Satanists Cite Hobby Lobby In Campaign For Religious Exemption To Abortion Laws
Satanists Cite Hobby Lobby In Campaign For Religious Exemption To Abortion Laws
A Satanist group is using the Hobby Lobby ruling to campaign for a religious exemption to anti-choice abortion laws.
The Satanic Temple (TST) is a religious group that "believes that the body is inviolable subject to ones own will alone" and encourages making personal health decisions "based on the best scientific understanding of the world, regardless of the religious or political beliefs of others. The group launched a campaign Monday on behalf of a woman's right to accurate medical information and cited the Hobby Lobby ruling as bolstering this position.
Hobby Lobby, a Christian-owned arts and crafts store based in Oklahoma, filed a lawsuit in 2012 due to a stipulation in President Obama's Affordable Care Act which required employer-provided health insurance to cover contraceptives. Hobby Lobby disagreed with this on the basis that certain contraceptives could be abortive and argued the law violates religious freedom. In June, the Supreme Court ruled that some closely held, for-profit corporations could be exempt from providing contraception coverage to employees on the basis of religious beliefs.
"Any suggestion that for-profit corporations are incapable of exercising religion because their purpose is simply to make money flies in the face of modern corporate law," the court's ruling said. Requiring religious corporations to cover contraception "demands that they engage in conduct that seriously violates their religious beliefs," the ruling also stated.
TST says that same ruling can apply to "informed consent" laws.
Informed consent documents are distributed to patients before surgical and aesthetic procedures so the patients will know what these procedures entail and what to expect from them. In terms of abortions, informed consent docs list the types of abortion procedures, complications and risks.
Here is TST's objection to the dissemination of information that could potentially discourage a woman from obtaining an abortion:
Informed consent bills requiring abortion providers to give their patients official informational material regarding the procedure have been criticized in the past for providing biased and false information to women in a bald effort at dissuading them from abortions. Such materials have included claims of a link between abortion and breast cancer, as well as claims regarding a depressive postabortion syndrome, both of which The Satanic Temple view as scientifically unfounded and medically invalid and therefore an affront to their religious beliefs.
Currently, 35 states require that women receive "informational" abortion counseling before terminating a pregnancy. This can include written materials with statements about the fetus's ability to feel pain, erroneous links between abortion and increased breast cancer risks and supposed psychological responses to abortion.TST considers this misleading and believes the Hobby Lobby ruling bolsters the temple's goal for religious exemption.
While we feel we have a strong case for an exemption regardless of the Hobby Lobby ruling, the Supreme Court has decided that religious beliefs are so sacrosanct that they can even trump scientific fact," TST spokesperson Lucien Greaves said in a press release. "This was made clear when they allowed Hobby Lobby to claim certain contraceptives were abortifacients, when in fact they are not. Because of the respect the Court has given to religious beliefs, and the fact that our our beliefs are based on best available knowledge, we expect that our belief in the illegitimacy of state mandated informational material is enough to exempt us, and those who hold our beliefs, from having to receive them.
On TST's website, the group provides a printable letter that women can give their health care providers to opt out of informed consent, stating that such a precondition is "based on politics and not science" and that it is against the Satanic religion.
The letter lists specific principles that allow TST's campaign to fall under the category of religious exemption:
My body is inviolable and subject to my will alone.
I make any decision regarding my health based on the best scientific understanding of the world, even if the science does not comport with the religious or political beliefs of others.
My inviolable body includes any fetal or embryonic tissue I carry so long as that tissue is unable to survive outside my body as an independent human being.
I, and I alone, decide whether my inviolable body remains pregnant and I may, in good conscience, disregard the current or future condition of any fetal or embryonic tissue I carry in making that decision.
Last year, TST made headlines for performing a "pink mass" ritual over the grave of Catherine Idalette Johnston, the mother of Westboro Baptist Church founder Fred Phelps, supposedly turning her gay for all eternity. Earlier this year, the group was back in the news after commissioning a seven-foot statue of Satan to be placed at the Oklahoma state Capitol, where a Ten Commandments monument was erected in 2012.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/07/28/satanists-hobby-lobby-religious-exemption-abortion_n_5627499.html?utm_hp_ref=politics&ir=Politics

If the Satanists find a Federal Law that appears to be in violation -- this could be fun.
Sincerely.
This can get very tricky.
What about a Wiccan? What if someone has a sincerely held religious belief in Wicca? How about Santeria (a very fascinating religion, BTW), various forms of Vodoo? Scientology? (IMO, anyone with a sincerely held religious belief in Scientology is a danger to society-- but that's another issue). How about a "Sun-worshipper"-- who sincerely believes the Sun is God!
What about someone who is an idol worshipper-- and he/she sincerely believes that the idols he worships are gods?.
Or even just someone who hears voices in their head-- and sincerely believes that it is God speaking to them?
If you're going to have the courts rule on which religious beliefs are valid and which are not...well, thats a very "slippery slope"!
There's a presupposition in your rhetorical question, Robert G -- that being all decisions by any given court is fair, reasonable and based on a "correct," or at least utilitarian understanding/interpretation of the law(s) pertaining to the case-at-hand.
Ideal but not real. The SCOTUS has as least one member who should recuse himself regarding any case involving the PPACA; that being Clarence Thomas.
Thomas' wife for openers.
...
As for Alito and HL, he couldn't reasonably explain how favoring the freedom of one religion could be done without violating that of another and I dare say you can't either.
But go ahead and try.
No. The question was simplistic still is.
In other words, you can't rebut so you do your usual make it personal.
Nothing dissembled; all the information regarding his wife and the obvious conflicts-of-interest are well known and factual.
No Justices of the SCOTUS are supposed to be OBJECTIVE, NOT BIASED that's why their function is as an arbiter of the law -- NOT MERELY THE GUARDIAN, BUT,interpreter of the Constitution.
Yeah; those WOULD BE IRRELEVANT. But her lobbying activities are QUITE RELEVANT.
See the difference?
RELEVANT
IRRELEVANT.
A conflict of interest arises in the workplace when an employee has competing interests or loyalties that either are, or potentially can be, at odds with each other. A conflict of interest causes an employee to experience a struggle between diverging interests, points of view, or allegiances.
Your authoritative-sounding pronouncements are often wrong.
It's not a Constitutional issue; it's aboutJudicial Ethics, "The Appearance of Impropriety."
Promoting Confidence in the Judiciary
A judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety.
Not the same question, Robert G. "Women's" rights are, like all other human rights, granted by the 14th Amendment's Equal Protection Clause. Being a Female Justice and being a female does not constitute a conflict-of-interests since equal protection is gender-neutral.
But, being the spouse of a lobbyist while being a SCOTUS Justice has the potential on its face, to give the "appearance of impropriety," if not in reality, an outright conflict-of-interests.
Now this has become a good debate.
Sometimes reality has a lot of "tough shit" in it.
Otherwise there could be NO OBJECTIVE JUDICIARY.
"PRIOR TO" being the proviso. On the other hand, if, while a Justice, she had a relative, spouse or close acquaintance in the contraceptive/Planned Parenthood, etc. upper echelon, and or one who lobbied professionally in those interests, that would be a conflict-of-interests AND SHE SHOULD RECUSE HERSELF FROM CASES IN THOSE GENRES.
That's why there is the option of RECUSAL.
It's part of Judicial Ethics.
________________________________
Still a really good debate, Robert G.
I wrote,
Robert G replied,
I didn't even come close to saying that. And we were doing so well in serious dialogue.
No, Justices don't divorce their spouses nor get rid of friends THEY RECUSE THEMSELVES FROM RULING ON CASES IN WHICH SUCH PEOPLE COULD CONSTITUTE "The appearance of impropriety" or a "conflict-of-interests."
Did I really need to explain that?
Irrelevant unless the wealth was accumulated in such a way as to constitute SPECIFICALLY the appearance/conflict, etc. .
His concerns are also irrelevant; only the particulars as they relate to cases are of relevance.
They're all possibly susceptible to bribes, again irrelevant unless there is a reasonable connection to her debts as they apply to a given case.
You don't want a discussion Robert G, at this point you want to play "gotcha." And without anything but speculation and innuendo, in law and in life, ya' got nothin'.
I cited the case, the conflict-of-interests and all the specifics re:HL.
Under the Supreme Court Ethics Act of 2013, supreme court justices would be prohibited from political activity and fundraising, among other conduct that could cast doubt on their impartiality.
Summary: H.R.2902 113th Congress (2013-2014)
Supreme Court Ethics Act of 2013 - Requires the Supreme Court to promulgate a code of ethics for the Justices of the Supreme Court that shall include the five canons of the Code of Conduct for United States Judges adopted by the Judicial Conference of the United States, with any amendments or modifications that the Supreme Court determines appropriate.
In the Supreme Court of the United States , the Justices typically recuse themselves from participating in cases in which they have financial interests. For example, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor generally did not participate in cases involving telecommunications firms because she owned stock in these firms, whereas Justice Stephen Breyer has disqualified himself in some cases involving insurance companies because of his participation in a Lloyd's of London syndicate. Justices also have declined to participate in cases in which close relatives, such as their children, are lawyers for one of the parties. On occasion, recusal occurs under more unusual circumstances; for example, in two cases, Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist stepped down from the bench when cases were argued by Arizona attorney James Brosnahan, who had testified against Rehnquist at his confirmation hearing in 1986. Whatever the reason for recusal, the United States Reports will record that the named justice "took no part in the consideration or decision of this case."
Also,
Kagan, DOMA, and recusal
Recusals apply. They apply to all judges at all levels. Thomas is a judge. See the connection?I'm out of this; you're smarter than you play this.