Study: Majority of Households Headed by Immigrant (Legal and Illegal) Use Welfare
This study is the first in recent years to examine immigrant (legal and illegal) and native welfare use using the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP). While its complexity makes it difficult to use, the survey is widely regarded as providing the most accurate picture of welfare participation. The SIPP shows immigrant households use welfare at significantly higher rates than native households, even higher than indicated by other Census surveys.
- In 2012, 51 percent of households headed by an immigrant (legal or illegal) reported that they used at least one welfare program during the year, compared to 30 percent of native households. Welfare in this study includes Medicaid and cash, food, and housing programs.
- Welfare use is high for both new arrivals and well-established immigrants. Of households headed by immigrants who have been in the country for more than two decades, 48 percent access welfare.
- No single program explains immigrants' higher overall welfare use. For example, not counting subsidized school lunch, welfare use is still 46 percent for immigrants and 28 percent for natives. Not counting Medicaid, welfare use is 44 percent for immigrants and 26 percent for natives.
- Immigrant households have much higher use of food programs (40 percent vs. 22 percent for natives) and Medicaid (42 percent vs. 23 percent). Immigrant use of cash programs is somewhat higher than natives (12 percent vs. 10 percent) and use of housing programs is similar to natives.
- Welfare use varies among immigrant groups. Households headed by immigrants from Central America and Mexico (73 percent), the Caribbean (51 percent), and Africa (48 percent) have the highest overall welfare use. Those from East Asia (32 percent), Europe (26 percent), and South Asia (17 percent) have the lowest.
- Many immigrants struggle to support their children, and a large share of welfare is received on behalf of U.S.-born children. However, even immigrant households without children have significantly higher welfare use than native households without children 30 percent vs. 20 percent.
- The welfare system is designed to help low-income workers, especially those with children, and this describes many immigrant households. In 2012, 51 percent of immigrant households with one or more workers accessed one or more welfare programs, as did 28 percent of working native households.
- The large share of immigrants with low levels of education and resulting low incomes partly explains their high use rates. In 2012, 76 percent of households headed by an immigrant who had not graduated high school used one or more welfare programs, as did 63 percent of households headed by an immigrant with only a high school education.
- The high rates of immigrant welfare use are not entirely explained by their lower education levels. Households headed by college-educated immigrants have significantly higher welfare use than households headed by college-educated natives 26 percent vs. 13 percent.
- In the four top immigrant-receiving states, use of welfare by immigrant households is significantly higher than that of native households: California (55 percent vs. 30 percent), New York (59 percent vs. 33 percent), Texas (57 percent vs. 34 percent), and Florida (42 percent vs. 28 percent).
- Illegal immigrants are included in the SIPP. In a forthcoming report, we will estimate welfare use for immigrants by legal status. However, it is clear that the overwhelming majority of immigrant households using welfare are headed by legal immigrants.
- Most new legal immigrants are barred from welfare programs when they first arrive, and illegal immigrants are barred as well. But the ban applies to only some programs; most legal immigrants have been in the country long enough to qualify for at least some programs and the bar often does not apply to children; states often provide welfare to new immigrants on their own; naturalizing makes immigrants eligible for all programs; and, most important, immigrants (including illegal immigrants) can receive benefits on behalf of their U.S.-born children who are awarded U.S. citizenship at birth.
- The heavy use of welfare by less-educated immigrants has three important policy implications: 1) prior research indicates that illegal immigrants are overwhelmingly less-educated, so allowing them to stay in the country creates significant welfare costs; 2) by admitting large numbers of less-educated immigrants to join their relatives, the legal immigration system brings in many immigrants who are likely to access the welfare system; and 3) proposals to allow in more less-educated immigrants to fill low-wage jobs would create significant welfare costs.
Entire Study is here:
http://cis.org/Welfare-Use-Immigrant-Native-Households

Is this nation-wide, or in a specific place? Just curious-- not being hateful.
What is the point of this again?
Nativist recruitment ?
"Welfare" in the U.S. is entirely based on income. If immigrants qualify on the basis of their income, what are you bitching about ?
I guess you could give them some of your money.
I guess you missed that ILLEGAL immigrants are are ILLEGALLY taking advantage of welfare. That's worth bitching about. Actually the fact they are letting people in that can't support themselves (buying constituents with tax payer money) is also worth bitching about.
Any "comprehensive" immigration reform needs to include provisions for deporting illegals unable or unwilling to support themselves and should not offer a path to citizenship in these instances.
Thanks, Sean.
I was thinking about Louisville, and can't see it. But, when you look at it nationwide, it makes sense...
Or refuse to.
I'm sure he was using the term "Nigger" in it's larger literary sense, meaning all the ignorant peoples, not it's very narrow racial one.
Another interesting concept revealed in that statement is the greatest progressive liberal of the 20th century thinking of all his loyal followers (and party members) as ignorant people.
Can you really not understand why it might be a good idea to have as much information as possible about the real world results of our immigration policy?
The government is supposed to worry about things other than generating new Democratic voters you know.
Perhaps deportation could be a contingency based somehow on a withdrawal of welfare benefits ?
Undocumented immigrants do not qualify for welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and most other public benefits.
Most of these programs require proof of legal immigration status and under the 1996 welfare law, even legal immigrants cannot receive these benefits until they have been in the United States for more than five years
Astonishing!
Q:Do illegal immigrants cost $338.3 billion dollars a year? More than the Iraq war?
A:A chain e-mail that makes this claim is loaded with errors and misleading assertions. Published studies vary widely but put the cost to government at a small fraction of that total.
Telling lies to those who want to believe them hate-peddling to zeal-without-knowledge recipients a cancer in America.
The same lies persist, Sean they are timeless for those to whom they are aimed and foisted upon.
Statistics have a lifespan . Yours ran out . Calling new ones lies is an illtempered joke .
Whether recent "statistics" or those of yesteryear when they themselves are either bogus, or, the "conclusions" they allegedly represent are bogus
they're both bogus and, in this case, insidious.
Nothing wrong with my temper, Petey.
Can you find any lies in this study based on the Census Bureau data ?
What is that in response to? It certainly doesn't refute anything in the study of census data.
en they themselves are either bogus, or, the "conclusions" they allegedly represent are bo
Do you have anything to refute this article other than unsupported conclusions? I I know you hope the data is wrong, but that doesn't make it so. You know what they say about opinions.
It's in response to the myths that organizations like CIS propagate via misstated, miscalculated and/or misrepresentations of the so-called statistics they allegedly compile "objectively."
There are standard myths/lies about both legal and illegal immigrants that are transmitted for political reasons to xenophobes in the hope they will vote for the politicians who pander to their xenophobia.
From the seeded CIS article
And RE:
Immigrants come here to get "welfare"
Undocumented immigrants do not qualify for welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and most other public benefits.
Mac, I respect and like you and consider you a friend, but you have to come off that lie. It is an absolute lie, my friend. I don't give a good damn how many times you post the freaking "law" that says they don't qualify, they DO qualify.
There is a huge, bold-lettered sign in social services offices that clearly states in English and SPANISH that they are PROHIBITED BY LAW from asking for proof of citizenship from those seeking assistance.
We also have a law on our books that illegal aliens are not allowed to work in this country, they are not allowed to have drivers licenses, they cannot hold political offices, they cannot take the bar to become a lawyer, but hey, dude!.... all those freaking laws are IGNORED BY OUR GOVERNMENTS EACH AND EVERY ONE... LOCAL, STATE AND FEDERAL!
Please don't tell me again they cannot access those social services because two illegal aliens related to our illustrious president lived in this goddam country over twenty years without being citizens and both of them lived off social services... public housing, food stamps, the whole shebang!!!!
Yes, they have been quietly granted citizenship after it all came out, but for twenty years they had full access to social services many citizens of this country couldn't get within a thousand miles of even with all their proof of being Americans.
YES, THEY CAN HAVE THESE SOCIAL SERVICES WITHOUT BEING CITIZENS!
Medical services? What the hell, Mac? Have you been asleep or just not reading the articles about the illegals who flood the emergency rooms at night to be treated for things common citizens go to their doctors during the day for? Go to an emergency room and they HAVE to treat you, that's why a lot of hospitals have shut down... they ran out of operating money providing emergency treatment.
How the hell do you think all these anchor babies were born here to illegal aliens? Do you think they dropped them on the sidewalks or parking lots? Hell no, they had them in hospitals with full medical treatment provided the way it is to legal citizens. They asked them if they had insurance, but when they said, "I no understand English," they didn't kick the freaking aliens already in labor out the door, they provided medical care for them and their anchor babies until it was time to leave the hospital.
What, you didn't see the article about Michelle Obama doing her publicity tour of a day care center in Virginia where the five year old asked if her husband was going to deport her parents (coached by her Mom, I'm sure) and the follow up story? Her parents had come illegally to the US from Honduras, abandoning a four year old daughter to grief at being left behind with an aging and poverty stricken grandmother to come to the US, where they dropped this anchor child; the father was now a cab driver, the mother working at the day care center, they managed to have a decent life THANKS TO VARIOUS SOCIAL SERVICES and the salaries they earned now, and once a year skyped a visit with the nine year old they threw away like garbage so they could come to the US and start a new life without her.
Yes, illegals can get social services, Mac. Why do you think they come here in droves the way they do? We have over forty million here, they would be dying of starvation in the streets if they weren't getting free housing, food and medical care. They aren't ALL working.
mimi,
The law is the law; abuses of the law do no negate their existence.
IMMIGRANT ELIGIBILITY RESTRICTIONS
Categories of Immigrants: Qualified and Not Qualified
The 1996 welfare law created two categories of immigrants for benefits eligibility purposes: qualified and not qualified. Contrary to what these names suggest, the law excluded most people in both groups from eligibility for many benefits, with a few exceptions. The qualified immigrant category includes:
Lawful permanent residents, or LPRs (persons with green cards).
Refugees, persons granted asylum or withholding of deportation/removal, and conditional entrants.
Persons granted parole by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for a period of at least one year.
Cuban and Haitian entrants.
Certain abused immigrants, their children, and/or their parents . [ 5 ]
Certain victims of trafficking.[ 6 ]
All other immigrants, including undocumented immigrants as well as many persons lawfully present in the U.S., are considered not qualified.[ 7 ]
In 2000, Congress established a new category of noncitizens, victims of trafficking, who are eligible for federal public benefits to the same extent as refugees, regardless of whether they have a qualified immigrant status . [ 8 ] In 2003, Congress clarified that derivative beneficiaries listed on trafficking victims visa applications (spouses and children of adult trafficking victims; spouses, children, parents, and minor siblings of child victims) also may secure federal benefits.[ 9 ]
Federal Public Benefits Generally Denied to Not Qualified Immigrants
With some important exceptions detailed below, the law prohibits not qualified immigrants from enrolling in most federal public benefit programs.[ 10 ] Federal public benefits include a variety of safety-net services paid for by federal funds.[ 11 ] But the welfare laws definition does not specify which particular programs are covered by the term, leaving that clarification to each federal benefit granting agency.In 1998, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) published a notice clarifying which of its programs fall under the definition.[ 12 ] The list of 31 HHS programs includes Medicaid, the Childrens Health Insurance Program (CHIP), Medicare, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), Foster Care, Adoption Assistance, the Child Care and Development Fund, and the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program.
Exceptions to the Restrictions
The law includes important exceptions for certain types of services.Regardless of their status, not qualified immigrants remained eligible for emergency Medicaid [ 13 ]if they are otherwise eligible for their states Medicaid program.[ 14 ]The law does not restrict access to public health programs providing immunizations and/or treatment of communicable disease symptoms (whether or not those symptoms are caused by such a disease).School breakfast and lunch programs remain open to all children regardless of immigration status, and every state has opted to provide access to the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC).[ 15 ]Short-term noncash emergency disaster assistance remains available without regard to immigration status. Also exempted from the restrictions are other in-kind services necessary to protect life or safety, as long as no individual or household income qualification is required.In January 2001, the U.S. attorney general published a final order specifying the types of benefits that meet these criteria.The attorney generals list includes child and adult protective services; programs addressing weather emergencies and homelessness; shelters, soup kitchens, and meals-on-wheels; medical, public health, and mental health services necessary to protect life or safety; disability or substance abuse services necessary to protect life or safety; and programs to protect the life or safety of workers, children and youths, or community residents.[ 16 ]
Verification Rules
When a federal agency designates a program as a federal public benefit foreclosed to not qualified immigrants, the law requires the state or local agency to verify the immigration and citizenship status of all applicants.However, many federal agencies have not specified which of their programs provide federal public benefits.Until they do so, state and local agencies are not obligated to verify immigration status.Also, under an important exception contained in the 1996 immigration law, nonprofit charitable organizations are not required to determine, verify, or otherwise require proof of eligibility of any applicant for such benefits.This exception relates specifically to the immigrant benefits restrictions in the 1996 laws .[17 ]
Eligibility for Major Federal Benefit Programs
Congress restricted eligibility even for many qualified immigrants by arbitrarily distinguishing between those who entered the U.S. before or on or after the date the law was enacted, August 22, 1996.The law barred most immigrants who entered the U.S. on or after that date from federal means-tested public benefits during the five years after they secure qualified immigrant status.[ 18 ]Federal agencies clarified that federal means-tested public benefits are Medicaid (except for emergency care), CHIP, TANF, food stamps, and SSI.[ 19 ]
As you point out, illegal aliens have access to a wealth of welfare programs which they, along with legal immigrants, take full advantage of.
Amac, the census data shows what it shows. The majority of immigrant households use welfare. End of story.
Everything else is spin.