╌>

“Something the Supreme Court is not supposed to do”: Are Christians getting preferential treatment?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  46 comments

“Something the Supreme Court is not supposed to do”: Are Christians getting preferential treatment?

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSS5ltYhTC6ckLiZfM1RdKLR8OgEx_tzYrP8xqx8jsz1scYC1tj4lZBpdc&width=100
Elias Isquith

Hobby Lobby ruling could mean some religious claims get more sympathy than others. "Troubling," an expert explains.

SCOTUS%20pix%202011.jpg?width=450

Liberals (and even some libertarians!) are still reeling from the Hobby Lobby decision the Supreme Court delivered on June 30th, a decision that seems to rather remarkably get even worse with time. Most on the left expected the result to be contrary to what theyd prefer, of course. But few beyond especially dedicated court-watchers imagined an ostensibly conservative court would in essence shatter decades of precedent on a bare-majority vote.

Hoping to further explore the Courts historically complicated relationship with social change and progress, Salon called up University of Pennsylvania Law School professor Kermit Roosevelt , author of The Myth of Judicial Activism , to discuss Mondays rulings and the inherently conservative nature of the Court. Our conversation can be found below, and has been edited for clarity and length.

First off, did anything about Mondays decisions surprise you?

I would say disappointed more than surprised. I sort of saw them coming; I think a lot of people did.You know, this is a pretty conservative Supreme Court and were getting conservative decisions.

Some folks who oppose the Hobby Lobby ruling have argued that its a form of right-wing judicial activism. Do you think thats a fair description?

Read theentireinterview with Prof. Roosevelt


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

In the past few years it seems that SCOTUS descions are based more on the of the justices political preferences rather than enforcement of the Constitution.

Conservatives maintain the Constitution is a fixed immutable document, while Progressives belive the Constitution is a living document that must be reinterpreted and amended over time as American culture and legal landscape evolves.

What do you think?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Since they believe the Constitution is a living document, then Progressives have no right, ever, to complain about a decision of the Supreme Court. Since Progressive believe the Constitution means whatever the hell 5 justices claims it does, so they must accept that it can "evolve" in ways they don't like just as easily as it can evolve in ways they do.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

If a bullfrog had wings - if a rabbit had a hip pocket - if the cow had jumped over the moon - if - if - if - if.

"IF" you don't have any facts to support your "if's" - why are you angry?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Jerry - I think - you got any links to your suppositions???

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Title not proven.Speculation as to "what it might mean," or could mean.

Take it up with Salon, it's their headline.(It's a news article Robert, news articles have "Headlines", books and essays have "titles".)

Anyway, what do you want 'proved' RG? the authors 'opinion' shown in quotation marks, or the part posed as a question?

The headline is properly structured.

".....then where would the good professor place it as to whether is should count, or not, in considerations by the Supreme Court?

Please rephrase, I don't understand your question. Where should they place what? They're preferential treatment?

Lower than free pills?

What "free pills"? The medication covered under the policy paid for by the insured or their employer as part of their employment package?

Nothing is 'free' Robert.

Btw, there have been three questions asked two in the article, and one by me;

1) Were you surprised at the ruling?
2) Do you think the ruling is a form of "right-wing judicial activism"?
3) Is theConstitutionis 'immutable' or is it a 'living document'?

Would you care to take a stab at answering any of them?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

If I knew damn well that what you said was true, I wouldn't be taking you to task over it. You have an issue with SCOTUS and Muslims?? What the hell's that got to do with the Hobby Lobby case? How 'bout showing me/us some "TRUTH" of how the decision rendered by SCOTUS was against the Muslims.

Didn't think so.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Conservatives maintain the Constitution is a fixed immutable document, while Progressives belive the Constitution is a living document that must be reinterpreted and amended over time as American culture and legal landscape evolves.

If it's a "living document" that changes over time, then what's the point of the rigorous process for amending it? To me, the words in the Constitution mean what they meant at the time it was drafted. If you want it to say something else, then amend it to change the words.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Join the Supreme Court Watch

3996_discussions.jpg?crop=1%3A1&width=150

The Supreme Court Watch was created to compile and discuss the latest SCOTUS rulings that affect our lives in very real ways. Please join us in our effort to evaluate the often controversial decisions of the "The Nine"

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

Nothing to do with the Constitution at all and they are fucking liars if they say it is about the Constitution.


Anybody, atheist or Christian, who thinks Hobby Lobby had anything to do with the Constitution would be a liar.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

We should amend the Constitution by eliminating the First Amendment as preferential treatment of religion.

While at it, we should require a two-thirds SCOTUS vote for any decision against Liberalisminstead of merely a majority. Majority votes against Conservatives can remain.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Liberals (and even some libertarians!) are still reeling from the Hobby Lobby decision the Supreme Court delivered on June 30th, a decision that seems to rather remarkably get even worse with time.

Why is it so astounding that some women can't demand that their employer pay for birth control methods (i.e. 4 out of 20 methods) that, in the employer's view, are tantamount to abortion. This is a very narrow and straightforward ruling striking a balance between the government's interests and the employer's. Hobby Lobby relied on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) which prohibits the government from substantially burdening a person's exercise of religion unless the government can show: 1) it furthers a compelling government interest and 2) the burden is the least restrictive means of furthering that governmental interest.

The government exempted non-profit corporations from its contraceptive mandate but included for profit corporations like Hobby Lobby even though there is no distinction between non-profit corporations and for profit corporations either in the law or judicial precedent. The government then "conceded" thatnon-profit corporations were persons within the meaning of the RFRA. Having conceded that the RFRA applies to corporations, and unable to explain how a for profit corporation would be outside the ambit of the law, the court applied the RFRA to the case. The court accepted that the government had a compelling interest but found that the government had not shown that saddling for profit corporations with the expense was the least restrictive means of achieving its goal. Specifically, the court noted that the government could assume the cost of providing coverage when employers raise a religious objection like the one Hobby Lobby raised or extend the exemption for religious non-profit organizations to organizations that raise religious objections.

My take on this is that the government lost, not because of a conservative court per se,but because the Obama administration's position was so arbitrary that only a rabidly liberal court could accept it.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I don't know enough about the case to knew if it favours Christians or not.

But I can't help wondering if it was seen instead as favouring, say, Muslims-- would the same liberals protesting this also protest it?

Curious minds want to know!Smile.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

In the past few years it seems that SCOTUS descions are based more on the of the justices political preferences rather than enforcement of the Constitution.

Are you basing that assumption on your having a good knowledge of court rulings in the past-- or is that something you just made up because its fits your political agenda?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

This "expert" contradicts himself:

1. few beyond especially dedicated court-watchers imagined

2.I sort of saw them coming; I think a lot of people did.

few imagined....a lot of people did.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Krishna - I think you'll note that I asked Jerry that question and also asked for links over 3 hours ago - as usual - no response.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Why is it so astounding that some women can't demand that their employer pay for birth control methods (i.e. 4 out of 20 methods) that, in the employer's view, are tantamount to abortion.

I contest the line of thinking that health insurance is a company paid item. It is part of your compensation for work done for the company. Youreceiveless cash money in lieu of being paid in benefits.

As such, the benefits are paid by the employee and the employer is working only to organize benefits in their name.

Further, the employee should have the right to determine which services are included in the insurance policy they purchase OVER those of the employer which is not paying for them, but definitely deducting taxes for "paying for them".

No one is being given anything for free here... and employees were not getting "free birthcontrol on their employeers dime" before.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Where does it say that?

I've always paid for my own benefits through my employeer. They were negotiated into the condition of my employment. They were deducted from my salary and added back in to calculate total compensation.

If my company is paying for them for me, then they should owe me more money to the terms of my total compensation package.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
A case decided by the religious freedom restoration act is a religious case? That's a bold statement.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I think the answer is pretty clear.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Well said indeed!
 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

As such, the benefits are paid by the employee and the employer is working only to organize benefits in their name.

Having been the controller for a couple of companies, I would certainly like to see how you come to this conclusion. From my viewpoint, the companies paid substantially more than the employees and we paid prevailing wages or more.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Why does the IRS not tax it as compensation?

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

How nice that you are in the position of being able to negotiate your compensation. 99% of workers are unable to do so. You are moving from the specific, to the general, a very bad logical argument.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

I think that the first part was the author, the second the expert....

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

I think that this decision is troubling.

The thing I find troubling is the way that the court used a law that was ostensibly written for persons and applied it to closely held corporations. Maybe if it were a sole proprietorship and the business was self insured I might buy the argument that the ACA was unduly burdening the practice of religious beliefs, but as a business that is Incorporated and has it's health insurance handled by an outside broker, nah, I do not see the corporation as a person and therefore do not see the application of the Religious freedom restoration act as appropriate. I see an individual human being as a person and view the corporation as a legal fiction set up to make the interface between government /business /customer more manageable.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
I am sure at some point the IRS will find a way to tax health benefits as imputed income. I think the amount paid for insurance is already being reported on w2 forms, for informational purposes only
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

jennilee - the IRS does tax medical benefits. When I retire, all the money that was listed in block 14 of my W2 ("Pre-tax vision, dental, health insurance), will be taxed.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

99% of workers are unable to do so.

Really? 56% of all internet statistics are made up on the spot is my answer to that.

I negotiated my wage starting at 16, my first job. My father always encouraged me to do so. I may have only gotten an extra 10c/hr, but it was 10c more than they offered me.

I realize negotiation is tougher now with less jobs to go around, but if they get you all the way through to the offer, you do yourself a huge disservice by not even asking. It takes time and money to vet a new employee... even at McD's they dont want to pay for a two pee tests to fill one slot.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Having been the controller for a couple of companies, I would certainly like to see how you come to this conclusion. From my viewpoint, the companies paid substantially more than the employees and we paid prevailing wages or more.

Prevailing wages PLUS competitive benefits are what is required to hire employees. It is a total package. If you offer only prevailing wages with no benefits and your competition offers both, they get the better employees.

It's capitalism at it's finest.

Wages should be wages earned. If benefits are no longer counted as wages, but as a gift that the company can control on a whim, then I should have the option to get higher wages to buy my own benefits. It's how contractors earn higher salaries, because they are meant to use the extra to buy their own benefits outside of the company.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Also, I would be more than happy to collect the amount that the company tells the government they pay me in lieu of my current salary. What they claim they pay me is tax extortion if I've ever seen it.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Prevailing wages PLUS competitive benefits are what is required to hire employees. It is a total package. If you offer only prevailing wages with no benefits and your competition offers both, they get the better employees . . .

To be clear, your comments areinconsistent with Obamacare which makes certain types of coverage non-negotiable for specified employers.The issue under the Hobby Lobby case was triggered by an HHS requirement that employers' group health plans include 20 methods of contraception without "any cost sharing requirements". That puts the cost squarelyon theemployer. If you want to negotiate coverage on contraception for all employers, then Obamacare would need to be amended or repealed.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Yes, it's still a wrong decision no matter what religion it's in favor of, IMHO. Still, you can bet that right wingers would be shitting themselves in anger. For them any ruling on religion that is not pro-Christianis a bad decision. And yes, this was a religious ruling.

It is not a religiousrulingat all. Congress makes law and the Court applies it as written. All the court did was apply the law to the facts as they're supposed to do. If people don't like whatthelawrequires,then change the law rather thancriticize the court forfollowingit.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The thing I find troubling is the way that the court used a law that was ostensibly written for persons and applied it to closely held corporations.

Once again, the government CONCEDED that a non-profit corporation is a person under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and could not explain any logical basis for saying that a for-profit corporation was not. As the Court said "no conceivabledefinition of person includes natural persons and non-profit corporations, but not for-profit corporations."

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Well, fornicate me.

Give me the correct statistic then.

I was using HYPERBOLE in that instance, I'll not make that mistake with you again.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

The link doesn't seem to work?

It's working now. At least, for me it's working. I'm using Chrome (I don't know if that makes a difference or not)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We should amend the Constitution by eliminating the First Amendment as preferential treatment of religion.

While at it, we should require a two-thirds SCOTUS vote for any decision against Liberalisminstead of merely a majority. Majority votes against Conservatives can remain.

In the first place, what do you mean by "preferential treatment of religion"? Secondly, "Liberalism" defies definition. So, on the face of it, your suggestion is absolutely absurd!

But then there's Albert Einstein ...

If at first the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it.

I agree about the 6 consenting votes idea, but it would have to be across the board.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Jerry - I think - you got any links to your suppositions???

Those 'suppositions' are conclusions based on my own observations, not links toconclusions based on someone else's observations.

Do you have any observations of your own you would like to share with us 1st? Like, do you think theConstitution is a immutable document, or a living document subject to reinterpretation as the American culture and legal landscape evolves?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If it's a "living document" that changes over time, then what's the point of the rigorous process for amending it? To me, the words in the Constitution mean what they meant at the time it was drafted. If you want it to say something else, then amend it to change the words.

That's a reallystrangecomment 1ofmany.

The Constitution doesn't change all by itself. It changes through amendments. The 'rigorous' process was put in place to make it difficult to make changes, therefore insuring those changes are notfrivolous.

To me, the words in the Constitution mean what they meant at the time it was drafted.

The Constitution was drafted in the 18th Century, we are now in the 21st Century. There are many things in the 21st Century American culture that could not have even been imagined by the 18th Century framers of the Constitution.

If you want it to say something else, then amend it to change the words.

(?!)

That's exactly what a Constitutional Amendment does! (Like I said "strange comment")

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Absolutely 1ofmany. That is the truth.

And you double down for him. Amazing. I honestlythoughtyou were smarter than that Dennis. Wrong most of the time, but ..... yeah, I thought you were smarter than that.

(strange x2)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Krishna - I think you'll note that I asked Jerry that question and also asked for links over 3 hours ago - as usual - no response.

What's this "as usual" shit?! I always have an answer, I don't always get a chance to post them, but you can be sure I always have one.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I think the answer is pretty clear.

What's that supposed to mean?

I have time explain to 1st that "suppositions" don't require links?!

'Facts' require links, 'references' require links, 'quotes' require links, ..... 'suppositions' require logic, but that's an area 1st is a little weak in, so I understand the reasoning behind (or lack thereof) behind his question.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"...... and that applies to several of the members of this site."

cookie200.jpg?width=80

NO!!!!!!

You're kidding!!!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"IF" you don't have any facts to support your "if's" - why are you angry?

If you had a response to his comment, you wouldn't be asking stupid questions.

 
 

Who is online





55 visitors