╌>

Beliefs Cannot Trump Rights

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  11 years ago  •  26 comments

Beliefs Cannot Trump Rights

Posted: Thursday, September 3, 2015, 1:08 AM
By George Panichas

'Old Jim," as everyone knows him, has been responsible for issuing gun licenses for as long as his county job has existed. Jim is a well-liked, affable, and devoutly religious fellow who does his job efficiently and well; he rarely makes an error.

But Jim's religious commitments have created something of a problem. The tenets of his faith, he has discovered, prohibit the possession and use of guns by women. So recently, when several women have applied for licenses, as is consistent with their Second Amendment rights, Jim has refused to issue them. His freedom of religion, he believes, exempts him from doing what is contrary to his religious convictions, and he feels that the county cannot require him to act against these convictions.

The problem can be worked around so long as someone else can take over for Jim, but the county is small, and there often is no one available to step in - that is, no one who doesn't share Jim's beliefs. So the question of whether Jim can be forced to issue gun licenses is now before the county commissioners.

As everyone knows, the First Amendment requires respect for religion, especially in the context of "the free exercise thereof." But the amendment also prohibits laws "respecting an establishment of religion." So there would certainly seem to be limits on Jim's appeal to religious freedom. He cannot legitimately expect that the county will take his particular religious commitments and establish them as governmental policy.

No one doubts the sincerity or depth of Jim's beliefs, but sincerity and depth do not and should not transform religious commitments into law. That is exactly what the First Amendment protects citizens against. No matter how deeply or widely held a religious belief may be, it has no special legal status; such beliefs do not trump properly enacted laws, specifically the laws that are implied by fundamental constitutional rights.

Now the First Amendment has been taken to require an appropriate accommodation of religion. And this is certainly part of what the "free exercise" clause is all about. So the county commissioners can't stop Jim from attending his church or acting in accord with the (legally permissible) requirements of his faith. Nor can they stop him from stating publicly his opposition to women having guns.

But the accommodation of religion must be neutral. That is, accommodating Jim's beliefs cannot require impositions on the rights of others. Accommodation requires neutrality, and Jim's religious commitments cannot be given priority over the rights of other citizens.

This is important because it shows that Jim has no legitimate complaint when he is required to act in accord with the terms of his job. His religious beliefs are being respected to the appropriate degree, a degree that is necessarily limited by the rights of others. Religious commitments do not exempt a person from his civic duties, especially when such an exemption entails a violation of the rights of others.

The fictitious story of "Old Jim" is designed to teach a lesson that is especially appropriate given the real case of Kim Davis, a clerk in Rowan County, Ky., who has, even after the Supreme Court declined to intervene on her behalf, refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Her situation is relevantly analogous to that of Old Jim. Same-sex couples have a constitutionally protected right to marry, and the Supreme Court has properly recognized that the denial of this right is an insult to gay and lesbian citizens.

As Justice Anthony Kennedy has consistently argued, marriage inequality demeans same-sex couples and their children, and does so in a way that violates their constitutional rights. As we would be appalled if Jim were denying gun rights to women or, for that matter, if a state were denying the right to marry to interracial couples, we should be equally appalled should Davis' religious beliefs be allowed to impose inequitable and impermissible burdens on certain citizens - those whose rights are out favor with Davis' religion.

Of course, if people with religious commitments feel they cannot, because of their religious commitments, issue gun licenses to women or marriage licenses to same-sex couples, they may refuse to do so. But they cannot legitimately expect others to accept infringements on their constitutional rights only because of these religious commitments.

The constitutional rights of Americans are protected against infringements emanating from even the most deeply held religious beliefs. Indeed, abandoning this commitment closes the door on a reasonable pluralistic democracy and opens it wide to an oppressive theocracy.

George E. Panichas is a philosophy professor who specializes in the philosophy of law at Lafayette College in Easton. panichag@lafayette.edu

http://www.philly.com/philly/opinion/20150903_Beliefs_cannot_trump_rights.html#YepoMYSZTzyep7CW.99


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

A Jewish woman wearing a necklace with a Star of David was denied a permit for a yard sale by a county clerk; the clerk's objection was based on the religious belief, that "Jews killed Christ," that "Jews do not accept Christ," and that "this is preventing the Coming of the Messiah".

Whether actual or not, comment on the scenario as it applies to religious belief vs. law.

For the record, in another thread, the comment was made that the "New Testament invalidates the Old Testament."

Keep it relevant to the question.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Thanks a lot for not mentioning this illustration was fictional . You seem to be bent on providing more reading material than even you can deal with . Did you read it ?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

When religious beliefs prohibit a person from performing the duties of his/her job, then he/she should resign.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Except if we are talking about sanctuary cities or federal immigration laws.

If the clerk in Kentucky is in jail, so should be the mayors of towns like San Francisco and the President.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Thanks a lot for not mentioning this illustration was fictional . You seem to be bent on providing more reading material than even you can deal with . Did you read it ?

Did YOU read it?

You seem to be bent on making irrelevant and personal attack comments because you can't viably rebut.

The point of the article is clear fictional, metaphorical -- it makes no difference. Either address the content or don't comment further.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

"If I had a son he would look like Trayvon ." Who cares how he would act ? Not me reveals B. Obama .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Except if we are talking about sanctuary cities or federal immigration laws.

No one herein, including myself, has advocated violating laws. Stop using innuendo and straw man arguments to sidestep. If a public official violates the law, there should be an investigation into the specifics, an indictment if one is warranted and a trial.

Agreed, Sean?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Thanks for not answering my question . I'm going with you did NOT read it . That's not a personal attack , just a conjecture which YOU refuse to address .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Thanks for not answering my question . I'm going with you did NOT read it . That's not a personal attack , just a conjecture which YOU refuse to address .

The article is seeded verbatim it contains the paragraph

The fictitious story of "Old Jim" is designed to teach a lesson that is especially appropriate given the real case of Kim Davis, a clerk in Rowan County, Ky., who has, even after the Supreme Court declined to intervene on her behalf, refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. Her situation is relevantly analogous to that of Old Jim. Same-sex couples have a constitutionally protected right to marry, and the Supreme Court has properly recognized that the denial of this right is an insult to gay and lesbian citizens.

And whether fictitious or not

is designed to teach a lesson that is especially appropriate given the real case of Kim Davis

Your tactic of creating a straw man and using it both as a dodge and personal attack is known well and quite annoying.

And since your righteous-indignation towards alleged refusals to address, in your case, rhetorical nonsense, how 'bout you address the very first comment in this thread.

Does the scenario it posits meet with your approval, or, does it signal the dangers of "religion trumping law"?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Sean, what is a sanctuary city, exactly? I'm not trying to be dumb, but you keep talking about them, and I really don't know what they mean...

I ask with all respect.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Your tactic of creating a straw man and using it both as a dodge and personal attack is known well and quite annoying.

I didn't create a strawman . I asked a question , one you have repeatedly avoided answering . You want my answer but won't answer anything in return ? Your skill at propaganda manipulation is well established !

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I believe in God and Hal does not. Do my rights to speak of God, (in general, not directed at Hal), trump Hal's right to pure, God-free air? Nope, I don't think so. Do I have the right to try to convince Hal of my beliefs? Absolutely not! By the same token, can Hal stop me from praying quietly to myself? Nope.

I truly make an effort to tamp it all down around Hal, because I respect his beliefs.

Excuse me, dear Hal, for using your beliefs as an example again. If this upsets you, I will stop! I do not mean this as an insult, nor do I wish to upset you in any way. I truly respect your beliefs, and know that you have thought about it a great deal.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

I'm not Sean, but he may not show up real soon. So I'm providing this:

The list there is incomplete. There are other cities which are not on the list at Wikipedia. Perhaps many.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I read the article in full before I seeded it, I knew the illustration was fictional

Please leave my article.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thanks, James! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    11 years ago

Dear Friend A. Mac: This one is really simple.

If the law is written in a certain way, it must be obeyed.

One can lobby to change laws. It isn't easy, but it is possible working within the system.

In the meantime, we are a nation under the law, with equal protection and equal enforcement mandates.

This issue affected me. There are certain states in which I am not yet allowed to marry persons of the same gender.

As a proudly Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, it is against my tradition to marginalize anyone. I may not discriminate based on intimacy orientation.

Until the law changes, I do not perform marriage ceremonies where they are not recognized by the State. I do officiate atcivil ceremonies where allowed. When marriage is allowed, one a case by case basis I will preside. My decision ins never based on genders of applicants. Rather it is based on agreements on terms and conditions of a Shtar Kebtubah. That is a technicality of Halacha (Rabbinic Law).

The Shtar Ketubah is the oldest known human rights document on the planet.

The only advise I can offer to those who find that their beliefs interfere with the performance of their legally mandated duties are to resign if they cannot in good conscience discharge them. They are free in our American society to lobby to change the law.

Should they choose to accept the civil disobedienceroute, they must expect that there will be predictable consequneces. Here they must pay their money, and take their choice so to speak.

These are never simple matters. They are not easy ones with which to live.

All I can add is that everyone's rights end where the rights of others begin.

Peace, Abundant Blessings to One and All.

Enoch.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

As a proudly Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, it is against my tradition to marginalize anyone. I may not discriminate based on intimacy orientation.

Wow! The world is so big!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Except the Constitution.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

XXJefferson#51 :

"The free excercise of ones religious beliefs is a right that no one should ever be able to override. That right should trump all others."
Suppose we agree with you on this, XXJ, .. How or what would that look like in practice? In a world and a nation with many, many religious views, how would it be possible to give equal weight to each and every one? Well, the answer is obvious. The nation would have to be secular, not religious -- just like the USA. And all local jurisdictions would have to respect the general principle of religious freedom: That each and all can have it in the only measure that can be distributed equally to the many. No one religious doctrine or view could "trump" all others.
Such a secular society would have to have principles of universal justice which transcend the doctrines of the many churches and religious institutions. Just like the USA has. So marriage, in the USA (for example) is secular marriage -- not religious marriage. And any religious group can make its own decisions about marriage -- within the confines of the group. Nothing can be universally imposed upon everyone -- unless it is something very basic ... such as the right of life, liberty and the pursuit of ... happiness.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I agree with your basic concept . For example the near religious beliefs of climatology fanatics wanting to abuse the economic rights of the rest of us with no real science to support their beliefs I find appalling . There are other examples some of which you gave ... And now I can leave .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

All I can add is that everyone's rights end where the rights of others begin.

And that is the essence of it!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The free excercise of ones religious beliefs is a right that no one should ever be able to override. That right should trump all others

Instead of doubling down on that premise, respond to the opening comment in this thread. Put your conviction to the test rather than making a pronouncement.

Again

A Jewish woman wearing a necklace with a Star of David was denied a permit for a yard sale by a county clerk; the clerk's objection was based on the religious belief, that "Jews killed Christ," that "Jews do not accept Christ," and that "this is preventing the Coming of the Messiah".

Whether actual or not, comment on the scenario as it applies to religious belief vs. law.

For the record, in another thread, the comment was made that the "New Testament invalidates the Old Testament." Does that mean it consequently invalidates Judaism?

Keep it relevant to the question.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

So, you support the snake handlers rights to get bitten? Even though it is against the law?

Just asking...

 
 

Who is online




CB


71 visitors