╌>

Study: Majority of Households Headed by Immigrant (Legal and Illegal) Use Welfare

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  26 comments

Study: Majority of Households Headed by Immigrant (Legal and  Illegal) Use Welfare

This study is the first in recent years to examine immigrant (legal and illegal) and native welfare use using the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP). While its complexity makes it difficult to use, the survey is widely regarded as providing the most accurate picture of welfare participation. The SIPP shows immigrant households use welfare at significantly higher rates than native households, even higher than indicated by other Census surveys.

  • In 2012, 51 percent of households headed by an immigrant (legal or illegal) reported that they used at least one welfare program during the year, compared to 30 percent of native households. Welfare in this study includes Medicaid and cash, food, and housing programs.

  • Welfare use is high for both new arrivals and well-established immigrants. Of households headed by immigrants who have been in the country for more than two decades, 48 percent access welfare.

  • No single program explains immigrants' higher overall welfare use. For example, not counting subsidized school lunch, welfare use is still 46 percent for immigrants and 28 percent for natives. Not counting Medicaid, welfare use is 44 percent for immigrants and 26 percent for natives.

  • Immigrant households have much higher use of food programs (40 percent vs. 22 percent for natives) and Medicaid (42 percent vs. 23 percent). Immigrant use of cash programs is somewhat higher than natives (12 percent vs. 10 percent) and use of housing programs is similar to natives.

  • Welfare use varies among immigrant groups. Households headed by immigrants from Central America and Mexico (73 percent), the Caribbean (51 percent), and Africa (48 percent) have the highest overall welfare use. Those from East Asia (32 percent), Europe (26 percent), and South Asia (17 percent) have the lowest.

  • Many immigrants struggle to support their children, and a large share of welfare is received on behalf of U.S.-born children. However, even immigrant households without children have significantly higher welfare use than native households without children 30 percent vs. 20 percent.

  • The welfare system is designed to help low-income workers, especially those with children, and this describes many immigrant households. In 2012, 51 percent of immigrant households with one or more workers accessed one or more welfare programs, as did 28 percent of working native households.

  • The large share of immigrants with low levels of education and resulting low incomes partly explains their high use rates. In 2012, 76 percent of households headed by an immigrant who had not graduated high school used one or more welfare programs, as did 63 percent of households headed by an immigrant with only a high school education.

  • The high rates of immigrant welfare use are not entirely explained by their lower education levels. Households headed by college-educated immigrants have significantly higher welfare use than households headed by college-educated natives 26 percent vs. 13 percent.

  • In the four top immigrant-receiving states, use of welfare by immigrant households is significantly higher than that of native households: California (55 percent vs. 30 percent), New York (59 percent vs. 33 percent), Texas (57 percent vs. 34 percent), and Florida (42 percent vs. 28 percent).

  • Illegal immigrants are included in the SIPP. In a forthcoming report, we will estimate welfare use for immigrants by legal status. However, it is clear that the overwhelming majority of immigrant households using welfare are headed by legal immigrants.

  • Most new legal immigrants are barred from welfare programs when they first arrive, and illegal immigrants are barred as well. But the ban applies to only some programs; most legal immigrants have been in the country long enough to qualify for at least some programs and the bar often does not apply to children; states often provide welfare to new immigrants on their own; naturalizing makes immigrants eligible for all programs; and, most important, immigrants (including illegal immigrants) can receive benefits on behalf of their U.S.-born children who are awarded U.S. citizenship at birth.

  • The heavy use of welfare by less-educated immigrants has three important policy implications: 1) prior research indicates that illegal immigrants are overwhelmingly less-educated, so allowing them to stay in the country creates significant welfare costs; 2) by admitting large numbers of less-educated immigrants to join their relatives, the legal immigration system brings in many immigrants who are likely to access the welfare system; and 3) proposals to allow in more less-educated immigrants to fill low-wage jobs would create significant welfare costs.

Entire Study is here:

http://cis.org/Welfare-Use-Immigrant-Native-Households


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Is this nation-wide, or in a specific place? Just curious-- not being hateful.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

What is the point of this again?

Nativist recruitment ?

"Welfare" in the U.S. is entirely based on income. If immigrants qualify on the basis of their income, what are you bitching about ?

I guess you could give them some of your money.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
nationwide.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I guess you missed that ILLEGAL immigrants are are ILLEGALLY taking advantage of welfare. That's worth bitching about. Actually the fact they are letting people in that can't support themselves (buying constituents with tax payer money) is also worth bitching about.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Any "comprehensive" immigration reform needs to include provisions for deporting illegals unable or unwilling to support themselves and should not offer a path to citizenship in these instances.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thanks, Sean.

I was thinking about Louisville, and can't see it. But, when you look at it nationwide, it makes sense...

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
I am already giving them money. Your deflection is sad.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

.....that can't support themselves (buying constituents with tax payer money)....

Or refuse to.

"I'll have those niggers voting democrat for the next two hundred years!" -- Lyndon Baines Johnson, 36th president of the United States when asked about the intent of the welfare policies in his "Great Society" plan.

I'm sure he was using the term "Nigger" in it's larger literary sense, meaning all the ignorant peoples, not it's very narrow racial one.

Another interesting concept revealed in that statement is the greatest progressive liberal of the 20th century thinking of all his loyal followers (and party members) as ignorant people.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Can you really not understand why it might be a good idea to have as much information as possible about the real world results of our immigration policy?

The government is supposed to worry about things other than generating new Democratic voters you know.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Perhaps deportation could be a contingency based somehow on a withdrawal of welfare benefits ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Undocumented immigrants do not qualify for welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and most other public benefits.

Most of these programs require proof of legal immigration status and under the 1996 welfare law, even legal immigrants cannot receive these benefits until they have been in the United States for more than five years

Here are 5 myths about undocumented immigrants, and why they're wrong.

Myth # 1: They don't pay taxes

Undocumented immigrants are already U.S. taxpayers.

Collectively, they paid an estimated $10.6 billion to state and local taxes in 2010, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), a research organization that works on tax policy issues. Contributions varied by state. In Montana they contributed $2 million. In California, more than $2.2 billion. On average they pay about 6.4% of their income in state and local taxes, ITEP said.

A 2007 Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report on the impact of undocumented immigrants on the budgets of local and state governments cited IRS figures showing that 50% to 75% of the about 11 million unauthorized U.S. immigrants file and pay income taxes each year.

A 2013 CBO analysis of the failed bipartisan bill introduced by the so-called "gang of 8" that would have created a path to legal status for many undocumented immigrants found that increasing legal immigration would increase government spending on refundable tax credits, Medicaid and health insurance subsidies, among other federal benefits. But it would also create even more tax revenue by way of income and payroll taxes. That could reduce deficits by $175 billion over the first 10 years and by at least $700 billion in the second decade.

ITEP estimates that allowing certain immigrants to stay in the country and work legally would boost state and local tax contributions by $2 billion a year.

Related: America's most dangerous jobs.

Myth # 2: They don't pay into Social Security

The truth is that undocumented immigrants contribute more in payroll taxes than they will ever consume in public benefits.

Take Social Security. According to the Social Security Administration (SSA), unauthorized immigrants -- who are not eligible to receive Social Security benefits -- have paid an eye-popping $100 billion into the fund over the past decade.

"They are paying an estimated $15 billion a year into Social Security with no intention of ever collecting benefits," Stephen Goss, chief actuary of the SSA told CNNMoney. "Without the estimated 3.1 million undocumented immigrants paying into the system, Social Security would have entered persistent shortfall of tax revenue to cover payouts starting in 2009," he said.

As the baby boom generation ages and retires, immigrant workers are key to shoring up Social Security and counteracting the effects of the decline in U.S.-born workers paying into the system, Goss said.

Without immigrants, the Social Security Board of Trustees projects that the system will no longer be able to pay the full promised benefits by 2037.

Myth #3: They drain the system

Undocumented immigrants do not qualify for welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and most other public benefits. Most of these programs require proof of legal immigration status and under the 1996 welfare law, even legal immigrants cannot receive these benefits until they have been in the United States for more than five years.

Related: Part-time jobs put millions in poverty or close to it.

Non-citizen immigrant adults and children are about 25% less likely to be signed up for Medicaid than their poor native-born equivalents and are also 37% less likely to receive food stamps, according to a 2013 study by the Cato Institute.

Citizen children of illegal immigrants -- often derogatorily referred to as "anchor babies" -- do qualify for social benefits. Also, undocumented immigrants are eligible for schooling and emergency medical care. Currently, the average unlawful immigrant household costs taxpayers $14,387 per household, according to a recent report by The Heritage Foundation. But in its 2013 "Immigration Myths and Facts" report, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce says most economists see providing these benefits as an investment for the future, when these children become workers and taxpayers.

A CBO report on the Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2007 concluded that a path to legalization for immigrants would increase federal revenues by $48 billion. Such a plan would see $23 billion in increased costs from the use of public services, but ultimately, it would produce a surplus of $25 billion for government coffers, CBO said.

Myth # 4: They take American jobs

The American economy needs immigrant workers.

The belief that immigrants take jobs that can otherwise be filled by hard-working Americans has been disputed by an overwhelming number of economic research studies and data.

Related: Four immigration fixes that could turbo-charge tech.

Removing the approximately 8 million unauthorized workers in the United States would not automatically create 8 million job openings for unemployed Americans, said Daniel Griswold, director of the Cato Institute's Center for Trade Policy Studies, in his 2011 testimony before the House Judiciary Sub-committee on Immigration Policy and Enforcement.

The reason, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, is two-fold. For one, removing millions of undocumented workers from the economy would also remove millions of entrepreneurs, consumers and taxpayers. The economy would actually lose jobs. Second, native-born workers and immigrant workers tend to possess different skills that often complement one another.

According to Griswold, immigrants, regardless of status, fill the growing gap between expanding low-skilled jobs and the shrinking pool of native-born Americans who are willing to take such jobs. By facilitating the growth of such sectors as retail, agriculture, landscaping, restaurants, and hotels, low-skilled immigrants have enabled those sectors to expand, attract investment, and create middle-class jobs in management, design and engineering, bookkeeping, marketing and other areas that employ U.S. citizens.

America's unions support the president's executive action. "For far too long, our broken immigration system has allowed employers to drive down wages and working conditions in our country," the AFL-CIO says on its website. "The brunt of the impact has been born by immigrant workers, who face the highest rates of wage theft, sexual harassment, and death and injury on the job."

Myth # 5: It's just a matter of following the law

Many Americans want immigrants to enter the country legally.

But under current immigration laws, there are very few options for legal immigration, the costs are increasingly prohibitive and the wait for any kind of status can be long and frustrating.

Related: I created 7 jobs and the US tried to deport me.

According to the State Department, that imaginary "immigration line" is already 4.4 million people long and depending on the type of visa sought and the country of origin, the wait can be years to decades long. In some countries, such as the Philippines and Mexico people have been waiting over 20 years for approval of a family-sponsored visa.

Immigrants can legally get to the U.S by being sponsored by an employer or a family member, they can enter the country as refugees, or they could receive one of the selectively distributed professional or diversity visas. The Diversity Visa Program makes 55,000 green cards available to persons from countries with low rates of immigration to the U.S.

According to the State Department, the fees to obtain permanent U.S. visas can range from $200 to over $700, excluding legal fees. Plus, there are visa quotas which limits immigration from any given country.

In many poor, violence-ridden countries, or in cases where parents are separated from their children, immigrants say the wait is unbearable, leaving many to resort to illegal border crossing.

That journey can be expensive and deadly.

Smugglers charge anywhere from $3000 to upwards of $70,000 depending on country of origin, mode of transport and distance travelled according to the Mexican Migration Project, a multidisciplinary research effort between investigators in Mexico and the U.S.

Many don't make it. According to federal records, more than 6,000 immigrants have died crossing the southern border since 1998

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

Astonishing!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Thanks for your outdated list.This comes from US Census data. Feel free to dispute the actual data contained in the report.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Q:Do illegal immigrants cost $338.3 billion dollars a year? More than the Iraq war?

A:A chain e-mail that makes this claim is loaded with errors and misleading assertions. Published studies vary widely but put the cost to government at a small fraction of that total.

FULLQUESTION

I wonder if much of this is true? Is this on your radar screen?

This is astounding and infuriating. Why isnt this in the papers? Please read and pass it on.

Click to expand/collapse the full text

FULLANSWER

This chain e-mail has been forwarded to us by readers many times over the past year. The most recent version adds a new angle, claiming that the amount of money taxpayers spend on illegal immigrants would be enough to "stimulate the economy." But no matter the spin, the e-mail is rife with errors.

It also contains several red flags that should tip off readers that this is more bogus than believable. For one thing, the figures given dont add up to a "whopping $338.3 billion dollars a year" spent on illegal immigrants in the U.S., as the e-mail claims.

The e-mail lists 14 claims about illegal immigrants, all of which were included in a longer list penned by anti-immigration activist Frosty Wooldridge and published on the conservative Web site NewswithViews.com on Jan. 22, 2007. Another NewswithViews columnist, Lynn Stuter, included Wooldridges list, with some updated links, in an article posted on April 15, 2008.

The source cited for at least nine of the items is either the conservative Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) or the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), both of which call for more restrictive immigration laws. CIS spokesman Bryan Griffith told us that he had never seen the e-mail but that he suspected something was out there because of occasional surges in traffic that forced him to rewrite Web pages. When told about the e-mails contents and conclusion of a $338.3 billion yearly cost, he responded that CIS "never said anything of the like and is not going to comment on a chain e-mail that is in no way scientific."

The e-mail also continually blurs the important distinction between legal and illegal immigrants a sign of sloppy and untrustworthy work.

Summary

Because were gluttons for punishment, weve gone through each claim in turn and report on each in detail farther down. But here are a few highlights (or lowlights) of what we found:

  • The e-mail includes a link to a CIS report that contradicts some of the e-mails own claims. The report found that illegal immigrant welfare use "tends to be very low." It also estimates the total federal net cost of households headed by illegal immigrants at under $10.4 billion, a small fraction of what this message claims.
  • One "paper" that is cited is a non-peer-reviewed, non-scientific study that essentially fabricates a number for illegal immigrant criminals.
  • Five of the links lead to transcripts of Lou Dobbs cable television show, which fulminates regularly against illegal immigration and is hardly a neutral source. Furthermore, in all instances, the e-mail then takes the original Dobbs reporting out of context.

So, how much do illegal immigrants cost federal, state and local governments in the U.S.? Estimates vary widely, and no consensus exists. The Urban Institute put the net national cost at $1.9 billion in 1992; a Rice University professor, whose work the Urban Institute criticized, said it was $19.3 billion in 1993. More recently, a 2007 report by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office examined 29 reports on state and local costs published over 15 years in an attempt to answer this question. CBO concluded that most of the estimates determined that illegal immigrants impose a net cost to state and local governments but "that impact is most likely modest." CBO said "no agreement exists as to the size of, or even the best way of measuring, that cost on a national level."

The Details

For those who want more, we take on each of the e-mails claims in order:

1. "$11 Billion to $22 billion is spent on welfare to illegal aliens each year."

This item is completely false. The link given to "verify" the claim actually leads to an issue brief by the conservative Federation for American Immigration Reform . But the FAIR brief says nothing of the sort. It says: "Each year, state governments spend an estimated $11 billion to $22 billion to provide welfare to immigrants." Thats welfare payments in 2001 to all immigrants both legal and illegal plus households including U.S. citizens if they are headed by a person who was born outside the United States.

The site says the FAIR report was last updated in October 2002, but a footnote credits this statistic to a March 2003 report from the Center for Immigration Studies . CIS began as an off-shoot of FAIR. But the CIS report doesnt actually say anything about $11 billion or $22 billion. And it explains that its references to "immigrant households" include persons here legally and persons born outside the U.S.

CIS report: Like the Census Bureau, and other academic work that has examined this question, this report looks at welfare use by immigrant and native households. Households are defined as immigrant or native based on the nativity of the household head. As already indicated, this report uses the terms immigrant and foreign-born synonymously.

CIS estimated that welfare payments to illegal immigrant households averaged $1,040 per household in 2001, mainly Medicaid "on behalf of their U.S.-born children." But the report did not attempt to come up with a total for all such households.

2. "$2.2 Billion dollars a year is spent on food assistance programs such as food stamps, WIC, and free school lunches for illegal aliens."

3. "$2.5 Billion dollars a year is spent on Medicaid for illegal aliens."

These figures supposedly come from a 2004 report by CIS that estimated the costs to the federal government of households headed by illegal immigrants in 2002. But the CIS report actually put the costs of food stamp, WIC and free school lunch programs to "illegal alien households" at $1.9 billion, not the $2.2 billion claimed in the e-mail. The $2.5 billion figure for Medicaid to such households is quoted accurately, but again, much of this was in benefits for U.S.-born children, who are citizens.

Most interesting is that the CIS report includes a total net cost estimate to the federal government for illegal immigrants of just under $10.4 billion for the year, after accounting for the taxes these immigrants paid. That doesnt include any potential costs to state or local governments, but its a far cry from this e-mails cost claim of $338.3 billion.

CIS report: Households headed by illegal aliens imposed more than $26.3 billion in costs on the federal government in 2002 and paid only $16 billion in taxes, creating a net fiscal deficit of almost $10.4 billion, or $2,700 per illegal household.

Even CIS figures have been questioned by other researchers. The Urban Institute reviewed a related 2003 CISpaper and concluded that its "methods overstate the percentage of the population receiving Medicaid and the share of immigrants on Medicaid, resulting in misleading conclusions about welfare use among immigrants."

Even so, the CIS report actually rebuts claims repeated by this chain e-mail:

CIS:Our findings show that many of the preconceived notions about the fiscal impact of illegal households turn out to be inaccurate. In terms of welfare use, receipt of cash assistance programs tends to be very low, while Medicaid use, though significant, is still less than for other households. Only use of food assistance programs is significantly higher than that of the rest of the population. Also, contrary to the perceptions that illegal aliens dont pay payroll taxes, we estimate that more than half of illegals work on the books.

4. "$12 Billion dollars a year is spent on primary and secondary school education for children here illegally and they cannot speak a word of English!"

5."$17 Billion dollars a year is spent for education for the American-born children of illegal aliens, known as anchor babies."

Both links given to "verify" these claims lead to an April 1, 2006, episode of "Lou Dobbs Tonight" on CNN. During the show, correspondent Christine Romans cited both of these stats and attributed them to FAIR. A FAIR research paper from 2005 does include these cost projections, but a closer look shows that the underlying assumptions are inflated or unsupported.

The FAIR report starts with the presumption that there are "1.5 million school-aged illegal immigrants residing in the United States." That figure is attributed to an Urban Institute presentation that doesnt actually say that. Instead, the Urban Institute said: "We estimate that there are about 1.4 million undocumented children under 18 with about 1.1 million of school age (5 -19)."

The FAIR report also assumes there are 2 million "U.S.-born siblings" of illegal immigrant families. However, the Urban Institute makes no estimates of U.S.-born siblings and FAIRgives no citation for its figure. And in any case, again, those U.S.-born children of illegal immigrants are themselves U.S. citizens and not "illegal aliens."

6. "$3 Million Dollars a DAY is spent to incarcerate illegal aliens."

7. "30% percent of all Federal Prison inmates are illegal aliens."

Both of these claims can be traced back to that same April 1, 2006, episode of "Lou Dobbs Tonight" on CNN, in the same segment, with the same correspondent, Christine Romans. But the e-mail misrepresents what Romans said. She gave figures for people who are "not U.S. citizens," a category that would include legal residents as well as "illegal aliens."

Romans said that "according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, 30 percent of federal prisoners are not U.S. citizens," adding that "most are thought to be illegal aliens."Actually, t he Federal Bureau of Prisons does not keep figures on illegal immigrants. What solid numbers we can find point to a much smaller figure. A Department of Justice report from 2003 found that only 1.6 percent of the state and federal prison populations was under Immigration and Customs Enforcement jurisdiction, and thus known to be illegal immigrants. Half of these prisoners were detained only because they were here illegally, not for other crimes.

The Bureau of Prisons does track prisoners by offense when information is available. By that metric, 10.7 percent of prisoners in federal jails were incarcerated for immigration offenses in 2009. In 2006, when Romans gave her report, the figure was 10.2 percent.

The "$3 million dollar a day" figure is based on the false assumption that 30 percent of all inmates are illegal immigrants, and thus is greatly inflated.

8. "$90 Billion Dollars a year is spent on illegal aliens for Welfare & social services by the American taxpayers."

The link to "verify" this claim is dead. However, we found a transcript of a Lou Dobbs episode on Oct. 29, 2006, in which Robert Rector of the conservative Heritage Foundation made the following statement:

Robert Rector, Oct. 29, 2006: Well, assuming that we have about 11 million immigrants in the U.S., the net cost or the total cost of services and benefits provided to them, education, welfare, general social services would be about $90 billion a year, and they would pay very little in taxes. Its important to remember that at least half of illegal immigrants are high school dropouts.

We checked with Rector, who said he was referring to both legal and illegal low-skill immigrant households (those headed by someone who doesnt have a high school diploma). His research also looked at many forms of government spending per household, including money spent on parks and transportation.

9. "$200 Billion Dollars a year in suppressed American wages are caused by the illegal aliens."

Again, this is from that same April 1, 2006, Lou Dobbs episode. On the show, Dobbs said that "estimates by the most authoritative and recent study put the suppressed wages at $200 billion a year, as a result of immigration, both legal and illegal." The e-mail continues its practice of ignoring any distinction between legal and illegal immigration.

We couldnt find any study that supported Dobbs figure.

10. "The illegal aliens in the United States have a crime rate thats two and a half times that of white non-illegal aliens. In particular, their children, are going to make a huge additional crime problem in the US"

This is false. The "verify" link leads to yet another transcript of Lou Dobbs speaking with Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation. This one is dated June 12, 2006, and Rector says, "Hispanics in the United States have a crime rate thats two and a half times that of white non-Hispanics."

Rector said Hispanics, not illegal immigrants, as the e-mail alleges. Considering there are 45.4 million Hispanics in the country, and an estimated 11.9 million illegal immigrants , the distinction is notable. Rectors statistic for all Hispanics is correct, according to a 2003 report from the Justice Department.

11. " During the year of 2005 there were 4 to 10 MILLION illegal aliens that crossed our Southern Border also, as many as 19,500 illegal aliens from Terrorist Countries. Millions of pounds of drugs, cocaine, meth, heroin and marijuana, crossed into the U. S from the Southern border. "

The link goes to a 2006 report written by the Republican staff of the House Subcommittee on Investigations of the Committee on Homeland Security. To start, the "19,500" number of "illegal aliens from Terrorist Countries" is nowhere to be found in this report. In fact, the report estimates the number of illegal immigrants coming over the southern border from countries known to harbor terrorists to be in the "hundreds." Weve seen a similar scare tactic used previously in ads advocating for a border fence .

And the 4 million to 10 million statistic is extrapolated using some imprecise reasoning. The committee report figures that since "Border Patrol apprehended approximately 1.2 million illegal aliens" in 2005 and since "Federal law enforcement estimates that 10 percent to 30 percent of illegal aliens are actually apprehended," that "therefore, in 2005, as many as 10 to 4 million [sic] illegal aliens crossed into the United States." That simplistic math produces a figure starkly different from more widely accepted estimates. The Pew Hispanic Center estimated that in 2005 there were 11.1 million illegal immigrants total, living in the United States. The center also estimated that about 500,000 illegal immigrants a year came to the U.S. from 2005 to 2008.

12. "The National Policy Institute, estimated that the total cost of mass deportation would be between $206 and $230 billion or an average cost of between $41 and $46 billion annually over a five year period. "

No, it didnt. The National Policy Institute, a group that says it promotes the rights of "white Americans, " ironically was citing figures from the liberal Center for American Progress in a report that argued against mass deportation of undocumented workers. CAP said such deportation would cost more per year than the entire Department of Homeland Security budget, illustrating "the false allure of deportation as a response to our broken immigration system."

13. "In 2006 illegal aliens sent home $45 BILLION in remittances back to their countries of origin."

This is another bogus figure. The emails link leads to the original Frosty Wooldridge article, which in turn cites as its source for this figure a link to a Contra-Costa Times article, which is no longer working. Nevertheless, we were able to find a news release from the Inter-American Development Bank stating Latin American immigrants sent $45 billion in remittances in 2006. But that figure applies to all immigrants, including legal residents.

14. "The Dark Side of Illegal Immigration: Nearly One Million Sex Crimes Committed by Illegal Immigrants In The United States."

Once again, the "verify" link is dead. But a little Internet research found the article cited . An independently published, non-peer-reviewed study did estimate that nearly a million sex crimes have been committed by illegal immigrants over a seven-year period, but it employs some highly creative math and interesting assumptions to get there. The "study" is actually a pretty good case study in bad research.

The author assumes that 2 percent of illegal immigrants are sex offenders after "examining ICE reports and public records," but does not say how that figure was calculated. A bibliography cites miscellaneous Immigration and Customs Enforcement press releases and media accounts of instances of apprehending illegal immigrants who were sex offenders (seemingly manufacturing a "rate" based on anecdotal evidence). The author then makes no distinction between male and female illegal immigrants when estimating the number that are "sex offenders."

As weve said before , anonymous chain e-mails making dramatic claims are quite likely to be false. And that goes even for those that may seem to cite legitimate sources. This one is yet another good candidate for the "delete" key.

Justin Bank

Sources

Steven A. Camarota, Back Where We Started: An Examination of Trends in Immigrant Welfar... , Center for Immigration Studies, March 2003.

Camarota, Steven A., " The High Cost of Cheap Labor: Illegal Immigration and the Federal B... ," Center for Immigration Studies, August 2004.

Immigration and Welfare ," Federation for American Immigration Reform, Oct 2002.

A Line in the Sand: Confronting the Threat at the Southwest Border ," prepared by the Majority Staff of House Committee on Homeland Security, Subcommittee on Investigations, Nov 2006.

Goyle, Rajeev, " Deporting the Undocumented: A Cost Assessment ," Center for American Progress. 26 July 2005.

Sending Money Home: Leveraging the Development Impact of Remittances ," Inter-American Development Bank. 18 Oct 2006.

Schurman-Kauflin, Dr. Deborah, " The Dark Side of Illegal Immigration: Nearly One Million Sex Crimes... ," Violent Crimes Institute, 2006.

Martin, Jack, " Breaking the Piggy Bank: How Illegal Immigration is Sending Schools... ," Federation for American Immigration Reform. June 2005.

Fix, Michael and Passel, Jeffrey, " U.S. ImmigrationTrends and Implications for Schools ," Immigration Studies Program, The Urban Institute, 2003.

"Estimates of the Unauthorized Immigrant Population Residing in the United States: 1990-2000," Office of Policy Planning, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service, January 2003.

"Table 169, Current Expenditure Per Pupil in Fall Enrollment in Public Elementary and Secondary Schools, by State: 1969-70 to 1999-00," Digest of Education Statistics 2002, National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education.

Telling lies to those who want to believe them hate-peddling to zeal-without-knowledge recipients a cancer in America.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Thanks for your outdated list.Thanks for your outdated list.

The same lies persist, Sean they are timeless for those to whom they are aimed and foisted upon.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Statistics have a lifespan . Yours ran out . Calling new ones lies is an illtempered joke .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Statistics have a lifespan . Yours ran out . Calling new ones lies is an illtempered joke .

Whether recent "statistics" or those of yesteryear when they themselves are either bogus, or, the "conclusions" they allegedly represent are bogus

they're both bogus and, in this case, insidious.

Nothing wrong with my temper, Petey.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

This study is the first in recent years to examine immigrant (legal and illegal) and native welfare use using the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP).

Can you find any lies in this study based on the Census Bureau data ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The Center for Immigration Studies refers to itself as a nonprofit, nonpartisan, independent research organization, boasting the puzzling tagline Low Immigration, Pro Immigrant. One of CISs founders, John Tanton, a retired ophthamologist from Michigan and known anti-immgration activist, was also behind Numbers USA, an immigration reduction organization that, according to The New York Times , helped kill President George W. Bushs attempt at comprehensive immigration reform in 2007. Another one of Tantons groups, the Federation for American Immigration Reform, or FAIR, helped draft Arizonas controversial SB-1070, permitting police to detain illegal immigrants. Numbers USA, FAIR, and CIS were all part of the effort that successfully defeated the DREAM Act in the Senate in 2010.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

What is that in response to? It certainly doesn't refute anything in the study of census data.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

en they themselves are either bogus, or, the "conclusions" they allegedly represent are bo


Do you have anything to refute this article other than unsupported conclusions? I I know you hope the data is wrong, but that doesn't make it so. You know what they say about opinions.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What is that in response to? It certainly doesn't refute anything in the study of census data.

It's in response to the myths that organizations like CIS propagate via misstated, miscalculated and/or misrepresentations of the so-called statistics they allegedly compile "objectively."

There are standard myths/lies about both legal and illegal immigrants that are transmitted for political reasons to xenophobes in the hope they will vote for the politicians who pander to their xenophobia.

From the seeded CIS article

In 2012, 51 percent of immigrant households with one or more workers accessed one or more welfare programs, as did 28 percent of working native households.

They can receive schooling and emergency medical care, but not welfare or food stamps . -

See more at:

And RE:

Immigrants come here to get "welfare"

  • Immigrants come to work and to reunite with family members.
  • Immigrant labor-force participation is consistently higher than native-born, and immigrant workers make up a larger share of the U.S. labor force (12.4%) than they do the U.S. population (11.5%). Moreover, the ratio between immigrant use of public benefits and the amount of taxes they pay is consistently favorable to the U.S., unless the study was undertaken by an anti-immigrant group. One study estimates that immigrants earn nearly $240 billion a year. Studies find that immigrant tax payments total $20 to $85 billion more than the amount of government services they use. [4]
  • Since the welfare reform of 1996, when limits were implemented cutting off benefits to two years consecutively or five years cumulatively, this is a bogus accusation.
  • To immigrate into the US, you must have a sponsor (generally the family member, such as the spouse, bringing you into the country) who will testify, and provide proof, that he or she has enough money to support you, if you are unable to support yourself, or if you lose your job.
  • This agreement means that until you naturalize as a U.S. citizen or have been a taxpayer for 10 years, your sponsor's income will be taken into consideration in deciding whether you are poor enough to qualify for means-tested benefits, and that if you do take those benefits, the government can sue your sponsor to recover those costs. You can also sue your sponsor if they fail to support you at the poverty level.
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Undocumented immigrants do not qualify for welfare, food stamps, Medicaid, and most other public benefits.

Mac, I respect and like you and consider you a friend, but you have to come off that lie. It is an absolute lie, my friend. I don't give a good damn how many times you post the freaking "law" that says they don't qualify, they DO qualify.

There is a huge, bold-lettered sign in social services offices that clearly states in English and SPANISH that they are PROHIBITED BY LAW from asking for proof of citizenship from those seeking assistance.

We also have a law on our books that illegal aliens are not allowed to work in this country, they are not allowed to have drivers licenses, they cannot hold political offices, they cannot take the bar to become a lawyer, but hey, dude!.... all those freaking laws are IGNORED BY OUR GOVERNMENTS EACH AND EVERY ONE... LOCAL, STATE AND FEDERAL!

Please don't tell me again they cannot access those social services because two illegal aliens related to our illustrious president lived in this goddam country over twenty years without being citizens and both of them lived off social services... public housing, food stamps, the whole shebang!!!!

Yes, they have been quietly granted citizenship after it all came out, but for twenty years they had full access to social services many citizens of this country couldn't get within a thousand miles of even with all their proof of being Americans.

YES, THEY CAN HAVE THESE SOCIAL SERVICES WITHOUT BEING CITIZENS!

Medical services? What the hell, Mac? Have you been asleep or just not reading the articles about the illegals who flood the emergency rooms at night to be treated for things common citizens go to their doctors during the day for? Go to an emergency room and they HAVE to treat you, that's why a lot of hospitals have shut down... they ran out of operating money providing emergency treatment.

How the hell do you think all these anchor babies were born here to illegal aliens? Do you think they dropped them on the sidewalks or parking lots? Hell no, they had them in hospitals with full medical treatment provided the way it is to legal citizens. They asked them if they had insurance, but when they said, "I no understand English," they didn't kick the freaking aliens already in labor out the door, they provided medical care for them and their anchor babies until it was time to leave the hospital.

What, you didn't see the article about Michelle Obama doing her publicity tour of a day care center in Virginia where the five year old asked if her husband was going to deport her parents (coached by her Mom, I'm sure) and the follow up story? Her parents had come illegally to the US from Honduras, abandoning a four year old daughter to grief at being left behind with an aging and poverty stricken grandmother to come to the US, where they dropped this anchor child; the father was now a cab driver, the mother working at the day care center, they managed to have a decent life THANKS TO VARIOUS SOCIAL SERVICES and the salaries they earned now, and once a year skyped a visit with the nine year old they threw away like garbage so they could come to the US and start a new life without her.

Yes, illegals can get social services, Mac. Why do you think they come here in droves the way they do? We have over forty million here, they would be dying of starvation in the streets if they weren't getting free housing, food and medical care. They aren't ALL working.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

mimi,

The law is the law; abuses of the law do no negate their existence.

IMMIGRANT ELIGIBILITY RESTRICTIONS

Categories of Immigrants: Qualified and Not Qualified

The 1996 welfare law created two categories of immigrants for benefits eligibility purposes: qualified and not qualified. Contrary to what these names suggest, the law excluded most people in both groups from eligibility for many benefits, with a few exceptions. The qualified immigrant category includes:

  • Lawful permanent residents, or LPRs (persons with green cards).

  • Refugees, persons granted asylum or withholding of deportation/removal, and conditional entrants.

  • Persons granted parole by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for a period of at least one year.

  • Cuban and Haitian entrants.

  • Certain abused immigrants, their children, and/or their parents . [ 5 ]

  • Certain victims of trafficking.[ 6 ]

All other immigrants, including undocumented immigrants as well as many persons lawfully present in the U.S., are considered not qualified.[ 7 ]

In 2000, Congress established a new category of noncitizens, victims of trafficking, who are eligible for federal public benefits to the same extent as refugees, regardless of whether they have a qualified immigrant status . [ 8 ] In 2003, Congress clarified that derivative beneficiaries listed on trafficking victims visa applications (spouses and children of adult trafficking victims; spouses, children, parents, and minor siblings of child victims) also may secure federal benefits.[ 9 ]

Federal Public Benefits Generally Denied to Not Qualified Immigrants

With some important exceptions detailed below, the law prohibits not qualified immigrants from enrolling in most federal public benefit programs.[ 10 ] Federal public benefits include a variety of safety-net services paid for by federal funds.[ 11 ] But the welfare laws definition does not specify which particular programs are covered by the term, leaving that clarification to each federal benefit granting agency.In 1998, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) published a notice clarifying which of its programs fall under the definition.[ 12 ] The list of 31 HHS programs includes Medicaid, the Childrens Health Insurance Program (CHIP), Medicare, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), Foster Care, Adoption Assistance, the Child Care and Development Fund, and the Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program.

Exceptions to the Restrictions

The law includes important exceptions for certain types of services.Regardless of their status, not qualified immigrants remained eligible for emergency Medicaid [ 13 ]if they are otherwise eligible for their states Medicaid program.[ 14 ]The law does not restrict access to public health programs providing immunizations and/or treatment of communicable disease symptoms (whether or not those symptoms are caused by such a disease).School breakfast and lunch programs remain open to all children regardless of immigration status, and every state has opted to provide access to the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC).[ 15 ]Short-term noncash emergency disaster assistance remains available without regard to immigration status. Also exempted from the restrictions are other in-kind services necessary to protect life or safety, as long as no individual or household income qualification is required.In January 2001, the U.S. attorney general published a final order specifying the types of benefits that meet these criteria.The attorney generals list includes child and adult protective services; programs addressing weather emergencies and homelessness; shelters, soup kitchens, and meals-on-wheels; medical, public health, and mental health services necessary to protect life or safety; disability or substance abuse services necessary to protect life or safety; and programs to protect the life or safety of workers, children and youths, or community residents.[ 16 ]

Verification Rules

When a federal agency designates a program as a federal public benefit foreclosed to not qualified immigrants, the law requires the state or local agency to verify the immigration and citizenship status of all applicants.However, many federal agencies have not specified which of their programs provide federal public benefits.Until they do so, state and local agencies are not obligated to verify immigration status.Also, under an important exception contained in the 1996 immigration law, nonprofit charitable organizations are not required to determine, verify, or otherwise require proof of eligibility of any applicant for such benefits.This exception relates specifically to the immigrant benefits restrictions in the 1996 laws .[17 ]

Eligibility for Major Federal Benefit Programs

Congress restricted eligibility even for many qualified immigrants by arbitrarily distinguishing between those who entered the U.S. before or on or after the date the law was enacted, August 22, 1996.The law barred most immigrants who entered the U.S. on or after that date from federal means-tested public benefits during the five years after they secure qualified immigrant status.[ 18 ]Federal agencies clarified that federal means-tested public benefits are Medicaid (except for emergency care), CHIP, TANF, food stamps, and SSI.[ 19 ]

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

As you point out, illegal aliens have access to a wealth of welfare programs which they, along with legal immigrants, take full advantage of.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Amac, the census data shows what it shows. The majority of immigrant households use welfare. End of story.

Everything else is spin.

 
 

Who is online



CB


74 visitors