They Lost, The World Moves On
What can be done about the American Indians, other native groups, and any group that laments it's displacement from a place that once was "theirs" ?
One theory is that nothing can be done.
They Lost, The World Moves On
Throughout human history one group displaces another , and the 'stronger' survives when cultures and tribal groups clash. Is this objectively lamentable? It can only be a matter of opinon. I had a family member who used to say , about once a week or so ,"it depends on whose ox is being gored", a folk saying about what is "fair". History is not "fair", it just is. The time for "fairness" is while something is happening, not in retrospect. Of course, some sort of "reparations" are always possible, but don't often happen because it isn't "fair" to make the children pay for the sins of the father.
There is a current discussion on NT that is somewhat about the above, and will no doubt end without any conclusion having been reached or consensus made. Liberals tend to believe past injustices should be redressed and conservatives generally think
They Lost, and The World Moves On
so, in other reading this morning I came across this article, and I think it is a companion piece. "White America" is about to lose to inevitable historical and demographic trends. The "loss" is occurring in slow motion every day. As it becomes more and more apparent , in increments, the outcry from the "victims" is more and more.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/joe-seldner/donald-trump-supporters_b_8055186.html
the bad news for this crowd: it is your last hurrah.
I am old and white (well, not old, but old enough to squirm in embarrassment when Hillary Clinton, the unhippest human in public life makes reference to Snapchat). And I get angry now and then.
But I don't get angry about immigration, legal or otherwise, or about women in power, or about people with Asian or Spanish accents trying to make lives for themselves or their families in the United States.
This is, old angry people, the future of America. You can rage against it and try to build fences and you may win in the very short run.
But in the long run, you will lose.
The numbers tell the story, and even if a fence could be built (it can't) or Donald says he can round up 11 million people and put them on buses headed south (he can't), the country is changing. Whether that is for the better or worse, it is an unstoppable development.
So fight it and be seen as the xenophobes you may well be, or embrace it - or at least accept it - and participate in the change.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/james-zogby/obama-won-so-did-netanyah_b_8091984.html
One day, in the not so distant future, whites will be a minority group in America. One day, with the rising and inevitable mixed race population, whites will be a tiny minority in the United States.
Because of income inequality and automation, America will become much more of a "welfare state" than it is today.
Will it have been "fair" ?

John - you've actually addressed two separate issues here - force of taking and loss due to population changes over time. Going to be some really interesting discussion - looking forward to them/it.
One day, it will be said to the few remaining whites , "get over it".
It is not either wrong or right, it's just the way the world went.
"It depends on whose ox is being gored"
( I am not saying that it wasn't wrong for the Europeans to break treaties with the Indians, and commit a defacto genocide against them, but rather that it is the way of the world and similar things have happened everywhere, throughout history.)
everyone with money is
when everything is automated, and all the created wealth is going to the top, what else do you think is going to happen ?
lol