╌>

Philadelphia mosque leaders try to cut off man's hand

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  12 years ago  •  47 comments

Philadelphia mosque leaders try to cut off man's hand

?m=02&d=20140718&t=2&i=938232295&w=320&fh=&fw=&ll=&pl=&r=LYNXMPEA6H11C Merv Mitchell, also known as Mabul Shoatz, who is charged with aggravated assault, criminal conspiracy, simple assault, reckless endangerment, and related offenses, is pictured in this Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Police Department photo released on July 18, 2014.

(Reuters) - Two men described as leaders of a Philadelphia mosque were accused of trying to cut off the hand of a suspected thief, whose wrist was sliced so deeply it required hospital treatment, police said on Friday.

The officials, described in police reports as the mosque's imam and amir, dragged the victim to the rear of the mosque, and attempted to chop off his hand with a machete, according to a police statement.

LINK


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

What a bizarre thing to do!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Hey, they have a "sincerely held religious belief!"

Anyone gotta problem with that?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Tough neighborhood...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Your sincerely held legal beliefs probably won't help them with people who actually understand the law.

Unlike yourself.

But please, explain how the rationale is any different -- the law is the law, and, if these assholes can't justify their actions/intentions by citing "sincerely held religious beliefs," AND THEY CAN'T, neither can any other PERSON nor any CORPORATE PERSONHOOD.

It ain't about contraceptives or who pays for what, it's about allowing religious convictions to take precedent over law.

My quip was intended to bring you back to the table, Robert.

Pull up a chair and give a direct explanation.

I'll rephrase:

Two entities refuse to follow two different laws. The general population overwhelmingly abides by each of the laws; both entities refuse to obey the laws in question, solely on the same basis -- that is, their "sincerely held religious beliefs."

Explain why one should prevail and the other should not?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Tough neighborhood...

We've got a few of those.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I'll be curious to see if anyone responds directly.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Explain why one should prevail and the other should not?

Why don't you explain why the govt should force people to spend money without their consent ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Why don't you explain why the govt should force people to spend money without their consent ...

That's not the issue I'm addressing; if you can't answer my question, either indicate that you can't or just ignore it.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

That's another example . But the excuse used was that the revenues were not dedicated and therefore could be spent how the admin decides to spend them . That is different from forcing people to make a purchase they don't want to .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The seeded article is about two men who were charged withaggravated assault, criminal conspiracy, simple assault, reckless endangerment, and related offenses all of which, in their "minds" are consistent with their religious beliefs despite laws against such acts.

Hence my question

Two entities refuse to follow two different laws. The general population overwhelmingly abides by each of the laws; both entities refuse to obey the laws in question, solely on the same basis -- that is, their "sincerely held religious beliefs."

Explain why one should prevail and the other should not?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Explain why one should prevail and the other should not?

There have been many more cases of religious beliefs (and/or practices) conflicting with civil laws than people realize-- in the U.S. But also in many other democracies. (There's been some conflict is some countries over whether to ban Islamic head-coverings in some countries, I think mainly in Europe).

So how do we decide which takes priority when the religious teachings conflicts with the law? I'm sure if you ask different people you'd get different answers. How do we decide who is right? Which side should win?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

In the US, you would have to be able to understand the difference between being inconvenienced and having your arm or head cut off before you could decide such a difficult philosophical question.

Not so; the metaphor, "Justice is Blind" is a basic tenet of American jurisprudence. The degree of deviation from a societal norm and a legal system using that as a kind of baseline, is supposed to be consistent in implementing decisions.

The degree to which a crime deviates from the 'norm" determines the punishment, not innocence or guilt!

Lady Justice is among the most recognized sculpted figures and symbols in the world. The blindfolded woman with sword and scales symbolizes impartial administration of justice, without corruption or favoritism

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Someone needs to tell this creep that we are a Christian nation! We don't cut off men's hands for minor offenses. An observant Christian reserves that punishment for women.

Deuteronomy 25:12
"If two men, a man and his countryman, are struggling together, and the wife of one comes near to deliver her husband from the hand of the one who is striking him, and puts out her hand and seizes his genitals, then you shall cut off her hand; you shall not show pity."
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Religions have been able to ignore the law without fear of reprisal for quite a while.

I cite as an example the Catholics who were the first to encourage illegal aliens to illegally cross the border, provided them sanctuary, helped them find homes to hide them in communities, assisted them in finding jobs under the table, and more or less told the authorities to go screw themselves.

As to your question, Mac, it would be evident that one decision, while preventing a person from obtaining a medical product with assistance from insurance benefits, does not, in fact, prevent the person from obtaining it on their own; therefore it does not bar a person from actually obtaining it. (Sounds convoluted to me, I don't agree with it, it's bullshit from Republican Supreme Court Justices who like to play G_d with women's lives, and they should all be disbarred immediately, but hey, they have jobs for life, which is the worse thing that could happen to the rest of us, as they don't have to live by the decisions they make for the rest of us, and can be brain dead on a ventilator and still draw their salary and hold their place on the court.)

The other brings physical and emotional harm and pain to the recipient, and the permanent loss of a body part that cannot be reclaimed from any other source.

Your religious rights end where my body parts begin. Which, come to think of it, should also include my interior body parts. Prostrate surgery should not be included under insurance coverage. It is only a "man thing" and can be obtained by personal finances./s

Have a great day!Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The metaphor is about fairness, not about a requirement to be stupid.

Another quip, another lost argument.

FAIRNESS! Exactly. A court deciding that a religious belief can trump a law, thus denying to some what they and others are legally entitled to, IS DISCRIMINATORY -- NOT FAIR.

If HL, et al want to earn their money in the public sector, they should abide by the rules/laws that apply to the public sector.

The SCOTUS has placed itself on a road to equivocation -- future cases will showcase its hypocrisy and double standard.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

it would be evident that one decision, while preventing a person from obtaining a medical product with assistance from insurance benefits, does not, in fact, prevent the person from obtaining it on their own;

Not the issue. It isn't about alternative options; it's about a religious belief forcing women to find alternative options despite a law mandating otherwise and NOT ALL WOMEN just those that a CORPORATE PERSONHOOD GETS TO SELECT.

Again

A court deciding that a religious belief can trump a law, thus denying to some what they and others are legally entitled to, IS DISCRIMINATORY -- NOT FAIR.

If HL, et al want to earn their money in the public sector, they should abide by the rules/laws that apply to the public sector.

The SCOTUS has placed itself on a road to equivocation -- future cases will showcase its hypocrisy and double standard.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Not fair, Mac!

You only quoted part of my comment. I was being sarcastic and as I went on with my little tirade surely you caught on to that.

SCOTUS was wrong in its decision. Congress was wrong to filibuster it until it died without reversing it. And by damn, if this decision affected men instead of women, it would not have been made as it was!

(Thus my parting crack about prostrate surgery....Grin.gif )

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Not fair, Mac!

You only quoted part of my comment. I was being sarcastic and as I went on with my little tirade surely you caught on to that.

My bad for not noting that; I used your sarcasm to make a point to those who don't view the HL decision the way you and I do, mimi.

(Thus my parting crack about prostrate surgery.... Grin.gif )

Well, if things aren't 100% in man-ville, that in-and-of-itself takes care of the birth control worries. I'm guessing HL would willingly cover castration and hysterectomy.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

LOL... have a good weekend Mac..

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Up to there, and minus the mindless rant, your comment about the lack of difficulty in understanding the difference between a person having his head cut off and another person not getting free bananas, was brilliant. : )

No matter how many times you declare it's about a particular service or item, IT ISN'T!

And your need to degrade members only emphasizes the weakness and insecurity of your "thinking."

Again,

The degree to which a crime deviates from the 'norm" determines the punishment, not innocence or guilt!

If you know an attorney -- one you trust (oxymoron?) -- posit the concept.

Be it spitting in a public library or armed robbery, the process is to be consistent and even handed.

Legal process (or sometimes " process "), are the proceedings in any civil lawsuit or criminal prosecution and, particularly, describes the formal notice or writ used by a court to exercise jurisdiction over a person or property. [1] Such process is usually " served " upon a party, to compel that party to come to court , and may take the form of a summons , mandate , subpoena , warrant , or other written demand issued by a court. [2]

Procedural law or adjective law comprises the rules by which a court hears and determines what happens in civil lawsuit , criminal or administrative proceedings . The rules are designed to ensure a fair and consistent application of due process (in the U.S.) to all cases that come before a court.

Under a rational basis test, the burden of proof is on the challenger.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

"Cut off the limb that offends you." (I think that's how it goes)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Going forward

the Court will decide instance by instance whether a particular religious exemption is warrantedand they will make that determination not by any consistently applied aspect of law, but by how many people are raising an objection and how compelling the Court finds the particular service to which the objection is being raised.

But

the majority opinion inHobby Lobbyopens the door for any religious group to use the ruling as precedent to challenge the RFRA. But precedent alone is no guarantee of actual results.

The Roberts Court doesn't seem particularly interested in granting exemptions under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act to just any sincerely held religious belief: after all, we would need to consider the legitimate governmental interests in each case.

But here's what we do know: in the case of equal opportunity for women versus a religious doctrine held by the plurality of the members of the Supreme Court, the religious doctrine just won, even as they say in the same breath that no precedent should be considered established by their decision.


 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Although chopping of his hands would eliminate recidivism, it's illegal. They should have shot him like Christians do and claim self defense. As for Hobby Lobby, I can't imagine what it has to do with this. Even if these fools could show that preventing them from chopping off a thief's hands violates their religious beliefs (which they can't show), it would take all of two seconds for the government to show that it has a legitimate interest in preventing vigilantism and that a single rule of law is the best method of doing it.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

And this is the problem with the SCOTUS ruling. How can we dictate which religion is being infringed upon?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

As for Hobby Lobby, I can't imagine what it has to do with this.

That's obvious.

Hint -- both HL and the two religionist nut jobs were using their religious beliefs as a rationale for avoiding compliance with law.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I have to agree with you jwc.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

PERSON 1 or CORPORATE PERSONHOOD 1 chooses to disobey LAW "X" on Religious Belief grounds.

PERSON 2 orCORPORATE PERSONHOOD 2 chooses to disobey LAW "Y" on Religious Belief grounds.

Any difference?

Where is the line drawn between which law must defer to religious objections and which will not?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Hint -- both HL and the two religionist nut jobs were using their religious beliefs as a rationale for avoiding compliance with law."And that's where the comparison ends. The court finding that Obama cannot arbitrarily exclude for-profit companies from the contraceptive dictates of obamacare while including for profit companies has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on whether people have a religious right to take the law into their own hands as vigilantes.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
It's not about who can chose to disobey a law but rather determining whether the government has chosen to restrict a religious freedom in the least restrictive manner. Maybe you think a court would scratch its head in trying to figure out whether people have a right to be vigilantes in light of Hobby Lobby but I don't.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The court finding that Obama cannot arbitrarily exclude for-profit companies from the contraceptive dictates of obamacare while including for profit companies has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on whether people have a religious right to take the law into their own hands as vigilantes.

Obama-- is this about Obama (rhetorical question)?

Subject for another day.

I think one of the companies should say "non-proft."

The exclusion is not arbitrary! Companies that profit in the public space but want to exclude themselves from laws that apply to interaction in that public space -- want it both ways. Their products and services are offered under tax-supported entities utilities, public roads, police and fire protection, etc. .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

whether the government has chosen to restrict a religious freedom in the least restrictive manner.

If, by failing to restrict one, it effectively restricts another?

And that's where the SCOTUS went.

Maybe you think a court would scratch its head in trying to figure out whether people have a right to be vigilantes in light of Hobby Lobby but I don't.

If "vigilantes" violate a law by acting as such, it's no head scratch -- whether or not the vigilante group has a religious belief that "allows" it, is irrelevant.

The very point.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

IMO this type of event would fall within the exception noted in the RFRA

(b) Exception

Government may substantially burden a persons exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person
(1) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and
(2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.
The compelling interest being the safety of its citizens and prohibiting the severing of hands for crimes for which punishment is provided under existing laws.
As I pointed out once before, the mantra of "compelling religious belief" has become clich of late
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

(b)Exception

Government may substantially burden a persons exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person
It says nothing about a corporation
(1)is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest;
If 99% of the employed females in the U.S., whose employers cover the contraceptives, then by virtue of the numbers alone, IMO it is "compelling.
and
(2)is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.
Being non-restrictive in deference to a religious belief goes well beyond being "least restrictive." It's a total capitulation (IMO) to a religious dogma.
RIO,
We will see as the cases come in, just what a mess the SCOTUS has or has not created for itself. I believe it will look hypocritical many times over by virtue of what will be viewed more and more as a partisan-driven double standard.
My opinion.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"I think one of the companies should say "non-proft."Yes it should."The exclusion is not arbitrary! Companies that profit in the public space but want to exclude themselves from laws that apply to interaction in that public space -- want it both ways. Their products and services are offered under tax-supported entities utilities, public roads, police and fire protection, etc. ."Obama's regulations excluded non-profit companies while including for-profit companies even though they're similarly situated for the purposes of the law. That's arbitrary.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
I think any court would agree with you Robert.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

But every conceivable argument, such as anything that pops into Amac's head, is not the same as every viable argument.

Viable arguments have always eluded you

Personal swipes not so much.

I have said a number of times that cases yet to be heard will determine the wisdom of foolishness of the HL decision -- giving explanations along the way.

But you (et al) -- you know the future and consequently, I need to stop thinking for myself and just follow you guys.

Shock and awe, mission accomplished!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Religions have been able to ignore the law without fear of reprisal for quite a while.

I cite as an example the Catholics

Yuk.

Catholicism throughout history has been responsible for more violence, gruesome torture, death and dismemberment than perhaps any other religion with the obvious exception of Islam. (Actually the Church has calmed down considerably in recent times -- but they still hold overwhelming power used for evil purposes in the the media and government)

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"It says nothing about a corporation"Except that the government conceded that non-profit corporations are persons within the meaning of the law and could offer no explanation as to how one cooperation is a person and the other is not."If 99% of the employed females in the U.S., whose employers cover the contraceptives, then by virtue of the numbers alone, IMO it is "compelling."The court did not dispute that thee was a compelling interest."Being non-restrictive in deference to a religious belief goes well beyond being "least restrictive." It's a total capitulation (IMO) to a religious dogma."The court said that, among other things, the government could have accomplished its goal by handling non-profits and for-profit corporations the same way i.e. Without going into the employer's back pocket. It's about being even-handed, not capitulation.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"It's the severance of limbs or appendages is long established and accepted practice of Islam. Their followers are just fine with it, just as some religions think it's just ducky do cut the foreskin away from a child who has no say in the matter."

It's not mandated by the Koran but rather an option. I note that the same verse that says you should cut off a thief's hand also allows a thief to relent and avoid that punishment. But I won't belabor that here. The Hobby Lobby decision applies to the federal government, not states. It also says that the government cannot impose a "substantial" (as opposed to any) burden on the exercise of religion unless it has a legitimate reason to do so and chooses the least restrictive means. Preventing Muslims from cutting off other people's hands is no more a substantial burden on the exercise of their religion than preventing Christians from burning witches or stoning homosexuals.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

IMO the decision concerns the rights of the people who are collectively the corporation and I know that you think that is a bad interpretation.

Be that as it may be, it is current settled law and in light of that I think the point I made about the exception portion of the RFRA is a valid one

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

there's another one proving why the only way they get near a court with an opinion is as a defendant, and then only to prove a defense of diminished capacity.

Really? What about a defendant that gives a factually specious argument in his/its defense and still "wins" by virtue of a bad opinion?

The folks behind the lawsuits similar toHobby Lobby there were at least 100, according to the National Organization for Women are pretty much the same people who stopped the Equal Rights Amendment.

Religionists who cry for "freedom of religion" are among the all time hypocrites. Freedom to discriminate and restrict the freedom of others in order to have one's religionist way is what HL is about.

And here's the bullshit rationale of Alito

Corporations qualify for protection of religious beliefs under the law, Justice Alito writes for the majority, because even though corporate personhood is a legal fiction, those corporations are formed by human beings and they represent the people who are associated with them and their rights. Protecting the corporation thus protects the people who own and control it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Again, this won't be one of them. It is too obviously foolish, and too obviously too boring for the courts to bother with.

I neither said nor implied it would, but others might merely to test the decision. "Boring" has nothing to do with it.

Factors the Court Considers When Choosing Cases

  1. The Court will Hear Cases to Resolve a Conflict of Law : The U.S. judicial system consists of 13 federal circuits and 50 state supreme courts. When a number of these courts reach different conclusions about an issue of federal or constitutional law, the Supreme Court may step in and decide the law so that all areas of the country can then operate under the same law.
  2. The Court will Hear Cases that are Important : Sometimes the Court will consider a highly unusual case such as U.S. v Nixon (concerning the Watergate tapes) or Bush v. Gore (concerning the extremely close election in 2000), or a case with an important social issue, such as abortion in Roe v. Wade .
  3. The Court will Sometimes Hear Cases that Speak to the Justices' Interests : Sometimes Justices give preference to cases that decide an issue in their favorite area of law.
  4. The Court hears Cases when Lower Courts Disregard past Supreme Court decisions: If a lower court blatantly disregards a past Supreme Court decision, the court may hear the case to correct the lower court, or alternatively, simply overrule the case without comment.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

It's just the overwhelming sense of intellectual superiority I get after reading some of the comments here.

There's a term that goes with your symptom.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

What is your favorite flavor of jello?

And they say you are not capable of viable debate.

'Course, one can see why.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

BINGO!

PARCHEESI!

 
 

Who is online






67 visitors