╌>

Rehashing Talking Points from Clinton Campaign Donors

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  13 comments

Rehashing Talking Points from Clinton Campaign Donors

Well, well, well: The Obama-appointed prosecutor who gave Obamas former CIA director a sweetheart plea deal when he was caught mishandling classified information now says theres no case against Obamas former secretary of state for mishandling classified information. How very persuasive.

Oh, and did I mention that the Obama-appointed prosecutor is a donor to the Hillary Clinton presidential campaign?

In what appears to be an audition for attorney general in a hoped-for Clinton II administration, Anne M. Tompkins, the former U.S. attorney for the western district of North Carolina (appointed by President Obama in 2010), has penned an op-ed for USA Today arguing that Hillary Clinton is not guilty of knowingly sending or receiving classified materials improperly.

Understand: Ms. Tompkins has had nothing to do with the FBIs investigation of Mrs. Clintons handling of classified information through an unauthorized private e-mail system. She is not privy to the evidence the FBI is gathering she knows no more about the case than anyone else who reads the papers. To exonerate Clinton, she relies on nothing other than her status as the government lawyer who oversaw the prosecution of David Petraeus.

The Petraeus case, she insists, was much stronger than the case or at least what she frames as the case against Hillary Clinton. She thus contends that there is no merit to the comparison between the Petraeus and Clinton situations offered in a Wall Street Journal op-ed by former Bush attorney general and top federal judge Michael Mukasey.

If it werent so disingenuous, Tompkinss reasoning would be comically incompetent.

She writes: The key element that distinguishes Secretary Clintons email retention practices from Petraeus sharing of classified information is that Petraeus knowingly engaged in unlawful conduct, and that was the basis of his criminal liability. [The italics are in Tompkinss op-ed; Ive added the bold.]

To begin with, Tompkins d id not prosecute Petraeus for sharing classified information . Instead, despite Petraeuss commission of several felonies, Tompkins struck a cozy arrangement with Petraeuss lawyer, David Kendall (who happens to represent Clinton), allowing the retired general and former CIA director to plead to a single misdemeanor count of unauthorized removal and retention of classified documents (section 1924 of the federal penal code).

As I pointed out at the time of Petraeuss plea, based on the prosecutions outline of the evidence it was in a position to prove, Petraeus not only transmitted highly classified information to his paramour/hagiographer; he retained it in a reckless manner, failed to return it on demand, and repeatedly made false statements to the government and investigating agents about his hoarding and disclosure of that information. Tompkins let all these felonies slide. Given her own failure to charge crimes she could easily have proved in a case for which she was directly responsible, she is hardly in a position to judge what crimes should be charged as the result of an investigation she has nothing to do with.

It is difficult to decide where to begin with Tompkinss laughable claim that Petraeuss certain knowledge that the information he was dealing with was classified is a key distinction from Clintons state of mind. Lets start with the most obvious fact: The FBI is not limited to investigating the same misdemeanor offense to which Tompkins chose to let Petraeus plead guilty. Th e plethora of potential crimes the agents are investigating have a variety of proof elements, including different scienter requirements.

For instance, as Ive previously explained, one of the several felony violations of the Espionage Act (section 793 of the federal penal code) makes it a crime for an official to exercise gross negligence in handling classified information e.g., to allow national defense information with which she has been entrusted to be lost, stolen, abstracted, destroyed, or improperly transmitted. So if a top government official were to set up an unauthorized private server system for storing and transmitting information under circumstances where she knew that (a) her job involved dealing with vast amounts of classified information and (b) the private system was easily penetrable by foreign intelligence services and other minimally competent hackers, she could be charged with a felony even if she did not have perfect knowledge that any one particular e-mail contained classified information.

But more to the point, as any competent prosecutor knows, you cannot make a definitive pronouncement about any suspects state of knowledge without knowing all the facts of the case. Tompkins has no idea what facts the FBI is turning up, and she seems to have a decided disinterest in reports that Clintons known e-mails are threaded with classified information.

Tompkins seems to believe that unless the prosecution has the kind of slam-dunk proof she had (but shied away from using) in the Petraeus case namely, proof that Petraeus admitted to someone that the information he hoarded was highly classified it is impossible to prove knowledge beyond a reasonable doubt. Nevertheless, there are innumerable cases in which investigators and prosecutors establish knowledge, intent, willfulness, gross negligence, and other mental elements without a confession by the suspect. In fact, in virtually every criminal trial, the judge instructs the jury that, because we are not mind-readers, knowledge and intent are usually proved by analyzing the totality of the evidence and the reasonable inferences that flow from it

In Tompkinss own prosecution of Petraeus, the government described the journals he maintained as containing the identities of covert officers, war strategy, intelligence capabilities and mechanisms, diplomatic discussions, quotes and deliberative discussions from high-level National Security Council meetings, and defendant DAVID HOWELL PETRAEUSs discussions with the President of the United States of America. Petraeus, of course, was the director of the CIA and had been the commander of U.S. forces in war zones. I daresay that even if he hadnt told his girlfriend that the journals he let her read were highly classified, Tompkins wouldnt have had the slightest difficulty proving that he was well aware of this fact. I imagine that the reason Petraeus pleaded guilty rather than going to trial other than the fact that Tompkins was offering him a slap on the wrist is that he realized his high-ranking position left him with no plausible state-of-mind defense.

The case that Clinton mishandled classified information appears so daunting that, even as Tompkins attempts to trash it, she cant help but bolster it. The current iteration of Clintons evolving defense is that she did not realize information on her server was classified because it was not marked as such. But Tompkins elucidates that Petraeuss journals were not marked top secret either. So lets put aside for the moment the fact that the investigation of Clinton potentially involves a quantum of classified information that dwarfs the materials in Petraeuss case. Tompkins illustrates that the lack of markings on the information in question is immaterial if an officials high position and familiarity with governments intelligence-handling protocols make it obvious that the information is classified exactly the point Judge Mukasey made in his op-ed.

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/423340/clinton-e-mail-scandal-a-laughable-defense


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Your bizarre obsession with Clinton's e-mails resembles nothing so much as it does the Benghazi pseudo-scandal. Endless gossip, rumors, half-truths and speculation.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

You are the one posting spin from Clinton donors as seeds, not me. Just trying to keep you from misleading the people.

Let's discuss obsessions. In the last week, I've posted one seed on this topic (this one). You have posted three. Physician, heal thyself.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean, isn't it true that the 150 e-mails released yesterday were designated "classified" BECAUSE they were about to be made public and given to the media, and that they were not "classified" at any point prior to that ?

Isn't it true that ABC News had a report where experts stated that it is not possible to send marked classified material through any unclassified e-mail system

"It is not possible to send a properly marked and classified email through an unclassified State Department account or a private email account, according to multiple senior government officials familiar with handling sensitive materials in the government email system."

...

Thus demonstrating that the materials could not have been classified when Clinton received them.

Your argument is down to the debatable proposition that she should have known that these various e-mails ought to be "classified".

If and when some controlling authority says THAT, maybe you will have a good political talking point. Right now all you have is confusing , dubious speculation and gossip.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

t true that the 150 e-mails released yesterday were designated "classified" BECAUSE they were about to be made public and given to the media, and that they were not "classified" at any point prior to that ?

No. both the State Department and Intelligence Community Inspector General have already stated, those materials were classified at "birth."

I t is not possible to send a properly marked and classified email through an unclassified State Department accountor a private email account,according to multiple senior government officials familiar with handling sensitive materials in the government email system. "


Who cares? The issue is if she included classified material in her emails, which she obviously did. The markings are irrelevant, especially for material that is obviously classified. To quote Andy McCarthy:

"Clinton rationalizes that because the emails were not stamped classified, she could not have been expected to know they were classified. As Ive been emphasizing since March, she is trying to exploit the publics unfamiliarity with the distinction between classified documents and classified information the former are obviously classified because they are marked as such; the latter, because of its nature, is well known to national security officials to be classified regardless of whether it is marked as such or even written down at all."

Further:

In the first year of his administration (December 29, 2009, to be exact), President Obama issued Executive Order 13526, entitled Classified National Security Information. It explains that information is deemed classified if its disclosure would cause damage to the national security... With that as background, the order makes clear that there is one category of information that is automatically deemed classified: information from foreign governments. S ection 1.1(d) of the executive order decrees: The unauthorized disclosure of foreign government information is presumed to cause damage to the national security....

As has been clear from the beginning, and is now patent after the latest disclosure of a subset of 6,000 of the emails Clinton deigned to preserve, at least 125 of which reportedly contain classified information, the emails Clinton sent, received and stored via her private server system were rife with information from foreign governments. This information was born classified. It makes no difference that these emails were not stamped top secret; all national security officials with security clearances know that foreign government information is deemed classified and must be handled as such. Period.

Read more at: ...


 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Here's some additional evidence showing the Federal Government believes HRC created classified information that she then shared on her private server:

In this July 2010 e-mail, for example, the entirety of Hillary Clintons message was redacted prior to its public release under the federal FOIA law. The redactions of the material were provided pursuant to a provision of law protecting national security information. The printed redaction code 1.4(D), cited next to the redaction and at the top of the document next to the official classification date, pertains to information on [f]oreign relations or foreign activities of the United States, including confidential sources[.] At the top of the document, a declassification date of July 1, 2025 is clearly noted:

Hillary Classified 1

That declassification date is highly significant because it is precisely 15 years after the date on which the e-mail was sent, rather than the date on which it was marked .

T hat is because under federal law, information is classified by nature, not by marking. As a result, federal classification authorities deemed that the information was classified the very second it originated, even if it was not marked as such until August 27, 2015. Also worthy of note is the fact that Hillarys message is the only content in the entire document that is redacted and marked as classified. This means that she was not merely a helpless, passive recipient of classified national security information; she was the originator. And not only did she intentionally originate the classified information, she intentionally disseminated it via an unsecured, unsanctioned private e-mail server.

...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

At best you have a political argument, not a scandal to appear leading the nightly news every day.

Hillary Clinton is not going to be prosecuted unless it is shown that she knowingly handled classified e-mails. Since a private e-mail system could not receive e-mails that were marked as classified , we know that she did not knowingly handle marked e-mails.

Numerous experts in this have said that she is not going to be prosecuted, for the reasons mentioned.

You are left with wanting a political witch hunt to dominate the news into the forseeable future.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Hillary Clinton is not going to be prosecuted unless it is shown that she knowingly handled classified e-mails. Since a private e-mail system could not receive e-mails that were marked as classified , we know that she did not knowingly handle marked e-mail

That's simply false as any non Clinton spokesman will tell you. Keep making silly shit up, maybe it will convince the idiots. The reality is that Clinton is exploiting your ignorance of the distinction between classified documents and classified information. (Hint, she's in trouble for improperly storing and distributing classified information. The form isirrelevantas the General Petearus diarydemonstrated.)

I've explained it clearly as I can. I can't help if it you want to persist in willful ignorance clinging to a fake legal standard that bears no connection to the actual statutes at issue.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Here's an interesting link from a former AG :

On MSNBC's Morning Joe, Mukasey said "I think the more dangerous part of this, from her standpoint, is not so much the placement of the material here as wiping the server."

"Number one, that's a felony, but that statute disqualifies you from holding any further office in the United States and she's running for a further office under the United States."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Petey, Mukasey has already apologized for his error, as I have explained to you on another thread.

You might want to delete your mistakes instead of just letting them lay here.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Until Mukasey explains why he changed his mind I'm going with his original assessment .

He was referring to a section of federal law making it a crime to file false crop or weather reports and forbidding federal employees to falsify financial records. A statute in that section, titled "Concealment, removal, and mutilation generally," provides that anyone who has custody of federal records and who "conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, falsifies or destroys" them shall be fined or imprisoned or both and "be disqualified from holding any office under the United States."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

He changed his mind because he was wrong. I gave you the info on another thread, which you are ignoring , lol.

You funny Petey.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

If he didn't explain his reasoning then he is obviously just yielding to political pressure.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

He was wrong Petey. He misread the law.

 
 

Who is online

CB


81 visitors