An Insider's Guide to the Gaza War - Matti Friedman (Tablet)
An Insider's Guide to the Gaza War
- The way the Gaza war has been described and responded to abroad has laid bare the resurgence of an old, twisted pattern of thought - namely, a hostile obsession with Jews. News organizations believe Israel to be the most important story on earth, or very close.
- If you follow mainstream coverage, you will find nearly no real analysis of Palestinian society or ideologies, profiles of armed Palestinian groups, or investigation of Palestinian government. The West has decided that Palestinians should want a state alongside Israel, so that opinion is attributed to them as fact, though anyone who has spent time with actual Palestinians understands that things are more complicated.
- Every flaw in Israeli society is aggressively reported. In one seven-week period (Nov. 8 to Dec. 16, 2011), I counted 27 separate AP articles, an average of a story every two days, on the various moral failings of Israeli society - a tally higher than the total number of critical stories about Palestinian government and society that our bureau had published in the preceding three years.
- Any veteran of the press corps here knows that Hamas intimidation of reporters is real. As an editor on the AP news desk during the 2008-2009 Gaza fighting, I personally erased a key detail - that Hamas fighters were dressed as civilians and being counted as civilians in the death toll - because of a threat to our reporter in Gaza. The policy remains not to inform readers that a story is censored unless the censorship is Israeli.
- The fact is that Hamas intimidation is largely beside the point because the actions of Palestinians are beside the point: Most reporters in Gaza believe their job is to document violence directed by Israel at Palestinian civilians. Many of the people deciding what you will read and see from here view their role not as explanatory but as political. Coverage is a weapon to be placed at the disposal of the side they like.
- The land that Israel controls consists of the 0.2% of the Arab world in which Jews are a majority and Arabs a minority. The conflict is more accurately described as "Jewish-Arab" - a conflict between the 6 million Jews of Israel and 300 million Arabs in surrounding countries (or, more broadly, 1 billion Muslims worldwide). Yet the "Israeli-Palestinian" framing of the story allows the Jews to be depicted as the stronger party.
- When journalists cover the Jews' war as more worthy of attention than any other, when they portray the Jews of Israel as the party obviously in the wrong, when they omit all possible justifications for the Jews' actions and obscure the true face of their enemies, international press coverage has become a morality play starring a familiar villain.
The writer was a reporter and editor in the Jerusalem bureau of the Associated Press (2006-2011).

Thanks for your thoughtful response to the summary though much of it evidently passed you by. You can read the full article by clicking on the title within the text.
Obviously Arab civilians are suffering from the Israel response to thousands of rockets. But what would be YOUR response if you were in charge? None?
Of course the summary is about press coverage, not strategy. But it reveals things not reported from Gaza because of the tight clamp Hamas has on reporters.
The war is not about land so much as religion: "namely, a hostileobsession with Jews."
In the news "you will find nearly no real analysis ofPalestinian society or ideologies, profiles of armed Palestinian groups,or investigation of Palestinian government." Your "analysis," though not surprising,is your own and not conveyed in the news. The point is that the news from Gaza is skewed to serve Hamas and your analysis reflects this skewing. Here is a sumary of a Forbes article on the subject:
Journalists working for American news outlets have "become part of the Hamas war machine" in the ongoing war in Gaza, notes Gary Weiss,one of the world's top business investigative reporters. On Aug. 11, thenormally Israel-averse Foreign Press Association in Israel condemned theterrorist group for "the blatant, incessant, forceful and unorthodoxmethods employed by the Hamas authorities and their representatives against visiting international journalists in Gaza over the past month."
Since the war began on July 8, so much of the Westerncoverage has been predictably skewed against Israel - through those time-honored journalism tools of sloppy and lazy reporting, superficiality, nuance, omission, lack of historical knowledge, or flat-out agenda-drivenlies and bias. "We're talking about journalism that functions as a tool of a terrorist organization, Hamas: breathlessly pushing its narrative, whether cowed by its threats, sympathetic to its cause, or simply ignorant," says Weiss.
This epidemic of journalistic malpractice is contributing tothe pain and loss of life that Palestinians in Gaza are suffering - as ithelps to empower Hamas. In turn, this no doubt helps spread oil on therising and frightening anti-Semitism we're seeing in Europe and elsewhere.
The arithmetic of civilian casualties in Gaza is one of the principal media crimes in this war. Major Western journalists routinely swallowed the huge civilian- casualty figures dished out to them by Gaza's Ministry of Health, a bureaucratic arm of a terrorist group that was shownto have lied about such figures in past wars. In some cases, reporters cite numbers instead from the UN, which gets its numbers from - surprise - the Hamas ministry. ( Forbes )
Other facts from the seed:
Flame, your message not only ignored the seed but, worse, it bought into all the false and prejudicial reporting discussed therein. IOW, you are a successful object of the malicious reporting.
Thank you again for all the effort.
You are giving Hamas too much credit for deception. They are straight arrows and don't fool around. You can find their unwavering goals in their charter andcovenant that include the following:
Flame; did you see my last message to you?
Actually, everyone could learn an important point from it.
Most of the seeds are opinion. The writer (The seed is a summary.) was a reporter and editor in the Jerusalem bureau of the Associated Press for five years(2006-2011); the Associated Press, not Fox News.
He is not writing about YOU as being obsessed but rather Israel's neighbors and the media. Based on all the articles about Israel, and considering all that is going on in the world, isn't this obvious?
Secondly, if you read the article (as well as my last message to Flameaway) you would be aware of the charge that the Gaza casualty figures are unverified but are fed the press by Hamas. Do you understand what this means? Do you realize that Hamas is playing for world sympathy to an antisemitic press who is only too happy to run with the lies?
Thirdly, and this is most important, in my last message to Flameaway, I presented many clauses from the Hamas charter and covenant. This is FACT, not opinion . You should read it when considering all the noise about "negotiating a two-state solution," and to become aware of what Israel is up against. Samples:
I hope this sheds some light on the matter.
And it never changes which is why all this bullcrap being posted about how Israel should slack off in consideration of civilians and allow the terrorists there to kill them just to show the world the "humanity" of the Israelis is stupid, and you can't fix stupid.
They are alive, and it beats the alternative which is certain death.
Dead babies make for great photo-ops ...
"Mass killing?" 200,000 Muslims have been killed in Syria by other Muslims. THAT is mass killing. Surely you know that Israel leans over backwards to avoid collateral damage by warning the human shields to leave targeted locations. Israel has avoided bombing high-rise buildings till this week.
I asked you before, with no response: What would YOU do if you were Netanyahu and were having your civilians bombarded with tens of thousands of missiles?
Do you know what moral equivalence means? If I had to give an example, your comment above is it. You equate the defendingvictim with the aggressor.
Again, what would you do if you were in charge of a nation being bombarded by its neighbor?
Whiskey-Tango-Foxtrot Flame!
What have I told you about that positive attitude of yours flame.....!
It doesn't belong here on NT.
The difference between ethics and morals is subtle but, if you prefer, you exhibit ethical equivalence. Someone who kills in self defense is not ethically deficient as was the would-be murderer. Same for nations.
It is working just great.
This carton is what it's all about.