U.S. Muslim Professor: Dire Need for Muslims to Lead Fight vs Fanaticism
Nothing could be more harmful to Islam than todays shenanigans of the so-called Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. Vicious attacks on non-Muslims are abhorrent to Islam. The Quran states clearly and unequivocally: There is no compulsion in religion. Forcing anyone to pay a tax is going back in history when non-Muslims were not drafted in armies and were asked to pay that jizya instead. But, soon after the religion settled, the practice was stopped.
I was born and raised in Egypt as part of a conservative Muslim family. My father was a teacher and scholar of Islamic jurisprudence. He was educated at, and became an official of, Azhar, the second oldest university and among the most highly respected religious institutions in the world. Because I was taught the unaltered tenets of Islam, todays perceptions of it distress me greatly.
Todays hysterical groups along both sides of the doomed Sikes-Picot line in the sand are all young men with guns. It is a deadly combination in a leaderless place. The ISIS threat is not only in its lawlessness, but also in the negative image of Islam that it is leaving in its wake. Those young men represent a disenfranchised lot with little education and no hope for a better future in their counties of origin. They were radicalized and misled by bitter, self-appointed preachers. Because they felt neglected, forgotten or oppressed they do not consider themselves part of any cohesive social fabric. Thus, they believe that in anarchy they would gain power, respect and a fair share of economic opportunity. Yet, their heinous acts are mistakenly ascribed to Islam by many observers.
The silence of religious leaders regarding this situation is deafening. Nothing in Islam condemns people who adhere to the tenants of Christianity or Judaism. These are specifically noted and protected in the Quran as people of the book. Furthermore, history has no parallel of an Islamic State. This is a recent concept that was initiated by the Iranian revolution of 1979 and the rule of Ayatollah Khomeini. Even in todays Iran there is no state-sponsored discrimination of people of other religions.
History is replete with examples of Christians and Jews who played significant and highly recognized roles within Islamic civilization. Let us not forget that the commander of the Fatimid army in Egypt, Jawhar Al-Siqilli, hailed from a Christian Byzantine family from Sicily. He built the city of Cairo and the Azhar University in the year 970. Similarly, the great Jewish philosopher Musa Bin Maimun (Maimonides) thrived in Cordoba under Muslim rule in southern Spain. He was duly invited to Cairo and served as chief physician in the court of Saladin until his death in 1204. More recently in Egypt of a century ago, Christians (Copts) and Egyptian Jews played a significant role in the development of the country and led its institutions, prior to the creation of Israel and the revolution of 1952 that followed.
Clearly, there is a dire need to assure proper education of Muslim youth in the religion. The task should be accomplished by properly trained teachers who are well-versed in the tenets of Islam and their meanings. It is not human to disregard disenfranchised youths. We cannot eradicate them or wish them to disappear. Instead of learning how to use guns, they should be trained for a profession to put them on a path for a useful life.
Such an effort should be first and foremost the responsibility of their countries of origin. This should be a major effort by national and multinational organizations. For example, we urgently need serious inputs from the Arab League, the Gulf Cooperation Council, and the Organization of Islamic-Majority Countries. Their neglect and silence have gone far beyond the acceptable. It is now time to act with courage and humility to assure a better future.
Dr. Farouk El-Baz is director of the Center for Remote Sensing at Boston University. He served as science adviser to President Anwar Sadat of Egypt.

I can't argue about anything the good doctor has to say, but his words and thought which are good ones need to be more than just words and thoughts.
How do you give people hope in a land where there is none?
The title of the Op-Ed piece in the Boston Herald sounds all well and good, but you only have to read the first paragraph to discern it is disingenuous at least and outright lying at times.
Nothing could be more harmful to Islam than todays shenanigans of the so-called Islamic State in Iraq and Syria.
He describes the savage brutality and daily mass murders of IS as shenanigans. The definition of shenanigans is "silly or high-spirited behavior; mischief". The professor makes it sound like IS is a bunch of fraternity boys engaging in harmless hazing.
Vicious attacks on non-Muslims are abhorrent to Islam.
Contained in Islam's tenets are "kill (unbelievers) where you find them"" and "instill terror in the unbelievers, smite their necks and cut off their fingertips".
Forcing anyone to pay a tax is going back in history when non-Muslims were not drafted in armies and were asked to pay that jizya instead.
A historical lie. From the very beginning of the Ottoman Empire, the elite army of Janissaries were comprised of thousands of kidnapped Christian boys from the Balkans who were enslaved and forcibly converted. Each year the Sultans emissaries would go to the Christian villages and pick out the strongest and brightest young boy from each family and take them away from their family forever.
There is much more nonsense like this in the piece. The professor can't even spell the WWI pact which defined many of the borders of the modern Middle East. He refers to the Sykes-Picot Agreement as the "Sikes-Picot line". A trivial error for one of us on NT, but not for a college professor in a published opinion piece.
Another lie among many by the professor. IS has publicly declared itself to be a caliphate which was what the Muslim Empire was called from the time of Muhammad until the last Caliphate was broken up in 1924. The current Caliph (leader) isAbu Bakr al-Baghdadi.
Every one of the Islamist terrorist groups are striving for a global Caliphate in which everyone will either be Muslim or Muslim subjects to be ruled over.
You can't.
Until the people begin to take responsibility for their own destiny (and stop blaming everyone else) there isn't any possibility for change.
The U.S. has tried to be the policeman for the world for too long. Until people show some efforts on their own to change things, nothing we can do can help them!!!
Hope has nothing to do with IS. More than half (and growing) of the Islamic State's active fighters come from Saudi Arabia, Western Europe, and North America, often from educated middle-class families. The hope they have is that the world will become Islamic. It sounds crazy to us, but they are true believers.
I'm just curious... do you have a source for this information? I'd like to read it.
It is no great secret, the information is widely available in newspapers, television, and the Internet. Here is part of an article in last week's Los Angeles Times , a liberal newspaper not prone to "Islamophobia" titled: " More Western fighters joining militants in Iraq and Syria."
Thousands of foreign fighters have bolstered the ranks of militant groups in Syria and Iraq in recent months, according to U.S. officials, driving fresh concern about potential terrorist plots aimed at the United States or its allies.
The surge, as well as intelligence that Yemeni terrorists have developed a powerful cellphone bomb designed to avoid detection at airports, is behind the Obama administration's increasingly urgent warnings that a European or American passport holder might try to take down a passenger jet or plan other deadly mayhem.
As many as 10,000 foreign fighters a third more than in February have joined the militias seeking to overthrow Syrian President Bashar Assad and the Islamic State fighters who have swept across northern Iraq, said a counter-terrorism official who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss classified assessments.
As many as 3,000 of them hold European or other Western passports and thus can travel easily across most borders. Several dozen, perhaps as many as 100, hold U.S. passports, and officials say that number is growing.
The potential partnership between some of those Westerners and sophisticated bomb makers from the Yemen-based Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, long viewed as the terrorist network's most dangerous offshoot, has raised alarm in Washington and other capitals.
"It's something that gives us really extreme, extreme concern," Atty. Gen. Eric H. Holder Jr. told ABC News last week. "In some ways, it's more frightening than anything I think I've seen as attorney general."
FBI Director James B. Comey told reporters in Washington that the threat "keeps me up at night." He sees the region as a "launching ground" for potential Sept. 11-style mass-casualty attacks in this country.
Two U.S. citizens have been arrested on terrorism-related charges since April before boarding flights to Turkey, suspected of being on their way to help the militants. One is said to have paid his way with his federal tax refund. In May, a Florida man became a suicide bomber in northern Syria.
"It's the largest number of Western fighters we have ever seen in a jihadist theater," said Seth G. Jones, a former U.S. counter-terrorism official now with the Rand Corp. think tank.
"The scale of this is huge," said Daniel L. Byman, professor of security studies at Georgetown University in Washington.
You can read the rest of it at:
...
I see where it says that there are more coming than the last count in Feb (this posted in July).
I was just curious if there was a source for the statement that over half the current active fighters are coming from SA, Western Europe and North America.
I hadn't seen that figure or read it anywhere.
As people here have stated, you don't here have to go back in history-- several exist today:
It seems fitting that the professor holds a doctorate in geology - he has rocks in his head. After reading this opinion piece, he would be better served teaching a course in taquia(Islamic religious permission of lying to promote Islam and deceive its enemies).
ROFL!