America's Ideological Splits Aren't As Simple As Left, Right And Center
American politics are perhaps more polarized than at any time in recent history. That doesn't mean, however, that either side is anything close to united. Those on the right and the left are ideologically fractured, a new Pew Research report finds , with the majority in the middle "unified by frustration with politics and little else" and posing challenges to both parties as they try to craft election messaging, build coalitions and motivate infrequent voters.
The report divides the American public into eight groups, many of which defy the traditional liberal/conservative boundaries. Of those, the three most consistently partisan are also the most over-represented in the political sphere, making up just a combined 36 percent of the public, but 57 percent of the politically engaged Americans who regularly vote and pay attention to the news.
Which group are you in? Take the quiz here .
The Republican base, according to the report, is anchored by two groups with very different priorities: "Steadfast Conservatives" and "Business Conservatives." Both groups dislike President Barack Obama and mistrust government intervention. But while the Steadfast Conservatives are strongly anti-immigration and opposed to homosexuality, as well as generally isolationist, their business-friendly compatriots mostly embrace immigration, tolerate homosexuality and believe the U.S. can solve world problems. Business Conservatives, unsurprisingly, are also far more sympathetic toward Wall Street.
The Democrats' most loyal voters are just one bloc: "Solid Liberals," who lean consistently to the left on most issues and reliably turn out on Election Day.
But the left also needs outreach to two groups who aren't in ideological lockstep: the young "Next Generation Left," which is socially liberal but less likely to support a strong social safety net, and the strongly religious "Faith and Family Left," which supports federal programs but is more socially conservative. Both are significantly less likely to be politically engaged.
Two more groups of even less frequent voters -- "Young Outsiders" and "Hard-Pressed Skeptics" -- fall closer to the center of the spectrum and don't particularly like either party. The former lean Republican thanks to their antipathy to government spending but are younger, more diverse and far more socially liberal than the GOP stalwarts. The latter share their support for federal programs with the Democrats but dislike Obama and the Affordable Care Act. A final group of young "Bystanders" rarely engages in politics at all.
Much about the political landscape is not new. Pew, which has been reporting on typologies since 1987, says social issues have long fractured both parties. Pro-business conservatives have typically been more socially liberal than their religious counterparts, while religious liberals are much less accepting of homosexuality and abortion than are others on the left. The latest study, however, finds the influence of New Deal Democrats largely dissipated, replaced by younger, more economically conservative voters. On the right, " Pro-Government Conservatives ," the hawkish, socially right-wing voters who helped elect President George W. Bush, have given way to the more libertarian Young Outsiders, who are socially liberal but wary of government intervention at home or abroad.
Pew surveyed 10,013 adults by phone Jan. 23 to March 16, calling both landlines and cell phones, and reached an additional 3,308 adults through a panel between March and May. Read the full report here .
Tags
Who is online
71 visitors

I ended up with Next generation left... but I dont really agree with it. The questions were too black and white for a good judge in my opinion. Once in a while I like to do these polls for fun...
Where do you fall in this weird poll?
I'm in the group who believes we have a moral obligation to help those who can not help themselves and help those who can do it. By that I mean we should have policies that do not increase our national liabilities but aim to motivate people and provide avenues that will enable them to have a decent life.
I don't expect everyone will be a millionaire and I don't want anyone to be homeless and feel helpless. I don't believe we can take the millionaires wealth and give it to the poorer people and make them any better off than they were before. Look at our recent politicians who have told you they were serving you and want to continue to serve you and examine who they have really served.
I would love to take the money out of politics, but I really don't see how that can be done so easily, since there are so many ways money can be used by outside groups to control elections.
I believe we need to change the landscape in Washington and throughout the USA and limit the number of terms Congressmen/Congresswomen and Supreme Court Judges can stay in power.
I wish more people were more informed, more involved and be more concerned with our future than they seem to be now. Any random street interview clearly shows how many people in this country are ignorant about the economic condition of this country.
I'm tired of politicians talking to us, telling us what they are going to do or are doing. I would rather have them introduce themselves and then start answering questions for the remainder of their speech with some sort of time limit on their answers instead of spending 30 minutes talking around the question and never giving an answer.
I like this...
Personally, I wish that the house of representatives was run more like civic duty office and everyone got a turn. It would be paid the same level as jury duty (15/day) and offer free room and board while in session. No more special retirement pool. Senate can still be elected, but maybe go down to 2 year terms like representatives are now... or have a consecutive limit like 4 times.
I also think that SCJ should be limited to terms and not life.
I guess I want to see more revolving door on government and less life term guys in. Mostly because the lifers gather the most pocket liners in their pants. Everyone just scratches everyone else's back until it's a corrupt pool of inbreeding.
I watch the same thing happen on acorporatelevel for all the big name companies I've worked for.And everyone in my industry tries to stick to startups for that reason... but once you get one oldtimer in, they start opening the door to all their friends... pretty soon the company is just like one of the previous companies that failed and fails for the same reason... corrupted inbred rot.
I'm going to come back to this... Got to go to Goodwill!!!
Thanks!!!
Miss,
I am also a next gen left. LOL, usually I come up as the disenfranchised.
We are in agreement in some things you've said.
Personally I don't think the 15 day idea is too good. First you have to understand the House is the House of the people who should have as much power as any other branch. They speak for each one of us. Cutting their power back to a 15 day jury duty doesn't do it for me.
The Senate represents each state.
The Executive is suppose to execute the laws. Today the Executive seems to have taken on the authority of all three branches plus it is using the bureaucracy and agencies to enforce actions not approved by Congress. The Executive Branch is way overstepping its authority.
The Judicial Branch is supposed to interpret the laws according to the Constitution. The Judicial Branch is not only interpreting the laws today, but rewriting them as well.
I think we may be able to agree:
Term limits for all three branches including the Judicial Branch.
Having the state legislatures elect the Senators from the state instead of the people. Consider we have already elected the legislatures so they would be representing us.
Granting the state legislatures and Congress (both Houses) the authority to override the Supreme Court with a vote of 60% from the states or Congress. That will not be an easy task, but we all know we are giving 9 people out of 300 million the power to rule over us. Shouldn't we have some recourse or do we want to let 9 people determine our future and as it is now they are there until they decide to retire or die.
Having a balanced budget amendment of an agreed percentage by 3/4 votes.
End any Federal Regulation after 3 years unless voted on to continue so some of these regulations are cast in stone.
Limit Federal power to take personal property.
Allow states to propose an amendment to the Constitution with support of 2/3 of the states. Right now we are operating outside the Constitution as though it didn't exist. With this we would have more control of the three branches of government and stop one branch from becoming all too powerful as it has become.
Allow the states to override Congress with 2/3 support from the states. This doesn't mean a single state can override Congress because they don't like something. It would take support of 2/3 of the states to accomplish this. It give more power to the people instead of the the elite in Washington.
Require more oversight on voting and voter ID's for all American Citizens of some sort to allow them to vote. With the recent fiasco in Mississippi of thousands of Democrats giving the election to Cochran, it clearly proves voter ID is not a problem, but an excuse that is being used for other purposes. When you have to show ID's to get into the DNC in Charlotte and many other places or receive benefits, it becomes obvious there is a problem. When organizations open right before an election such as one called "Rising Phoenix" I saw in Fayetteville right before the 2012 election and described themselves as a community help program to go out into the community and help people, but closed right after the election there is more to the story. Unless you are in a swing state, you will probably never see anything such as this.
So I know there are some of these Miss_Demeanor you must agree with here. It would work the same in practice. It would take 2/3 of the state legislatures to pass any one of these suggestions, plus any others that would be brought forth for considerations. If less than 2/3 support from the state legislatures was received on any of these, then they would not be accepted or passed.
What do you think?
I can tell you right now "I wish" isn't going to get any of those 3 branches to do anything to reduce their power.
First, a clarification. I dont mean that reps should serve 15 days. I mean the pay rate should be the same as jury duty... as in $15/day pay rate. That is in addition to free room and board while serving.
I think the tenure should be decided on the individual serving since it is a community service. I think minimum should be 3 months and maximum should be 1 year. The long standing policies should be given to those serving longer so they can see the finished product through at least into the senate.
And like jury duty, you can refuse for the common reasons (medical, family, work etc). But also like jury duty (Or FLMA), you should retain the ability to regain your job, or a similar job, when you get back.
For your suggestions... I dont know that I like senate being chosen by state legislators or not. It's an interesting concept, but it still fosters cronyism since most senators come from state office anyway and everyone likes to vote for their friend Ted... especially when the job he's going to opens up his job for your other friend Mike.
I like the idea of overriding the supreme court on it's face, but I could see congress and the president grandstanding over these decisions and more gridlock. I like the finality of having a stop button on forever going back and forth, but I dont want that stop button to be on the same desk for 45 years at a stretch. Technically the override power congress has (already) is to revise the law that the judicial branch is reading so that it reads differently. And heaven knows how long they already take to do that part.
Not sure if you mean 3/4 public or in congress. Currently it's the president's job to write the budget and congress gets to approve the amount of money (since 1974). I dont think the budget would actually get written ever again if 435 people had to write it. As for the agreed percentage... its currently at 66% I think... so taking it to 75% means they would never pay the bills again either.
I do like this up to a point. Specific required offices shouldnt be at the mercy of the political wind. I mean, I dont want to hoof and mouth to be imported because the USDA office had to shut down. Rebirth of a government system every three years would make progress difficult. I like the revolving door on the people, but the system should be more solid IMO.
I think I could get behind something like this if new regulations were put into place and reviewed after something like 1 year and then 3 years. If they pass again after 1 year and 3 years with the same level of votes that they passed with initially or MORE, they stick a little harder and dont get reviewed again. If they pass with less, they have to be reviewed again. If they dont pass, they're out.
I personally think the 4th covers this, but the interpreters (judicial) are getting a little slack. We need new interpreters, or at least a refresh rate on them.
I like the idea of states proposing. I dont know about amendments to the constitution since the state of that isnt doing bad (IMO)... but if states governments had a way to officially propose legislation in the form of bills or even motions on the floor, that could be cool.
The system of state governments voting at national level would be tricky at best. It sounds like a good idea, but organizing who represented each state when grouping states together... hmmm
I dont think voting IDs are really a good policy. I dont agree with them or support instituting them. With the sad state of voter turn out, the biggest thing is to get more people in there to actually vote. Too many decisions are on the backs of too few people because of apathy. In fact, I would welcome illegal votes because at least they are caring enough to show. What I dont want is stuffing the box with fake people, dead people, or paid votes.
I used to live in a swing state (Colorado). I've been in Washington for a couple years and want to move back (I dont like the left coast). In Washington they do mail in ballots only... and even with that... voter turn out is really low. WTF... all you do is vote, put a stamp on it and send it back... and you cant get people to do that in high numbers.
I think people cant see what their votes accomplish anymore and figuring out how to change THAT is actually what will help politics. That's kind of the root of my community service in congress idea in the first place... getting people to see government and feel it, smell it, touch it... taste it and change it.
Awesome read, thanks for the posting. Off to the link.....
Mike - The link has a ton and the book would be a fantastic read for me. Newest version, 7th edition is a little pricey, can purchase the 6th edition economically...have you read either? Checked my local library, nothing by this author
I got Solid Liberal, but I have reservations about the answers supplied. On several, I found myself in deep disagreement with both choices offered. One specifically had to do with race, and I did not answer. There were a couple of others that were almost as bad, but I bit the bullet and answered them anyway. when it gave me the results, the program indicated that I did not respond, and in hindsight, I should not have responded to the others.
It is all right to know where you fall on the political landscape, but you should really acknowledge the moral feelings that are intrinsic to most of us and respond accordingly. If that means disagreeing with the canned, falsely dichotomous answers on a web test, so be it.
Gonna agree with ya Brolly. I found myself saying that I really didn't believe in either choice. There is another quiz like this, but at least it gave you 5 choices instead of two, and even then I had a hard time.
Thank you for your response. 3/4 of the states have to participate in this.
One thing you are failing to realize is the House of Representatives are the people's representatives, not a jury for a year. They are part of the checks and balance of the three branches of our government. I'm not for career politicians, but I am for someone being there long enough to be effective for our benefit. I'm totally against your suggestion Miss_Demeanor concerning the House of Representatives. You see, we disagree here. Do you know how the Bill of Rights came about? If not it is very interesting, because it uses all the principles I have outlined here.
As far as the Senators being elected by the state legislatures that is the way it was originally. Then the Constitution was eroded to make the Senator's election no different than the House Representative's election. Think about it for a moment. There are many state legislature representative in each state representing the people of that state. The Senator is suppose to represent the state. If you already have selected your representatives for your state, then let them elect the people they want to represent the state. You have already elected the members of the House of Representatives who are representing you. Some reading on this may be interesting as well.
As far as the Supreme Court, you said you like a stop button. Do you like the idea of one person in the United States and only that one person to be able to push it and you and the other 300 million people have no recourse? The president, by the way would not come into play on this. This is just Congress and the State Legislatures. We have to have a balance of power among these three branches of government. Like anything else, there would be no litigation unless there was ample evidence it would be worthwhile, so you don't have to worry about gridlock forever on this. You can bet Congress will not do anything most of the time, because they are government whether they are Republican or Democrat and they are not going to allow one ounce of their power to be taken away unless they have no other choice. I'm not crazy about having one person determine my fate who is going to be determining it until he/she retires or dies.
I like that "not liking the stop button sitting on the same desk for 45 years". Neither do I. But we do have the power to change it. Not by voting. It will never happen by voting for the right candidate.
Cool! We do have that power and Congress, The President nor The SCOTU can not override that power. Isn't that cool? But it isn't easy. Especially in this day when so many are uninformed and complacent as you will be stating later in your comment. But it is possible.
I want to thank you for hearing me out.
Remember, we voted for all our state legislators. They represent us from the different districts in our state. They would control one vote for each state.
We totally disagree about voter ID's. Maybe we can talk later about our reasons, but for the time being we just disagree.
Now Miss_Demeanor I've run a test here. Let me tell you the results, but first let me tell you I used 3 people (You, Me and one other person) for these suggestions in order to consider the 66% or 2/3.
#1 On the House of Representatives you are overruled. You lose. Doesn't mean it can't be discussed and come to agreement that all or 2 of us would agree upon.
#2 On the Senate suggestion you win. My suggestion was rejected by the other person. So the two of you are 2/3 of the votes not in favor of doing it the way I would like to do it. I still reserve the right to try and convince you by bringing ideas and reasons to the table, but once it is voted on and is final, then that's the way it will go to Washington. Like 2/3 of the states agreed with you.
#3 Term limits on the Supreme Court Judges. We are unanimous on this one if you would like term limits. That would mean all of the states carried 50 votes to Washington to make it a law, with neither the President, Congress or the SCOTUS being able to do anything about it. They would have to abide by it like we have to abide by things we don't like when they do it. That's cool, right?
#4 Personal property. Let's leave this alone at this time since we are not in agreement and we haven't investigated it enough to really see what is happening, like the government taking quite a few people's land and making it Federal Land.
#5 States proposing is covered in Article V of the Constitution. That is what this whole thing is about.
Article Five of the United States Constitution
...
#6 Voter ID. You lost. 2 for and 1 against. Doesn't mean we can't discuss the reasons we feel the way we do, but in this case for all Federal elections we would have 66% in favor of the 100% participation of the 3 states. And those states being Miss_Demeanor, sixpick and state #3 would go to Washington and it would become law. Congress, President and SCOTUS would have to eat beans. We'd eat steak.
So, this is the only way anything is going to change in Washington. There is no other way and no hope for that matter, because Washington is going to continue to erode the Constitution until we are truly "Fundamentally Transformed".
Read the Article V link especially...
Ratification of amendments
After being officially proposed, either by Congress or a national convention of the states, a constitutional amendment must then be ratified by the legislatures of, or by ratifying conventions , in at least three-fourths of the states. Of the 27 amendments to the Constitution that have been ratified, Congress has specified the state conventions ratification method for only one: the 21st Amendment , which became part of the Constitution in 1933. Most states hold elections specifically for the purpose of choosing delegates. New Mexico provides, by state law, that the members of its legislature be the delegates at such a state ratification convention.
Although a proposed amendment is effective after three-fourths of the states ratify it, states have, in many instances, ratified an amendment that has already become law, often for symbolic reasons. The states unanimously ratified the Bill of Rights ; the Thirteenth Amendment , abolishing slavery; the Fourteenth Amendment , providing for equal protection and due process; the Fifteenth Amendment , prohibiting racial discrimination in voting; and the Nineteenth Amendment , granting women a federal constitutional right to vote. [ 5 ] In several other amendment cases, the ratification process took over a century.
Oh really?
If what you say is true, you should have no problem coming up with may links (from reliable sources) proving that.
My personal view is that there are really only two types of people- - those that believe that polls like this have any validity-- and those that don't!
I can't put my results down, because it would ruin my image.
I'm pretty sure that I do realize that... and that having people, normal people, would be exactly a representation of the people. The "people" that are representatives now are (for the most part) white, male, laywer, well off, well connected, cronies of the same "people" that have always been "the people". They arent "the people" at all.
I think what you're not seeing is that the entrenchment will never be broken through buddy buddy elections. And that allowingcertainlevels of officeto elect other levels of office with the exclusion of the general population, just further entrenches what is already there. It is the whole problem with the cabinet, the fed, the supreme court and just about every office where one set of people gets to decide for all of the people who is put in charge.
Well, technically it's several people. And also, again, it's up to congress to write the laws. The people with the stop button can only read them. And the person with the big stick can only execute them. What is wrong right now is muddling and meddling.
The laws are sufficient protection if read and executed correctly.
New laws should be sufficiently written to allow for correct execution and reading... but have become monsters of garbage.
These kinds of comments make it hard to communicate with you. I have been open and honest thus far. But make no mistake, if you want to go down this kind of road, I have no interest in discussing things that you apparently "know more than me" about further.
You've completely lost me from this point on in your comment. You've run a test? You come off patronizing and very difficult with these statements. The rest of your points are just random tics on a list.
I appreciated the open suggestions we were sharing and was looking forward to more dialogue. But if you "know better than I do" and have decided that I am uniformed and complacent, well I guess you can go pound sand because you lost me as an audience for your "all knowing" pronouncements.
Thanks anyway six.
Sorry, I thought I might help you understand it Miss_Demeanor, but you missed the whole point of my comment entirely.
Maybe I'm just not that good at getting my point across.
All and each branch is just as important as the other. That was my point. Maybe I didn't say it as politely as you would have preferred.
My point had nothing to do really with any of that. It was we as a people have the power to accomplish the objectives we have through the states. Whether you won or lost or I won or lost in these examples didn't mean anything. They were just examples of how it would work.
This is the same way the Bill of Rights came about.
Sorry I upset you. I too, was hoping to enjoy something actually worthwhile. Guess it is just impossible.
Six said:
"Granting the state legislatures and Congress (both Houses) the authority to override the Supreme Court with a vote of 60% from the states or Congress."
No No no no no no.... And I will tell you why. The SCotUS is there, as you have said, to interpret thelawsthroughthe lens of the Constitution. If you make a mere supermajority ofstatesor congress able to overturn a ruling by the SCotUS, then you, in effect, are giving the legislative branch of govt the authority to tell the SCotUS we are not going to listen to you, we think that this is what the constitution means, so SDSTFU... poof* there goes the whole constitution. As much as Idisagree with some of the rulings, I am not willing to give the power of making the CotUS subject to willy nilly change. There is a process for change and it should be followed.
I got solid liberal also. Yes I believe there are things to need to happen and change, I don't believe it is the governments job to force those changes. Of course, the answers brooked no leeway.