The Legislation of Spontaneity
LINK :
http://nation.time.com/2013/02/27/whats-wrong-with-the-violence-against-women-act/
Whats Wrong with the Violence Against Women Act?
The political fight on Capitol Hill over the Violence Against Women Act has little to do with the central debate feminists and academics are having about whether better policing is the best way to stopping domestic violence
When Congress passed the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) in 1994, it was a landmark in federally recognizing the scourge of domestic violence. It also brought about a very practical change, meant to address the problem of cops treating such cases as private family matters instead of serious crimes. With grant funding as reward and with the backing of many leaders in the battered womens movement, VAWA encouraged states to adopt mandatory arrest policies that allowed domestic violence cases to move forward without the cooperation of victims. Eighteen years later, with a reauthorization of VAWA now stalled on Capitol Hill, a vocal group of researchers and advocates are questioning whether VAWAs original intentto make law enforcement the primary tool to stop domestic violencewas the right approach. VAWAs focus on law enforcement reduces the really more complicated thing of violence against women to be a problem of the law, says Beth E. Richie, a sociologist and professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago who studies violence against women. And its not just a problem of the law.
VAWA has increased prosecution rates of domestic violence cases, but there is little conclusive evidence that it has significantly reduced the incidence of violence. According to the Department of Justice (DOJ), the rate of intimate partner violence dropped 64% between 1994 and 2010, a drop pro-VAWA policymakers largely attribute to the law. But this decrease happened at the same time violent crime as a whole fell dramatically nationwide, making it hard to know whether a drop in domestic violence might have happened without the policies adopted under VAWA.
( PHOTOS: Photographer as Witness: A Portrait of Domestic Violence )
Domestic violence is still a severely under-reported crime and some critics say mandatory arrest policies have exacerbated this problem. These policies, which existed in some states before VAWA but became more common after early versions of VAWA encouraged them, require police officers responding to domestic violence calls to arrest alleged abusers if there is probable cause to believe assaults have taken place. The intent of these laws was to spur a culture change in law enforcement, which had a long history of declining to intervene in domestic violence situations. But some say mandatory arrest discourages some women from reporting domestic violence because they fear their partnerssometimes a familys sole earnerwill be automatically arrested and thrown in jail.
Domestic violence victims who avoid calling the police or seeking other help can put themselves in even more danger. A 2007 Harvard study found that the rate of intimate partner homicide is higher in states that have mandatory arrest laws on the books. Paradoxically, it appears VAWA may have had a much greater effect on the rate of women killing their partners (down 40% between 1995 and 2008) than on men killing their partners (down just 7% in the same period). Women may be less likely to kill their partners when an aggressive police response is readily available, but it appears the threat of arrest and prosecution has done little to dissuade abusive men from killing. In addition, in some cases, victims themselves are taken into police custody because of mandatory arrest laws. Police on the scene may not be able to determine who is the primary aggressor in a violent episode and may feel compelled to arrest both parties if they have probable cause.
Some feminist researchers have another reason to criticize mandatory arrest laws: They say the policies do nothing to address the causes of intimate partner violence, which is highly correlated with unemployment and economic distress. Even worse, these researchers say, mandatory arrest laws remove the preferences of abused women from a process that can leave them financially strapped and worried that the state will take custody of their children. When you institute a mandatory arrest policy, the hope is that you will control the police and make sure they respond, says Donna Coker, a former battered womens shelter worker and now a law professor at the University of Miami. But too often, it has the unintended consequence of increasing the potential for state control of marginalized women.
( MORE: One Billion Rising: An End to Violence Against Women )
Coker believes some of the VAWA funding now allocated to law enforcement should be redirected to prevention, job training and services that help women with the logistics of leaving their abusive partners. You look at the relatively miniscule amount of money going to transitional housing compared to criminal justice and its outrageous, says Coker. Federal funds authorized through VAWA for transitional housing in 2012 were about one-fifth the total allocated for law enforcement action. Housing is by far the most common unmet need for victims.
Leigh Goodmark, a law professor and director of the family law clinic at the University of Baltimore, has represented abused women in court for two decades and says VAWA is blind to the needs of victims who want abuse to stop, but dont want to permanently separate from their partners. As a movement, weve been ambivalent about these women, says Goodmark, author of the new book A Troubled Marriage: Domestic Violence and the Law . Coker and Goodmark are among a group of academics who advocate allowing some domestic violence victims to have options beyond just automatic arrests and prosecution of their abusers. These ideas include restorative justice, which focuses on repairing harm caused by violence, counseling services for victims and batterers, and orders of protection that might allow partners to still have contact.
This kind of advocacy makes lawyers like Dorchen Leidholdt, legal director for Sanctuary for Families, a New York City organization that provides legal and social services for domestic violence victims, nervous. I worry about sending the signal to law enforcement that domestic violence should be treated differently from other forms of crime, she says. Such an approach could turn back time, says Leidholdt, to the days when police officers responding to a domestic violence incident would merely tell a batterer to cool off and walk around the block.
Queens County, NY, where Leidholdt has represented domestic violence victims in court, has the highest domestic violence conviction rate of any borough in New York City. The head of the domestic violence unit in the district attorneys office there, Scott Kessler, prosecutes cases using many of the ideas embodied in VAWA. His unit receives about $325,000 a year in VAWA grant funding, which helps prosecutors build domestic violence cases without victim cooperation. Kessler says less than 25% of domestic violence victims cooperate in his cases, so he relies on evidence like 911 calls, digital photographs taken by police at the scene and recordings of telephone calls accused batterers in jail make to their victims in violation of protective orders. Its a chess match, says Kessler. I need to think one step ahead.
( MORE: Shaima Alawadis Murder: A Hate Crime Against Women? )
The current political fight over VAWA, while not centered on the law enforcement focus of the law, illustrates the difficulty of passing nuanced federal legislation that can target the specific needs of communities and victims. A 2013 reauthorization of VAWA, which passed with broad bipartisan support in the Senate, is stalled in the House in part because of Republican opposition to a new provision that would apply to Native American victims of rape and domestic violence. (Other contentious provisions would apply to gay, transgender and immigrant victims.) The Senate version, which the House may soon pass , would allow tribal courts to try non-Native alleged abusers and rapists, which some Republicans say is unconstitutional. The needs of Native American women, who experience rape and domestic violence at rates much higher than the general population, are not met by VAWA in its current form, according to those who support the tribal courts provision.
Other communities may also be left behind or even harmed by VAWA. Richie, the University of Illinois professor, has written extensively about how law enforcement affects communities of color and says economic empowerment might do far more to curb domestic violence in poor black neighborhoods than the policies in VAWA. When it becomes the only thing we do and it takes so much lobbying and research attention, it does harm other strategies, says Richie.
Kim Gandy, president and CEO of the National Network to End Domestic Violence, which is lobbying hard to reauthorize VAWA, says its clear why the legislation focuses so squarely on law enforcement. VAWA was originally part of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994, one of a series of tough on crime laws enacted in the 1990s when the violent crime rate in the U.S. was four times higher than it is now. Were lucky its got something beyond law enforcement money, says Gandy, a former prosecutor. Every year, more than $100 million in VAWA funding is devoted to non-law enforcement priorities, including transitional housing, special assistance for victims in rural communities and the disabled, and civil legal assistance. Were not looking to shift money from law enforcement to services, says Gandy. Were just looking for more money for both.

some significant comments :
1)
lynnig
Two months ago my husband and I (married 22 yrs) had an "animated argument". Im not proud of it, there was screaming and yelling, objects were thrown down stairs. Neither of us physically or verbally threatened each other. My 16 yr old son was upset. He never saw us behave this way. He called 911. I was ashamed and mortified having the police come to our house. I was crying, but I assured the police there was no abuse. The way this law works, It was assumed I was lying because I am afraid of my husband. My husband taken off to jail in handcuffs, I asked how I can bail him out, no I cant do anything. He gets his name in the local papers, Now we are paying thousands of dollars in legal fees. I can assure you, I am not a victim.
I take responsibility for our horrible behavior that made my son call 911. I am deeply ashamed of that, and we apologized to my son. I am a nurse, I understand the reason behind this law, but if this can happen to me, how many other innocent people are dragged into this net? What if my husband and I were going through an acrimonious split. His wrongful arrest would give ridiculous advantage to his partner.
Maybe my nightmare is just an isolated freak by product of this law. But my opinion has changed. I think there is huge business being generated by this law. Very disillusioned!
2)
MarkGraebner
The very name of the law screams unconstitutional, violating the (14th) equal protection under the law amendment.
3)
cycleracer
As a male victim of domestic violence I find the title of this bill, and this article by Time, to be disgusting and bigoted. The article did, however, get one thing right: that there is a problem with under reporting of domestic violence. The reason for this is because male victims face the risk of losing their children, their house, and everything they have worked their entire life for to their abuser, who will simply use America's male-hating family courts as a weapon for further abuse. It is sad that the act cannot be provided with a gender-neutral name and provisions to ensure that the application is gender-neutral as well. Whatever happened to "equal protection under the law"? One would have thought that America moved passed such bigotry long ago, but apparently not. The only thing that has changed is the class of victims - the hatred remains the same.
In general, the law in most states is that if the police are called, SOMEONE IS GOING TO JAIL.
A lot of the problem in these cases is that more LEOs are injured or killed responding to domestic violence cases than in any other type. And they have faced a ton of negative feedback from the general public in the past because they would respond to a dv call, the people involved would calm down when they arrived and say everything was good, and when they left it would escalate again with one of them, usually the female, ending up seriously injured or dead.
I'm sorry for what happened to you but it may have not been up to their discretion as to whether or not someone was arrested and taken in. Don't know the particulars of your state, but as I said, in some states, there is no choice for them... it's protocol.
Apparently you are taking the comments I copied from the Time article as originating from me . I have not been involved in such an incident . My point in quoting those comments was to explain my title as to the legislation of spontaneity . That is the unintended side effect to this law IMO .
What that proves is that you can't legislate behavior by force . You can only suppress behavior temporarily . Thanks for your observations .
You haven't been whipping the wife have you Petey?
That is , in effect , what this law implies . The male is guilty until proven innocent . Perhaps a better name for it would be the : Have You Stopped Beating Your Wife Yet Act . HYSBYWYA !
Jim thinks you beat your wife. LOL
......you don't, do you?
That guy right there is in some serious trouble . If he fights back the law will get him . If he doesn't she will . His only hope is escape . Do they have shelters for battered men ... hell no .
I have never seen a shelter for battered men and you are correct that there ARE battered men. It is a subject that I have never seen addressed except one or twice in a "movie of the week" on A&E.
On the subject of battered women, when their only recourse is to run to a shelter with their children, leaving the abusive husband in the comfortable home with all the amenities and the court telling them they cannot remove the husband from the home, they see themselves between the old rock and hard place and elect to go back thinking that if they just try harder to "be good" it will be okay.
And those of us on the outside looking in shake our heads from our smug positions and tell ourselves we just don't understand why she puts up with it and oh, well, if she won't help herself it's all on her.
When she is finally fed up or reaches that point where she feels her life is in real danger or the lives of her children are in danger she kills the SOB and the cops give her a hard stare and say, "Hey, lady, you could have just walked out, ya' know?" And she goes away for capital murder.
And the holier-than-thou politicians sit on their cushy asses and don't want to pass any legislation that would give these women and children any viable means to help them get on their feet with a start at a new life, any training at a new vocation in this fast-moving world, and call them a drain on society.
We should just shoot them, send their male children off to military schools and their female children off to work as maids in the service industry.... oh, wait, we have underpaid illegals to do that... just sell the female children off into prostitution, there are always openings for that job.
I did not write this article to belittle the very real plight many women find themselves in . There is no doubt much damage is done to many women by the men they live with . Still I think the unintended consequences that the VAWA causes are issues that need to be examined & thought about . Women are being hurt by this law by having the law step in & declare their men guilty when no crime has even been committed [see the 1st comment I left ] .
Frequently the results are that she is not even arrested . If there were signs of violence on her person then that is usually declared a case of self defense .