Blacks Must Confront Reality
Though racial discrimination exists, it is nowhere near the barrier it once was. The relevant question is: How much of what we see today can be explained by racial discrimination? This is an important question because if we conclude that racial discrimination is the major cause of black problems when it isnt, then effective solutions will be elusive forever. To begin to get a handle on the answer, lets pull up a few historical facts about black Americans.
In 1950, female-headed households were 18 percent of the black population. Today its close to 70 percent. One study of 19th-century slave families found that in up to three-fourths of the families, all the children lived with the biological mother and father. In 1925 New York City, 85 percent of black households were two-parent households. Herbert Gutman, author of The Black Family in Slavery and Freedom, 1750-1925, reports, Five in sixchildren under the age of six lived with both parents. Also, both during slavery and as late as 1920, a teenage girl raising a child without a man present was rare among blacks.
A study of 1880 family structure in Philadelphia found that three-quarters of black families were nuclear families (composed of two parents and children). What is significant, given todays arguments that slavery and discrimination decimated the black family structure, is the fact that years ago, there were only slight differences in family structure among racial groups.
Coupled with the dramatic breakdown in the black family structure has been an astonishing growth in the rate of illegitimacy. The black illegitimacy rate in 1940 was about 14 percent; black illegitimacy today is over 70 percent, and in some cities, it is over 80 percent.
The point of bringing up these historical facts is to ask this question, with a bit of sarcasm: Is the reason the black family was far healthier in the late 1800s and 1900s that back then there was far less racial discrimination and there were greater opportunities? Or did what experts call the legacy of slavery wait several generations to victimize todays blacks?
The Census Bureau pegs the poverty rate among blacks at 28.1 percent.
A statistic that one never hears about is that the poverty rate among intact married black families has been in the single digits for more than two decades, currently at 8.4 percent. Weak family structures not only spell povertyand dependency but also contribute to the social pathology seen in many black communities for example, violence and predatory sex. Each year, roughly 7,000 blacks are murdered. Ninety-four percent of the time, the murderer is another black person. Though blacks are 13 percent of the nations population, they account for more than 50 percent of homicide victims. Nationally, the black homicide victimization rate is six times that of whites, and in some cities, its 22 times that of whites. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, between 1976 and 2011, there were 279,384 black murder victims. Coupled with being most of the nations homicide victims, blacks are also major victims of violent personal crimes, such as assault, rape and robbery.
To put this violence in perspective, black fatalities during the Korean War (3,075), Vietnam War (7,243) and all wars since 1980 (about 8,200) come to about 18,500, a number that pales in comparison with black loss of life at home. Young black males had a greater chance of reaching maturity on the battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan than on the streets of Philadelphia, Chicago, Detroit, Oakland, Newark and other cities.
The black academic achievement gap is a disaster. Often, black 12th-graders can read, write and deal with scientific and math problems at only the level of white sixth-graders. This doesnt bode well for success in college or passing civil service exams.
If it is assumed that problems that have a devastating impact on black well-being are a result of racial discrimination and a legacy of slavery when they are not, resources spent pursuing a civil rights strategy will yield disappointing results.
The Best of Walter E. Williams
Walter E. Williams is the John M. Olin distinguished professor of economics at George Mason University, and a nationally syndicated columnist. To find out more about Walter E. Williams and read features by other Creators Syndicate columnists and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate web page .

You make some good points John, but, I would like to add this, if I may.
Anyone not white in today's society is seen as "the other". 'Member the elderly Asian man who was beat to death in NYC for "jaywalking". There are many stories of abuse and murders of Hispanics, Asians (specifically Vietnamese in Louisianna, Mississippi, and Alabama fishing industries) and Native Americans - because they "don't belong".
Sure, there are some serious issues within the Black community, but the largest issue, IMO, is within the vastly White/non-ethnic community for not being able to accept all people as equals - which we are.
While you're looking, set your sights on Detroit, Philly, San Francisco, New York, Kansas City, Los Angeles, New Orleans, Atlanta - nice try. The cities mentioned need to also be looked at for their inner city issues - the inner cities with a vast majority of Blacks with no leadership and no families (read the article flame). Whites did not put those folks in the inner city - many of them chose to move there 'cause it was/is the only place where they can be/are accepted for who/what they are - "the other". BUT, those in the inner city are, for the most part, the cause of the damage done to the rest of those living there. Why is that? Do they consider those living in the inner cities as "the other" even though they are also of the same ethnicity, living in the same conditions?
Think back to your question on anthropology flame - perfect example.
Yeah, in my world there is very little, if any, gray - it is all straight-forward based on cause and effect. Again, in my world, it has to be. There are reasons for everything - we just have to take the time to find the reason which may, then, present a possible solution.
Nope - just loopholes - big loopholes
The current President of the United States is a "Black" who has "Confronted Reality."
The prototypical racist will describe his ideal "Black Man" as a "clean cut, crime-free, hard-working-non-welfare-recipient, drug-free, husband and responsible father and member of his community."
But the haters/bigots/racists relentlessly and conveniently criticize and piss on all that President Obama says, does or advocates demonstrating both their bullshit values and hypocrisy.
As for Walter E. Williams
Conservatives support blacks who are, you know, conservative. They don't support liberal blacks. Funny how that works. Ask bill Clinton if white conservatives gave him a pass because he is white.
And even more racist to oppose him for the same reason.
Conservative disdain for a failed liberal president, black or white, is the result one would expect in a color blind world.
I made no such argument; I merely illustrated the talking-out-of-both-sides-of-the-conservative-mouth aspect of pretending to be objective and open-minded while being subjective and close-minded.
The shit began before Obama's inauguration.
It's one thing to support outright or reject outright but quite another to create straw men and foist them as realities.
"Failed liberal president?"
Another pronouncement.
Pretending to be serious and objective while playing to the Limbaugh crowd is not being "successful."
It's playing to extremists, haters and zeal-without-knowledge willing dupes.
Relying on the posts in this thread, it is apparent, to me, that Bush was disliked because he was White, Charles Curtis because he was Kaw Indian. In other words, they belonged to "the other", not based on their performance or activities or actions or results.
Sad.
Obstructionist? How so?
Now this is obstructionism.
I believe you have ironically, describe your ilk via projection.
Advocating economic fairness, employment fairness, an end to disproportionate traffic stops of blacks by white police officers, an end todisproportionatevarious arrests and convictions of blacks, to racist-politically motivated gerrymandering, an end to bullshit voter ID (suppression) laws in red states, toInstitutional racism if that's being a "savior," one expecting something in return, then you could be THE PROBLEM.
That's nutty. Seriously Ignorant stuff. Racism predates the united states by thousand of years. Read Tacitus or open any book on ancient Chinese history. Moreover, the concept of the "other" is innate to human nature and as old as humanity. Any anthropology textbook will demonstrate the concept.
The idea that America created these concepts is just pure ridiculousness. It's propaganda for the ignorant,and poor propaganda at that.
What nonsense ! (;~ P
Regardless of WHEN racism becomes part of a culture/society, it invariably is part of the "justification/validation/rationalization" of slave-owners who establish a societal hierarchy within which they place themselves at the very top.
Below any so-called "human being" who experiences no moral, ethical, religious, nor any other humanistic disdain regarding the enslavement of others, are in fact those categorized as "THE OTHERS" -- "the permanent underclass, the lower class, the inferior class."
"Obama he's not really one of us, born in Kenya," hehates white people," "he doesn't love America," -- shall I post the videos, the signs, the cartoons, the haters circle-jerk?
SHALL I?
Only a racist would deny the existence of institutionalized racism.
The other?? Simple - even for you - but there was a hidden point that you totally ignored.
No problem.
Not belaboring any of your comment A. Mac, but, only an idiot would think that the U.S. invented racism - which appears to be a very prevalent thought in NT.
Only a racist would deny the level of black self-hatred in the US .
A moron often makes comments with no reference to who he is talking to . Also morons commonly quote 2 different sources w/o distinguishing who said what .
Well done ... in IDing yourself !
Flame ,
I think any misrepresentation of destructive tendencies to conceal the status quo is racism . Semantics is not the issue .
JR knows what racism used to mean . Today's racism ? Not so much .
So ... you're saying you don't accept Darwin ?
That's absurd . Sociology is a highly unmathematical topic . Since most of the sociologists have a strong liberal bias so do their daffynitions . Those are designed to reinforce victimology and not to uncover any underlying truth .
For example when a white kills a black it is automatically declared to be racism even if it was justified and legal .
But when a black kills a white ... it is never racism BY DEFINITION ! Eg :
Apparently you are not going to answer my question . That would make you a propagandist.
"Racism is bigotry written into laws and enforced by societal authorities"
Its shows how desperate you are that you have to redefine the word in a desperate attempt to piece together a bullshit argument. Even with your mangling of theEnglishlanguage, youfail.
Ancientsocieties, like theAthenians, were obsessed withmaintainingracial purity. You need to read more if this surprises you. Classical authors, both Greek and Roman, believed that intermarriagemeantsocietal degeneration. Tacitus admired the Germans strength and vitality and attributed in large part because " they were not mixed with other people through intermarriage or intercourse."
Accordingly, under Athenian law Athenian citizens had to be the offspring of two citizens tokeep the purity of the Athenian's lineage.There you have it, even under your silly definition, an example of a law from 2,500 years ago based on racism.
You haven't got the ability to even understand the material you post let alone discuss it . In fact all you've got is ad hominem attacks ... one trick pony .
Not even. I didn't like Bush because he was a terrible president in my opinion, but I was much younger then and fooled much easier. If I was as old as I am now I would have hated him, probably.
Clearly you have misstated what happened in Iraq . That part of the world is full of violent attacks on civilians . That 100 K would have died with or without US intervention . Look at what is happening there now . The US is not even involved but ISIL is busily killing Iraqis .
Still delusional I see ...
You are starting to talk completely irrationally . Is there anyone who knows what that meant ? I haven't a clue ...
Racism, IMO, is not an "invention," rather a societal and social phenomenon a state of mind and resultant practices arising from the insidious delusions of those who cannot deal rationally with the inherent insecurities of reality.
To create the illusion of "being in control," "humans" have indeed invented fantasy-world institutions like organized religion which, in-and-of-itself is a form of "racism" known as "ethnocentrism."
The extreme of racism, religionism and ethnocentrism is genocide -- the most extreme examples of which are perpetrated by government and hate groups!
Elected officials who pander subtly or overtly to individuals and entities that derive their senses of superiority, NOT ON ACCOMPLISHMENT OR MERIT, BUT ON SOME PSYCHOTIC HIERARCHICAL BULLSHIT are a large part of the problem.
And then there are the Dathans
Institutionalized Racism IS INDEED BIGOTRY WRITTEN INTO LAW AND/OR THE WILLFUL FAILURE OF GOVERNMENT TO WRITE LAWS THAT PREVENT OR ABOLISH IT!
"Racism exists when one ethnic group or historical collectivity dominates, excludes, or seeks to eliminate another on the basis of differences that it believes are hereditary and unalterable. An ideological basis for explicit racism came to a unique fruition in the West during the modern period. No clear and unequivocal evidence of racism has been found in other cultures or in Europe before the Middle Ages. The identification of the Jews with the devil and witchcraft in the popular mind of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries was perhaps the first sign of a racist view of the world. Official sanction for such attitudes came in sixteenth century Spain when Jews who had converted to Christianity and their descendents became the victims of a pattern of discrimination and exclusion."
"Race is a significant social issue because people use racial differences as the basis for discrimination. Much of today's racism can be traced to the era of colonialism that began in the 1400s. When Europeans began colonizing Africa and the Americas, the white settlers adopted the idea that they were superior to the other races they encountered and it was their job to "civilize the savages." This false notion became known as "the white man's burden," and was used to justify the Europeans' taking land and enslaving people. In this way, naturally-occurring racial differences became the basis for systems of exploitation and discrimination."
Holocaust denial, science denial, racism-denial, etc. politically-motivated, economically-expedient and/or religionist-motivated IT'S FASCINATING AND QUITE PREDICTABLE THAT THE VARIOUS DENIERS OF INCONVENIENT TRUTHS GALVANIZE WITH EACH OTHER AND BECOME THE POLITICAL BASES OF PARTIES THAT PANDER TO THEIR UNDERLYING FEARS, IGNORANCE AND STUPIDITY.
Doesn't anyone wonder or ask why the slave traders in America didn't have any white slaves
or do we all just get it some acknowledging and some denying the obvious?
That's a fabricated mischaracterization; no one who ACTUALLY sympathizes, empathizes or otherwise addresses human indignities and works against them, does so selectively
unless it's someone who, every time a black kid gets killed by a cop or cop wannabe, makes the unfair accusation that those who are appalled by the on-going "open season on N_____S, "don't also care about black-on-black killing."
One life or a thousand taken without justification THEY ALL MATTER.
Fuck the straw man bullshit arguments!
Focus on the word "ACTUALLY."
And whose fault is that ongoing tension John? Those who didn't assimilate - those who did - those who cross the lines?
Sorry A. Mac - there were white slaves in the U. S. - many white slaves -
" Alexander Stewart was herded off the Gildart in July of 1747, bound with chains. Stewart was pushed onto the auction block in Wecomica, St Mary's County, Maryland. Doctor Stewart and his brother William were attending the auction, aware of Alexander being on that slave ship coming from Liverpool England. Doctor Stewart and William were residents of Annapolis and brothers to David of Ballachalun in Montieth, Scotland. The two brothers paid nine pound six shillings sterling to Mr. Benedict Callvert of Annapolis for the purchase of Alexander. He was a slave.
Alexander tells of the other 88 Scots sold into slavery that day in "The Lyon in Mourning" pages 242243. Jeremiah Howell was a lifetimeindentured servant by his uncle in Lewis County, Virginia in the early 1700's. His son, Jeremiah, won his freedom by fighting in the Revolution. There were hundreds of thousands of Scots sold into slavery during Colonial America. White slavery to the American Colonies occurred as early as 1630 in Scotland.
According to the Egerton manuscript, British Museum, the enactment of 1652: it may be lawful for two or more justices of the peace within any county, citty or towne, corporate belonging to the commonwealth to from tyme to tyme by warrant cause to be apprehended, seized on and detained all and every person or persons that shall be found begging and vagrant.. in any towne, parish or place to be conveyed into the Port of London, or unto any other port from where such person or persons may be shipped into a forraign collonie or plantation.
The judges of Edinburgh Scotland during the years 16621665 ordered the enslavement and shipment to the colonies a large number of rogues and others who made life unpleasant for the British upper class.
The above accounting sounds horrific but slavery was what the Scots have survived for a thousand years. The early ancestors of the Scots, Alba and Pics were enslaved as early as the first century BC. Varro, a Roman philosopher stated in his agricultural manuscripts that white slaves were only things with a voice or instrumenti vocali. Julius Caesar enslaves as many as one million whites from Gaul.
Pope Gregory in the sixth century first witnessed blonde hair, blue eyed boys awaiting sale in a Roman slave market. The Romans enslaved thousands of white inhabitants of Great Britain, who were also known as Angles. Pope Gregory was very interested in the looks of these boys therefore asking their origin. He was told they were Angles from Briton. Gregory stated, "Non Angli, sed Angeli." (Not Angles but Angels).
The eighth to the eleventh centuries proved to be very profitable for Rouen France. Rouen was the transfer point of Irish and Flemish slaves to the Arabian nations. The early centuries AD the Scottish were known as Irish. William Phillips on page 63 states that the major component of slave trade in the eleventh century were the Vikings. They spirited many 'Irish' to Spain, Scandinavia and Russia. Legends have it; some 'Irish' may have been taken as far as Constantinople. Ruth Mazo Karras wrote in her book, "Slavery and Society in Medeivel Scandinavia" pg. 49; Norwegian Vikings made slave raids not only against the Irish and Scots (who were often called Irish in Norse sources) but also against Norse settlers in Ireland or Scottish Isles or even in Norway itself slave trading was a major commercial activity of the Viking Age. The children of the White slaves in Iceland were routinely murdered en masse ."
Economic enslavement, unequal funding of schools, job discrimination those are manifestation of de facto enslavement and these are maintained by Republican legislators by virtue of how they vote, when they won't allow a vote and to whom thy pander!
This is why the "war on drugs" needs to stop. It's not really a war on drugs at all.
While a fact, these were sold into slavery as punishments for political reasons; they were not enslaved as a race per se.
King James II and Charles I also led a continued effort to enslave the Irish. Britains famed Oliver Cromwell furthered this practice of dehumanizing ones next door neighbor.
True, but responding to your statement that there weren't anywhite slaves . . . . .
You can rephrase a specious argument but that doesn't make it any less of one.
You're the one who tries to make the inane point that an individual can't view two situations simultaneously and understand the outrage associated with both and the need to address both.
The most dangerous neighborhoods in the world are perpetuated by design, not by their inhabitants, but by the power brokers who own the politicians who benefit from having a permanent underclass to pit against a struggling middle class.
That the inhabitants are in fact contributors to their own despair, is part of what the power brokers know in advance will occur, and, count on as being an exploitable manifestation of their insidious engineering and politicking.
And you, Robert G, are one of their advertiser and shills.
It is clear that you have no idea as to what else, other than the killings, takes place in the most dangerous neighborhoods in America. Not one f'n clue.
Myopia, profiling, demagouguery -- those are your "credentials" and the basis of your "expertise." Get your ass into those dangerous neighborhoods and meet the majority of those who live there -- there are lots of opportunities for faux-humanists like yourself to volunteer and help.
So, you are throwing in President Obama why? Your comment is off topic.
As for Walter Williams, what? Looks like he is an intellectual who teaches others.
Carter.....failed Democrat President. Has nothing to do with color. Same with our current President.
You're correct; my bad for failing to make the distinction.
So, lets reverse this a little:
It is absolutely not racist to oppose Barack Obama just because he's black.
Based on your logic, this is also a true statement.
I disagree with your thoughts on this.That's not what the Liberals on this site have been saying for the past, oh how many years now?
I find it preferable to be confused "again" as opposed to being perpetually so Robert G.
Not naming anyone in particular, but if the shoe fits
take it out of your mouth.
A. Mac's sudden diatribe about President Bush.
Only if you fail to understand why Williams is praised by the same conservatives who condemn Obama as "not loving America."
My comment is precise and clear.
Appearing in the stead of the Rush Limbaughs of the media makes him, not a teacher, rather an opportunist.
Were Williams to castigate blacks in politically-neutral venues, then I'd agree with you. But
Ayn Rand's views hardly work for people who are legislated into underclass status.
I don't recall mentioning President Bush. I'm gettin' old so if you can cite where I did that, I'd like to know.
I guess then that being called slaves by their owners just didn't make them slaves, right?
You're talking two different ballgames flame. The white "slaves" couldn't buy their way out either.
But if/when they got out and if they were given citizenship, the once white-slaves didn't have to go through this racist bullshit.
1867
1866 Civil Rights Act of 1866 grants citizenship, but not the right to vote, to all native-born Americans.
1896
Louisiana passes "grandfather clauses" to keep former slaves and their descendants from voting. As a result, registered black voters drops from 44.8%...
1964
Poll taxes are outlawed with the adoption of the 24th Amendment.
1965
President Lyndon B. Johnson signs the Voting Rights Act into law, permanently barring barriers to political participation by racial and ethnic minorities, prohibiting any election practice that denies the right to vote on account of race... (Video)
1970
President Richard Nixon signed an extension of the Voting Rights Act.
Nixon: "The Voting Rights Act of 1965 has opened participation in the political process."
1975
President Gerald Ford signed an extension of the Voting Rights Act.
1990
Due, in part, to the enforcement of the Voting Rights Act, the number of black elected officials in Georgia grows to 495 in 1990 from just three prior to the VRA.
2010 to Present
Since 2010 alone, the Department of Justice has had 18 Section 5 objections to voting laws in Texas, South Carolina, Georgia, North Carolina, Mississippi and Louisiana. (video)
2011
Restrictions to voting passed in South Carolina, Texas and Florida are found to disproportionately impact minority voters. (Video)
2011
Texas passed one of the nation's most restrictive voter ID laws. Under the VRA, the state was required to submit the law to DOJ or... (more)
2011
South Carolina passed a restrictive voter ID law that would keep more than 180,000 African Americans from casting a ballot. (more)
2014
In January 2014, a bipartisan group of legislators in Congress took the first step toward developing a new formula and modernizing the Voting Rights Act. (more)
1869
Congress passes the Fifteenth Amendment giving African American men the right to vote.
1940
Only 3% of eligible African Americans in the South are registered to vote.
Jim Crow laws like literacy tests and poll taxes were meant to keep African Americans from voting.
1965
More than 500 non-violent civil rights marchers are attacked by law enforcement officers while attempting to march from Selma to Montgomery, Alabama to demand the need for African American voting rights.
1965
By the end of 1965, 250,000 new black voters are registered, one third of them by federal examiners.
1972
Barbara Jordan of Houston and Andrew Young of Atlanta become the first African Americans elected to Congress from the South since Reconstruction. (Video)
1982
President Ronald Reagan signed a 25-year extension of the Voting Rights Act.
2006
Congress extended Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act for an additional 25 years.
2011
A record number of restrictions to voting were introduced in state legislatures nationwide, including photo ID requirements... (more)
2011
Florida passed a law that restricts voter registration and made cuts to early voting. The majority of African Americans in Florida... (more)
2011
Under the VRA, the DOJ blocked South Carolina's voter ID law, saying it discriminates against minority voters... (more)
2013
2013 Shelby v. Holder at the Supreme Court. (more)
Impressive - old, but impressive.
Now, how 'bout throwing up the same collauge of the Indian "racist" bullsh*t. Betcha it'd be one helluva lot longer
When I address racism, voter discrimination, institutionalized racism, disenfranchisement based upon race and all that goes with it, you can assume I include Native Americans among the victims.
Thank you A. Mac.
Very few on this thread will really pay attention to the information you posted - sadly. We will even "probably" have a few comment with their snitty, shoddy remarks.
But of the greatest import, to me and to many others, is the primary statement posted - "
Discrimination against Native Americans is the longest held racism in the United States ."
Having not lived it, they can't truly talk of or to the subject. Which confuses me - since they are not Black/Yellow/Brown/Red, how can they go on and on and on and on about what racism is and how it impacts people. As another old saying goes "Don't tell how bad it is until you have walked a mile in my moccasins".
Thanks my friend.
Sorry flame - I really don't have the time nor fortitude to continually "Prove" my comments to you. You are wrong - in a very big way - Indentured servitude was a labour system whereby young people paid for their passage to the New World by working for an employer for a certain number of years. It was widely employed in the 18th century in the British colonies in North America and elsewhere. It was especially used as a way for poor youth in Britain and the German states to get passage to the American colonies. They would work for a fixed number of years, then be free to work on their own. The employer purchased the indenture from the sea captain who brought the youths over; he did so because he needed labour. Some worked as farmers or helpers for farm wives, some were apprenticed to craftsmen. Both sides were legally obligated to meet the terms, which were enforced by local American courts. Runaways were sought out and returned. About half of the white immigrants to the American colonies in the 17th and 18th centuries were indentured. During the late 17th and early 18th centuries poor children from England and France were kidnapped and sold into indentured labor in the Caribbean for a minimum of five years, but most times their contracts were bought and sold repeatedly and some laborers never attained their freedom .
What is slavery- A person who is wholly subject to the will of another; one who has no freedom of action, but whose person and services are wholly under the control of another. Webster. One who Is under the power of a master, and who belongs to him ; so that the master may sell and dispose of his person, of his industry, and of his labor, without his being able to do anything, have anything, or acquire anything, but what must belong to his master.
There is a difference - a huge difference.
You did know that Native Americans were both slaves and indentured servants - ina very big way.
Sorry I didn't post the links that you would've liked, but my "research" was also carefully sought.
So, when you can accept others information without the FANATIC urge to discredited them, let me know.
Guess Black's Law Dictionary and WestLaw are good enough "sources" for you?
I gave you two quotes - one from Blacks (slavery) and one from WestLaw (indentured servitude).
Unfortunately, they've got wwwwaaaaayyyyyyyyy too much information to do a one paragraph summation properly.
BTW - started classes last night - Tue, Wed, Thur - so my responses here will be a bunch shorter 'cause we've got so dammm many research projects to turn in - sux man - sux.