Experts In Government Secrecy Law See Almost No Possibility Of Criminal Action Against Hillary Clinton Over E-Mails
No evidence has emerged showing Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton broke government secrecy laws
Experts in government secrecy law see almost no possibility of criminal action against Hillary Clinton or her top aides in connection with now-classified information sent over unsecure email while she was secretary of state, based on the public evidence thus far.
Some Republicans, including leading GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump, have called Ms. Clinton's actions criminal and compared her situation to that of David Petraeus, the former CIA director who was prosecuted for giving top secret information to his paramour. Others have cited the case of another past CIA chief, John Deutch, who took highly classified material home.
But in both of those cases, no one disputed that the information was highly classified and in many cases top secret. Petraeus pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor; Mr. Deutch was pardoned by President Bill Clinton.
By contrast, there is no evidence of emails stored in Hillary Clinton's private server bearing classified markings. State Department officials say they don't believe that emails she sent or received included material classified at the time. And even if other government officials dispute that assertion, it is extremely difficult to prove anyone knowingly mishandled secrets.
"How can you be on notice if there are no markings?" said Leslie McAdoo, a lawyer who frequently handles security-clearance cases.
Ms. Clinton's critics have focused on the unusual, home-brew email server Ms. Clinton used while in office and suggested that she should have known that secrets were improperly coursing through an unsecure system, leaving them easily hackable for foreign intelligence agencies. But to prove a crime, the government would have to demonstrate that Ms. Clinton or aides knew they were mishandling the informationnot that she should have known.
A case would be possible if material emerges that is so sensitive Ms. Clinton must have known it was highly classified, whether marked or not, Ms. McAdoo said. But no such email has surfaced. And among the thousands of documents made public, nothing appears near the magnitude of the Top Secret material Mr. Petraeus and Mr. Deutch mishandled.
http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20150831/POLITICS/150839992/experts-say-clinton-likely-to-be-cleared-in-email-scandal
Petraeus prosecutor: Clinton committed no crime
Unlike Petraeus, Clinton did not "knowingly" store or share classified information in violation of the law.
Former attorney general Michael Mukasey recently compared the inquiry into Hillary Clintons use of a private email server when she was secretary of State with former CIA director David Petraeus federal conviction for the unauthorized removal and retention of classified information.
As the former U.S. attorney for the Western District of North Carolina, I oversaw the prosecution of Gen. Petraeus, and I can say, based on the known facts, this comparison has no merit. The key element that distinguishes Secretary Clintons email retention practices from Petraeus sharing of classified information is that Petraeus knowingly engaged in unlawful conduct, and that was the basis of his criminal liability.
The facts of Petraeus case are a matter of public record . During his tenure as the commander of the International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan, Petraeus recorded handwritten notes in personal journals, including information he knew was classified at the very highest levels.
These journals contained top secret and even more sensitive code word national defense information, including the identities of covert officers, war strategy, intelligence capabilities, diplomatic discussions, and quotes and deliberative discussions from National Security Council meetings, including discussions with the president of the United States.
Both the law and his oath required Petraeus to mark these books as top secret and to store them in a Secured Compartmented Information Facility. He did neither.
Rather, Petraeus allowed his biographer to take possession of the journals in order to use them as source material for his biography.
Importantly, Petraeus was well aware of the classified contents in his journals, saying to his biographer, Paula Broadwell on tape, I mean, they are highly classified , some of them. They dont have it on it, but I mean theres code word stuff in there.
When questioned by the FBI, Petraeus lied to agents in responding that he had neither improperly stored nor improperly provided classified information to his biographer. As Mukasey also highlighted , the key element is that Petraeus conduct was done knowingly. That is, when he stored his journals containing highly classified information at his home, he did so knowingly. Petraeus knew at that time that there was classified information in the journals, and he knew they were stored improperly.
In sharp contrast, Clinton is not being investigated for knowingly sending or receiving classified materials improperly.
THE REST http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/08/30/clinton-controversy-no-comparison-petraeus-column/71421242/

"Former attorney general Michael Mukasey recently compared the inquiry into Hillary Clintons use of a private email server when she was secretary of State with former CIA director David Petraeus federal conviction for the unauthorized removal and retention of classified information.
As the former U.S. attorney for the Western District of North Carolina, I oversaw the prosecution of Gen. Petraeus, and I can say, based on the known facts, this comparison has no merit. The key element that distinguishes Secretary Clintons email retention practices from Petraeus sharing of classified information is that Petraeus knowingly engaged in unlawful conduct, and that was the basis of his criminal liability."
Anne Tompkins