╌>

The last refuge of prejudice - by Rupert Read

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  james-martin2  •  11 years ago  •  21 comments

The last refuge of prejudice - by Rupert Read

It is no longer socially-acceptable to exhibit prejudice against ethnic minority people on grounds of their ethnicity, women on grounds of their gender, or working-class people on grounds of their class. The last bastions of discrimination are being overcome: such as prejudice against gay and lesbian people, and against disabled people.

But is there one crucial bastion of discrimination still strongly in place?

Take this kind of remark, which I sometimes hear on the doorstep while Im out talking to my constituents: I just dont care about what happens after Im dead and gone. We might dismiss this as the attitude just of some old curmudgeon, and think that it is of no moral or political consequence. But: it directly implies not caring about future people , the next generation(s). How would we react if someone said to us, I just dont care about what happens to black people or I just dont care about what happens to disabled people? I take it that we would be singularly appalled.

Future people count, too. Their lives matter just as much.

>>> continued >>>

https://www.opendemocracy.net/rupert-read/last-refuge-of-prejudice


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

It's a fairly clever conceit, but "future people" don't have lives.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

" It's a fairly clever conceit, but "future people" don't have lives."

Many agree with you on that one, LGL, but I've never had the luxury of not feeling the palpable presence of those people (and other living beings) who you say "don't have lives." I say "luxury" because I am able to feel their pain in the face of our own intergenerational disregard and neglect of them. This causes me grief. And I do not have the luxury of not feeling such grief.

And I'll go an important step further. Not only do we who exist now deeply and often directly influence the lives of future generations yet unborn, but those not-yet-born, whom you say "don't have lives" can deeply and importantly impact our own lives -- if we will only hear their silent yearnings and care for them as we say we care for those now living.

I know this in part (but not exclusively) because I've been the recipient of many extraordinary, invaluable gifts from past generations no longer living. (I and you are that to those who are to come.) Past generations of real, palpable people have dreamed of certain aspects of the world in which I now live, and in so dreaming made personal sacrifices and gifts to me and the rest of us now alive. They have seen our potential to largely outgrow certain prejudices and abuses, and with such a vision in their hearts they reached out and gave to us -- and we live in the down stream of their giving, risk and devotion. Should we not extend them gratitude?

But we also receive an unfathomably precious gift from those who will not be born in our lifetimes. They give us a sense of our own lives as something we can give, in turn, ... passing the gifts on and forward, caring for all of life ... as if it were near and not far. As if we could sense their breath in our breath, their joys in our joys, their fears and hopes in our own.

____________________

Intergenerational Justice

Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

The potential for life does not have any rights. I turn your attention to contraception and abortion.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

The ''Seven Generations''....

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

The best way to protect the next generation is to not murder your fetus.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Thank you, Feronia , for taking the time to engage with this topic in a sincere and thoughtful way. I appreciate that very much!

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Feronia: "The earth does have it's cycles, it has and will experience more ice ages. Our presence here is such a short blip in comparison to the overall time that the earth has existed, yet we think we can affect what the planet does to retain homeostasis."

Oh, it's not an arrogance to KNOW that we can affect the Earth's current capacity to recover from our own species' recent assault upon climatic homeostasis. To give Earth a little breathing room to recover from our species' recent assault may not be simple, but it is real, nevertheless. We can burn less fossil fuels. No, really, we can. We burn far, far more than we need to. I guess we'd have to let a few big hotels in far off places go bankrupt, but we could start by taking care of our own neighborhood rather than flying off to other people's neighborhoods for a four star vacation.

We could use the sun to heat our homes. That's a fact -- for most of us. (We could also grow our own food in community garden farms!) But we don't, because "natural gas" and coal-fired electricity is still, as we like to say, "affordable". .... Ultimately, our poverty is that we don't pause, don't think, don't care.... We lack basic knowledge of how things work and prefer to work in corporate slums rather than pause a moment and ask basic questions.

Most of us are on auto-pilot in a world we neither understand or care about. That's poverty.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Thanks for your questions, Feronia.

To answer such questions is difficult as a result of the necessity of concision. I've devoted a LOT of my time over the last thirty years studying the many and diverse interpenetrating topics of human ecology, the biodiversity crisis, energy issues, economics, philosophy... and so on and so forth ... trying to understand how humanity could -- in theory -- best navigate our current eco-social crisis. I have read extensively ... and had thousands of conversations with "ordinary citizens" to names recognized as at the top of the eco-social fields (and world famous climate scientists and activists, whom I've had on "speed dial". I had my moment in the sun as one who may have had a world-significant influence ... and seen it slip thorough my fingers like sands in an hour glass. I say this not to brag but to indicate my level of engagement and commitment.

I only have time here to succinctly hint at what I've learned after thousands of hours of deep engagement with these topics.

1. Industrialism One must be abandoned as a death trap. We need to find a path to another world which includes industrial practices and processes, but which basically abandons industrialism as we have known it. .... Unless some unforeseen major energy technology comes into play -- which I doubt will happen..

2. This means we have to run our "civilization" on ever less energy inputs -- especially those which are derived from fossil fuels. We can expand solar, wind, etc., tremendously ... but the transition to these will tend to require a massive fossil fuel input to create the physical infrastructure ... so it's all very tricky to say the least.

3. Global tourism should be kindly, gently abandoned as quickly as possible. Humans cannot afford long distance jet travel for the many. Should we give it the the rich few? I don't think so!

4. Obviously, we're talking about a shock to current economic ways of life. But what would you rather have, a broken arm or a hole in your head? I'll take the broken arm, thanks.

5. We're going to need to return to a way of life which involves attending to our needs mostly on a local and regional basis, with the local being primary. You should not be depending upon goods produced thousands and thousands of miles away. Those days are over. Or, alternatively, we must be willing to accept ecocide. It's your choice.

6. Food, water and shelter are our primary "economic"needs. These will need to be swiftly converted to local / regional provisioning in small-scaled "operations" (tiny local and regional farms / gardens, etc...). People will need to begin using their bodies, rather than machines, as energy inputs into these productive processes. Or the machines will need to be produced, maintained and energy sourced by renewables.

7. We can create a higher quality of life than the current popular one at less than half of the negative ecological (and CO2) footprint as the one we currently have. And when we've achieved this we will be in a good position to lower our negative footprint even further while continuing to increase quality of life for people.

8. A social, not a "political," revolution will be required to do these things. Politics is broken. It is of little use to us -- as it is owned and controlled by those who are only seeking to expand their bank accounts, not our collective well-being.

9. The social revolution we need depends upon "direct action" -- or directly serving the values we cherish, rather than asking permission from our rulers to do so.

If you half way understand this list of ideas so far, you can add to them so I don't need to.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

"What would places do whose primary source of income is tourism?"

They would gradually (ideally - but not too gradually!) shift to a local-regional community self-provisioning of basic needs such as food, water and shelter (etc.). This is the way all people once lived. And all future people will live in this way again, in time. We will return to a food system, for example, where those who live on coasts will eat fish while those who live inland will depend more on beans, corn, squash ... eggs, etc. If you don't live in the tropics, tropical food items (bananas, pineapple, etc.) will become rare delicacies, not daily fare. In other words, we will return to the way nature designed our diets. You may visit faraway places on a once-in-a-lifetime basis, but probably not an annual one. We may return to sailing ships, which are slower than modern non-sailing ships. Stuff like that.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
That's a sad world with a low quality of life. The industrial revolution was a boon to mankind, with higher quality of life and longer life expectancy. I don't plan on curbing my global travel any time soon. If the Luddites would bother to learn about risk versus benefits we could have a thriving fission/fuel cell economy.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
How depressing.
 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Cerenkov :

"How depressing."
Why?
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

He won't be able to get his suit dry cleaned ...

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Cerenkov :

"That's a sad world with a low quality of life."
Many people live very happily and healthily on less than half of the average American's fossil fuel energy budget. So there is no necessary relationship between fossil fuel consumption and quality of life.
"The industrial revolution was a boon to mankind, with higher quality of life and longer life expectancy."
The nearly simultaneous (and almost synonymous) industrial and scientific revolutions have indeed provided many tremendous benefits to humanity, but we squandered those by allowing the down side of these two great boons to grow to a proportion as great, and then finally greater, than the bright side of each. Now we like to pretend that it's all "bright side," but it's getting harder and harder by the day to pretend this way.
"I don't plan on curbing my global travel any time soon."
Good luck with that.
"If the Luddites would bother to learn about risk versus benefits we could have a thriving fission/fuel cell economy"
I think you know where I'd have them stick their fission. As for fuel cells, just how long would that take, and what energy inputs would support it?
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
A duel cell or hydrogen economy would require the use of fission power, the safest most efficient power source currently known.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
A tribalistic culture with no growth and no enriching travel would be a step back to the bronze age. No art, no science, no sharing. Depressing.
 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  J Martin    11 years ago

Cerenkov :

A tribalistic culture with no growth and no enriching travel would be a step back to the bronze age. No art, no science, no sharing. Depressing.
Is "no growth" being treated here as "no economic growth" or as "no personal" ... or "no social" growth? Or all of the above? Are these being treated as equivalent and synonymous?
No art? Why? No science? Why?
No sharing?!
Why?
(I suspect people living in a much less "hot" economy would share even more!)
 
 

Who is online




CB


71 visitors