╌>

Fox News Hypes Mythical Automatic Classification To Smear Hillary Clinton

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  18 comments

Fox News Hypes Mythical Automatic Classification To Smear Hillary Clinton

Fox News Hypes Mythical Automatic Classification To Smear Hillary Clinton

Fox News figures twisted a 2009 executive order to allege that communications related to or with foreign officials are "automatically classified," a misrepresentation of the law meant to smear Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's email use while secretary of state.

Fox Figures Claim 2009 Executive Order Automatically Classified Communications With Foreign Officials In Clinton's Unmarked Emails

Fox Contributor: Clinton "Obviously Should Have Known" That Some Of Her Unmarked Emails Were "Automatically Classified" By Obama's Executive Order. On the September 1 edition of The O'Reilly Factor , Fox News contributor Monica Crowley pointed to an executive order issued by President Obama in 2009 to claim it requires all information discussing foreign governments to be automatically classified and thus Clinton should have known she was handling classified information:

CROWLEY: Look, in 2009, Barack Obama issued an executive order called Classified National Security Information. And by doing that, he automatically classified information that is related to information that foreign governments have provided. What we're now hearing from this latest batch, what we can see from these emails, is that nearly all of the emails in question contain information provided by foreign governments.

[...]

Automatically classified. Mrs. Clinton obviously should have known that. [Fox News, The O'Reilly Factor , 9/1/15 ]

Fox Contributor: Clinton's Emails Were "Indisputably Classified" Under Obama's Executive Order. On America's Newsroom on September 2, Fox News contributor Stephen Hayes claimed that Clinton's email communication concerning foreign officials violated Obama's executive order because it was not marked classified:

HAYES: The fact that the information that she sent, that she created and sent and also received, was classified -- it's indisputably classified. It's classified according to President Obama's executive order 13526 issued in December of 2009 which suggests that information derived from foreign government sources included in a non-classified setting violates that executive order. That's a huge problem for her. [Fox News, America's Newsroom , 9/2/15 ]

Fox Guest: "It's The Law" That Some Of Clinton's Emails Were "Considered Classified" Even If They Were Not Marked As Such. On the September 1 edition of The Real Story , guest host Heather Nauert asked Shannen Coffin, former White House counsel to Vice President Cheney, about his belief that Clinton violated the law when she sent and received email with former Prime Minister Tony Blair because of the executive order:

NAUERT: One of the things that you say is that there is a rule of thumb that everyone in the State Department should know that foreign government communications are considered classified because they could harm national security.

COFFIN: It's more than a rule of thumb, Heather. It's the law. By executive order issued by President Obama in the beginning of his administration that says that the disclosure of foreign government information, that is, communications from foreign governments that's intended to be held in confidence, is presumed to harm the national security, which is the threshold for classifying information. [Fox News, The Real Story , 9/1/15 ]

But Classification Of Communication With Foreign Officials Is Not Mandatory Under 2009 Executive Order

Executive Order 13526: Classification Can Be Considered Only If Unauthorized Disclosure May Cause Damage To National Security. In December 2009, Obama signed an executive order prescribing "a uniform system for classifying, safeguarding, and declassifying national security information." The order did not mandate any classifications. Instead, it authorized communications concerning "foreign government information" and "foreign relations" to be considered for classification if "its unauthorized disclosure could reasonably be expected to cause identifiable or describable damage to the national security":

Sec. 1.4. Classification Categories . Information shall not be considered for classification unless its unauthorized disclosure could reasonably be expected to cause identifiable or describable damage to the national security in accordance with section 1.2 of this order, and it pertains to one or more of the following:

(a) military plans, weapons systems, or operations;

(b) foreign government information;

(c) intelligence activities (including covert action), intelligence sources or methods, or cryptology;

(d) foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States, including confidential sources;

(e) scientific, technological, or economic matters relating to the national security;

(f) United States Government programs for safeguarding nuclear materials or facilities;

(g) vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, infrastructures, projects, plans, or protection services relating to the national security; or

(h) the development, production, or use of weapons of mass destruction. [Executive Order 13526 -- Classified National Security Information, 12/29/09 ]

E.O. 13526: "Information May Be Classified," And If Classification Need Is In Doubt, "It Shall Not Be Classified." The order did not mandate that communications dealing with foreign relations must be classified. Instead, it clarified that "[i]f there is significant doubt about the need to classify information, it shall not be classified":

Section 1.1.b

(b) If there is significant doubt about the need to classify information, it shall not be classified. This provision does not:

(1) amplify or modify the substantive criteria or procedures for classification; or

(2) create any substantive or procedural rights subject to judicial review. [Executive Order 13526 -- Classified National Security Information, 12/29/09 ]

Security Expert: Order "Authorizes Classification; It Doesn't Require It." In an interview with Mother Jones , security expert Steven Aftergood explained that Executive Order 13526 on classification "is permissive, not mandatory." Rather than requiring that communication between foreign officials be marked classified, the order "authorizes classification":

"Strictly speaking, the executive order on classification is permissive, not mandatory, " Steven Aftergood, who writes Secrecy News for the Federation of American Scientists, told Mother Jones . "In other words, it authorizes classification; it doesn't require it." Aftergood pointed to Executive Order 13526, signed by President Obama in December 2009, which says "information may be originally classified," but does not explicitly mandate it.

Government policy encourages these sorts of communications to be classified in most instances. "It is obviously good practice to respect the confidentiality of communications from foreign partners if one hopes to maintain a productive relationship," Aftergood says. But it's not always mandatory, making it hard to judge from the outside whether Clinton mishandled the information in specific instances. [ Mother Jones , 8/21/15 ]

State Dept. Has Long Utilized Informal Back Channels To Discuss Communications With Foreign Officials

State Department's Use Of "Informal Back Channels" Predates Email. In an August 27column, David Ignatius of The Washington Post explained that "in the real world of the State Department ... informal back channels [have] existed long before email":

"It's common" that people end up using unclassified systems to transmit classified information, said Jeffrey Smith, a former CIA general counsel who's now a partner at Arnold & Porter, where he often represents defendants suspected of misusing classified information.

[...]

What happens in the real world of the State Department? Smith takes the hypothetical example of an assistant secretary who receives a classified cable from, say, Paris, about a meeting with the French foreign minister and wants quick guidance from the secretary. So he dashes off an e-mail -- rather than sending a classified cable that would be seen by perhaps a dozen people.

[...]

Informal back channels existed long before e-mail. One former State Department official recalled the days when most embassies overseas had only a few phones authorized for secret communications. Rather than go to the executive office to make such a call, officers would use their regular phones, bypassing any truly sensitive details. "Did we cross red lines? No doubt. Did it put information at risk? Maybe. But, if you weren't in Moscow or Beijing, you didn't worry much," this former official said.

Back channels are used because the official ones are so encrusted by classification and bureaucracy. State had the "Roger Channel," named after former official Roger Hilsman, for sending secret messages directly to the secretary. The Joint Chiefs of Staff had a similar private channel. CIA station chiefs could send communications known as "Aardwolves" straight to the director.

Are these channels misused sometimes? Most definitely. Is there a crime here? Almost certainly not. [ The Washington Post , 8/27/15 ]

http://mediamatters.org/research/2015/09/02/fox-news-hypes-mythical-automatic-classificatio/205333


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Yesterday the Washington Post printed an article claiming that Hillary Clinton not only received "classified" e-mails, she had also written six such e-mails that have now, in preparation for their release to the media, have been designated "classified".

I suppose this was considered a big "gotcha" by the writer, and the toads such as Joe Scarborough, but it's really just more of the nothingburger.

As this article tells us, there is no mandate to automatically consider correspondence with or about foreign diplomats as "classified". There is a recommendation, which we can presume (since it is a recommendation) can be superseded by human judgement.

The witch hunt continues.

 
 
 
Dan Sauers
Freshman Silent
link   Dan Sauers    11 years ago

You would think that someone such as yourself (blind party hack) would be upset with Clinton for the simple fact of the inexpiable use of a private email server when all she had to do was use a .gov account. Now here you are running around like a doosh with his head cut off trying to defend the indefensible making yourself look like an even bigger hack than anyone here thought possible.

Just sayin....

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I wonder what he's going to do if she drops out of the race, (entirely a possibility)

I will be seriously concerned for him after his apoplexy attack is over.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Thank you for your fact free comment. You didn't let me down Dan.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

If I'm a hack, what does that make you ?

Useless ?

What's the word ?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

More pointless blabber.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Regardless, this does not excuse the stupidity or lack of integrity for what she has done. Thankfully this scandal has gotten a lot of people to look closer and find out they don't like a lot of other questionable issues in her past, and that there are far too many. I nothing else, Her drop in the polls has reinstalled a bit of faith in regards to the intelligence of the American voter.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

More blabber.

Hillary Clinton is not going to go to jail.

Whether or not her campaign can survive the witch hunt is unknown at this time. That's the sad fact of it.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

John

A simple and sincere question --

Would you agree that whether information is classified or not classified has nothing whatsoever to do with whether it is or was marked CONFIDENTIAL or SECRET but rather depends on the information itself and the source of the information?

Would you therefore agree that whether an email was marked CONFIDENTIAL or SECRET or TOP SECRET is immaterial in determining if the data/information in the email is classified?

 
 
 
Dan Sauers
Freshman Silent
link   Dan Sauers    11 years ago

Don't bother Robert. He is completely incapable of saying or admitting anything at all that might be negative towards Monica's boyfriend's wife.

 
 
 
Dan Sauers
Freshman Silent
link   Dan Sauers    11 years ago

Hilary - the queen of getting HERSELF into needless scandals. The funny part is that she's already admitted that she was stupid for doing so. You keep up the good work though little buddyGrin.gif

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

RIO, the e-mails that have been retroactively marked "classified" have been done so BECAUSE they were under court order to be released to the public (the media).

Do you know that there are many experienced , knowledgeable people in national security and in the media that covers national security that think this whole "scandal" is ridiculous ?

Hillary Clinton appears to have made a public relations mistake by using a private server to hold these e-mails. Maybe at the time she got bad advice, or maybe there was some miscommunication with the then new Obama administration. Maybe she wanted this system in order to exert more control over this material than other Sec of States have. This is a fair political question, and can be fairly used to determine if one would vote for her.

This does not rise to the level of "disqualifying" her from office seeking and justifying a year long witch hunt, with every new 'revelation' (most of which are meaningless) causing a new round of demands she be thrown in jail , or some such. Most of the people making these calls have no idea what they are talking about.

If Clinton had actually done something to compromise national security, we would have heard about it by now, from people in controlling authority. That has not happened. The FBI is not investigating Hillary Clinton for criminal wrongdoing. No one is.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

You know John has reached the desperation point when he has to seed Media Matters (which is owned by a longtime Clinton hardcore loyalist and mudslinger) to try and defend her obvious wrongdoing. Although the she's too dumb to understand security rules argument is a great qualification for commander in chief.

Keep telling yourself that the "label" matters. Someday you will appreciate the difference between classified information and classified documents. We now know the State Department has already identified 6 emails so far she authored containing classified information, and sent them to people with no security clearance.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Soon this whole thing will take on Mc Carthy era proportions. No one can find a single thing Clinton did said or wrote that jeopardized "national security". There is a new right wing hysteria being ginned today claiming that certain emails were "born classified". Of course this is something that can only be discovered retroactively.

Think of all the money that is being wasted on this nonsense. If people don't like her they don't have to vote for her.

Until then, let the investigators do their jobs without all this ridiculous right wing and media hysteria, the essence of a witch hunt.

Jesus H, wtf is wrong with this country ?

Now , as predicted, there are hundreds of people pouring over all these emails looking for gossip and sensationalism to reveal to their braindead audiences.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

John

You answered neither of my questions.

Please try again

I have not said that the email issue disqualifies her from being president,it speaks to her trustworthiness in the eyes of others is for the electorate as a whole to decide not me.

I also agree that it has become a media circus.

That being said the two questions I asked are valid ones and ones that you should be bale to answer and ones thatH Clinton surely knows the answers to, so please try and answer te questions. They require no elaborate answers, simply yes or no.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

No one can find a single thing Clinton did said or wrote that jeopardized "national security".


wow. Do you think the fact the State Department has redacted hundreds of emails because they contain classified information might matter here? Yourpreposterousargument is thatyou can't prove she didn't hurt national security because you can't see what classified information she improperlyhandled. What ajoke.

Of course this is something that can only be discovered retroactively.


No it's something that's discovered immediately when proper procedure is followed, which includes using the State email system. How absurd is your standard that one can blab any state secret they want, so long as they don't first get confirmation that the information is classified.

Look up what happened toJohn Deutch, Bill Clinton's CIA director, who had to be pardoned by thePresidentbecause he kept classified information on his homecomputer.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

John

A simple and sincere question --

Would you agree that whether information is classified or not classified has nothing whatsoever to do with whether it is or was marked CONFIDENTIAL or SECRET but rather depends on the information itself and the source of the information?

Would you therefore agree that whether an email was marked CONFIDENTIAL or SECRET or TOP SECRET is immaterial in determining if the data/information in the email is classified?

Some piece of information may have been worthy of classification , in someone's eyes, at the time Clinton sent or received it. Another person may not have classified the same piece of information.

When it is marked, everyone handling the document knows that this information HAS BEEN deemed classified by someone with the authority to do so. There could still be disagreement between two different people (in the department or agency or between depts or agencies) as to whether or not it should have been classified, but it has been , and must be treated as such. When no classification has been made, the material may be "born classified", or it may not be, it could be a matter of opinion.

Of course the "information itself" could lead to it being classified, but until it actually IS classified it may well be a matter of opinion.

That is what you all are misunderstanding. Well, one of the things.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean, you have a diseased hatred for Clinton, Obama and all Democrats and liberals. Seek therapy.

Hillary Clinton is not going to be indicted and is not going to prison. I hope you will be able to withstand that crushing disappointment.

There is no doubt that this "scandal" is a witch hunt.

Do you really believe that Hillary Clinton is the only person in government or in the military who ever inadvertently passed along "classified" information ?

 
 

Who is online



CB


74 visitors