╌>

Michael Moore's Marxist Narrative History Of The United States, Refuted

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  14 comments

Michael Moore's Marxist Narrative History Of The United States, Refuted

http://faithandheritage.com/2015/08/michael-moores-marxist-narrative-of-american-history-refuted/

"Of this video my pastor friend said:This link was sent to me by a young college student who hesitatingly referred to herself as the only white person in the class of a local community college history course.In order to forward it to the pastor after class, she had found it again on YouTube by word-searching the phrase, America history cartoon white people suck.She forwarded it to the pastor because she was offended by it; she wanted advice on how to handle such an anti-White atmosphere as she encountered in class. The pastor likewise floated the video on Facebook for the same reason because he thought it outrageous.

The resulting commentary which ensued on his Facebook wall was all but unanimous in the opinion that the video represented a gross distortion of American history. That is, until a young Black attendee of the pastors church weighed in. Confident in his social superiority, he affirmed the accuracy of the video and issued blanket rebukes to all the Whites who had commented ahead of him. At which point all the candid critics of the video fell silent, or fell in behind the young Black, applauding his courage and the de facto superiority of his ethnic perspective .

The following critique of said video is a tidied-up version of the response I posted in that thread.

First, the Puritan fathers didnt leave England for fear of being persecuted. They left because they were persecuted .Their priority wasnt to assuage any irrational fear, but rather, to find a land where they might establish a more godly society so that their children would be free to obey God in public life.

Similarly, the Pilgrims didnt kill the Indians out of irrational fear. Upon arrival in the New World, the Puritans sought to evangelize the Red man, but the reaction of the Red man ranged from indifference to frequent campaigns of genocide. Of the London divines, Gray and Symonds are noted to haveviewed the conquest of this continent as a direct parallel to Israels conquest of Canaan, to be pursued principally by violence (see Grays 1609 sermon, A Good Speed to Virginia ), but the majority demurred: Daniel Price, Richard Crakathorpe, George Benson, Robert Tynley, and Richard Eburne held the founding of Virginia a part of the divine plan for the conversion of her benighted people, who were to be raised to civility, and brought to Christ, not exterminated. 1

This was the case not only in Virginia, but also in New England:

[T]here were missionary efforts to convert the Indians of New England to Christianity. As early as 1643 Thomas Mayhew labored for the conversion of the Indians of Marthas Vineyard Island, and a Narragansett sachem to whom he applied for permission to preach to his tribe replied: Go make the English good first. 2

These labors on behalf of the Red man were pursued in spite of preceding campaigns of genocide against the Whites:

In 1622 the Indians, under leadership of Opechancanough, Powhatans brother and successor, massacred three hundred and fifty of the Virginia colonists, and reduced eighty plantations to eight [only after which] [t]he whites began a terrible war of revenge against the savages. 3

Nonetheless, from the beginning, men such as John Eliot spent decades of their lives learning Indian dialects, translating the Bible and the Catechism into Indian languages, and preaching to the Red man in his own tongue. These are not the actions of irrationally fearful men bent on genocide, but the courageous and merciful acts of men seeking to disciple the nations of a heathen race.

Yetthe genocide campaigns against the Whites only increased in frequency and intensity:

In 1675 the Wampanoag prince, Metacomet, commonly known as King Philip, the son and successor of the good Massasoit, commenced a war of extermination against the white people of New England . . . and many of the whites were massacred. The whites were soon aroused, and seized their arms, while the savages desolated the English settlements on the Connecticut river . . . the following year (1676) the Indians were subjugated. 4

...And the Indians were not exterminated, as Mr. Moore alleges, for that was not the settlers objective. In fact, there are far more Indians today than there were then: eminent historian, scholar, and missionary to the Indians R.J. Rushdoony reports that prior to the coming of the White man, The Indian population was small, perhaps at most 250,000 to 300,000, and perhaps even less than half that number. 7 Compare this with the 2013 census which recorded 3,797,970Amerindians in the U.S. alone. 8 Far from a genocide, these figures seem to confirm a massive proliferation of the Indian population under the circumstance of White hegemony. And even if we granted the outrageously inflated estimate of Indian numbers in pre-columbian North America bandied about by leftists 18 million we realize that by dealing with the whole of the continent, that figure includes the Aztec empire.But if we count the descendants of those Aztecs in our tally, we are talking about 54 million within U.S. borders alone as of 2013. 9 And even if it were proven that American Indian populations have dwindled, the presence of smallpox (for which Europeans provided Indians with vaccines) and of intertribal Indian genocide would serve equally well as helpful explanations.

Underlying the whole issue is the question of whether our settlement of the Americas was an ethical enterprise. Moores video implies it was not. His view is in keeping with the zeitgeist, which holds European colonization to be the original sin of mankind.

But think about it when the White man arrived, he found an open wilderness owned, according to the rarely encountered Indian denizens, by no one; because the Red man had not even the concept of property. Like Bedouins or gypsy rovers, the Indians merely camped in a valley until they exhausted its resources, and then moved on to the next. The Indians presence in the land was transitory and rootless, without parcel or boundary. They were vagabond savages absent deed, territorial claim, or legal theory of property. Following Christian law, Europeans merely claimed the vacant, ownerless territory bestowed to them by Providence.

THE REST http://faithandheritage.com/2015/08/michael-moores-marxist-narrative-of-american-history-refuted/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Who ever wrote this, has a vast blank space between his ears. It can be refuted line by line. Why bother, I suppose there are those that think that this is gospel.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

This comes from a religious website, Christian, they say. Maybe xx has some insights to offer.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

if you say so

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

The thesis of Mr. Moores cartoon is that Whites are uniquely depraved, paranoid, and violent because we remove our children from the likelihood of rape, murder, and mayhem. On such premises, we should rather just move to Compton. But Michael Moore doesnt do that. He lives in an all-White, gated community with bodyguards. Because its safe.

There ya go . Mr. Hypocrite Moore at work

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

That is what you got out of that long article ?

lol.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

That's more than you got out of it ... LMAO !

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

How about these passages from the article Petey ?

The Indians presence in the land was transitory and rootless, without parcel or boundary. They were vagabond savages absent deed, territorial claim, or legal theory of property. Following Christian law, Europeans merely claimed the vacant, ownerless territory bestowed to them by Providence.

-

For all their endeavors to clear people of charges, the fact was that witchcraft was in deed present. So much so that the people of the town had turned a blind eye to soothsayers and renowned families of fortunetellers for generations. By the time of the trials, the court was faced with well-known dynastic covens sometimes three or four generations deep.

-

the only convicted person to have been pardoned for her crimes by the Salem court was Tituba, the slave woman from Barbados. The court reasoned that while the White girls whom Tituba coached in witchcraft knew better, Titubas African background and ignorance actually made her less culpable. Thus was she spared the penalty suffered by her White counterparts.

-

African servitude in America didnt come without reward for the slaves. They worked the fields seasonally, as is typical of all agrarian workers, and had all Sabbaths off. The rest of the time they were allowed to hire themselves out to neighbors for odd jobs to earn money and build their own estates.

-

And it wasnt White fear or oppression that inspired the slave revolt. The slavesattacked the Whites because they were still half-savage blacks . . . some of whom could still remember the taste of human flesh and the bulk of them hardly three generations removed from cannibalism.

There is a lot more but we could start with these.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You know John, since you posted the whole damned article, (instead of using a link) you could have at least posted the footnotes also.

  1. Alfred A. Cave, Lethal Encounters , p. 42
  2. Israel Smith Clare, The Standard History of the World , 1930 edition, p. 2935
  3. Ibid. , p. 2932
  4. Ibid. , p. 2935
  5. The author here cites Virginia: A History of the People by John Esten Cooke (New York, 1883), p. 28
  6. Richard Kelly Hoskins, Vigilantes of Christendom , chapter 3: Virginia, pp. 65-67. Hoskins does not cite other sources, so his telling may be apocryphal, yet whether or not it is, John Esten Cookes attestations deem such an account to be highly intrinsically probable, hence reflective of such Indians motivations. For Cooke testifies that the Indians worshiped Okee as an evil god who delighted in the suffering of children and innocents ( Virginia , pp. 28-29), they seeing no need to propitiatea good god who would not cause them injury anyway.
  7. R.J. Rushdoony, What Is Overpopulation? See also his Myth of Over-Population lecture transcription .
  8. . Of the 2013 U.S. population of 316,497,531, 1.2% was American Indian, hence 3,797,970.
  9. Ibid. Take the Hispanic or Latino category which can, admittedly, include a number of blacks and others identifying as Hispanic, but predominantly refers to Mestizos. This figure of 17.1% would yield a population of 54,121,078.
  10. This source can also be acquired here .
  11. Increase Mather, Cases of Conscience Concerning Evil Spirits , page 66 .
  12. Israel Smith Clare, op. cit. ,p. 2936
  13. Eric M. Pratt, Self-Government and theUnalienable Right of Self-Defense: Restorin... : The Colonial Approach
  14. Ibid.
  15. See this link concerning slavery in Massachusetts , for example.
  16. See this interview with Michael Hoffman .
  17. The Constitution a Pro-Slavery Compact; or, Extracts from the Madis... , p. 43.
  18. R.L. Dabney, A Defense of Virginia and the South , p. 50
  19. Ibid .,p. 47
  20. Ibid .,p. 54
  21. Steve Wilkins and Doug Wilson, Southern Slavery As It Was
  22. George Fitzhugh, The Blessings of Slavery
  23. Frank L. Owsley, The Irrepressible Conflict, Ill Take My Stand , p. 62
  24. James Henley Thornwell, The Rights and Duties of Masters , p. 14.
  25. 10 Surprising Facts About the NRA That You Never Hear
  26. George Rutherglen, Civil Rights in the Shadow of Slavery , p. 41
  27. See this article on Red Rosa , which also outlines the previous escapades of another opponent of the bus laws, Claudette Colvin .

Just in case anyone is interested in the research basis of this....

The author:

Not that I suspect anyone posting would be interested in reading about anything they have already disposed of in their own mind as bunk.This further info is not for you.

But, there are a few that still have open minds that might like to learn a different perspective than the mainstream liberal version of history. (not claiming that one side is right and the other side wrong, just that the truth usually lies in the middle.) But if you cannot or refuse to see the other side your choosing to remain blind.

I offer the rest of the info for those that choose not to remain blind.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

If you would like to hear about some of the crackpots and racists in that footnote list, I will oblige.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"Rush Limbaugh: There is so much distortion, so many lies, so many untruths taught to our innocent young skulls full of mush throughout American history about Thanksgiving and one of the things that has been taught is that the arrival of the white man, I don't know if it was the Pilgrims or whoever came later, Christopher Columbus even prior to that, and what happened was that the Native Americans were basically slaughtered. They were wiped out. We came in here, we basically took what wasn't ours and it was devastation out there.

But I ask if we could run the numbers on this. Does anybody know the total number of Native Americans killed as a result of the arrival of the white man? When we get that number we need to compare it to the number of tobacco deaths since the white man arrived in this country because it was the Native Americans who figured out what to do with tobacco. Smoke it, and in some cases chew it. And we've been told that tobacco smoking, cigarette smoking, all that, is deadly, lung cancer and so forth. How many millions of people die every year because of it? Add up the number of years, and who really killed who here in the New World? It's just a question. I'm just saying."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Is there a legitimate viewpoint that makes a case that "good" came from the European takeover of North America, in this case particularly the United States? There is such an argument because the U.S. has done some good on the world stage, especially when contrasted to the actions and activities of some other countries over the past 400 years, but I don't believe this particular article makes that argument , at all.

Which begs the question of what will appear in school textbooks. There has to be a constant vigilance as to the changing content and emphasis of what children are to be taught. The crackpot that wrote the present article and those who agree with this article would probably like his view to fill the pages of school history texts.

He claims that all the white Europeans wanted was to teach the savages the word of God, and the savage Indians resisted and started massacring and torturing the saintly Christians. He also claims that God intended for the white Europeans to have dominion over this continent.

He claims that the devil was present at Salem and there was active witchcraft, taught by an African woman who was filled with "ignorance".

He says that slaves were not mistreated by their white masters, and that whites were the ones who were afraid because many of the African slaves might be cannibals.

He says the Ku Klux Klan was actually a benign organization who merely wanted to protect white southerners from the black savages.

He says "civil rights" for Americans is a concept created by liberals and Marxists in the government in order to take away the natural God given rights of whites.

Which of these do you think belong in our history books ?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Personally, I would like the truth to fill our history books. but as in anything having to do with man, History is replete with stories of certain mans desires and the fulfillment of such desires.

The Victor writes the history in most cases, that is why there is so little truth in the history books.

Were the Indians all bad, no.

Were the colonists all bad, no.

But they did have issues, like Europe for a thousand years before any white man set foot on the continent.

As did the Indians did between each other.

I don't buy that it was all apples and cherries before the white man showed up.

But I also don't buy that it was entirely a savage frontier populated by heathens either.

AS I've said on many an occasion the truth lies somewhere in between. But the only way to reach that truth is know what both sides say the truth is, and attempt to discern the real truth from that.

It's not easy, like reading sandskrit at times. (and you take a lot of abuse from all sides)

But when your done, there is a satisfaction most will never ever know. (but then you remember that such is a job that is never done, cause the history is constantly being written as we speak)

History reveals how small humans actually are.

And who is going to give a damn 100 years from now.

Some fool just like me, (who love the abuse, sometimes I wonder if it is worth it)

 
 

Who is online







86 visitors