Would You Rather Be Rich In A Poor Country, Or Poor In A Rich Country?
![]()
Which is the better lot in life: To be poor in a rich country, or rich in a poor country? Take a guess now, before you read further. You may find the answer surprising.*
Since the financial crisis, the decline of the West and the rise of the rest has become a fixture in the thinking of not just Americans, but people all around the world. A 2013 survey by Pew Research Centers Global Attitudes Project showed that 34% of respondents believed that China was the worlds leading economic power, up from 20% in 2008.
These respondents were wrong: the US was the worlds largest economy in 2013.** But its easy to see why they might have thought the US had lost its superpower status.
The media abounds with tales of Chinas stunning economic rise, the gross excess among the nouveau riche in emerging markets, and the decline of the middle class and rising inequality in the US. As if to rub it all in, Chen Guangbiao, a Chinese recycling tycoon, staged an expensive charity event in Central Park in June where he fed hundreds of American homeless sesame-seed encrusted tuna and expensive cuts of beef.
So is it better to be rich in a poor country? Unless you are Chen Guangbiao or one of his rare cohorts, the answer is no. Your standard of living is likely to be higher if you live in a rich country, no matter where youfall on the income distribution.
Despite the recent troubles in advanced economies and growth in emerging economies, the gap between rich and poor countries remains large. Even the poorest of Americans, for example, were still richer than 60% of the worlds population on a purchasing power parity basis in 2005; they were also roughly on par with Chinas top 15% and Indias top 5%.
Of course, these trends are changing. Economies are converging, meaning the income levels of both poor and rich countries are coming together, due largely to the rapid transmission of technology from advanced to developing economies. Convergence is a powerful force, perhaps the biggest economic story of the 21 st century.
Yet wealth and economic activity remain both incredibly path dependent. They also tend to cluster around global economic centers, which take decades or centuries to establish.
http://news360.com/article/252730801#

Global income distribution is changing dramatically of late and interpretations of exactly how it looks vary from expert to expert
I'm not at all clear what the meaning is of the X-axis in the article graphic ...
Petey
Hope this helps I didn't get it either till I found this
Thanks ; That helped . Now I need to digest the info .
I'm getting 2 things from my 1st look :
The wealthiest ventile were doing quite well in 2005 especially in the US & Brazil .
The rise from the bottom ventile is not very steep in India but a little better in China .
Also I expect things have changed a lot since 2005 . I'm thinking that the US middle class would have fallen since then [the 10th ventile ? ] .
I deleted my comment.
Larry
What?
It is not strictly income that would answer such a question . Access to healthcare and dentistry might be a better measure .
Robert,
I thought when I saw your article that this was an ethical question. Ha! You fooled me.
In my view, those things are part and parcel in determining if one is rich or poor
But good point
Perrie
Not as deep and profoundas that, but I thought it was interesting
It seems hat that sort of aversion to taking responsibility in ones life is becoming increasingly popular-- the fallacious reasonig blaming externals for lack of success-- or lack happiness in ones' life.
Because the actual fact of the matter is-- whether or not the country has "real Christian Ideals" or pays lip service-- its still possible to better oneself and help others. In fact-- lots pf people do!
(But only if you stop blaming externals, and look within...)
jwc2blue
Very noble and altruistic
Good for you
J P M
Appreciate your perspective
No one believes in personal accountability and that people need to take control of and ownership of their choices and their lives than I do, but one must also acknowledge the external challenges and obstacles that people must overcome "to better oneself".
GINI Index