╌>

Civilian Deaths in Gaza - Hamas’ dead baby strategy works because the media facilitates it.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  12 years ago  •  7 comments

Civilian Deaths in Gaza - Hamas’ dead baby strategy works because the media facilitates it.

by Alan M. Dershowitz

The media loves to count the dead bodies on each side of a conflict. Its much easier to count that to explain. Hamas knows this. Thats why they employ what has come to be known as the dead baby strategy.

Hamas strategy since Israel left Gaza in 2005 has been exactly the same. The media response has been exactly the same. And Hamas will continue to employ a strategy that causes many Palestinian civilians to die as long as the media keeps up its thoughtless body count.

Heres the way it works: Hamas deliberately fires its rockets from densely populated civilian areas, using hospitals, disability centers, mosques and schools as launching sites. This puts Israel to the tragic choice of either allowing the rockets to endanger its civilians or to destroy the rocket launchers, thereby risking civilian casualties among Hamas human shields. Often Israel chooses to forgo attacking military targets, so as not to put Palestinian civilians at risk. Sometimes it has no choice, because the rocket fire against its civilians is persistent. Palestinian civilians are killed despite Israels best efforts precisely because Hamas wants civilians to be killed, especially if these civilians are children, women or the elderly. Hamas stands ready to parade these human shields in front of the media which is eager to show the dead and count the bodies.

Hamas could easily reduce the death and injury toll among its civilians by simply allowing them to go underground into tunnels and shelters which abound throughout Gaza. But Hamas has a deliberate policy of refusing to allow civilians to enter the tunnels or shelters. They reserve these places of refuge for their fighters and commanders, which explains why so few Hamas fighters have been killed. If Hamas were to reverse its policy and allow civilians into the shelters while requiring its fighters to stay above ground, the ratio of civilians to fighters killed would dramatically change. That is why in each of the wars between Hamas and Israel there have been more Palestinian than Israeli civilian deaths and injuries. It is part of Hamas dead baby strategy and it works, because the media facilitates it.
The media also emphasizes the fact that thus far no Israelis have been killed by Hamas rocket fire. Indeed some media and international organizations seem implicitly to be condemning Israel for protecting the lives of its own citizens, by repeatedly pointing out there has been only one fatality, while Palestinian deaths have reached over 200. The reason there has been only one Israeli death so far is because Israel spends hundreds of millions of dollars trying to protect its civilians, while Hamas spends its resources deliberately exposing its civilians to the risks of Israeli counterattacks. Israel has built shelters all throughout the country and has spent a fortune on the Iron Dome system. The results have been impressive, though many Israelis suffer from trauma, shock and the inevitable long term consequences of being exposed to constant rocket fire.

How many times have you heard, seen or read the body counts: nearly 200 Palestinians dead, no Israelis dead. This is usually accompanied by an accusation that Israel is violating the international law requirement of proportionality. This is a misuse of the term, which has a precise meaning in international law that reflects a broader morality. Under international law, a nation has the right to attack military targets. Period! It doesnt matter whether the rockets coming from these launchers have as yet succeeded in their task of killing civilians. There can be no doubt under international law that rocket launchers, and the fighters who employ them are legitimate military targets. Israel is therefore entitled to attack these targets, even if no Israeli civilians have been killed, so long as it can do so without causing disproportionate civilian casualties.

This rule was not addressed to an enemy that deliberately uses human shields to protect its military targets and combatants against legitimate attacks. Proportionality is not judged by the number of civilians actually killed by Hamas rockets, but rather by the risks posed to Israelis. These risks have been diminished, but not eliminated by the Iron Dome system. They have also been considerably diminished by Israels counterattacks on the missile launchers and those who employ them. Without these counterattacks, it is highly likely that more Hamas missiles would have made it through the Iron Dome system which has been approximately 85% effective. Israel has every right under the rules of proportionality to attack these military targets, so long as they take reasonable efforts to reduce civilian casualties. They have done so by leafleting, by calling, and by other methods of warning civilians to leave target areas. Hamas leaders, on the other hand, have urged, and sometimes compelled, their civilians to remain in harms way as human shields.

The media, by emphasizing the comparative body counts without providing the reasons for the disparity, play into the hands of Hamas, and encourage that terrorist organization, to continue to pursue its dead baby strategy. So the next time those in the media promote a body count without explanation, they should point a finger at themselves for contributing to this deadly count.

http://www.aish.com/jw/me/Civilian-Deaths-in-Gaza.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

No doubt about it, the World would be a better place if Israel obliterates hamas.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Agreed, Larry.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

I'd say the people most influenced by the propaganda are people who live in the Western world, including Israel. Democratic societies in the world have become increasingly ideologically liberal, which gives rise to populist mindsets. The extent of the examination is "stronger party is evil, weaker party is good". Add to this a helping of Arab/Islamic immigration, and you have the ingredients to whip a country or a region (read: EU) into the appropriate frenzythat will line up with the terrorists, because they lack the sophisticated weapons to defeat the "colonialist/imperialist".

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Incidentally, most Egyptians agree as well.

Which is why Egypt not only closed its border with Gaza, but has been sealing off the smuggling tunnels between Gaza and Egypt.

Why? Simply because when the Gazan "Resistance"couldn't murder Jews or Christians, they snuck into the Egyptian Sinai and murdered Egyptians. The Egyptians didn't mind much when Hamas murdered non-Muslims-- but when they started terror attacks against Egyptians, Egypt got really, really pissed!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I'd say the people most influenced by the propaganda are people who live in the Western world, including Israel

I agree.

BTW, one difference between this war and the last Gaza war: outrage in the west is much greater. But ironically, outrage is the Arab world is slightly less.

Its still present, as they have been brainwashed from childhood to hate Jews-- but much of the Arab world has been threatened by extremist terrorist crazies-- ao they know what Hamas' game is. 9In addition, Egypt has themselves suffered terror attacks from Gaza).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Democratic societies in the world have become increasingly ideologically liberal, which gives rise to populist mindsets. The extent of the examination is "stronger party is evil, weaker party is good". Add to this a helping of Arab/Islamic immigration, and you have the ingredients to whip a country or a region (read: EU) into the appropriate frenzythat will line up with the terrorists, because they lack the sophisticated weapons to defeat the "colonialist/imperialist".

Excellent analysis Smile.gif

I just read today that ISIS just murdered 700 people in Syria. And this was during a 2 day period!

But-- where's the outrage?

Huge violent demonstrations against Israel in Paris-- but so far not much if anything, about Syria in the streets of Paris-- or the hypocritical self appointed "human rights experts" on NT.

(More about their hypocrisy is HERE -- comments welcome)

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I think there is another part to this...

I just read today that ISIS just murdered 700 people in Syria. And this wasduring a 2 day period!

But-- where's the outrage?

Try to find an ISIS supporter and you'll be hard pressed. So if there is no controversy in the fact that ISIS is a group of assholes, there is no news story. Who wants to watch over and over how ISIS is murdering people? Yep, they're evil. Yep, we hate them. Meh... no news.

Now if Israel, who is supported, is killing people, there is some controversy there. It makes for news... at least it makes for what PASSES as news these days... which is... sex and violence sell, boring facts do not.

 
 

Who is online





47 visitors