Out of Touch Punditry Should Get a Grip -- Hillary's Email Is Non-Story
Out of Touch Punditry Should Get a Grip -- Hillary's Email Is Non-Story
"A message to the out-of-touch Washington pundit class: get a grip. What was or was not on Hillary Clinton's email server when she was Secretary of State is not a game-changing news story.
In fact, no one outside the chattering class -- and right-wing true believers -- could give a rat's rear about this story -- and there is a good reason: there is no "there" there. If someone really thinks the great "email" story -- or the Benghazi investigation -- are going to sink her candidacy, I've got a bridge to sell them.
Of course, this is not the first time that the media -- with an assist from right-wing political operatives -- have laid into Hillary Clinton in an attempt to create a "scandal" where there was none.
Over the weekend, syndicated columnist Gene Lyons quoted a New York Times editorial as saying:
"These clumsy efforts at suppression are feckless and self-defeating." It argued that these actions are "swiftly draining away public trust in (her) integrity."
That editorial actually appeared in January 1994. The Times was expressing outrage at Hillary Clinton's turning over Whitewater documents to federal instigators rather than the press, which, as Lyons pointed out, " had conjured a make-believe scandal out of bogus reporting of a kind that's since become all too familiar in American journalism."
Speaking on NPR's Diane Rehm show, the Atlantic's Molly Ball sounded the same notes 21 years later. The email issue "continued to contribute to the perception that she has something to hide."
The Times' Sheryl Gay Solberg added that the email issue "creates and feeds into this narrative about the Clintons and Mrs. Clinton that the rules are different for them, and she's not one of us." Really?
What might really feed a negative narrative would be the New York Times' own story several weeks ago that falsely accused Ms. Clinton of being under criminal investigation. Which she is not and never was. The Times public editor acknowledged that the story was false and that it feed another narrative: that the New York Times had an ax to grind against the Clintons.
Of course the bottom lines of this story are simple:
At the time Ms. Clinton was Secretary of State there was no prohibition against the Secretary of State having a private email server. In fact, no Secretary of State before Ms. Clinton had a government email account.
None of the emails on the Secretary's personal account were classified at the time they were sent or received. That is not in dispute. There is an on-going controversy between various agencies of what ought to be classified in retrospect as the material is released to the public by the State Department, but that does not change the fact that none of it was classified at the time. In fact, one of the several emails at issue actually says the word "unclassified" in the upper left hand corner and can still be accessed by the general public on the State Department web site.
Finally, no one has ever pointed to an instance where the fact that something was on her server instead of a government server had any negative consequences whatsoever.
There is no issue here, period.
And as for the Benghazi "affair," none of the many investigations that have already been completed concerning the events surrounding the death of the American Ambassador to Libya in the Benghazi attack has found a shred of evidence that that Hillary Clinton did anything wrong whatsoever leading up to or in response to that attack.
And frankly if you ask most people about the Benghazi affair they think you're talking about something you rub on your muscles to reduce pain.
So now Congressman Trey Gowdy, who is the Chair of the Select Committee that was set up by the Republicans in the House to once again investigate this non-scandal, has decided to investigate the non-existent issue of the Clinton email server as well -- even though he acknowledges that it has nothing to do with Benghazi.
Not withstanding the lack of substance to any of these issues, people like Chris Cillizza of the Washington Post proclaim that they could be a terrible weight on her candidacy.
Who exactly are these pundits talking to? Rarely have they been so out of touch with the real American electorate. The perceptions and narratives they are discussing are the perceptions and narratives of the insider pundit and political class -- not normal voters.
And the same goes for often-unnamed Clinton backers that are wringing their hands that Clinton has not yet put the email issue behind her.
No one is handed the American presidency -- and that is especially true of a candidates that are not incumbent Presidents.
Every candidate faces many challenges and hurdles to getting elected -- and Hillary Clinton is no different. But the email-server issue is not one of them.
Clinton's campaign completely recognizes that it must fight for every delegate in the primaries and every vote in the general election.
In the general election, she must motivate Democratic base voters to turn out in massive numbers. She must excite new voters -- especially young people and women. And she must persuade undecided voters that she will fight effectively to actually change the rules of the political and economic game so that we have economic growth that benefits every American, not just Corporate CEO's and Wall Street Banks.
These are her real challenges -- and her campaign is focused like a laser on meeting those challenges.
It's time for her supporters to focus on those challenges as well -- and for the media to resist continuing to play its role as enabler of baseless right wing attacks like the great email and Benghazi "scandals" of 2015."
Tags
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agoLast night 7000 e-mails were released to the media. Reports are that 150 of them were "classified" in preparation for them being released to the public. They were not indicated as classified when Hillary Clinton received them.
The national media is CLEARLY aiding and abetting the Republican Party and other various Clinton haters by their fanning the flames of this paltry "scandal".
It is time for Democrats and all people who want fairness in politics to push back against this witch hunt.
Sean Treacy
11 years agoThis take is insane.
Such a lapdog of the powerful you are. Even if you look at her actions in the best possible light, She set up a private server to evade required oversight and record keeping. that doesn't even go into national security law she so grossly violated by storing hundreds of classiifed and top secret documens on her insecure server.
The fbi investigates the leading contender for the democratic nomination for violating the espionage act and you call it a non story. I'm sure Nixon wished he had more people around like you to support him. Laws don't mean anything to people like you, if the perpetrator is rich and powerful enough.
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agoI think that the matter of Clinton using private email is something people should consider, should they choose to, when they decide who to vote for in the presidential contests. They can decide how much, if at all, it bothers them.
People like you want to end her candidacy over something that is at best a tangential issue, and the media is happy to try and create a snowball effect because controversy drives their ratings.
Most people are sheep and follow whichever way the wind is blowing, and right wingers are most like that. They have go to pundits like those on Fox and Limbaugh and Levin and a few others. They have their go to web sites. They are unable to create original thoughts, so their leaders tell them who to hate.
Hillary Clinton is not being investigated by the FBI, the e-mails are.
You better hope this puts a stake through her heart, because if she comes back from this, when it is over the pendulum will swing in the other direction.
Dean Moriarty
11 years agoRobert Creamer is a political strategist that get paid to fluff Democrats. This is what he does for a living.
LynneA
11 years agoThe problem I see for Hillary is lost campaign momentum. Peoplemade theirdecision regarding Benghazi a long time ago.
As far as the server, different story as people are waiting to see if there is a smoking gun. Having them released in this manner has got to be an albatross around her neck. Everyone knows she shouldn't have used the server, but I don't think criminal attaches...only time will tell.
Sean Treacy
11 years agoillary Clinton is not being investigated by the FBI, the e-mails are.
"The FBI does not investigate machines. It investigates people, and to say she is not one of the people being investigated is ridiculous."
Former Attorney General Mukasey
jennilee
11 years ago
96WS6
11 years agoThey don't necessarily have to be marked classified.
Keep telling yourself she didn't do anything wrong and maybe it will be so. LMAO!
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agoFormer AG Michael Mukasey Says he's Wrong About Clinton Emails
Former U.S. attorney general Michael Mukasey says he was wrong to suggest that if Hillary Clinton was ever convicted of destroying government records by
Nowhere Man
11 years agoIt is time for Democrats and all people who want fairness in politics to push back against this witch hunt.
Push back against this witch hunt? HUH?
Unless you missed it....
They are...
Trying to get Biden to run since Warren has absolutely refused.
Says the inside power brokers in the Democrat party are having serious issues with Ms Clinton's candidacy.
Only the ideologically blind cannot or are unwilling to see it.
Little by little they are inching closer and closer to saying a law has been broken, a crime committed...
If Hillary goes down because of this scandal, people are going to react against the party, not her.
But I suspect all things being equal, this is too far along to sweep away, and is a huge boat anchor she will be dragging around with her forever.
And it is about personal integrity, which she has already said in hindsight wasn't what it should have been as far as the e-mails were concerned.
She's her own worst nightmare as a candidate for president at this time. And the rank and file are reacting to it, given her steadily decreasing polling numbers as more and more is revealed.
Petey Coober
11 years agoGood link John :
On MSNBC's Morning Joe, Mukasey said "I think the more dangerous part of this, from her standpoint, is not so much the placement of the material here as wiping the server."
"Number one, that's a felony, but that statute disqualifies you from holding any further office in the United States and she's running for a further office under the United States."
Petey Coober
11 years agoThis is what happens when one hasn't got the interest to read anything but the headlines . Mukasey said in no uncertain terms that wiping the server means that Hillary's political career is toast .
1ofmany
11 years agoI see no other purpose to a private email account maintained on a private server other than to correspond in a fashion that would be completely inaccessible to anyone who filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) with the State Department or anyone pursuing a Congressional inquiry. No one in the State Department responding to inquiries would even know that her private server existed and, therefore, she ran no risk of anything being disclosed (even a redacted version). If the server is discovered, it's simply wiped clean and all her correspondence, including her Benghazi shenanigans, disappears into oblivion. She may or may not have violated criminal statutes with some of these emails but she was surely trying to evade having any eyes on her correspondence other than her own.
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agoThis is what happens when one hasn't got the interest to read anything but the headlines . Mukasey said in no uncertain terms that wiping the server means that Hillary's political career is toast .
There is something wrong with your mind Petey. Maybe more naps or something along that line will help.
On MSNBC's Morning Joe, Mukasey said "I think the more dangerous part of this, from her standpoint, is not so much the placement of the material here as wiping the server."
"Number one, that's a felony, but that statute disqualifies you from holding any further office in the United States and she's running for a further office under the United States."
-
On MSNBC's Morning Joe, Mukasey said "I think the more dangerous part of this, from her standpoint, is not so much the placement of the material here as wiping the server."
"Number one, that's a felony, but that statute disqualifies you from holding any further office in the United States and she's running for a further office under the United States."
He was referring to a section of federal law making it a crime to file false crop or weather reports and forbidding federal employees to falsify financial records. A statute in that section, titled "Concealment, removal, and mutilation generally," provides that anyone who has custody of federal records and who "conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, falsifies or destroys" them shall be fined or imprisoned or both and "be disqualified from holding any office under the United States."
But now, Mukasey says he was wrong.
Some legal scholars pushed back against his Monday comment immediately, most notably Seth Barrett Tillman, a former teacher at Rutgers Law School, now at Maynooth University in Ireland.
He wrote that applying the statute to candidates for president would be unconstitutional. The only limits on qualifications to be president are in the Constitution having US citizenship, being at least 35, and having lived in the US at least 14 years.
Tillman quoted from a recent court opinion that said, "The democratic presumption is that any adult member of the polity ... is eligible to run for office" and Congress cannot "supplement these requirements."
Tillman's objection was picked up by a legal blog maintained by UCLA Law Prof. Eugene Volokh.
On Thursday, Volokh said he received an email from Mukasey that said, "On reflection ... Professor Tillman's (analysis) is spot on, and mine was mistaken."
The disqualification statute, Mukasey said in the e-mail, "may be a measure of how seriously Congress took the violation in question, and how seriously we should take it, but that's all it is."
YOU ARE WRONG PETEY. WRONG.
What else is new ?
Sean Treacy
11 years agoYeah, the only plausible explanation for setting up a private email server was to avoid government oversight/required record keeping. Long way towards establishing intent.
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agolol
When she is not indicted , what will you do as penance? I think you should watch Rachel Maddow and Lawrence O'Donnell every night for a month.
Petey Coober
11 years agoThis is obviously the result of political pressure brought to bear on Mukasey and is not a reflection of what the law says .
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agolol
You are always entertaining, in a pathetic sort of way, I'll give you that.
J Martin
11 years agoNuthin like a good chicken little sandwitch, by golly, by gee.
Nuthin beats Kenyan chicken -- mmm mmmmmm!
J Martin
11 years ago"When she is not indicted , what will you do as penance? I think you should watch Rachel Maddow and Lawrence O'Donnell every night for a month."
And Democracy Now! ... and Mike Malloy!
Petey Coober
11 years agoYou will never live down that Chicken Little criticism . This should be a learning experience for you but you will prevent that from happening .
J Martin
11 years agoI'm just going to pretend that it would be meaningful and coherent to say that this whole topic is a chicken little topic.
Those with an interest in details may request my curried chicken little recipe.
Petey Coober
11 years agoIt's important that you protect little James Martin from the real world ...
LynneA
11 years agoMaybe not to you, but you would not criticize anything she did.
Jennilee - Is this in response to me or someone else? I'm confused
1ofmany
11 years ago
seeder
JohnRussell
11 years agoIf she and Obama really believed the attack was spontaneous, how is it that a "mastermind" was arrested and charged with the oxymoronic act of planning a spontaneous event?
It's simple , it was planned and carried out in the span of a few hours. On the scene witnesses said that some of the attackers mentioned the video.
They "spontaneously" decided to attack the consulate that day, after watching Al-Jazeera coverage of the "video" riot in Cairo. Then they "planned" the attack and carried it out. It wasn't rocket science, as they say.
Randy
11 years ago1ofmany is just writing down an outline to a novel he is going to write to try to compete with Tom Clancy. Like "The Hunt for Red October", it'll be pure fiction too.
Randy
11 years agoIt is time for Democrats and all people who want fairness in politics to push back against this witch hunt.
Which is exactly what it is. A witch hunt.
Petey Coober
11 years agoA secret private server is essentially a hiding place and people keep hiding places because they have (or expect to have) something to hide.
Exactly . And since Hillary wiped hers clean that shows an intent to hide something .
1ofmany
11 years agoIt's simple , it was planned and carried out in the span of a few hours. On the scene witnesses said that some of the attackers mentioned the video.They "spontaneously" decided to attack the consulate that day, after watching Al-Jazeera coverage of the "video" riot in Cairo. Then they "planned" the attack and carried it out. It wasn't rocket science, as they say.
And that, sir, proves why the emails ARE a story. One of the recovered emails is from Sidney Bluementhal who tells Hillary on September 13th that the attack on September 11th had been planned for about a month and carried out by well-trained killers. There were apparently other Bluementhal emails that are as yet undiscovered as well as Hillary emails to Bluementhal that have alldisappeared.All of this grey area as to what she knew and when she knew it is there precisely because Hillary used a secret private server instead of a government server. She knew exactly what she was doing.
1ofmany
11 years ago1ofmany is just writing down an outline to a novel he is going to write to try to compete with Tom Clancy. Like "The Hunt for Red October", it'll be pure fiction too.
Hillary's writing it for me and I shall call it "Lies don't mind who tell them."
Nowhere Man
11 years agoOut of Touch Punditry Should Get a Grip -- Hillary's Email Is Non-Story
let me ask one simple question then.
IF this is such a NON-STORY...
then why are you writing about it so vehemently?
jennilee
11 years ago
LynneA
11 years ago
No sorry required Jennilee, sometimes trying to connect the dots on this forum is not easy! Thanks for responding.
Spikegary
11 years agoSo does John, except the paycheck part.
The bottom line is Hillary skirted the rules (and laws) for the sake of her convenience and personal privacy. It was bad judgment, which she continues to use. That's the issue. Is that the kind of person America needs as President? No. She is viewed as dishonest-which is hurting the Democrats in their pursuit of the White House.......
Spikegary
11 years agoOne of your more coherent and truthful comments, John, but the CoC and all.....
1ofmany
11 years agoExactly . And since Hillary wiped hers clean that shows an intent to hide something .
She knew that keeping potential evidence outside of government custody makes it easy to eliminate and, once eliminated, can't be usedagainst her in a criminal action. Of course, the alternative is that this is all perfectly innocent and that she was just too stupid to put two separate email accounts on one phone . . . so she stupidly commingled personal and governmentcorrespondence without realizing (as an attorney) that all her personal email may be subject to scrutiny iftheserver is seized to get access to government related emails.
