Hobby Lobby Backfires on Republicans As Ruling Being Used By al-Qaida Facilitator In GITMO
We tried to warn conservatives about the precedent the Hobby Lobby decision would set, but they were convinced that religious freedom meant freedom for right wing Christian conservatives and their corporations only. You know, the alleged good guys.
But then logic came out to play and rained on right wing gloating. Guantnamo (Gitmo) detainees are now citing the Hobby Lobby case as the reason that their religious rights should be acknowledged. After all, how can they be less of a person than a corporation?
If, under our law, Hobby Lobby is a person with a right to religious freedom, surely Gitmo detainees are people too, the prisoners lawyer wrote in a statement .
The motions , via Think Progress , ask for the right to observe communal prayer during Ramadan, the 9th month of the Islamic calendar in which Muslims worldwide observe as a month of fasting between dawn and dusk. The filing argues that prisoners were told they were not persons previously and thus do not have religious freedom. Yet, the prisons military authorities prevented them from praying communally during Ramadan because they are not persons.
But, they argue that Hobby Lobby made it clear that every entity is a person, Hobby Lobby makes clear that all persons, human and corporate, citizen and foreigner, resident and alien enjoy the special religious free exercise protections of the RFRA. l
Awkward.
Especially because the right wingers who championed Hobby Lobby just set the stage for an admitted al-Qaida facilitator (thats terrorist! in Republicanese) to demand his religious freedom in Gitmo. The suit was filed on behalf of Ahmed Rabbani of Pakistan and Emad Hassan of Yemen. Rabbini is an admitted al-Qaida facilitator, while Hassan is thought to be an al-Qaida recruiter but has denied this allegation.
The filing pleads, Guantanamo Bay detainees, as flesh-and-blood human beings, are surely individuals, and thus are no less person[s] than are the for-profit corporations in Hobby Lobby or the resident noncitizens whom Hobby Lobby gives as an example of persons to whom the RFRA must apply.
The prisoners lawyer explained in a statement that banning of communal prayers is one of a series of recent measures against detainees on hunger strike.
We are witnessing two bad right wing ideas colliding. First, Gitmo as a concept violates our democratic and moral principles and should be closed. The President has ordered the ode to Bush to be closed, but Congress (led by Republicans, but this rejection of closing Gitmo also includes many Democrats and an Independent) has denied the funding to close it. The biggest champions of Gitmo are the same folks who sell fear for a living and dont think much of freedom if it applies to anyone but themselves.
Second, the right wing Hobby Lobby argument and the right wing SCOTUS decision were bad for many reasons not the least of which was that it violates separation of church and state and discriminates against women as an entire class of people now not entitled to same protections under the law.
Prior to the Hobby Lobby decisions, I asked a conservative how they were going to feel when a Muslim used this decision to avoid following the law as it applies to everyone else. They scoffed, because when riding high on delusions of power, its easy to ignore precedent and reality. But we already went down this path and rejected it. That rejection was one of the founding principles of this nation.
For people who see danger and fear everywhere they turn, its bizarre that Republicans did not see where Hobby Lobby was taking them. They, who fear-mongered about Sharia law taking over the country, have actually managed to do just that only they opened the gates with their own alleged religious beliefs (which they dubiously qualify as Christian). They, who co-opt the founders at every turn, just spat in the face of the founders.
Turns out, there was a pretty good reason we fought so hard to be free of the tyranny of others religious beliefs being imposed upon us as law. Just wait until a Muslim business, citing the Hobby Lobby decision, sues for the right to deny a conservative something they should be entitled to under the law.
http://www.politicususa.com/2014/07/08/payback-precedent-hobby-lobby-decision-gitmo-detainees.html
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

And now it begins.
Oh, by the taxpayers who think HL should not be made to pay for contraceptives
But in future cases addressing other situations, the court says that government expense even large expenses that may have to be borne by us all are no obstacle. Thats not just unfair to other corporations and businesses that dont have a religious objection, it forces the American taxpayers to pay for the owners religious objection.
Read more: ...
How many days did it take? 7?
Oh yeah... I think I just won a bet...
Of course, If any Supreme Court gives them a leg to stand on its rasul, which gave enemy combatants the rights of citizens. I'm sure you freaked out all the people hyperventilating over this filing were equally disgusted with the liberal judges who think foreign terrorists have equal rights with American citizens. Or not, liberals seems to only get mad when Americans who own business and create jobs have their rights protected.
There can be no reasonable dispute that detainees are people but they will not prevail under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). Why? Because the Military Commissions Act of 2006 stripped the federal courts of jurisdiction to hear any case concerning the conditions and treatment of an alien confined as an enemy combatant. I believe the court will quickly dismiss the case on that ground and the Supreme Court will see no reason to review that decision.
Nothing broad-brush or subjective there.
I haven't taken a position on this -- just seeded the article. But in response to your comment, how about the detainees who were never charged and regarding whom, there has been no evidence of any kind presented.
Are they "people?"
Human beings are people by definition.
Does this mean anything to you???
"Held - As applied to closely held corporations the HHS regulations imposing the contraceptive mandate violate RFRA."
"(3) This decision concerns only the contraceptive mandate and should not be understood to hold that all insurance-coverage mandates, e.g., for vaccinations or blood transfusions, must necessarily fall if they conflict with an employers religious beliefs."
Didn't think so.
GITMO is not U. S. soil - I believe. As prisoner's of "War", they're not guaranteed 14th protection - I believe.
"Executives conduct of a foreign war."
What else needs to be said?
Indeed it does. Note what I posted in bold particularly
NECESSARILY and IF
I've been involved in arbitration awards that were decided on single words like these.
PARAPHRASING: "It should not be understood that all coverage mandates must necessarily fall BUT THEY CERTAINLY COULD."
Thelanguage is nebulous and the door is opened. I've been there -- 32+ years worth.
Is GITMO administered under American Military jurispridence?
If we're talking "war crimes" then we're talking Geneva Conventions and
And I know you revere decisions of the Supreme Court.
As far as I remember, that decision still stands if I'm wrong, please correct me.
I'm betting you're an extremist, as am I. I presume then that as long as we don't get caught and put in jail we continue to have rights. Enjoy them while you can.
The whole Gitmo situation is asinine. I find it interesting that the residents are always referred to as "detainees" rather than prisoners. I presume that is because prisoners have rights and detainees don't. Prisoners have set sentences to serve, detainees don't.
I'm betting that because of their "special situation", their petition won't go far.
Humans have rights, whether in prison or from another country.
We are now reaping the benefits our shortsightedness.
Other persons have the right to vote. Why can't they vote?
You made the statement:If you had rights, you wouldn't be here.
So let's see where that statement leads.
Premise: Humans have rights.
Prisoners don't have rights
Therefore: prisoners aren't humans.
I am hard pressed to go anywhere else with your statement. Perhaps it is not exactly what you meant. I don't know.
Well, for their kind of inmate sex, the morning after pill hasn't been a big concern until now.
I've read this twice, and, as an article, it gets better and makes more sense, each time.
I think they call this The Law of Unexpected Consequences.
Technically - no - the U. S. has rights of use - period.
At times, entities will send what are called "token claimants" into a jurisdiction to test a law. As a strategy, or even as a "serious" action, it can force a decision that, if not in favor of the claimant, then one that will demonstrate the pitfalls and or hypocrisies of a bad law or conflicted, if not corrupt system.
GITMO, as I already explained is under either military, U.S. Law and/or the Geneva Conventions. One, or possibly all or portions of each apply in matters that are to be adjudicated.
You can use qualifier words like "technically" and definitive sounding closings like "period," but that does not make GITMO an entity that exists outside of law. Eventually, when we have a functioning Congress, all of the arbitrary and capricious bullshit at GITMO will be addressed via whichever law(s) obtain.
You mean having a "sincerely held religious belief" that you can decapitate someone doesn't trump the laws that state you cannot?
What a novel revelation, Robert G.
Ah! Reality as opposed to allowing religious dogma to call the tune -- how un-right-wing
and a breath of fresh air.
So, then you agree that Hobby Lobby can't deny covering ANYTHING based solely on its "sincerely held religious belief" when a law mandates otherwise!
Back at ya' Robert G!
Correction --
I was curious so I went and read the pleadings. The case in court appears to be turning not on the Military Commission's Act (MCA) but on precisely the question A Mac raised i.e. is a detainee a person. An earlier court decision sidestepped the MCA, through its authority over habeas corpus, and ruled that detainees are not persons within the meaning of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act because it doesn't apply to non-resident aliens outside sovereign US territory. The detainees are arguing that the Supreme Court in Hobby Lobby effectively changed that precedent. The detainees are arguing that communal prayer is vital in Islam and that being able to hear each other pray in separate cells isn't good enough. Without determining whether Hobby Lobby actually changed anything, the judge appears to be trying to determine whether the prisoners' religious freedom is actually impaired and, if so, to what degree. Among other outcomes, it's possible the judge could still think the prisoners are not persons within the meaning of the RFRA and, even if they are, rule that the government has met its burden of showing that it has a compelling interest and achieved it in the least restrictive manner. But it doesn't look like the MCA will play a role in the decision as I originally thought.
Forget GITMO. What about all the Muslims in the USA in prison? Are they going to get special meals and rugs too? Oh, I forgot, they already do.
Yeah; I mean the HL decision was way back days ago. Justice isn't always swift.
Wait until the lawsuits are filed and reported. The so-called "nuisance" lawsuit is one of many test cases to come. When a law or decision or the unilateral abrogation of a contract. etc. occurs, a plaintiff entity will use a "token claimant" to "shake the tree" so-to-speak.
Do you think there's never been any lawsuits filed and heard on behalf of incarcerated individuals?
Sometimes the law is put on trial like when the SCOTUS hears a case duh!
Yes, I do go on. That happens in discussion forums. And many times I'll make a comment without making any reference to a member whose comment I'm addressing. You, however, make that difficult since you often begin ad hominem.
Six,
Prisons have chapels and chaplains.
Lawsuits don't just proceed because they're filed. A jurisdiction must decide if there is merit to go to trial. And most human beings, free or incarcerated, when accused of almost any wrong doing, are likely to claim "I didn't do it," some even when caught in the act.
"Why not demand release on religious grounds, as Muslims are superior to infidels and should never be submissive to them?"
Your myopic stereotyping is showing.
LMAO Gary!