the not too distant past when the average CEO compensation package was about 40 times more than the average worker, and people did not have too much of a problem with that, however things are different now.
Forbes Report : CEOs Earn 331 Times As Much As Average Workers, 774 Times As Much As Minimum Wage Earners
Excerpt;
"With CEO compensation analysis season in full swing, the AFL-CIO released data this morning stating that American CEOs in 2013 earned an average of $11.7 millionan eye-popping 331 times the average workers $35,293."
This gross disparity of income and wealth has caused the middle class American to all but completelydisappear, creating a huge gap between the haves and the have nots. The real and very present danger this has caused is the parallel between the disparity of income and wealth, to the disparity of power and control.
There is no question that the Citizens United ruling will go down in history as the most horrendous ruling SCOTUS has ever made. If the Citizens United ruling is not overturned, and soon , we will indeed on a irreversible path to becoming an Oligarchy.
(That was not necessary smartass.)
You're wrong, and I'll show you why later. Right know I have to go pay the captain oftheboat that brought me to this strange world of yours, and also take care of a few more important chores.
:D
I think it would beinertial mass, or maybe massive inertia, or, for the department of redundancy department, massively inertial mass...
Robert,
There is no conflict between the first amendment and what a whole lot of people are saying:
Following your logic, Church's are made up of groups of people, so they should also be allowed to opine on matters of political import. Wait, religious people with a corporation can, according to the same justices whomyouappear to agree with. What part of "Congress shall make no law..." don't they understand?
Krish said:
I thought that the money paid to workers as compensation was taken as an expense to the corporation before figuring profit/loss....