╌>

The Answer to Corporate ‘Inversion’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  12 years ago  •  8 comments

The Answer to Corporate ‘Inversion’

T he Obama administration is highly exercised about inversion, the practice by which an American corporation acquires a foreign company and moves its headquarters out of the U.S. to benefit from lower tax rates abroad.

Not fair, says Barack Obama. Its taking advantage of an unpatriotic tax loophole that hardworking American families have to make up for by the sweat of their brow. His treasury secretary calls such behavior a violation of economic patriotism.

Nice touch. Democrats used to wax indignant about having ones patriotism questioned. Now they throw around the charge with abandon, tossing it at corporations that refuse to do the economically patriotic thing of paying the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world.

Odder still because Democrats routinely ridicule the very notion of corporations as persons. AfterMitt Romney suggested this in 2011, Democrats mocked him right through Election Day. In the Hobby Lobby case, they challenged the very idea that corporations can have religious convictions. Now, however, Democrats are demanding that corporations exercise a patriotic conscience. Which is it?

Moreover, corporations have an indisputable fiduciary responsibility to protect their shareholders interest. Surely Walgreens betrayed this responsibility when it caved to administration pressure and canceled its plans to move its headquarters to Switzerland. The inversion wouldve saved it billions of dollars. Its cancelation caused an instant 14 percent drop in Walgreens shares.

But the Democrats problem is deeper. Everyone knows why inversions are happening. Americas 35 percent corporate tax rate is absurdly uncompetitive. Companies are doing what they always do: legally loweringtheir tax liabilities.

What is maddening is that the problem is so easily solved: tax reform that lowers the accursed corporate rate. Democrats and Republicans agree on this. After the announcement of the latest inversion, Burger King buying Tim Hortons and then moving to Canada, the president himself issued a statement conceding that corporate tax reform lower the rates, eliminate loopholes is the best solution to the inversion problem.

Its also politically doable. Tax reform has unique bipartisan appeal. Conservatives like it because lowering rates stimulates the economy and eliminating loopholes curbs tax-driven economic decisions that grossly misallocate capital.

The appeal to liberals is economic fairness. By eliminating loopholes, tax reform levels the playing field. Today, the more powerful companies can afford the expensive lobbyists who create the loopholes and the expensive lawyers who exploit them. Which is why the nominal corporate tax rate is 35 percent but the effective rate for some of the largest corporations is about 13 percent.

So why not attack the inversion problem with its obvious solution: tax reform? Time is short, says Obama. He cant wait. Instead, he wants legislation to outlaw inversion.

No time? Where has he been? He does nothing about tax reform for six years (during two of which Democrats fully controlled Congress), then claims now to be too impatient to attempt the real solution. Instead he wants to hurry through a punitive anti-inversion law to counterbalance the effects of our already punitive tax rates.

This is nuts. But amusing, given that a major financier of the inversion-celebre of the day, the Whopper-to-Canada deal, is none other than Warren Buffett, Obamas favorite plutocrat.

Buffetts demand that the rich be required to pay more taxes made him a hero to the president. In 2012, Obama repeatedly held up Buffett as a champion of economic justice. What does Obama say today about his 2012 class-war comrade-in-arms now become, by Obamas own lights, an economic traitor?

And more such Benedict Arnolds are being minted every week. One of the reasons for the recent acceleration of inversions is that corporations want to move before Obama outlaws it, locking them into Americas anti-competitive corporate tax rate.

The Wall Street Journal cited a Buffett confidant as saying he likely wouldnt have backed a deal like Burger King if it were purely for tax reasons. Indeed, there are other considerations that can always be invoked. Which makes some of the contemplated anti-inversion proposals even more absurd: They would outlaw only those mergers done for tax reasons. How do you prove motivation? Lie detectors?

A real political leader would abandon this sideshow and actually address corporate tax reform with a serious revenue-neutral proposal to Congress. There would be hearings, debate, compromises. We might end up with something like the historic bipartisan tax reform of 1986 that helped launch two decades of nearly uninterrupted economic growth.

But for that you need a president.

http://www.nationalreview.com/article/386620/answer-corporate-inversion-charles-krauthammer #!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Excerpt worth noting:

Democrats used to wax indignant about having ones patriotism questioned. Now they throw around the charge with abandon, tossing it at corporations that refuse to do the economically patriotic thing of paying the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world.

Odder still because Democrats routinely ridicule the very notion of corporations as persons. AfterMitt Romney suggested this in 2011, Democrats mocked him right through Election Day. In the Hobby Lobby case, they challenged the very idea that corporations can have religious convictions. Now, however, Democrats are demanding that corporations exercise a patriotic conscience. Which is it?

The hypocrisy is palatable.

If it benefits the Democrats, a corporation CAN have human traits.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Well said. It seems there is no depth to their arguments.
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Check that. It's billions. With a "b".

Buffet is embarrassed by his riches sometimes. When the subject of taxation comes up, he admits that he could afford to pay more than others, and mused that he should be subject to a higher rate. The President ran with it.

Now, Buffet is participating in this merger, and stands to make yet another fortune. I say "good for him". He's a businessman, with an eye for value.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Democrats used to wax indignant about having ones patriotism questioned. Now they throw around the charge with abandon, tossing it at corporations that refuse to do the economically patriotic thing of paying the highest corporate tax rate in the industrialized world.

Inversion is tax evasion, plain and simple. Nothing to do with being a patriot or not.

A couple of corrections here. Japan has the highest corporate tax rate at 40%, with effective rates ranging between 37% and 38% after deductions.

The US tax rate is 35%, but the effective tax rate is 23%-28%. I'm not crying for them...and it's BS excuse for taking business abroad.

Oh and on another note effective personal tax rates in the western world are much higher than ours. We don't even make the chart.

So these CEO's live here, pay next to nothing in taxes and make max profit abroad. Sweet for them. Sucks for the rest of the country.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

RL,

Robert is correct on this.

But here is the rub. Because of inversion, corporations can avoid our corporate income tax with this loophole.

But the CEO and upper management, still make income, which it taxed at one of the lowest effective rates than the rest of the western world.

So they make max bonuses, which get min. taxes. The only loser here, is the average working stiff, whose job just got off shored.. which is most of us.

Our tax code is the issue here. It is a pile of loopholes and inconsistencies.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Business owners like myself often do pay the business profits under their personal income tax. Between all the different taxes I pay it's estimated that the government takes close to half my earnings as my business is classified as a sub S corp. I have about three hundred employees and the tax bill is significant and damaging to my business. I do not borrow money so all expansion and growth is funded with profit. While I'm no longer involved in day to day operations of the business I do spend a lot of time dealing with the accountants and lawyers in an attempted to minimize my tax burden.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Dean,

Sub S's pay the highest effective tax rate, somewhere about 31%, which is insane compared to partnerships, 29% and C corporations 17%. Why wouldn't you restructure?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

There is a lot to it and some of it I don't really understand. The business was originally founded in the mid fifties with five thousand dollars and three employees and was originally a C corp. As the tax code kept changing and to avoid a double taxation it was reclassified a S corp in the mid 80's. Along with that came all kinds of llc's, grats, trusts and a post office box in the Cayman Islands to minimize estate taxes that can devastate a business. The accounting firm is UHY which to the best of my knowledge is considered a top notch outfit. They claim the business is one of the best run they've ever seen because it has no debt and never has and has a strong history of growth. It has almost always turned a profit of about thirty percent before taxes except for two years out of its sixty year history. Almost all the profit is then reinvested into the company.

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot


71 visitors