╌>

Hillary Clinton, the Great Defender

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  11 years ago  •  6 comments

Hillary Clinton, the Great Defender

NYTLogo.jpg?width=200
Op-EdColumnist David Brooks Sept. 1, 2015


la-pn-hillary-clinton-2016-campaign-analysis-20150412?width=350

Hillary Clinton obviously had a bad summer. Shes losing in New Hampshire to Bernie Sanders, even among women. Shes barely leading him in Iowa. In a Quinnipiac University poll [ 1 ] of potential general election matchups, shes beating Donald Trump by only four points, 45 to 41, and shes beating Marco Rubio by only one point.

The conventional Democratic muck-a-muck view is that she horribly mishandled the private email server issue. Thats part of it, but the polling shows a much more pervasive personal set of weaknesses.In an AP/GfK poll
[ 2 ] , only 40 percent of Americans think she is compassionate. Only 30 percent say she is honest. In a variety of polls, many voters say she just doesnt get people like them, usually the key Democratic strength .

Not all of these troubles are her fault. Its tough to run as a member of the establishment in this time of popular disgust with establishments (ask Jeb Bush). But Clintons campaign nonetheless has a distinct aura. Maybe next to Michael Dukakiss, it is the least romantic, poetic and uplifting Democratic campaign in decades.

All descriptions of her campaigns have to start with the fact that for most of Clintons politicalcareer she has been playing defense. Sometimes shes had to defend herself from critical barrages amid scandal: Whitewater and the Rose Law Firm records straight through to Benghazi and the email server. Other times shes had to endure emotional and media exposures sparked by her husbands escapades.

Even when she ran for president in 2008, she was on the defense against the Obama tide. She campaigned best when the Obama tide was strongest and she was forced to struggle against it.

This pattern of playing on the defensive side of the ball has given her real strengths she has endured and persevered and rarely bent. But this defensive posture has given her, at least in public, an embattled combative posture, and sometimes an air of reactiveness.

In her campaign speeches she describes a political, economic and global world that is red in tooth and claw. The main traits required to survive in this struggle against the contemptible foes are tenacity, toughness and calculation. There is a pervasive us/them assumption in her speeches, and the need for armoring up. The defining verb in her political campaign is fight.

In speeches she is at her best when describing people who have been pushed to the wall by circumstances the single mom who is trying to find a way to pay for day care, the college student deluged with rising tuition costs. She can be quite funny in her speeches, but her humor is the humor of the counterattack mostly sarcastic humor aimed at Republicans, the press and her critics.

The ironic fact is that she now bears the subliminal weight of scandals more heavily than Bill. Thats in part because he at least gives the appearance of putting any resentments he might have about them in the past. He seems emotionally loose, open and trusting. She often does not give that impression.

Shes still the prohibitive favorite to get the nomination, but we have yet to see if she can play offense. Campaigns do have to have some creative romance to them, an uplifting mood if not a new agenda. So far Clinton has not creatively defined a new field in front of the country. Instead, shes left a void others are filling.

[ LINK ]


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

On March 29th of this year I wrote an article expressing my concerns regarding Hillarys' viability as the best choice for the Democrats in 2016.

In it I said, " I want to see a Democrat in the Oval Office come January 2017, and in my opinion, running Hillary is way too risky. Mainly, she has too much baggage and because of her propensity to ma ke major PR blunders, she is likely to create more baggage along the campaign trail. "

Well guess what, we aren't out of the primaries yet and the NY Times is publishing op-eds questioning her ability toadequately manage her campaign.

Just as Brooks states in his op-ed about Hillary always being in the defense, I said this Spring, " Hillary is a lightening rod and seems to be constantly putting herself in positions where she has to be on the defense, and she's not that good at it, is what I'm concerned about. "

I think the only save for the Dems is going to be Joe Biden,especially if he can convince Liz Warren to be his running mate.

I once thought Bernie Sanders might be a premium choice for the Dems, but his announcement wasreceivedwith littlemore than moderateenthusiasm, so apparently he hasn't got the magic touch ittakes to turn on thevoters.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Its strange, but comparing Hilary to Bill, she just doesnt have that something, whatever it is, that makes Bill likeable even among political foes. Bill could give a speech and sound compassionate and sincere, even when lying his ass off. Hillary, on the other hand, sounds condescending and rude. She just does not have the likeable factor.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Jerry

I think "Pretender" rather than "Defender" is a much more accurate descriptor for Mrs. Clinton - she pretends to part of the middle class, she pretends to be anti-Wall Street, she pretends to anti "big money". she pretends to be a progressive........

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

You are the liberal that falls into the trap Jerry. If more liberals spoke out in defense of Clinton she wouldn't be in this bad of a predicament now. The enemies have successfully manipulated the media narrative about Hillary Clinton.

Her best and most natural constituency is the moderates, who tend to be a pretty silent group that doesn't want to get involved. The people best able to defend Hillary, the vocal and activist left who are used to getting their hands dirty, don't want to defend Hillary because they want Bernie Sanders to get the nomination. I want Sanders too, but I still know a rat when I see one. Clinton is getting railroaded.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Her defensive posture and "victimhood" that arises from her constant blurring of the line between the legal and illegal is what makes her so appealing to a certain species of democrat. It's certainly not her track record of constant failure unmitigated by any public successes that pushed her to the top of the democratic race. The only qualities that make her a viable candidate are nostalgia for her husband and the fact that Republicans don't like her.

Luckily for her, there's a significant number of democrats who feed off her paranoia. The more she blames her constant failures, ethical troubles etc.. on a "Republican conspiracy" the more they support her. They don't have to think about her uninterruped string of failing at every public job she's had and her inability to bring anything new to the table. They can blame Republicans and rally around the all- important Party, which is all they need or want.

Sort of like Trump thrives off of violating PC taboos, HRC thrives off of the scandals that inevitably follow her refusal to follow the ethical rules that the rest of us mere mortals do. There are a significant number of paranoid, hyper-partisan democrats who will excuse her anything, so long as they can blame Republicans for it. In a weird way, her failures and misdeeds actually help her with these extremists, as it allows them to wallow in the conspiracy thinking that dominates their world view.

 
 

Who is online

CB


81 visitors