If it's a fact that Obama harbors Muslim beliefs is he Sunni or Shia ?
Here is the evidence supporting that statement :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=wv79-pYPkXk
The source as you can see in the video was the Rev. Jeramiah Wright who was Obama's pastor for 23 years .
Since Obama spent time as a child in Indonesia it seems likely to conclude that he is Sunni :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shia_Islam_in_Indonesia
Shi'a Islam in Indonesia represents a small minority in that largely-Sunni Muslim country.
Also :
http://countrystudies.us/indonesia/37.htm

That's right John . Don't watch the video . Don't become informed . Just launch personal attacks . The subject is Edward Klein's interview of the Rev. Jeramiah Wright , not me . Get on topic or leave the article . That was your 1st and last warning .
Misleading him about what ? Since the interview is on tape it really doesn't matter . You can't shoot down the words of Edward Klein and expect them to have ANY effect on the taped words of the pastor for Obama for 23 years ...
BTW for someone who is supposed to be that non-credible why was he : "a former New York Times magazine editor" ?
FIRST, OMG, reading a book as part of getting the right to vote. Yeah very Constitutional/NOT.
Love the generalization about the Hamptons. Then let's go right into character assassination with anecdotal stories. Well, my in laws have a house in the Hamptons, and I know tons of Republicans and Conservatives there. Then we go right into calling "liberalism"as the "Blob". No fear mongering there. Then we go into bashing book publishing. Well my husband works for John Wiley and Sons... and I am sorry they publish all subjects from all perspectives.
I would love to hear the actual recordings. Otherwise... I have my doubts, given this guys outrageous generalizations that I heard in the beginning. I'm going to be looking for said recordings.
OK , so you're saying that Wright lied in a taped interview about Obama ? That would be a major story if it was accurate . What lies did he make ? We know for a fact Obama spent many childhood years in Indonesia . Why is it surprising that he was "steeped in Islam " ?
OK so this is what I found:
A short clip of Rev. Jeramiah Wright clearly saying that Obama was NOT a Muslim and that he was sure he got grief from his Muslim family members. Then we hearKlein's interpertation of what Wright said, but not from Wright's recording. Sorry, this is a no go.
John,
Gotta say not happy about my position here. I call BS when I see it, and that is what I just did.
BUT.......
NT's conservatives will turn this around and tell me that my liberal panites are showing, while you will call me a closet right winger.
Yeah.. being an vocal independent sucks.
Thanks for the link .
The exact words Klein quoted from Wright was that he was "steeped in Islam" . Not that he believed in Islam but that he was exposed to it . There seems to be little doubt about that aspect of Obama's childhood . And given that it also is a natural question to examine which branch of Islam he was "steeped in" . That branch is Sunni . Given that the ISIS attacks are from the Sunni branch , this info could be very significant point of info .
Perrie ,
You won't see me calling you anything but an independent . Thanks for inserting your POV . But don't you think it is important to understand what branch of Islam that Obama was exposed to as an uncritical naive child ?
steeped in Islam means that it was a total part of his life. He spent 4 years of his life there. I spent more time going to a Christian School in England. I must be C of E.
Yes ... very formative years of his life learning about "submission to Allah" . No effect at all ... How foolish of me to even think of that !? BTW he spent 23 years being influenced by an anti-white Marxist minister . How about that for an effect ?!
Like I said I went to a Church of England School from age 5 to 12... formative years. I sang hymns at morning assembly and even religion classes. I am not Anglican.
You see, you are going to have to make up your mind. Which one is it? Obviously he spent a heck of lot more time atJeramiah Wright church and probably had more of an influence from there. But really, pick one and go with that.
What ... A person can't have more than 1 influence in their lives ?
No, I don't think that it means anything more than me being exposed to the Anglican faith as a naive child. His mother wasn't a Muslim and I am sure she had an influence on him, too.
I agree with Pierre. I went to Catholic school for years but I'm not a Catholic. I'm a vegetarian and my son is not. Learning my dietary habits will tell you nothing about him.
Odd that he didn't write a book about her , isn't it ? The book he did write was :
"Dreams from My Father: A Story of Race and Inheritance" .
Notice what the title said... race... not religion.
Furthermore, when he was in Indonesia, he went to the state school that his mom taught in.
Judging a book by it's title ? Only slightly better than by it's cover ...
If Obama is a Muslim, he's the only Muslim I've heard of who prayers in a Christian Church and not a mosque! LOL
According to the interview tape he doesn't pray anywhere . The Rev. Wright said that he and Michelle are "not church people" .... They don't send their kids to Sunday school either .
There are 5 requirements for being a Muslim:
1. The Shahada- The declaration "There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is His prophet."
2. Salat (prayer)-- 5x/day, prostrate, facing Mecca
3. Zakat - charity. Given only to needy Muslims or Muslim charities.
4. Sawm (Fasting) - During daylight hours for an entire month
5. Hadjj (Pilgrimmage to Mecca at least once)
Does Obama qualify? Does he do all five?
I dunno-- what do you think?
I poop once a day facing away from Mecca . What does that make me ?!
It makes you.. .politically correct!
This is very confusing . If your poop is aimed at Mecca that is politically correct ?
It is NOT a fact, Petey. He has attended the same Christian church for years. Here is the article where he tried to set the record straight.
Obama Sets Record Straight
Obama Religion
Obama's Religious Beliefs
In short, he is not a Muslim. He is Congregationalist, otherwise known as Christian Church. My great-great grandparents were Christians from Germany. Not Lutherans, not Methodists, not Catholics, Christians. Like this sign:
Petey. I think it is important for YOU to tell the truth, rather than speculate and offer sheer conjecture.
I am disappointed in you. This is a crap article and you know it. All you want to do is smear mud. You are way more intelligent than this!
He only says that for political purposes . But he is really a Marxist like his minister for 23 years . Bottom line , his religion does not come into play [although some refer to Marxism as a religion ] ...
BTW that last link was before his election so you can be certain it was a polysci crafted spin ...
I call BS, Petey. You who are so interested in separation of church and state want nothing more than to muddy the waters.
Besides, he IS the president. It's too late now.
(shoosh... actually I don't own any)
Thank you Petey!
OK did you read the book?
I haven't.... but I can do some research.
So all we have is the very obvious title.
Zackly BF. All I could find was a short clip where clearly Wright says that Obama is NOT a Muslim.
They sound like a mineral formation... Panites, formed when small grains of calcite/quartz roll over and over along a shoreline, resulting in a concentric lenticular core layered by calcium carbonate over the parent material...
The United Church of Christ and the Christian church are two different churches, Petey. The United Church of Christ is not a liberal denomination. The Christian Church is.
Once again, you are being nasty just for sake of being nasty. Put a cork in it. You didn't like my proof, then toooo bad. This is a Front Page article. You want to behave nastily, then go back to Heated Discussions.
Maybe. Maybe not.
But there is nothing inconsistent with being a Marxist and a Christian. Or a Marxist and a Muslim. Or for that matter, a Marxist and an Atheist. Marxist is pretty broad, and people differ on the definition. Perhaps a better term is "Socialist"-- but that's also pretty general, and there are many shades of "Socialism"... (Some people would argue that Jesus was a Socialist...)
(Communism, OTOH is different-- atheism is an inherent part of true Communism, as is totalitarian rule).
There was a proof ? I must have missed that . What was that again ?
I actually think he leans towards Marxism . Certainly his minister of 23 years was a Marxist ...
^^^ That's why we love you, Dowser !
You can't judge a person's spirituality by their church attendance.
I can't argue with that . And you can't even judge it by their praying ...
SORRY, John and Petey-- I was confused. My screen is jumping around... Please accept my apologies.
That would be fine with you John, but only if her opinion was the same as yours as it is at this time. I assure you that you wouldn't feel the same if it wasn't.
He's a liar. There's no denying that. There is plenty of proof. Sunni or Shiite..... Personally I think he is a little piece of each, maybe a little more of the latter.
Which is just another opinion and based on nothing factual.
Actually, I'm pretty sure the Pope is also a Muslim.
Look at all the strange clothes he wears-- he definitely looks like a furriner!
Definitely not one of us American "Good 'Ole Boys"!
Heh
(I wonder-- is the Pope a Sunni-- or a Shia? Hard to tell....)
You cain't fool me-- this is not The Pope:
You say he is not a liar Perrie?
Thanks, John.
A lot of us that are spiritual wouldn't set foot in a church. Personally, I'm one of them. I've gone to church for years and years and become more and more disillusioned. I am, in fact, quite angry about it.
Even "Honest" Abe lied, Six. They all have to lie, it is a part of their job. No president in my lifetime hasn't lied at one time or another. Sometimes they have a good reason for lying, and sometimes it is for their narrow personal interest.
About all we can do, I think, is seek out the truth-- not the biased truth, which is next to impossible to find these days, but the truth.
Meaning no disrespect to any president, living or dead.
How do I know? Grandma told me. She went back to Chester Arthur, and she said they all lied.
What is it about this topic that reverberates so much ? I think it is the way foreign Islamics view Obama . They have been asking the question posed in the title for a long time now ...
OMHO, he is.. but so are most Presidents.
Dowser, I was made to attend a morning mass (Catholic) six days a week for eight years.Talk about indoctrination !
Hey, Petey, I know something about praying. See my above comment.
I left the RCC when I got my first driver's license. And never looked back.
Bless your heart!
The Methodist church was bad enough, but not that bad. About all I can stand to be is Methodist. They are also the only ones that would have me, and ONLY because my great great grandfather built the first Methodist church west of the Alleghenies in 1812.
I am not well-liked at my church, because I don't toe the line. Nor am I going to. I go with my conscience, and not the social aspect of church. Therefore, I am a pariah, and that's fine by me.
Just as a general FYI , John got the famous comment # 69 ... whatever that indicates .