Pelosi’s home city exempted from water restrictions imposed on rural farmers
The Endangered Species Act has wreaked havoc for decades on rural communities, but a newly filed lawsuit could force San Francisco urbanites like House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi to share their pain.
A federal complaint filed this week contends that the Hetch Hetchy Project, which supplies water to San Francisco and the Bay Area, has unfairly enjoyed an exemption from the severe cutbacks required in rural California in order to save endangered fish species.
Craig Manson , who heads the Center for Environmental Science, Accuracy and Reliability (CESAR) in Fresno, said the lawsuit is aimed at addressing the double standard that forces farmers to give up water in the name of species conservation without requiring Bay Area residents to do the same.
Mr. Manson wants the National Park Service to press the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to end the special exemption from the Endangered Species Act (ESA), but the Park Service just wont do it.
Why not? Jeffrey Olson, National Park Service spokesman, said the agency cannot comment on ongoing litigation, but critics point out that San Joaquin Valley farmers have nowhere near the political clout of San Francisco s political leadership, which includes Mrs. Pelosi and a good chunk of the states dominant liberal power structure.
I think the law is being subjectively applied, said Aubrey Bettencourt, executive director of the California Water Alliance. California is a tale of two cities. If you added all the agrarian counties of California together in terms of registered voters, thats not even enough to offset either San Francisco or Los Angeles. There are not enough votes.
The Hetch Hetchy Project at Yosemite National Park diverts water from the Tuolumne River dam to a pipeline that sends water 167 miles away to San Francisco . Without that diversion, about 15 percent more water would flow to the Sacramento Delta, which is critical habitat for threatened fish like the delta smelt, the green sturgeon and several species of salmon, according to the lawsuit.
The Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries Service have ordered severe cutbacks in the amount of water provided to the Central Valley in order to protect the fish habitat, says the lawsuit, but those agencies have required no such cutbacks for the Hetch Hetchy Project diversions because [the] defendants have never initiated the statutorily required ESA consultations.
San Francisco residents may be some of the nations most ardent defenders of the environment and endangered species, but theyve also resisted for decades calls from environmentalists to drain the Hetch Hetchy reservoir, which provides 85 percent of the citys water.
San Francisco is politically powerful in California, and they have been able to fend off Hetch Hetchy lovers for years, said Mr. Manson . If that valley, the Hetch Hetchy Valley, were anyplace else, it would not have been flooded in the first place. It just goes to show people are wedded to their own interests even if it goes against their philosophical leanings.
While environmentalists have long pushed to drain the Hetch Hetchy reservoir, theyre not exactly embracing the lawsuit. Kieran Suckling, executive director of the Center for Biological Diversity, accused CESAR of attempting to provide more water for Big Ag.
A former Department of the Interior assistant secretary under President George W. Bush, Mr. Manson serves as general counsel for the Westlands Water District, which serves agriculture customers in Fresno and Kings counties.
The goal is not to provide more water for fish, the goal is to provide more water for Westlands, Mr. Suckling contended.
Mr. Manson stressed that Westlands is not involved in the lawsuit and in fact may think it imprudent.
His nonprofit is dedicated to supporting scientific research with an emphasis on ensuring absolute rigor and complete transparency, rather than a focus on outcome.
Hes also focused on ensuring that rural Americans arent the only ones forced to bear the costs of federal environmental regulations. The groups mission also calls for consistent application of these statutes throughout all industries and all sectors.
Mr. Suckling accused CESAR of trying to turn urban areas against the environment by playing the water card in the midst of a drought. San Francisco leads the state in water conservation, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
But Mr. Manson argued that cities shouldnt be exempt from species-conservation mandates.
There seems to be an attitude of, Well, theyre just farmers, and some of the more urban jurisdictions dont care very much about the farmers, said Mr. Manson . There are a lot of people who dont understand agriculture, frankly, and they believe the [rural] water users are the biggest threat to the Delta, and they certainly are not.
The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, names the National Park Service , the Interior Department and Interior Secretary Sally Jewell as plaintiffs.
Debate has raged for years over the Hetch Hetchy Valleys OShaughnessy Dam, which was built in 1913 and flooded the picturesque wilderness under 300 feet of water. Environmentalists have fought for years to drain the dam and restore the valley to its original state.
The politicians in San Francisco will tell you they have no other choice, and Im not sure thats the truth, said Mr. Manson . San Francisco politicians are protecting their turf. Theyre not in a mood to share. And with the conditions we have in California today, which we will have for a long time because its a naturally semi-arid area, its time to share. Share the benefits and share the burdens.

Is that bacon I smell?
Screw the farmers!!!! That's what I said!!!! Who needs them anyway????
There is a plant growing in the middle of the interstate that needs watering.
Seems like there is too much water flowing into San Francisco. While more help from the east would be great, fixing existing problems in California is probably also a good way to start.
I tend to disagree but at least you'll have water to drink. Big farmers are bad bad bad. Don't forget that.
Mexico seems more reasonable. After all California is part of Mexico isn't it?
When you drive up/down Hwy 99, you'll see signs plastered on the highway about how Pelosi, Boxer and Feinstein are the three causes for the water issues in the first place.
Six - the San Fran/San Juaquin area gets its water from the Delta which flows right between them. That's one of the reason the largest farmers are in the northern part of the state.
Of course, doesn't everyone?
I'm not sure where you got that idea. Is that what Nancy is saying now?
Steven Greenhut: Who's leaving the state, and why
Businesses and individuals get tired of being viewed mainly as an ATM machine for government.
Let me bring you up to date....
A new study from the Manhattan Institute, "The Great California Exodus: A Closer Look," offers a reality check. Yes, Californians are fleeing, mostly to pro-growth states with a better tax and regulatory climate. California used to be a destination state, but has seen 3.4 million residents leave in the past 22 years.
Governmental instability is an understandable reason to relocate. In cities that have overspent on employee pensions and wasteful redevelopment projects, traditional public services (infrastructure, public safety, parks, etc.) suffer a trend that will get worse as more localities file for bankruptcy.
California is a highly urbanized state, and coastal metropolises are understandably crowded, but Draconian land-use restrictions and misguided transportation policies (roads are bad, rail is good) exacerbate the problem. These "New Urbanist" policies embraced statewide have created unnecessary sprawl and congestion by pushing development far from job centers and into the Inland Empire and the Central Valley.
Governmental instability is an understandable reason to relocate. In cities that have overspent on employee pensions and wasteful redevelopment projects, traditional public services (infrastructure, public safety, parks, etc.) suffer a trend that will get worse as more localities file for bankruptcy.
The Manhattan Institute authors argue that California can be fixed if Californians have the "political will." Unfortunately, protests in Spain and Greece, which are much further down the same path California is taking, suggest that politicians can go many more years without demonstrating the necessary political will to make necessary but tough reforms. Let's hope California retains enough of its historic entrepreneurial spirit to muster the will to turn things around.
~Link~
If that is not enough for you then here are more...